Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Diane Francis

GET UPDATES FROM Diane Francis
 

Europe Boots Out its Political Morons

Posted: 11/21/11 03:43 PM ET

The party that calls itself Europe is over.

The sovereign debt crisis afflicting its weakest members has ended the eurozone's political Ponzi scheme -- the proclivity to hand out entitlements today and run up a tab due tomorrow.

The continent's La Dolce Vita lifestyle will disappear along with subsidies; cushy civil servant jobs; six-week holidays; 30-hour work weeks, Freedom 50 retirements and its people's belief that the world owes them a living.

This is the Great Markdown in Europe. A more gradual one is underway in North America. Both are due to debts, deficits, demographics and democracy.

Europe's situation is compounded by its badly devised, decentralized and balkanized fiscal regime -- one currency for 17 out of 27 countries and a central bank in each nation state. This is like herding cats and unsustainable as last week's political upheavals revealed.

Two democratically-elected leaders in Greece and Italy were unceremoniously pushed aside and replaced by technocrats and the IMF.

Greece's prime minister was replaced by a de facto "bankruptcy trustee" whose job is to take orders from the IMF, in the hopes of turning around the bankrupt country.

Then Italy's playboy prime minister was replaced by a "soft receiver," Mario Monti. He's a tough-minded academic, with huge political and moral leverage across the European Union, who will make Margaret Thatcher look like Mother Teresa.

By the way, Italy is not a basket case like Greece, Ireland or Portugal. But its bonds are under siege, which could prove ruinous for the region, and this is not due to fundamentals but to trading games that can be halted as described below.

Here are some facts about Italy:

  • Total government assets in Italy are slightly less than the total of its public debts.
  • Italy could raise an estimated 45 billion euro by selling its stake in oil giant ENI, utility ENEL, Poste Italiane or aerospace conglomerate Finmeccanica alone and Monti loves privatizations.
  • Offsetting Italy's high public debt, of 120 per cent of GDP, is its low household debt of 42 per cent. By comparison, the U.S. and Canada have public debts of 90 per cent and 80 per cent respectively, but their household debts are among the highest in the world or above 160 per cent of GDP.


By the way, the relatively seamless transition from elected to technocrats is a healthy and necessary way to circumvent short-term democracies which have failed to cope with this crisis. This is no different than a private sector "workout" where the CEO is removed from a failing corporation and is replaced by the bankers' representatives.

Those reforms are now in place and new leaders in Portugal, Ireland and Spain (in this weekend's election) are kowtowing to the dictates of bondholders and bankers.

But financial reform is necessary in order to arrest and cool off the world's hot money. These are hedge funds and others who have caused the sovereign debt contagion and profited from it by making self-fulfilling short-selling bets.

A fascinating set of remedies has been suggested this week by Leonard Waverman, dean of the Haskayne School of Business at the University of Calgary and former professor at London University.

He rightly suggests that the Euro crisis is similar to the Asian contagion in 1997 when speculators picked off one currency after another. The difference is that, in this case, there is one currency, the euro, but the similarity is that there are the bonds of 17 eurozone members to pick off. This permits a "classic run" because the bonds are substitutes for currencies that can be pummelled down in value for a profit.

"These one-way bets are yielding large profits to some at the expense of hundreds of millions of people," said Waverman.

It is time to put "sand in the wheels" of the "herd" through "capital controls." These include eurozone members mopping up embattled bonds and paying higher than market prices to destroy short-seller profit-taking; raising margin requirements to 50 per cent or more and imposing a Tobin Tax on trades.

It's interesting that in an imperfect currency union, the bonds of each country behave like separate currencies to market players. Waverman also notes that Malaysia was able to avert a currency run in 1997 by deploying such controls.

The European situation is considerably more serious than next week's "drama." The U.S. Congressional "super committee" is supposed to come up with $1.5 trillion in cuts and tax hikes by the end of the week, but they are also politically challenged.

