Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
David Frum

GET UPDATES FROM David Frum
 

What I Learned From My Sister

Posted: 10/23/11 10:34 AM ET


Away at camp in the summer of 1976, I received an unusual flurry of postcards from my mother.

"Unusual" because my mother did not like to write by hand: Her right arm had been injured in early childhood, forcing her, unnaturally, to use her left for manual tasks.

The time is coming (she wrote) when you and Linda will be forced to rely much more upon each other.

It would be another year before I was told that my mother had been diagnosed with the cancer that would kill her. Yet even in advance of the formal revelation, my sister and I lived in a house unusually conscious of mortality. My mother would live with cancer from 1974 until 1992, 18 years. But she was not given 18 years to live. She was given two years to live, nine times.

My mother's premonition was right. My sister and I were introduced to a heavy load of mutual emotional responsibility at an early age. But we did not carry it. It carried us.

My wife comments that I am one of nature's pessimists. I take a generally dark view of human nature. I don't deny that people will sometimes act kindly or generously. I just don't expect it.

Linda is very different. She is an enthusiast and a booster. She sees the best in people, makes the widest allowance for human failings, and is always ready to believe in the possibility of change and improvement.

You can see why Linda has flourished in politics. Through the hard years from 1993 through 2006, Linda tirelessly championed the fluctuating cause of Canadian Conservatism. Even after the reunion of the shattered party, the new Conservatives met suspicion and resistance in the Toronto business community. They were mistrusted as too western, too socially conservative.

Linda's house became the forum in which the new party met its business constituency. She worked especially hard to shift the Toronto Jewish community from its old, obsolete attachment to the Liberals. When Stephen Harper at last emerged as the leader of a united party, Linda threw herself into the fight to elect him prime minister.

She sponsored events, smiled her way through disappointments, raised money, and -- much more necessary -- raised spirits.

Politics is a very human business. Only very rarely are votes won by logical argument. Much more often, they are won by a remembered name, an arm around the shoulder, a moment of human connection.

I've watched a lot of politicians close up. And though Linda is not strictly speaking a politician, it is from watching her that I've learned most about the temperament and personality a politician needs.

In 2009, Linda was elevated to the Senate. The swearing-in ceremony is quite funny. Senators take an oath written in a mock ye-olde style of English, whose main theme is... attendance.

I, ABC, do solemnly swear to attend wheresoever Her Majesty the Queen to summon me, and to do whatsoever business Her Majesty the Queen requires, and to remain in such place for howsoever long it shall please Her Majesty the Queen to require my presence, etc. etc.

Yet any thought of the Senate as a sinecure has shriveled, as I have watched Linda diligently discharge the duties of her office. The days are long, the work is hard, and the separation from family is onerous. The day must come when Canada finally reaches a consensus on how to reform its Senate. Legislators should be elected, that seems pretty basic. But it's not the senators who pose the obstacle to reform.

Some have asked: How has your sibling helped you to develop as a person? That is a nearly impossible question to answer. Linda and I have so formed each other from such an early age that there is no "before" for me to measure against some "after." But I can say that there is no thought I have about public or private life that has not been touched in some way by her influence or example.

And if Canada never does get around to Senate reform? Well, I have to admit, I won't be altogether sorry.

This blog was previously published by the National Post.

 
 
 

Follow David Frum on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@davidfrum

Away at camp in the summer of 1976, I received an unusual flurry of postcards from my mother. "Unusual" because my mother did not like to write by hand: Her right arm had been injured in early chi...
Away at camp in the summer of 1976, I received an unusual flurry of postcards from my mother. "Unusual" because my mother did not like to write by hand: Her right arm had been injured in early chi...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 26
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
TT Esty1
Failure is a temporary condition.
04:09 AM on 10/25/2011
I agree with Mr. Frum. Using the Senate as a place to warehouse constituency volunteers not only smacks of nepotism but demeans the individual appointed by implying that it is not what one knows but who one knows. Can we really have respect for a House composed of friends of the Boss especially since the Boss holds that same House in low regard? Harper seems to be saying that the Senate is so irrelevant that it doesn't matter who is appointed as long as they can spell 'Conservative'.

As for all that work that Senators do, why?
09:10 PM on 10/24/2011
I have one Brother, & he has always been my BFF !
09:08 PM on 10/24/2011
God Love All Brothers & Sisters !
09:07 PM on 10/24/2011
No matter where you are from, siblings are always special !
02:22 PM on 10/24/2011
Can some US neocon company pleeeeease give this guy a job coming up with catchy war slogans.

