Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
David Menzies

GET UPDATES FROM David Menzies
 

War on Christmas Reaches Defcon One

Posted: 12/24/11 10:56 AM ET

Is it just me, or did the War on Christmas ramp-up to Def-Con 1 status this year?

Item: School buses in Kingston, Ont., are forbidden to display any sort of Christmas decorations. Safety first, you understand. After all, that Santa Claus poster affixed to the roof of the bus might somehow impair the driver's vision.

Item: Home Hardware is marketing something called a "pre-lit tree" that looks very much like a... Christmas tree. No, I've never heard of a "pre-lit tree" either. Still, isn't there a bigger issue at play? Presumably, only Christians are in the market for Christmas trees in the first place. Why would a retailer think that calling a Christmas tree a "Christmas tree" would be offensive to Christian consumers of Christmas trees? It simply does not compute.

Item: In August, I drove by a York Region police station with a video message board wishing everyone a "Happy Ramadan." I don't have an issue with the cops wishing those of the Muslim faith a Happy Ramadan. But it would've been quite jolly to see that same video board wishing folks a Merry Christmas come late December. Instead, motorists are greeted with the lame "Happy Holidays" salutation. I really hate to be a nitpicker, but if Christmas is rebranded as a generic "holiday," then shouldn't Ramadan simply be referred to as a "holiday" too?

Of note, I pursued the matter regarding the double standard when it comes to the holiday double standard. Here's the official explanation courtesy of Tracy Smith of York Regional Police: Ramadan is identified by name is because "Ramadan is the only holiday in August" whereas December encompasses Christmas, Hanukkah, and the even the fake holiday of Kwanzaa; thus, the police just want to be "inclusive."

I informed Smith she is either misinformed or lying for there is indeed another holiday in August -- Simcoe Day. Her reply: "I'm sorry you feel that way."

Item: Without doubt, the Jump-The-Shark Award regarding this year's War on Christmas marketing goes to Christine McGee of Sleep Country Canada. In radio ads promoting Sleep Country's Boxing Week sale (already underway), the CEO rhetorically asks, "Why wait unit after the holiday [singular]" to take advantage of Boxing Day discounts? It's an uncanny statement given that Boxing Day, by definition, always occurs on December 26. That's the day after Christmas -not the day after Hanukkah or even the day after Festivus. And yet, even in this scenario, McGee just can't bring herself to utter the "C"-word. Amazing.

Still, the point of my rant isn't to merely bemoan the War on Christmas. That's old hat. Rather, I want to suggest an option when it comes to standing up to those waging war on Christmas. Namely, fighting back. The weapon of choice: your pocketbook.

Thus, during this "holiday season", I decided to go out of my way to patronize only those merchants that actually used the word "Christmas" in their TV, radio, or newspaper ads.
It's slim pickings, but there are still some merchants that aren't terrified to say "Christmas."
So it was that I purchased a table from Bad Boy and a set of headphones from 2001 Audio Video. And I made certain to tell the clerk in each case why I selected their store. (As a side note, neither clerk was Christian, yet they both agreed that avoiding the "C" word at Christmastime was ludicrous. So kindly remind me again: Who are we protecting from being offended?)

I also plan to write the CEOs of these chains, informing them why I chose to patronize their stores. As an army of one, it will be hard to make headway. But if enough people do likewise in the Decembers to come, maybe there's a chance we can collectively make a tangible difference regarding the War on Christmas.

Won't you join me?

 
Is it just me, or did the War on Christmas ramp-up to Def-Con 1 status this year? Item: School buses in Kingston, Ont., are forbidden to display any sort of Christmas decorations. Safety first, you u...
Is it just me, or did the War on Christmas ramp-up to Def-Con 1 status this year? Item: School buses in Kingston, Ont., are forbidden to display any sort of Christmas decorations. Safety first, you u...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 33
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
04:19 AM on 12/27/2011
HUH? What war on Christmas? Where have you been over the last 20 years? This is Canada remember, and we don't give a spit what they call it or when, we still go shop and do all those pagan things that we pagans wee children like. Get over it. This is not the US or a Fox news replay. Were Canadians eh?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
03:18 AM on 12/27/2011
I shopped all day, started at 4:00 am. Boxing day is now my xmas.
03:06 AM on 12/27/2011
Very impressed by my fellow Nucks here. Thought I was the only sane one left. I mean the comments of course, not the article.

I do however have a new name on my list of professional journalists to never ever ever take seriously. In fact David Menzies I am now permanently suspicious of anything you write about. There's no way Christmas is the only thing you write about without any idea what your talking about.

