Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Denise Brunsdon

GET UPDATES FROM Denise Brunsdon
 

Lean In Until You Fall Over, Ladies -- You Still Won't Find Gender Balance

Posted: 12/27/2013 12:28 pm

Recent news has hit about two pieces of published Canadian research that fly directly in the face of this year's most popular women-in-business self-help book, Lean In.

The motto of Lean In is that women can overcome career challenges and break the glass ceiling by speaking up, growing supporters in the office and working hard.

Meanwhile, the Conference Board of Canada has found that an "unconscious bias" leads companies to underestimate and overlook young women employees. The study results demonstrate that only 45 per cent of young women are likely to be identified as "high potential" compared to 53 per cent of their male peers, even though 74 per cent of young women display the characteristics of "high performers" compared to only 66 per cent of their male peers.

Similarly, the Gandalf Group's C-Suite Executive Survey for the Report on Business, BNN and KPMG has found -- though women face under-representation on boards and in senior positions -- a majority of C-Suite executives are unconcerned about the disparity. A full 64 per cent of respondents say they're satisfied with the number of women in their company's executive roles. In case you're counting, 42 per cent of TSX-listed companies have zero women on boards, 23 per cent have only one woman.

Another recent December report found that Canadian women MBA grads earn $8,167 less in salary in their first post-degree job, possibly because they also start out at a lower level.

The Canadian data

Critics can try to attack these data rather than address the issue, but they'll have little luck. I'd encourage everyone to review the reports in depth, and also to verify the top quality of these stats. Canada doesn't produce nearly as much public interest research as the United States, as a result of Statistics Canada cuts and other factors. But when we do it, we tend to do it well.

I've reviewed the data collection methodology wherever the information is not bluntly externally certifiable. Also, I used to work at the Gandalf Group and can confirm they have the most rigorous, integrity-focused public opinion data production and analysis. Their C-Suite Survey is no exception.

The Implication

So how can one reconcile the two schools of thought? The Lean In zeitgeist says individual women can take personal responsibility for failure and act to achieve success. Meanwhile, recent research says there is an unconscious bias in corporate Canada that prevents equally qualified women from attaining the same level of success as men, and even more concerning, that senior execs remain unconcerned.

Well, the answer is easy -- the two visions of how to achieve equality aren't reconcilable. The Lean In school is decidedly wrong. Their foundational belief that women just need to be better, do more, and proactively so, starts to sound a lot like the evil stepmother in the incredibly apt Cinderella parable. If you get all your regular chores done, and take on these special chores, then you can go to the ball.

This parable is especially relevant when you consider the rarely discussed StatsCan data that proves "men continue to have an overall greater involvement in paid work than women, and a lesser involvement in housework."

This is where the Lean In story starts to seem more like a fairy tale than reliable career advice. The symbolic few women who exemplify the method's success against all pre-discussed mathematical odds tend to be high income, are often not racialized, and are able to afford to extricate themselves from household labour inequality.

The Result

Let's be clear: the term "unconscious bias" is an inoffensive way of saying that corporate Canada is discriminatory, specifically based on gender. Another word to describe this is sexist. I'm happy to use whatever pragmatic language encourages business people to be self-aware without becoming self-conscious.

For what it's worth, to anyone feeling self-conscious about the gender discrimination or sexism inside their organizations, it's not your fault. It is no individual's fault. We are all part of a system of movies, images, music, fairy tails and family stories that affirm two distinct and harmful gender roles. This system tells us that women are more suited for things sugar and spice, and everything nice, like working retail or in mid-priced, dimly-lit franchise restaurants. It also tells us that men are storm troopers of the corporate battlefield.

It's true for some people; It's not true for others. Leadership, business and home skills are gender irrelevant. The point is, broad stereotypes exist for all of us and harm all of us. They hurt women because we are women. They hurt men because every man has a capable woman in his life that he knows and loves. No gender is alone to blame, just as no gender is alone to solve the problem. In short, both men and women need to lean in to create equity in business. It's the only way to achieve balance.

ALSO ON HUFFPOST:

Loading Slideshow...
  • United States

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>12 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> No national program but cash benefits may be provided at the state level.

  • Iceland

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>3 Months <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 80

  • Germany

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>14 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Japan

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>14 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 67

  • Malta

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>14 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • New Zealand

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>14 Weeks Paid, 38 Weeks Unpaid<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Switzerland

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>14 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 80

  • Belgium

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>15 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 82 per cent for the first 30 days and 75 per cent for the remaining period.

  • Finland

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>105 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 70

  • Slovenia

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>105 Days <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Austria

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>16 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • France

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>16 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Latvia

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>112 Days <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Luxembourg

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>16 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Netherlands

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>16 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Spain

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>16 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Greece

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>119 Days <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 50

  • Australia

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>18 Weeks <br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> Each parent can take up to 12 months of leave, of which 18 weeks are paid.

  • Lithuania

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>126 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Belarus

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>126 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Moldova

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>126 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Ukraine

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>126 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Romania

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>126 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 85

  • Portugal

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>120 to 150 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> Parental benefits paid at 100 per cent for the shorter duration of leave and 80 per cent for the longer option

  • Estonia

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>140 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Poland

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>20 Weeks<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Russia

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>140 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Italy

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>5 Months<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 80

  • Bulgaria

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>135 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong>90

  • Hungary

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>24 Weeks<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 70

  • Ireland

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>26 Weeks<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 80

  • Czech Republic

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>28 Weeks<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 60

  • Slovakia

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>28 Weeks<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 55

  • Macedonia

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>9 Months<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> Not found.

  • Norway

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>36 to 46 Weeks<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> Parental benefits paid at 100 per cent for the shorter duration of leave and 80 per cent for the longer option.

  • Albania

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>365 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 80 per cent prior to birth and for 150 days after and 50 per cent for the rest of the leave period. <i>Albanian Prime Minister Sali Berisha shown here</i>.

  • Bosnia And Herzegovina

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>1 Year<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 82 per cent for the first 30 days and 75 per cent for the remaining period.

  • Canada

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>52 Weeks<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 55 per cent at 17 weeks for maternity leave, and the additional 35 weeks can be taken by either parent. Wages also depend on province.

  • Croatia

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>1 Year<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Denmark

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>52 Weeks<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • Serbia

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>52 Weeks<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 100

  • United Kingdom

    52 Weeks 90 (p)

  • Sweden

    <strong>Length Of Maternity Leave: </strong>420 Days<br><strong>Percentage Of Wages Paid:</strong> 80

 

Follow Denise Brunsdon on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@brunsdon

FOLLOW CANADA BUSINESS