Because pretending to be a sensitive new age guy is insulting my intelligence.
12:24 PM on 10/24/2011
David, you and your sister have been a source of consternation to me. I was a big fan of your mother who was a terrific and progressive journalist and CBC anchor. How can it be that both of you have turned so much against the values that she raised you with? Was it your dad's real estate tycoon's influence? You should know that there are many many knowledgeable people (yes, even some who spent careers in the financial industry) who hold conservative ideology responsible for the economic difficulties the world is facing. You can't push for short term profits at all cost, massively deregulate, expect public bail-outs when things don't work out as planned, and then blame governments for running high deficits. Shame on you all!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Peddler
Peddler of Information
11:53 AM on 10/24/2011
Sometimes, everything is not what it appears to be-----we see what we want to see and hear what we want to hear-------paint it as you see it------and hear as you hear it.
photo
thejazz
I'll burn that bridge when I come to it.
10:04 AM on 10/24/2011
The only reason to reform the senate in Canada is to create gridlock, and promote the conservative "do nothing" policy that works so well here in the United States.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Troff
I am not superstitious
09:37 AM on 10/24/2011
I for one am happy that David Frum is around to remind us of the time when conservatism was an ideology and not a psychosis. We may not agree on much but we do seem to agree that the current Republican party is so deep into the woods that it's no use to go looking for them.
11:02 AM on 10/24/2011
Yeah, I agree. Reading rational conservative thought is like reading Elizabethan prose: It may have vanished long ago but you can't help but admire it.
11:55 AM on 10/24/2011
"Rational" can be a subjective descriptive.

Frum writes, "She worked especially hard to shift the Toronto Jewish community from its old, obsolete attachment to the Liberals," and then "Politics is a very human business. Only very rarely are votes won by logical argument."

Frum makes the first statement in service of his own brand of ideological calculation which is blueprinted in the latter. There's your "rational."
09:21 AM on 10/24/2011
David, I know your trying to be conciliatory, but 95% of communication is non verbal. You have aligned yourself people that trying to destroy our country under the guises of smaller Government. Its anti-American because our Gov. is the only part of this nation that is the USA. The rest our states. Move away form that ideology before this country brings out pitch forks and we all lose. Remember history? What is downfall of every empire? Its corruption, nepotism and too large of gap between rich and poor. I can not believe that conservatives haven't figured this out and figured out if they push their assault on the common man they will some day rise up and take it. Just remember fellow citizens who would quell such anarchy traditionally won't kill fellow citizens for people with no compassion. I think your probably a good person relative to the rest of us. That is why I asking you to think about this. Thx
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PrometheanSalvation
Bringing fire to cleanse the land.
04:06 AM on 10/24/2011
Mr Frum, I was sorry to here that you felt the Republican party had so moved beyond your views that you felt you could no longer represent them as a counter weight to Dr Reich on NPR. Though I often disagreed with you, I felt that there was at least some logical consistency to your views and thought you a good spokesperson for them. I hope that you are able to find a place in the modern world of politics and wish you the best in your future endeavors.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sonshine
Truth over ideology.
01:06 AM on 10/24/2011
I don't know much about the Frum family but from what I gather, David is willing to admit when he has been wrong and try to make it right. Hopefully his sister Linda has that same awesome quality. I met David Frum and read his site daily and he seems like a genuinely good person.
photo
thejazz
I'll burn that bridge when I come to it.
09:49 AM on 10/24/2011
you are correct, you really don't know the Frum family.
photo
tippisheadrun
Get 2 birds stoned at once
12:51 AM on 10/24/2011
Unlike his adopted aboriginal brother, who seems to have been written completely out of the Frum family's universe since sis Linda trashed him so effectively in her book about their Mom.
12:16 AM on 10/24/2011
"I take a generally dark view of human nature... Linda is very different... She sees the best in people ... and is always ready to believe in the possibility of change and improvement." Sounds like a good explanation of the fundamental psychological difference between a neoconservative and a 'progressive' conservative.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
McGuffin18
Yee-Haw is not a foreign policy
11:09 PM on 10/23/2011
"I take a generally dark view of human nature."

Not me. I just take an exceptionally dark view of neoconservatives and Enterprise Institute types.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Margo Arrowsmith
Elizabeth Warren in 2016!
08:07 AM on 10/24/2011
Fanned and faved.  It seems that they are looking in the mirror when they talk about 'human nature'