Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Daniel D. Veniez

GET UPDATES FROM Daniel D. Veniez
 

Don't Let the Roar of F-35s Drown Out the Robocall Scandal

Posted: 04/05/2012 12:57 pm

In light of the unprecedented incompetence exposed by the Auditor General on the F-35 procurement scandal, the swirl of parliamentary and media attention surrounding the other simmering scandal of fraudulent robocols has died down somewhat.

But the issue will not go away because a fraud occurred and Canadians must find out what happened. A few weeks ago, the Chief Electoral Officer told a Commons committee that impersonating officials responsible for the integrity of the voting system is an affront to our democracy. Indeed it is. Those that perpetrated this crime must be found.

Despite the lame attempts of Conservative MP's to shrug off, minimize, or even make the incredulous suggestion that this must be all Elections Canada fault, all signs point to them. The technological tools they use and the black-op tactics they employ are widely established. These underlying behaviors and kill at all costs culture is also perfectly in keeping with how the Harper Conservatives operate.

As more complaints emerge we see the clear outlines of a deliberate, systematic and calculated strategy. No one believes that such an effort could have been planned and executed by one rogue operative, "Pierre Poutine," operating alone and without the knowledge of his superiors.

That is utterly implausible.

The Harper Conservative Party simply does not operate that way, and never has. Do they ensure that they organize themselves with the protective layer of plausible deniability? Of course they do. That's why it will take some time and shrewd investigative work to smoke them out.
Thus far we have only seen a small glimpse of Conservative black-op techniques. The calls to Irwin Cotler's riding which erroneously claimed that he was retiring was one recent example. A call center hired by the Conservative Party did that. In defending themselves, the Government House Leader, Peter Van Loan, called this reprehensible act "free speech".

Other, just as odious, tactics used by the Harper Conservatives are designed to sow confusion in the voter's minds and discourage them from voting. These bear serious investigative and public scrutiny.

One such technique is called the "push poll." My British Columbian constituency was a target such "polls," both before and during the election campaign, but they were conducted across the country. A so-called "push poll" is an insidious form of negative campaigning, disguised as a political poll. "Push polls" are not surveys at all, but rather unethical political telemarketing -- telephone calls disguised as research that aim to persuade large numbers of voters and affect election outcomes. No one is really collecting information. No one will analyze the data. It will not include any demographic questions. The "push" poll will contain negative information -- sometimes truthful, sometimes not -- about the opponent.

Here's how they work: You get a phone call from someone identifying themselves as being from a "market research" company (not the Conservative party). They emphasize that this is an "independent research firm." Calls are typically very short and only a few "questions" are asked. They start by sounding fair and reasonable: "If the election were held today, whom would you vote for?" That is part of confirming voter identification. Toward the end of the call, the real purpose becomes clear.

For instance, they could ask leading questions such as: "Would you re-elect an MP that misrepresents himself by saying he's an international human rights and constitutional lawyer, but really has no track record at either? Do you agree or disagree?" Or "Would you be embarrassed that your MP wastes your tax dollars by consistently ranking at the very top spenders for first-class travel and office expenses? Agree or disagree?"

They also sometimes involve more lengthy preambles to firmly plant a negative image in the mind of the voter. For example: "The Vancouver Sun reported that your MP ranks number one in the Conservative caucus for taking all-expense paid luxury international trips sponsored by foreign governments and organizations. In justifying accepting these unethical first-class gratuities, your MP said: 'When I take trips paid for by others, I do what my constituents elected me to do.' Do you agree that your MP was elected to accept free trips from foreign governments?"

The answer, of course, is obvious. Questions are geared to gin up specific responses. These techniques employ loaded questions under the guise of doing an objective survey.
The first use of this tool in the political black-operative's arsenal technique was by Lee Atwater in the 1980's. It was later refined by his protégé, Karl Rove, and adopted by the Stephen Harper Conservatives.

Professor Russell D. Renka, of Southeast Missouri State University, explored such practices in his 2010 paper, "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly of Public Opinion Polls."

"All such ugly polls commit gross violations of ethical standards of behavior," according to Renka. "They masquerade as legitimate objective surveys, but then launch into statements designed to prejudice respondents against a specific candidate or policy."

While this technique is not illegal, it quite obviously crosses an ethical line. It is one of many tools that the Conservative party employs to suppress and confuse voters.

There is no doubt that the techniques employed by the Harper Conservative party are effective at their core objective of suppressing the opposition vote and getting out theirs. Like the barrage of negative advertising three years before a general election, these tactics raise very important questions about the corrosive impact they have on our democracy. And as such, they deserve rigorous scrutiny from serious journalists and parliamentarians.

