THE BLOG

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Duncan Kinney Headshot

Brad Wall's Sask. A Wild West Of Corporate Political Donations

Posted: Updated:
BRAD WALL
PC
Print

When Brad Wall rolled through the Calgary Petroleum Club's wood-paneled walls on June 8, he got the headlines he wanted.

"We're in the middle of a battle and frankly we haven't been winning too many battles," said Wall about the oil and gas industry in a quote that made the rounds.

But the mainstream media didn't really clue in into as to why Wall was coming through Calgary. It was a fundraising pitch. And make no mistake -- Brad Wall is an incredibly successful out-of-province fundraiser.

The data on campaign donations is publicly available but it's a scan of a printout of a spreadsheet. It needs some work to be turned into something that's usable. We downloaded the last nine years of corporate donations returns for the Saskatchewan Party and used optical character recognition to build a spreadsheet so we could analyze the results and figure out where Wall's corporate donations actually came from. You can search the database by clicking here.

Weak election finance laws can have a toxic effect on the political process.

Since 2006 the Saskatchewan Party has raised $3,091,356.85 from out-of-province sources. More than $2 million of that came from Alberta. And that doesn't include money raised for the 2016 Saskatchewan election, which won't be available to look at until 2017.

This is for a province with a population of just over a million people. And only Saskatchewan, British Columbia, Newfoundland and Prince Edward Island accept out-of-province political donations. While Alberta just recently got corporate and union money out of provincial politics, it figured out 39 years ago that accepting out-of-province donations probably wasn't the best idea.

Tom Chambers was a Progressive Conservative MLA who rose in the Alberta legislature on May 13, 1977 to speak to Bill 24, the Election Finances and Contributions Disclosure Act:

"It is our view that the people of Alberta feel quite strongly on the subject of outside influence in our province and on our political system. Surely a political party in this province should survive on its own merits and with the support of the people of Alberta."

Read 39 years later, that's quite a rebuke to Saskatchewan's lax election finance laws. Not only are out-of-province donations OK in Brad Wall's Saskatchewan, but so are corporate and union donations. There are no donation limits of any kind, and out-of-country corporate donations are allowed as long as that corporation has a Canadian presence.

It really is the Wild West out in Saskatchewan.

crescent point energy
Scott Saxberg is the president and CEO of Crescent Point Energy, a Calgary-based company that donated more than $125,000 to the Saskatchewan Party since 2006. (Photo: REUTERS/Todd Korol)

Weak election finance laws can have a toxic effect on the political process. The Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development released a paper in April 2016 called Financing Democracy: Funding of Political Parties and the Risk of Policy Capture.

"If the financing of political parties and election campaigns is not adequately regulated, money may be a means for powerful special interests to exercise undue influence, and 'capture' the policy process," says the report.

When you find some of Brad Wall's largest corporate donors, his public statements start to make a lot more sense.

  • Crescent Point: 126,923.67
  • Cenovus: 68,108.06
  • Encana: 50,556.52
  • PCL: 88,817.29
  • PennWest: 83,347.71
  • CAPP: 5,612.33
  • Canadian Energy Pipeline Association: 8,882.40

Out-of-province corporate donations make up roughly a quarter of corporate donations to the Saskatchewan Party, but it's not just out-of-province donations that are problematic.

In going through the database we found that the Saskatchewan Party regularly accepts donations from taxpayer-funded municipalities, postsecondary institutions and other government-funded organizations. Brad Wall's Saskatchewan Party also accept donations from registered charities, other political parties and even the media that covers provincial politics.

Cities and towns like Estevan, Lloydminister, Meadow Lake, Tisdale, Birch Hills, Big River and Regina have all donated to the Saskatchewan Party. Groups like the Saskatoon Community Youth Arts Program and the Regina Public Library are regular donors. The two universities in Saskatchewan have donated over $12,000. Saskatchewan Polytechnic has donated over $6,000 in the same time.

For some reason he needs donations from the Regina Public Library, the Make a Wish Foundation and Ronald McDonald House to defeat his political opponents.

Even straight-up government agencies like Sask Film, the Lloydminster Public School Division and the Regina Qu'Appelle Health Region have sent money back to the Saskatchewan Party.

This has happened before. In the late stages of the Progressive Conservative regime in Alberta, the same stories broke. We learned that taxpayer dollars were being cycled from public organizations back to the ruling political party. While those donations were illegal according to Alberta law and eventually paid back, it's not clear if that's the case in Saskatchewan. Perhaps it's something Saskatchewan's auditor should look into.

Regardless, it is wrong and it needs to stop. While Brad Wall holds himself up as the great defender of Saskatchewan, for some reason he needs donations from the Regina Public Library, the Make a Wish Foundation and Ronald McDonald House to defeat his political opponents.

You can check if an organization you belong to has donated to the Saskatchewan Party at BradWallTookMoneyFromWho.ca, and if you think it's not OK to have government-funded agencies funding partisan politics it's time to get organized and stop it.

Follow HuffPost Canada Blogs on Facebook

Also on HuffPost:


Close
Saskatchewan Election 2016
of
Share
Tweet
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide