Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Daniel D. Veniez

GET UPDATES FROM Daniel D. Veniez
 

Harper's "I Know Nothing" Sgt. Schultz Routine isn't Flying

Posted: 02/29/2012 3:42 pm

Stephen Harper stood in the House of Commons today and said emphatically that the Conservative Party was not behind the Robocalls. Well, if not them, then who did?

If the Conservatives are so adamant that they have done nothing wrong, Harper should be the first on his feet to call a full judicial inquiry into allegations of electoral fraud. The Sergeant Schultz -- "I know nothing" -- routine just isn't good enough.

There are deeply troubling questions that require answers. For example, who owns these firms? What are their ties to the Conservative Party? Do any senior members of the Conservative Party or their fundraising arms have any financial interests in these firms? What specific instructions were the firms given and who gave them? If they were freelancing on these calls and other dirty tricks, how will they be held accountable? Did these firms sub-contract to call centers in the United States, Singapore, India, and elsewhere? What role did third party actors play? Where did they get their financing? Who ultimately wrote the cheques, and what ties, if any, do they have with the Conservative Party?

If there's nothing to hide, let's open this up to public scrutiny so that we can restore confidence in our electoral system.

Robocalls scratch the surface of the ugly underbelly of dirty tricks. "Push-pull" polling -- a commonly used technique by Conservatives -- by telemarketing firms are just another example, as are the use of cellular phone scrambling technologies to disrupt the campaign organizations of political opponents.

There's also a structural problem that can use thoughtful investigation. Last May, my counsel and I filed two complaints with Elections Canada on serious matters pertaining to Conservative dirty tricks in my riding. We have yet to receive even a formal acknowledgement of the complaints and we have heard nothing from them in almost a year.

I am not alone. Many of my colleagues in the Liberal Party and NDP have filed complaints have yet to hear back from Elections Canada. That is because they are incredibly understaffed and under-resourced to do much more than supervise the mechanics of holding elections. This is not a criticism of the people of Elections Canada. They are outstanding public servants who are doing a good job with the limited tools and resources available to them. Fixing this should be on the top of parliament's agenda.

It is a testament to the sorry state of our politics that we even have to even discuss beefing up the enforcement capacity of Elections Canada. But we do.

Our political system is now populated by legions of people who make their living from it. It is an industry. There is a professional class of political operators that consider this a game, and nothing more. You canfind them working in staff jobs with the prime minister, ministers, MP's, and political parties. They are consultants in government relations, public relations, advertising, marketing, law, polling, market research, telemarketing, and accounting firms. Some of them hang their hats in industry associations.

These people form a gladiator class who have done nothing in their lives except be in the world of politics, campaigning, and political organization. And it truly is a world apart. Stephen Harper himself was born and raised in that world. Before he became an MP himself, Mr. Harper was a staffer for an MP, was a paid employee of the Reform Party, and was President of a three-person office at the tax-payer subsidized National Citizens Coalition. Not unlike the current generation of gladiators, this is the only world he has ever really known.

There is a certain indefinable insidiousness to that culture. The concept of right and wrong are blurred because these political professionals consider it a "game." The basic notions of morality and the national interest do not enter into the equation. The stock and trade is simply to kill the enemy. It is all about getting the other guy. And doing that is just fine so long as you don't get caught. Partisans salivate. The game is advancing their party's interest, not substantive issues, or even predicated on a well-considered guiding philosophy. The guiding mantra is "my party, right or wrong." What's right for the country takes a back seat.

Liberals and New Democrats are responsible for more than their fair share of questionable tactics over the years. To suggest otherwise is itself a lie. Canadians aren't stupid and this whole matter should not be about partisan posturing and gamesmanship. The system is sick and the people in it work with a far different moral and ethical compass than the rest of us. Take them out of that poisonous culture and they are the nicest people you'll ever want to meet. Put normal people in it and they magically are sucked into a vortex where subterfuge and character assassination is just another day at the office.

I'm a Liberal, and one does not have to look too far back in Canadian history to know that we are far from pure as the driven snow. Neither are New Democrats. But this is a critical inflection point in the life of our democracy.

For its part, I want my party and its leaders to set a different, higher standard. That's why I want Liberals to acknowledge openly that we are part of the problem, and we must be part of the solution. Unless we do, what credibility can we possibly have with Canadians? This isn't a game. This is our country and the health of our democracy. Citizens must have confidence in it, and at the moment, we sure don't.

Our political culture cannot and will not be changed overnight. It shall take time. In the meantime, there must be measures to safeguard what is most fundamental in any democracy -- the sanctity of our votes.

Theoretically, at least, Elections Canada is supposed to referee the electoral process to ensure its fairness. While the good people of that agency try their best, they are hopelessly under-resourced to do that job. The Elections Canada Act was designed for another time. Parliamentarians should agree to reform the legislation to give it some real teeth and the resources and capacity to protect the integrity of the electoral system for the future.