*NOTE: A previous version of this blog suggested that the company RMG was involved in push polls. On further checking I am satisfied that RMG was not involved in this polling though others were. I regret any incorrect information to that effect being published.

 

Follow Daniel D. Veniez on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@danveniez

FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
The Canadian
Stop Harper
07:26 PM on 04/11/2012
The Conservatives new strategy is to continue hatching a new scandal every time the previous scandal seems to be growing to epic proportions. As soon as the new scandal comes, the media and everyone else forget the first one and latch onto the next one.

I call it the "Squirrel!" strategy.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tyler Austin
Women = people. Corperations ≠ people.
08:47 PM on 04/07/2012
Whats it matter? They're going to walk away from both.

I'm starting to think that Canadians just arn't a people ready for democracy yet.
08:38 AM on 04/07/2012
I am a UK fulltaxpaying citizen voter who has been studying the fraudulent expenses and other claims of MPs in the UK parliament since the Conway Scandal became public knowledge! I note that a senior official of the ruling Conservative Party Leader has been reported in the UK press as winging his way over to Canada to pick up tips from the 'successful Canadian Conservative Prime Minister' on 'how to target minority groups' more effectively! I can only assume that the UK Conservative Party, the major player in the UK Coalition Government, is intending to study and adopt the reprehensible political strategies highlighted here! Feel free to refuse this official access to your country if you wish!

www.johnlbell.blogspot.com
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
4evercanadian
Still my guitar gently weeps
11:49 AM on 04/07/2012
Good luck, and I really hope that what is going on here doesn't happen there. I have a large number of relatives living there and I wouldn't wish this on them. Not sure if you have to worry about robocalls, but here something that might help you:

How to move votes: http://sandrafinley.ca/?p=4859

Contains a link to this video originally posted by someone else in these forums: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sennr_y02Ro
03:52 PM on 04/07/2012
Thanks, 4evercanadian!
I will follow these up and try to add the link to my posts on the subject to the online version of the UK The Independent Newspaper where I often comment on the antics of our UK MPs!
Thanks again!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
12:41 AM on 04/07/2012
Jo go dog good article will share on my wall Tom

I feel some men have some balls after all

O
11:30 PM on 04/06/2012
Thank you Mr. Veniez - You are spot on about this issue dying down , despite that it could save us all.

I am very disappointed about this lack of interest. After all, Robocalls is election fraud ["voter suppression"] and therefore we just might have an illegitimate government in a majority position.

With that illegitimacy considered, the Conservatives have no right to decide Canada's future, and they are changing the vision in radical ways. The CPC-Harper vision for Canada is totally a negative one: F-35 killing machines, an economy based on "boiled Canada" [see Matt Price], and for us in BC, "DilBit in the coast, through the mountains and salmon streams" [Gateway pipeline]. NO WAY, we say, and yet there go we.

Only 37% of Canadians "may or may not" have voted for this crew, yet we and future Canadians will have to live with these mistakes, with decisions based on ignoring science, democracy, and fair play; Mistakes propelled with oil money, payola. Mistakes by Randroids who chant "nothing matters but to increase shareholder value", and they believe it.

And then the great gift of Robocalls comes along with the potential to remove this dangerous, irresponsible, illegitimate government in PM Harper and crew!! We should all be very engaged on the Robocalls issue - I have to read Hansard to get the latest.... is media control yet another irresponsible tactic the Harper govt uses? Uh huh.
photo
yukoner1
Living way up the left coast.
11:17 PM on 04/06/2012
Great story on the F35 fiasco on CPAC right now.
01:31 PM on 04/06/2012
I'm sorry Mr. Veniez your article seems self-serving. My leading question would be, "Was there money taken from Skeena Cellulose profits to enhance Eastern pulp mills"?
That ($470mil) meant people(workers) losing 20 plus years of pension and a community losing 600 families directly over the short term.
I don't agree with the Robocall issue or the F-35 fiasco. I do find your mention of unethical behavior ironic. Explain ethical behavior and Skeena Cellulose to readers.
photo
albertarick
These are questions for wise men with skinny arms
12:15 PM on 04/06/2012
The Commons procedure and House affairs committee voted that “the government’s failure to produce documents constitute a contempt of Parliament” and that “this failure impedes the House in the performance of its functions. How is it that the Prime Minister is not once again in contempt of Pariament with the AG report? Was this a backroom deal with when the NDP alluded to a "big fight" promised if the budget was too focused on cuts? Either way between the robocalls and this latest disaster we need a new election.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mike Keohane
12:08 PM on 04/06/2012
I don't think it's really an issue of the government being corrupt or having hidden ideological agendas. The government is just incompetent. They have dropped the ball on so many things. This government could screw up the procurement of a cheese sandwich.
photo
albertarick
These are questions for wise men with skinny arms
01:29 PM on 04/06/2012
You are correct about not having a hidden agenda. It is right out there for all to see. On the point of corruption however, there was just a Auditor General report that just called the PM and DM responsible for the obfuscation of the facts on the F35 issue. Commiting the taxpayers to billions of dollars under false pretenses is pretty corrupt in my book.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
okgranny
Egalitarian by birth
06:18 PM on 04/06/2012
The Harper government is a perfect example of "The Peter Principle" having reached their level of incompetence, they are a menace to good governance. Peter Mckay could be their poster boy/
08:13 AM on 04/06/2012
Great post M. Veniez