Investors are assuming nothing will be accomplished. This means that the only big news will be if these American politicians actually agree to make cuts before the football games start on Thanksgiving Day.
But don't count on it. The Europeans stand a better chance of fixing their problems before the 2012 U.S. federal election because they have learned how to unseat the incompetents in between elections.

-- Financial Post

 

Follow Diane Francis on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@dianefrancis1

The party that calls itself Europe is over. The sovereign debt crisis afflicting its weakest members has ended the eurozone's political Ponzi scheme -- the proclivity to hand out entitlements today a...
The party that calls itself Europe is over. The sovereign debt crisis afflicting its weakest members has ended the eurozone's political Ponzi scheme -- the proclivity to hand out entitlements today a...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Larry Mutter
04:39 PM on 11/22/2011
We are not talking about a business we are talking about nations,this is simply a shock doctrine coup by the financial elite. The long term goal is austerity to lower wages to up profits.It amazes me how we find a way to blame wage earners for all the worlds problems.To put unelected bankers in charge of countries is the final insult.The one per cent should enjoy their wealth while they still have it,
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:48 PM on 11/22/2011
"By the way, the relatively seamless transition from elected to technocrats is a healthy and necessary way to circumvent short-term democracies which have failed to cope with this crisis. This is no different than a private sector "workout" where the CEO is removed from a failing corporation and is replaced by the bankers' representatives."

That, Ms Francis, is otherwise known as a coup. Which, here in America, is also called treason. I recommend resisting the urge toward ego inflation and the advocating of policies that are fundamentally unconstitutional, lest you find yourself on the authoritarian side of history, part of that long list of usurpers and destroyers. This is a country of people - one person, one vote - not a corporation. Your words betray your comfort with that top-down, dictatorial hierarchy, and your lack of attention to the ideas out of which America was conceived - that there are urges toward power that must be checked, or freedom becomes what usurpers and dominators decide it will be.

www.offthgridmpls.blogspot.com
03:11 PM on 11/22/2011
It is painfully obvious that the short sellers are doing to European Governments what they did to Lehman Brothers and Bear Stearns in 2008. Those who are colluding in the short selling need to be taught a very severe lesson. I think that what everyone is missing is that the manufactured CRISIS has given Germany hegemony in Europe without firing a shot. Perhaps all the short selling is coming from BERLIN. The situation in Europe won't be resolved until Germany is kicked out of the European Union.
11:21 PM on 11/21/2011
Government price controls will not save the Euro. Ask the Brits how well that turned out for them in 1992? Soros called their bluff and the Wall Street sharks today will do the same.They are chomping at the bit. They to will call the bluff of any smoke and screen operations the Euro-elites may attempt to employ to keep their failed experiment alive. The Euro was doomed to failure.The markets don't lie. As much as people complain about speculators, they are often the first ones to ferret out rogue companies and inefficient governance.
12:45 AM on 11/22/2011
Sorry, I don't agree with you. "The Markets" act from a more wholesome economic point of view irrational and/or destructive (not in the sense of "creative destruction"). The problem is amplified by high speed computerized trade.

For example, if you compare the current state of the British economy and the French, Dutch or Austrian economy it's certainly not understandable why the later are "pressured" and the UK is not.

On a broader scale it's irrational because:
A) no nation is able to just pay back all the sovereign debt in just a year or even a decade alone. The only sustainable option is to now embark on a course that will quickly balance the budgets and then start to pay back the accumulated debt continually.
B) the current practice of "gaming the system"/ creating self- fulfilling prophesies and then shorten the sovereign bonds to capitalize (in utter disregard of rational, national economic considerations) will probably only end in all nations taking extraordinary measures, like for example all EZ nations just defaulting on all (foreign held) sovereign debt or a harsh monetary reform.
So the result is a moral hazard only "The Markets" can solve for themselves since if they continue their current practice their institutions and investors will find themselves being legally, forcefully disowned. Because in the end, they are people, thus they are under national jurisdiction and unlike maybe their money they are not beyond the reach of the law.
12:52 AM on 11/22/2011
And please excuse me to say this bluntly (I mean no offense though): Your nonchalant claim or acceptance that it's "The Markets" who "ferret out [...] inefficient governance" is unbearable. Governments (and their efficiency) are controlled by parliament and parliaments are judged at the ballot box by their citizens with the help of free media.