The use oftechnology that didn't even exist a few years ago has created whole new avenues for political professionals to circumvent well-established norms of fairness and decency. For those predisposed to cheat -- and there are plenty out there -- room to undermine the integrity of the electoral system is never been broader.

Separate from a judicial inquiry, the Canada Elections Act must be modernized to protect us from fraudsters and those that play fast and loose with the spirit and intent of election laws and procedures. As pathetic as this might be, it has become painfully clear that we need to strengthen legislation to protect Canadians and our rights and freedoms from this "law and order" government.

We need a truly independent electoral authority that is provided with a substantially increased and multiyear appropriation from parliament. Perhaps the highly respected Jean-Pierre Kingsley could chair ablue ribbon task force tasked with providing the House of Commons recommendations on what a modernized Act could look like and what kind of budget Elections Canada would require. This should be at the top of the legislative agenda and a report should be tabled within a reasonable period of time.

The Commissioner of Elections should have strengthened statutory authority and powers of investigation and enforcement. A beefed-up Act would provide the Commissioner with forensic accountants and search warrant powers. Those powers are needed to get at the huge volume of "off balance sheet" activity that takes place in the shadows of all political parties.

And what if the Commissioner is not satisfied that the election has been conducted fairly? Or if evidence is found that systematic electoral fraud has been committed as to call the legitimacy of the government of the day into question? In such a case, our Head of State, the Governor General in his constitutional role, should have the authority to dissolve parliament and order new elections.

Having confidence in the sanctity of free and fair elections is fundamental to our democracy and a sacred trust that must not be tampered with.

 

Follow Daniel D. Veniez on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@danveniez

 
 
  • Comments
  • 52
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
06:56 AM on 03/08/2012
If Elections Canada and the RCMP and investigating the robocall issue, why should we insist on a "judicial inquiry " so quickly? Why not wait for some answers from those 2 agencies before spending a few more million on some travelling road show?
As for the people who comlained about (and listened to) robocalls, have news for you- everyone gets them cause everyone uses that system for promoting credit cards to vacations including me.
And I hang up, very quickly. So if some clown thinks that a vote was swayed because of a robocall that person should not be allowed to vote in the first place for reasons of sheer stupidity!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kenneth T Tellis
11:11 PM on 03/04/2012
You may quote Sgt, Shultz about the Tories knowing nothing, but FUDDLE DUDDLE was not any better, unless you are a LIBERAL clone.
Wonder Land
...Words Matter
09:58 PM on 03/04/2012
Hearing the news tonight that Vladimir Putin had won in Russia and that allegations of wide spread
electoral fraud were being made, my initial sentiment was frustration. Frustration for the people of
Russia who were being abused by Mr. Putin and his gang of operatives..From afar it is so easy to see
the wrongdoing...Then I thought about the robocall scandal here in Canada and I felt frustration for us..
No longer can we watch from afar and feel somehow superior...God help us all.
05:03 PM on 03/01/2012
CONTACT YOUR MP! let them know you are not happy with elections canada, then go to elections canada and tell them yourself, too. what happened to "the buck stops here? and I am ultimately responsible" Steven!?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rayma Allaby
03:10 PM on 03/01/2012
basic question:::who benefited....easy answer there....and at least one of the call centers is con friendly...doesn't take a genius to figure out which party was behind the robo calls.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
djelimon17
what's this thing for?
04:30 PM on 03/01/2012
Means motive and opportunity, this is true.

Regardless open inquiry is the only way. Mass attempt at voter fraud, multinational operation... Too serious a threat, compared to say, environmental groups
11:37 AM on 03/01/2012
I completely agree. The issue isn't necessarily whether the Harper Conservatives were directly behind this. The issue is someone, somewhere, felt it would be acceptable to attempt to steal democracy from the people to put the Conservatives in power. What IS the issue is that Harper and his party seem to not care at all about how serious this really is. They show zero interest in finding out the truth, zero interest in condemning this horrible behaviour, zero interest in launching any sort of investigaion, etc.

To me, the Conservatives disinterest in this issue is an sort of endorsement of it. Support for it, whether they were actually behind it or not. Their attitude seems to be "Oh well, we won. We really don't care if it was honestly or not. Too bad for you."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tyler Austin
Women = people. Corperations ≠ people.
11:22 AM on 03/01/2012
Harper is a man obsessed with controling the messege. He's got his own MPs living in fear of saying or doign the wrong thing off script and the PMO takes pride in knowing each and every time a back bencher so much as breaks wind...
For him to say 'oh, I had no idea that this dirty trick was in play' boarders on the absurd.
photo
TonyOnly
Truth matters.
11:18 AM on 03/01/2012
"The guiding mantra is "my party, right or wrong." What's right for the country takes a back seat."

The reason they get away with it is because there's an underlying sentiment among those whose job it is to police the process, that for the good of the country, we can't publicly undermine our political process. We can't appear on the international stage as though we have a broken democracy.

