Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Daniel Alexandre Portoraro

GET UPDATES FROM Daniel Alexandre Portoraro
 

Protestors, Stop Your Engines

Posted: 06/06/2012 2:02 pm

The Formula One Canadian Grand Prix is a point of pride for this country, an event watched by millions from around the world. Little wonder then why the Quebec protestors, in dire need of a landmark event after their 100th day anniversary, would threaten to disrupt the highly anticipated race set to begin this weekend.

In an attempt to appropriate the Grand Prix as their own, however, protestors in Quebec are quickly demonstrating their lack of political cohesion. The protests, they say, are no longer about tuition hikes but about general economic inequality. It says a great deal about a protest when, halfway through, it changes its message from a specific issue that can be argued against, to a generalization such as the "tearing of social fabric." The last time a group of protesters engaged in such oblique terms, they were justifiably snuffed out by cold weather and general apathy.

One would think the students would have learned their lesson, and avoid trafficking in such social vagueries. But what is the alternative?

In a HuffPost blog, Andrew Cooper explains the significance of boycotting sports. Over the course of history, these boycotts have dealt with a variety of issues of paramount international importance: In 1964, South Africa was banned from the Olympic games because of apartheid; in 1980, the Moscow Olympics were unattended by the USA because of the Soviets' invasion of Afghanistan. This year, the Euro Cup is in danger of not being attended by many European officials because of host country the Ukraine's inhumane treatment its braided heroine, NAME, and actual revolutionary leader Yulia Tymoshenko.

Now here's Quebec before the world and what are they protesting? An abstract idea at worst; a couple of hundred dollars a year and a law that has hardly been implemented at best.

But perhaps what is most striking about the recent threats to disrupt the Canadian Grand Prix are the contradictions behind it. When one gets down to it, money is the root of the problem here. These protests started with tuition increases and in all likelihood, will cease when the students' financial demands are met. If money holds the key to both cause and cessation, then why would these cash-strapped protestors get in the way of Montreal's most profitable weekend? An estimated $100 million will go into the province over the course of the Grand Prix alone.

Regardless of how hard they may try, the victims of these disruptions are not those fabled one-percenters but the 99 per cent. The American consulate has warned Americans from coming to Montreal. Hotel bookings for the month of May are down 10 per cent, and are expected to decrease even more as these protests go on. Shopkeepers are getting nervous. Restauranteurs are at risk. One of the world's largest comedy festivals has already reported a decrease of 50 per cent in ticket sales compared to last year. This is feeding season; a time which helps keep businesses stay afloat for the rest of the year, and the money's being taken away from them.

But maybe most saddening of all, this Sunday, organizers of the Canadian Grand Prix announced that the popular "open doors" day will be cancelled. To be frank, Thursday's open doors are a chance for those without the financial means (or those who, understandably, cannot justify spending $300 over the course of a weekend) to experience a part of the Grand Prix. This year, the much-anticipated event has been taken away from them.

Student groups say organizers of the Grand Prix have overreacted in cancelling the free opening day of the event. But did they really have any other choice? When you have people like Jaggi Singh, who have made careers out of being arrested, saying "Rich douchebags are going to be disrupted by night demos"; when you have hackneyed hacker groups like Anonymous stealing the personal information of ticket-buyers and publishing it online; when you have an independent anti-capitalist group announcing they plan to "disrupt this crass elite at play"; when you have the leader of CLASSE saying, "You have to understand we cannot block the hundreds of thousands of students of Quebec from doing an action if they want to do an action," what is one to do but assume the worst?

The organizers have overreacted? Sorry, but any group which intends to disrupt a huge money-making event in the name of a petty tuition hike cannot possibly pass judgment on others. Not only does this demonstrate the lack of political sense of this entire endeavour, but it proves how these protests are quickly dissolving into the sort of sensationalist, childish machinations which Quebec students have tried so vehemently to disprove. One sincerely hopes not all of Canada is judged by these bellicose few.

