Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Daniel Alexandre Portoraro

GET UPDATES FROM Daniel Alexandre Portoraro
 

Why Learn, When You Can Protest?

Posted: 05/16/2012 5:10 pm

Back in March, Michael Ball of the Montreal Gazette described the then-novel Quebecois protests as "charming." In his piece, "Those kids made me smile," Ball argued that while he did not agree with the motives behind the protests, their conduct -- sorry, comportement -- was "admirable." He claimed that there were "No arrests. Face (and sometimes breasts) were exposed and not hidden behind bandanas. The police even thanked the protesters for not straying from the predtermined route, allowing them to control traffic accordingly."

Oh, how times have changed.

Today, the behaviour of one-third of Montreal students was anything but exemplary. In fact, it was downright disdainful, disgusting, and completely nullified the effects of March's "charming" march.

Due to a recent court injunction, students -- once protesters, maybe still protesters -- have gone back to attend the classes they pay such supposedly high rates for. These were the same classes which the striking students led to being cancelled for quite some time.

And, of course, in the name of solidarity, how did those still striking respond? By storming the Université du Québec à Montréal. But rather than keep to themselves and chant about in the hallways (like some graduating class prank), these supposed fighters for student rights decided to flood into the classrooms of their peers, grabbing their once-comrades by the arm in attempt to push them back into rank, spray-painting the walls, and throwing their books on the ground -- maybe not a capital offence, but surely a symbolic one considering the costs of course materials.

But maybe most disgruntling of all was that when those paying students decided to film the disruptors in the middle of the act, protesters attempted to grab their phones out of reach -- funny, considering how if the police were to do such a thing, we would all be privy to an uproar regarding civil rights, a totalitarian, Orwellian state.

This use of vicious violence and vandalism runs contrary to any feeble notion of solidarity; in fact, this represents a dire schism in the Quebec student protests movement; one reminiscent of some sort of purge, the "if you're not with us, you're against us." Never mind that these students are paying to learn, and that many, because of these strikes will have to prolong their studies by another year; the movement must come first.

This Friday, Quebec will decide on its own variant of the mask law that's caused so much controversy amongst protesters, and former protesters alike. But in light of Wednesday's events, if these supposed masked avengers, these bandana'd student fighters are so quick to turn on their own kind -- manhandle them, hurl insults, vandalize the property of others, and attempt to erase any trace of evidence -- then maybe such legislation intended to hold people accountable is necessary to snap these children out of their delusions that such behaviour is what will allow their voice to be heard.

The sorry fact of the matter is that with only one third of students in Quebec left on strike, we should hope these vandals would stay out of university, and keep up their charade of fighting for what is justifiably theirs; after all, that would increase the likelihood of actual students to find employment after graduation. Students who instead of donning cowardly, immature masks, are actually working.

 

Follow Daniel Alexandre Portoraro on Twitter: www.twitter.com/dportoraro

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:15 PM on 05/17/2012
I haven't followed the details of the strike for a while. I looked on line but couldn't find an answer to the following question: What was (or is) the stance of the student protest groups toward the current semester? I gather they didn't want it suspended-so was it to compress it into the next 8 weeks or so, or the split it with a few weeks now and a few weeks in the Fall or some other position. Or no position? Just curious. Does anyone know?
06:01 PM on 05/17/2012
maybe this student needs to do more research. these are an excellent series of articles. he could start here.
http://andrewgavinmarshall.com/2012/04/24/canadas-economic-collapse-and-social-crisis-class-war-and-the-college-crisis-part-5/
05:43 PM on 05/17/2012
Great article!

regardless of whether or not tuition should be increased, what the protesters are doing is wrong. Although I would go even further and say that most of what people considered 'peaceful' protests were wrong if they infringed on other peoples freedoms.

see http://wp.me/p27AoJ-4i for my full opinion.
05:05 PM on 05/17/2012
perhaps this student needs to do some research, here is a good series of articles where he could start.
http://andrewgavinmarshall.com/2012/04/24/canadas-economic-collapse-and-social-crisis-class-war-and-the-college-crisis-part-5/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
arkymorgan
Nobody knows the trouble I've been...
02:24 PM on 05/17/2012
I realize this 'journalist' is only in his senior year of university, so I can understand that he doesn't yet grasp the long history, the trajectory or the mechanics of social protest. Every point he makes could have been ripped from the editorials of the establishment, in any newspaper published in 1850, 1912, or 1967. Each time, the writers have been proven to be mere mouthpieces for aristocratic or corporate masters.

It's said that while women tend to become more radical with age, it is the opposite for men, since as they age, they have more and more invested in the status quo. It is sad to see how far from radical this boy is, and if the dictum holds true, to imagine how reactionary he will be in a few years.
10:48 AM on 05/17/2012
It's pathetic how people in this country will condemn anyone who is making a fuss publicly, but they sit idly by and tolerate it as massive thefts and slow-motion violence are inflicted on whole sectors of society, as long as it is done quietly.
photo
albertarick
These are questions for wise men with skinny arms
11:49 AM on 05/17/2012
I would argue that the thefts and violence haven't been so quiet as of late and these students actions are a rational reaction to the ramping of the general disrespect shown to the masses by our leadership.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
arkymorgan
Nobody knows the trouble I've been...
02:26 PM on 05/17/2012
I agree. I'm not sure what it will take to rouse the rest of us to protest against the theft of every right, principle and value we claim to hold dear, and I suspect that when the breaking point is reached, it will already be too late.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
valar84
09:02 AM on 05/17/2012
This is the consequence of the Liberal government's reaction to the crisis.

You talk about the big March protest. Yes, it was admirable and I would like to see all protests look like it... but you know what it resulted in? Nothing. The government completely ignored it and kept refusing to even meet the student leaders after it. Pacific protests quite evidently didn't matter to Charest and his gang.

When protests started going wrong after weeks of conflicts where the government refused to budge an inch or even talk, then the government invited student associations to a discussion and started talking about maybe increasing grants or spreading the hike over more years.

In other words, the Charest government basically told students "pacifism gets you nowhere, but commit violent acts and maybe we'll budge". This was exactly the wrong message. It should have agreed to discuss right after the pacific protest and not let the situation fester like it did. The crisis has lasted so long that spirits are becoming enraged on both sides.

I keep hearing people against the students wanting police to beat them up or in favor of locking striking students. I also hear people against the government start wishing violence on Charest and his ministers.

This has gone out of control, and the government is to blame.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
01:21 AM on 05/17/2012
I agree with half of this article: yes, the current methods of protest used by these students are abominable. However, I do not agree that these protestors are simply "vandals" who should be shunned from universities, since these establishments should apparently be reserved for those who are "actually working". Should they be reprimanded for their choice of behaviour? Yes. But I cannot condemn their fight. Regardless of what many appear to think, most of the students fighting for the lowering of tuition fees (both in Quebec and elsewhere) are not privileged, middle-class kids whining on the streets. They are smart, hard-working kids who come from low-income families and would just really like to not be thousands of dollars in debt upon graduation. So of course, props to those hard working students who deserve to be in school! But why shouldn't a student who- despite working as much as possible- faces thousands of dollars of debt and a slim chance at the education which will eventually determine their employability also be applauded for their hard work AND respected for their determination to fight so that those who follow in their footsteps may not face such heavy burdens? Knock the method, sure, just not the general intention behind it.
07:57 PM on 05/16/2012
Some people just really want to jump into the "let's cut our neighbours' throats" Social Darwinisan dystopia, don't they... they look forward to a future with many, many losers suffering horribly and with the winners so smug with self-superiority having chosen to create a hell of a society patting themselves on the head for a job well done.