Yeesh, you even straddle between 2 different people with the same "Holiday (singular) not Holidays (plural)" argument. Did you brief the Sleep Country Lady about Tracy Smith's opinion about Ramadan and that her comments were to reflect the statements of someone she's probably never met? Do you know how bad of a journalist you have to be to not notice you're using the lack of an s on the end of a word said by one person in regards to one thing and transferring her opinion to a completely different person in a completely different context without any logical connection?
02:34 AM on 12/27/2011
But what if I use the word Christmas solely to fold in those that boycott people that use the word holiday, but don't believe in Christ or the spirit of Christmas myself? Wouldn't I just be taking advantage of people who don't understand the difference between honesty and rhetoric? Oh if only Jesus hadn't left us without giving us an idea of how he stood on using religion to make money...
photo
TT Esty1
Failure is a temporary condition.
01:54 AM on 12/27/2011
Yes, I agree entirely with both your premise and your strategy. It should be obvious to all but the obtuse that 'Christmas' has become a generic title like 'Kleenex' or 'Google' and, I might add, 'Easter'. One has only to think of the myriad of 'religious' holidays available to realize that few if any are celebrated outside the specific aggregation.

Certainly, 'Christmas' and 'Easter' have enhanced back stories but we all know that the names were substituted for event long practised by the populace. That we accepted the names and the quaint folk lore speaks to the adaptive nature of our species. This is not the time to go into the cruelties and avarice that the agencies of the names incurred suffice to say that the more positive elements remained because they were more rooted in the humanity of our species than in our story telling qualities.

Let us, therefore, allow the fantasies of all belief systems to revel in their time and those who, through attraction or curiosity, imbibe in the practise if not necessarily in the spirit. With certainty a pre-lit Menorah will follow a pre-lit Christmas Tree and a glowing Ramadan Moon.

In keeping with the joyous spirit of the time, may I wish you the greatest 'Ho, Ho, Ho'.
12:31 AM on 12/27/2011
To me "Christmas" is just the solstice celebration. I still do the gift giving and getting together thing but I could care less what it is called, personally I prefer Mōdraniht.
12:23 AM on 12/27/2011
Really? the measure of social acceptance of a religious holiday is the number of furniture retailers that employ the name of a holiday in an advertising campaign? and you think a salesman on the floor is going to give you an honest opinion? he makes 10 bucks an hour and the customer is always right.

Sadly, Christmas is not the holiday it used to be before retail surpassed worship as the dominant social force driving people's desire to observe the holiday. it hangs in the air and is all pervasive- like bad perfume. try looking for religious symbols next time and I bet you will find that your nostalgic view of Christmas is already dead. It wasn't fear that killed it, it was need to broaden marketing messages to take in the largest number of consumers.
06:33 PM on 12/26/2011
He needs to read David Frum's article on this subject: http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/david-frum/jesus-santa-christmas_b_1167848.html
04:07 PM on 12/26/2011
You lost me when you called Kwanzaa a fake holiday.
03:47 PM on 12/26/2011
"Won't you join me?"

No.
03:46 PM on 12/26/2011
your article ignores the blatant reality that many non-christians began celebrating christmas when they immigrated to Canada basically to fit in even though they do not believe in celebrating Christ's birth. They did it because there really wasn't a choice. Stores were generally closed over the holidays and kids returning to school had to deal with everyone getting gifts. Christmas has therefore evolved into a holiday and is celebrated as such. For many non-christians it is seen as a time of rest to spend with the family, share good food, gifts, and create memories. It is very different from Ramadan, Diwali, Hanukah etc. in that the majority of the population do not celebrate these holidays. We live in an ever-changing society that will very soon not be predominantly christian. Using happy holidays instead of merry christmas is just an accommodation. I agree with the other comments though, there are bigger problems in the world to be writing about.
03:07 PM on 12/26/2011
Seriously? Because God came to earth in the person of Jesus so he could be glorified in our shopping malls? If you are going to vote with your pocketbook do it at WorldVision or charity:water where your money will care about the same people Jesus did, the poor and oppressed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Helen In Canada
02:08 PM on 12/26/2011
I love this idea!
12:45 PM on 12/26/2011
It took me most of the way through the article to decide that the author is actually being serious and this is not just satire of the "war on Christmas" hyperbole. This would only need to be made slightly more outrageous to make for a decent article on "The Onion". No Mr Menzies, there are actual real wars in this world where people are being killed that I am more concerned about; I won't be joining you in your hyped up defense against the war on Christmas. I'll be using the normal criteria of price, quality, convenience and customer service to decide what stores get my xmas dollars in 2011. Happy holidays, season's greetings, happy yule!
photo
The Canadian
Stop Harper
01:37 PM on 12/26/2011
David Menzies also thinks there is a war on Remembrance Day too. I replied to his post on that, challenging his lies and BS.

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/david-menzies/in-remembrance_2_b_1088160.html
09:01 AM on 12/26/2011
Oh please, David Menzies, how pathetic this silliness is getting. Here's my advice as a Christian pastor. Christmas is what YOU make of it. If your enjoyment of and celebration of Christmas is dependent on what decorations school buses have or don't have, or on what name Home Hardware is using for a tree, or on what message a police station is flashing then it's you, sir, who have lost sight of the meaning of Christmas and who are badly in need of some pastoral advice. So let me offer it. Remember Jesus - not just his birth but how he lived and what he taught? Remember "why worry about the speck in your brother's eye when you have a plank in your own?" Remember "do not judge?" If you're so bothered by what everybody else is doing then you've obviously not learned those two lessons. Let it go, man. Christmas is what you do with - not what others do with it.