 

Follow Daniel Alexandre Portoraro on Twitter: www.twitter.com/dportoraro

FOLLOW CANADA
The Formula One Canadian Grand Prix is a point of pride for this country, an event watched by millions from around the world. Little wonder then why the Quebec protestors, in dire need of a landmark e...
The Formula One Canadian Grand Prix is a point of pride for this country, an event watched by millions from around the world. Little wonder then why the Quebec protestors, in dire need of a landmark e...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 31
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
04:08 PM on 06/08/2012
this clown Portoraro has no problem with Grand Prix Ecclestone running his Formula Race in Bahrain, where people are fighting for their rights?...and people are fighting for their rights in Quebec also..anyway, Charest can end all these protests and disruptions by giving students justice, it is in his hands..
photo
NTodd
Aude Sapere
08:50 PM on 06/07/2012
You're right. Democracy is not a money-making endeavor. The hell with it.
03:16 PM on 06/07/2012
This is really depressing. Montreal is such a beautiful city with so much to offer, especially in the summer. The protestors think that disrupting F1 is sticking it to the rich, yet most F1 fans are probably middle class and the people most effected by the loss of tourism won't be major corporations but small business owners who run the city's restaurants, cafes and bars. And what is this all about anyways? The protestors are simply arguing on principle, not on practicality. The majority of Canadians can afford to pay $3000 a year in tuition and for those few who can't, there are loans, charities and scholarships. In a city where one in two people seem to sport a $500 Canada Goose winter coat and Ray Ban sunglasses (ever taken a walk through McGill's campus?), it seems hard to argue that some $300 a year will destroy the ability of most people to get a good education.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:50 PM on 06/07/2012
Wait... I recognize you. Youre the guy that's dating Frum's daughter right? He is the one that got you this position, eh? Surprise surprise that you sound just like him.
photo
Ian Llangan
Your Invisible Sky Friend Is Morally Abhorrent
01:12 AM on 06/07/2012
Money talks and you-know-what walks. Sorry Montreal/QC et al. But I've cancelled my plans to drop any tourism $$ in your province this year - which I have done annually for the F1 for several years. It's one thing to stage a protest march and make your point. It's quite another to lessen your already meagre future economic prospects by scaring people away. Thanks but there are other more compelling places to see F1 races where the local population is more educated, and knows and appreciates that advances in F1 technology have led to increased fuel efficiency in production vehicles, as well as leading-edge advances like regenerative braking etc.
ChrisH75
Je ne réponds pas aux commentaires de Canada Libr
07:56 AM on 06/07/2012
I certainly don't blame anyone for avoiding Montreal right now. It's a shame, as I love the city and it's culture. It's amazing how such a small group of malcontents can ruin things for everyone.
11:52 PM on 06/06/2012
oops.............. I get so excited''!!!!... my previous comment was meant for the all knowing burlesque lea
11:49 PM on 06/06/2012
so---you are telling ALL of us in 'cyberspace' that there will be ---No boycotting---of this sporting event?
with this kind of insider information I will now feel ccomfortabe re-booking my flight to QUEBEC to attend---I am of course doing this on your 'inside' information that no disruption will occur--of course with this kind of guarantee -I just know you will honour ALL my expenses incured in my re-booking, flight, and associated 'land' costs...' thanks you for this reassurance - I don't know how you did it-- but it's great
11:29 PM on 06/06/2012
Gabriel Nadeau Dubois has been very clear on the subject - the attention presented by this event is an opportunity to present information to this global audience. Now, this may be seen as a threat by those who don't like his message, and who would rather shut the thing down than allow this to happen. There have been hysterical overreactions designed I think to turn the public against the protesters. This is why it's very appropriate that this be mocked by the protesters.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
05:13 AM on 06/07/2012
The Gabriel fans girls are as annoying as the Bieber ones. Maybe we'll get lucky and see a cat fight between the two some day.
ChrisH75
Je ne réponds pas aux commentaires de Canada Libr
07:50 AM on 06/07/2012
I have news for you. Hardly anyone cares for about this issue outside of Quebec. Sure the protests make headlines, but solely because of the fact that people are protesting. Most don't know why the protests are taking place, and certainly have no influence on Quebec's internal policies. The only people who will give a darn are the failed Occupy people and the career "Activists" who come out of hiding every time there is a chance to cause some trouble.
11:17 PM on 06/06/2012
Once again, a sorry lack of critical thinking haphazardly veiled in a haughty pomposity—ostensibly to suggest an informed analysis, which is in fact almost completely lacking.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
05:13 AM on 06/07/2012
And you're all about pomposity ain't ya.
10:17 AM on 06/07/2012
I was hoping someone would get the joke, but all the way through, not halfway.
ChrisH75
Je ne réponds pas aux commentaires de Canada Libr
07:46 AM on 06/07/2012
Blogs are meant to be slanted towards the author's opinion. He has an opinion, which many agree with and he has backed it with some economic facts. You have a right to disagree and propose a counterpoint, but I suppose that it's easier to insult a person's intellect.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Burlesque Lea
the dog is the only animal that has seen his god
09:52 PM on 06/06/2012
you are a total lack of information source. The students just engage themself in not boycotting any kind of cultural, sport, or political event to be held in Quebec province during the summer. The news papers are saturated of this single news, the students leaders even reassured it in a press conference.... make a good use of your fingers by googling the news , and your misinformation will ,once again, leave you in total ridicule.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stormlight
10:59 PM on 06/06/2012
That's just damage control once their threats of boycotting the event turned the public tide against them. In a heartbeat they'd be there to stop the event and thrust their red patch into the public spotlight. The fact they've changed their message from the tuition increase to protesting everything unjust under the sun shows the leadership aren't piloting the rebellious ship lollipop these days.