Will it be possible to turn some Conservative operatives in order to expose the depth of corrupt, illegal tactics used by the Neocons ?

This might be the best route towards rolling back the cancer that is movement conservatism.
02:08 AM on 04/06/2012
While we are it, let's also send more than 1 crooked Liberal to Jail for the Sponsorship Scandal. keep digging. And Muldoon too.
photo
albertarick
These are questions for wise men with skinny arms
12:17 PM on 04/06/2012
Send every crooked politician and bureaucrat to Jail for whatever their crimes were. Time for some real accountability.
photo
BCSLAVE
Got a key?
11:25 PM on 04/05/2012
I agree this needs to never go away until the culprits and ringleaders at caught. Second, there needs to be by elections in all riding's were mass illegal impersonating suppression calls were made because it spoiled all the ballots. The government today is illegitimate until it wins a fair and open election, something the evidence is showing they have yet to do. To let the mater drop and do otherwise is to allow an organized criminal cabal get away and do it again and again. They will and have made a mockery of our democracy and all the soldiers who gave their lives to defend it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thalin Lea
11:17 PM on 04/05/2012
This is kind of scary what conservative are doing, everything seems sooooooo well planed since the beginning.

All that comes to my mind is : minister of defense planing to make a billionaire purchase of some F-35s planes, but they need to stay in power on a second mandate in order to make effective the purchase. Then ..who knows ... somebody related to this purchase decide to hire a whole call center on the States to make sure the conservative party remains in power by doing dirty robot-calls tricks and this way they will get more conservative MP elected and that purchase becomes a real transaction. Resuming, Canada's democracy is in danger and threatened on daily basis as far as this bunch of western cowboys remain in power. There should be a way to get rid of them , elections Canada may have the last and definitive word. To my eyes we have been governed since last elections by an illegitimate party.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
05:19 PM on 04/05/2012
The real shame here is that Harper knows his staunch followers believe he can do no wrong. They believe that he is on their side, and has proven himself by his 'tough on crime' legislation, and his pledge to slay the deficit and reduce the size of government. Harper paints his adversaries as left wing loonies who want to return the country to nature and wreck the economy and spend all the money on welfare bums.

The truth is that the only parts of the government Harper wants to shrink are those departments whose functions are to regulate and oversee the financial sector, food safety, the environment, transport and the drug and medical industries. Oh, and CBC and Katimavik, of course. Every Conservative government has increased the size of the bureaucracy (massive patronage appointments) increased the deficit, and increased the debt, and handed billions to corporations.

F-35 scandal? Robocalls? Just unleash Stephen Woodworth to rally the Pro-Life troops, and refocus the followers on the ‘important’ things. After all, any party whose members are Pro-Life must be at the right hand of God, no?

The truth is that the only part of the government Harper wants to shrink those departments whose functions are to regulate and oversee the financial sector, food safety, the environment, transport and the drug and medical industries. Oh, and CBC and Katimavik, of course. Every Conservative government has increased the size of the bureaucracy (massive patronage appointments) increased the deficit, and increased the debt.
08:44 PM on 04/05/2012
And the Wheat Board and pensions and health care and a justice system which was working and anything else which makes sense such as the long form census and the long gun registry. God forbid mercy or commonsense or experts or inteligence enter into any decision of the Harper government.
09:05 AM on 04/06/2012
>>>God forbid mercy or commonsense or experts or inteligence enter into any decision of >>>the Harper government

It is not disorganized.
It is not random.
It is the road they chose by design.

The end game is not to improve life for the average Canadian.

The end game is to perpetuate their reign and consolidate their grip on power.

The trouble is that their philosophy and dirty tricks work for gaining power but fail miserably when it come to the business of governing.

They are the Republican party of Canada.

They must be ushered out of power.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tony frm Banff
Search for truth,not spin
09:31 PM on 04/05/2012
F and F, nice comment and insightful LDW.