So scapegoats and underlings pay a monetary price, which undoubtedly the Party covers. And the transgressions continue, each becoming successively more serious than the previous one. Having so much to gain while the politicians themselves remain untouchable, there's no longer enough integrity to expect otherwise.

I believe it's gotten to the point where the only way to stop political parties from breaking the law, is to start sending politicians to prison.
08:53 AM on 03/01/2012
If the CONS have nothing to worry about then call a public inquiry. People's right to vote were stolen from then on a mass scale, the government should be helping to understand what happened and make changes to the system. All I hear right now is "we didn't do it"... which isn't the answer Im looking for... I want to hear "Our party is looking into the matter. Our government is looking into the matter and Elections Canada has a separate investigation."
08:01 AM on 03/01/2012
the jails are full of guys who protested their innocence and plead not guilty
02:19 AM on 03/01/2012
If you`re too stupid to look up where your polling booth is on the website of Elections Canada, and just blithely believe everything you`re told on the phone, then it`s likely robocalls are the least of your concerns and not the significant impediment to your voting! ;) :)
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
canobserv
08:37 AM on 03/01/2012
and the blame the victim mentality is as asad as it is typical.........and SO NOT the point
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Irazu
I have nothing to declare
10:32 AM on 03/01/2012
Yeah - isn't it convenient? "We couldn't have defrauded you if you were smarter. It's not MY fault you're not smarter."

And, perhaps if we didn't want to be assaulted, we shouldn't have dressed so "provocatively".
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tyler Austin
Women = people. Corperations ≠ people.
11:23 AM on 03/01/2012
So I can rob you and it's your fault for not barrign the windows....
Good to know! Got a flat screen?
01:32 AM on 03/01/2012
Call me paranoid, but I'm not entirely convinced that lack of action on the part of Elections Canada is due to short staffing. Let's not forget that the two head honchos (Marc Mayrand and Brian Saunders) are Harper appointees .... as are the RCMP commissioner and the Governor General. Harper has insulated himself very well. I think we need to keep very close eye on the 'investigation'.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Maria Korovessis Sewell
To decimate is to reduce by one tenth.
09:08 AM on 03/01/2012
Fanned & faved. Deplorable how he has politicized the top layer of Canadian bureaucracy.
11:53 AM on 03/01/2012
Well, to be perfectly fair, the US hasn't had a clean or clear election for a decade or more. And since standardizing voting machines, there has been never-ending stream of problems and issues that any sane person would say calls their whole election process and results into question. But they just ignore it and say its not a big deal. Seems that attitude is spreading up to us.
09:27 AM on 03/04/2012
We don't need to see that as 'perfectly fair', in my opinion. 'Perfectly fair' isn't finger pointing to someone else. Why not stop THAT attitude from spreading that you can minimize the effect of anything if you find that someone else is doing the same or worse.
It was wrong of whoever was behind this to dupe Canadians during our election process and I believe we have the right to know who has done this.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
colpy
10:18 PM on 02/29/2012
Got some evidence of wrong-doing?? Electoral fraud?? Vote buying??

Call the RCMP and lodge a complaint.

And I hope any perpetrators, and I mean any....get 10 years.

But you need to provide the evidence.

Right now, Harper is correct to call it a "smear".
02:21 AM on 03/01/2012
Prepare yourself to be called an evil fascist Con shill just because you think independently and believe in democratic principles like innocence till guilt is proven.
photo
freeSpeakr
I stand on the shoulders of giants
09:11 AM on 03/01/2012
the evidence is accumulating daily. There is the taint of questionable legality to this.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
canobserv
08:38 AM on 03/01/2012
or he could call a public enquiry??..
photo
freeSpeakr
I stand on the shoulders of giants
09:13 AM on 03/01/2012
Yes he could. I'll be surprised if he does though.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patrickwwalker
10:02 PM on 02/29/2012
Is there an example of a NDP election scam? *crickets* That's what I thought. Equating the Liberals and the NDP smacks of dishonesty.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
10:23 PM on 02/29/2012
There was lots of NDP bullying of the Greens for a long time.....I witnessed some pretty basic stuff, stacking nomination meetings with NDP there to cause procedural obstruction, and there were some moles/fifth columnists as things turned out....but nobody breaking LAWS on election day, that's for sure...but nothing as catastrophically evil as this is.....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patrickwwalker
05:46 AM on 03/01/2012
The Green Party in Canada is a Tory front. Check out their early backers. Also, check out the late night deal the Nova Scotian Liberals and Tories created before the last provincial election.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tyler Austin
Women = people. Corperations ≠ people.
11:26 AM on 03/01/2012
or the Liberals for 10 years for that matter.

Harper saying 'oh ell, under Chretchien the Liberals were bad too." just dosen't cut it as an excuse anymore.
10:01 PM on 02/29/2012
Great read, thanks...