Easiest way to end this: "Hey we'll stop protesting if you rescind Bill 78 and give us a better repayment deal on student loans and help for lower income students who want to attend university." "Okay, sounds good to us in the government" *Shakes hands in agreement* THE END
ChrisH75
Je ne réponds pas aux commentaires de Canada Libr
07:44 AM on 06/07/2012
The government already made that offer, even while they were protesting. The students did not accept and will not accept anything less than a tuition freeze.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rhiness
12:44 AM on 06/07/2012
I'm pretty sure this is also racially motivated Burlesque! Stand against it! Britain fights back!
09:02 PM on 06/06/2012
I take more pride in protests than I do in a very corporate car race.
07:37 PM on 06/06/2012
"The Formula One Canadian Grand Prix is a point of pride for this country"

lol

protip: few care.

Go protestors go!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
05:12 AM on 06/07/2012
I'll bet you there are more race fans than CLASSE fans.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:44 PM on 06/07/2012
In Quebec? I doubt it. In Texas? Most assuredly.
The Grand Prix is there for rich tourists, not for locals.
07:35 PM on 06/06/2012
Spot on observation, Daniel, about the students obscuring their goals when they changed their message halfway through from a matter of a few hundred dollars to demanding free education for all. It begs to reason that there is more to this "uprising" than meets the eye. My gut tells me that the PQ and union interests are stage managing the whole show from the wings.
ChrisH75
Je ne réponds pas aux commentaires de Canada Libr
07:42 AM on 06/07/2012
Haven't you heard? It's a revolution... A Maple Spring! At least that's what the former Occupy types would like to believe.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stormlight
07:22 PM on 06/06/2012
You've hit the nail on the head here. Nothing shows how wrong this protest truly is by taking money from the hard working businesses in Montreal. Without that tourism a LOT of people will lose their jobs and possibly their stores too. And when that money doesn't make it in to provincial coffers then unfortunately that increase will be passed onto those students tax-paying parents AND possibly even more of a tuition increase.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:46 PM on 06/07/2012
And yet those people still fight the protests. If they join the protests and pressure the government this didn't need to be the case at all. As long as there is no solution to the crisis, there are going to be issues like this. Store owners and business owners who are under threat must pressure the government (maybe have their own protests) towards a solution.
05:32 PM on 06/06/2012
Admit it, this is literally the first time you've EVER cared about the Grand Prix.

If there were no protests, you'd be ignoring it or whining about what low-brow entertainment it is.
ChrisH75
Je ne réponds pas aux commentaires de Canada Libr
07:40 AM on 06/07/2012
I'm not a racing fan myself, but the caliber of this event goes well beyond the race track. The people and money that come into town play a large role in the survival of many people employed in the service sector in this city. The contribution can be recognized even by those who don't care for the event.
09:38 AM on 06/07/2012
Oh, please, give me a break.

All this sudden convenient weeping for the working class has nothing to do with concern for anyone's livelihood, it's about scoring political points against the protests.

Nobody who's complaining will care in the slightest about the people who are affected once there's no political battle anymore.