Don't you think it's ironic that on the one hand some consider computer hacking as an act or at least a pre- stage of w@r but organized, foreign speculation against the wealth of sovereign nations not?
09:52 PM on 11/21/2011
I gotta laugh....you really think ENTITLEMENTS (aka socialism) did the dirty?

Take a GOOD look.....most of the problems are due to good, old fashioned, deregulated, laissez faire style capitalism.....as practiced by the banks, stock markets, oligarchs, and incompetent politicians.
09:10 PM on 11/21/2011
Modern day financial investment bankers have no more credibility than hackers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tomdavis
05:04 PM on 11/21/2011
The Tobin Tax is dead in Europe. At the November 10, 2011 EC meeting on the financial transactions tax (Tobin Tax), twenty-one EU finance ministers spoke on the subject.: Ten were against the FTT: the UK , Sweden, the Czech Republic, Malta, Cyprus, Italy, Ireland, Latvia, Bulgaria and Romania. Three others expressed serious reservations and would probably vote against it: Luxembourg, the Netherlands and Slovakia. Of the six finance ministers who did not speak at the conference, two are believed to be against the tax. There are 10-15 votes against the financial transactions tax which is not even close to the unanimous consent required for new EU/EZ taxes. The Swedish Finance Minister, Anders Borg, called it a "non-starter." There will be no EU or EZ Tobin Tax.
01:06 AM on 11/22/2011
Could you please provide a source? Because while your statement isn't refuted by the sources I know but it seems to me that your view represents the most conservative (or optimistic, depending on where you stand regarding the FTT) count.

For example, what I could read Italy was not fully opposed, just skeptical.

I do agree that there is only slim chance to implement it EU- wide (UK, Sweden). But I think it's possible EZ-wide; especially if you follow political dynamics. For example, if you look at your list of "opposition", one can pick out Malta, Cyprus(, Italy) and Ireland who will, because of their dire situation and (future) need for help by France, Austria, Germany and Finland, probably reluctantly compromise.

From the people's point of view (and supported by many economists) it makes sense. First, the current, deregulated situation is obviously damaging and needs to be fixed. Solving the sovereign debt situation needs the contribution of all national forces, including the financial sector. And last but not least, a fair share of the recent jump in sovereign debt is attributed to the damages incurred by the financial sector.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tomdavis
09:05 AM on 11/22/2011
I watched the entire meeting real-time via webcast with a friend of mine who lives in Sweden.

There were many arguments against the FTT: (a) First and foremost was the argument that the FTT isn't a tax on financial institutions, it's a tax on retail investors and retirement plans. This information was mentioned by the UK, the Netherlands and others who said that pensioners would end up paying a sizable portion of the tax. (b) Many other EU FMs referred to the EC "Impact Assessment Report" that predicted higher EU unemployment as a result of the FTT. One of the FMs(I think it was the Czech) pointed out that after factoring in the effects of unemployment and reduced GDP the FTT is actually a net negative tax because the income taxes lost will be greater than the FTT collected. (c) The Swedish FM said the EC study was overly optimistic because it over-estimated FTT revenues and underestimated unemployment. He also said it would increase the cost of capital thereby increasing the costs of goods and services resulting in a secondary "tax" on consumers. (d) Many others (e.g., Malta and Cyprus) were against the FTT unless was implemented worldwide, otherwise the financial sector would simply relocate to Switzerland, Hong Kong, Singapore, Canada, Australia, the US, China, Russia, South Korea etc.