Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Erica Diamond

GET UPDATES FROM Erica Diamond
 

Has Madonna Still Got It? Yes.

Posted: 02/ 6/2012 2:07 pm

I love Madonna. I have loved Madonna from the moment she burst onto the scene in fishnet stockings, too much hairspray, and a bad die job.

If my iPod playlist isn't enough proof, well frankly, I don't know what is.

So you can imagine how excited I was to see Madonna perform the halftime show at the Superbowl. In fact, I love Madonna so much, I went to her concert in Montreal a few years ago with my girlfriend and my barf bag.

I puked for nine whole stinkin' months throughout both my pregnancies, and I would throw up any time, any place. But when I heard Madonna was coming to Montreal, I just couldn't miss it. Not even if it meant dancing on my feet for three hours, 9 months pregnant, 40 pounds heavier, with my barf bag in my purse.

But, let's return to halftime at the Superbowl. I left my house at 5:30 last night for a "girls" dinner when too much testosterone walked through the door after hockey practice at 5p.m. There were big men and little men. It involved the Superbowl, Dominos Pizza, a lot of chicken wings, and a ton of junk. I decided to put on my "awesome" mom hat, and buy the kids junk galore for a change, since I'm usually the killjoy who puts out tangerines and vegetables.

Dad's Oatmeal cookies are generally as rough as it gets around here. But anywhooo, I got gummies, jellies, kettle corn sweet n' salty popcorn, chips, swedish berries, etc... let's just say my boys were proud.

Once I put the goodies out, I left for dinner with my neighbour and her eight-year-old daughter. After some delicious Japanese food and a glass of wine, I darted home for halftime. I had to see Madonna live. With all the testosterone in the den, and the boys still in sugar-shock, I cranked up the surround sound and waited for Madonna with baited breath. Then, we heard it. Just the music, no Madonna, for "Vogue."



Alright. Let's be honest. Madonna didn't stand a chance. Of course the critics would rip her apart. Yes, she apparently lip synced. Yes, she hardly moved compared to her usual showcase of crazy awesome dance moves (she is rumoured to have a bad hamstring injury). Yes, she annoys people with that odd fake British accent. Yes, her new song is a little, well, again, annoying. Yes, she emits this overwhelming sense of narcissism. Yes, some say she was overshadowed last night by younger talent or even M.I.A who flipped the bird.

All that said, let's take her for what she is -- her past to present. This 53-year-old legend is just that: a legend. A doer. She is a reinventer. She can make Vogueing still current and relevant today. She can party with the Party Rockers. She can sing a duet with a young popstar and still rock it. You be 53, move like that, look like that, sing like that, dance like that, be a mom of four, have a history of decades of success, still push the bar, still stay relevant, and then come back and criticize.

I have discovered along the way that it is the people who never risk who are always the first to criticize. Who are the most judgmental. When you've walked into a sea of unknown and have risked, you don't judge. You know just how tough it is.

And those are my two cents on last night's Superbowl halftime and on life in general.

I'll be a Madonna fan for life: 'cuz she's raw and gritty, 'cuz she never goes down without a fight, 'cuz she has an insurmountable work ethic.

Madonna still remains, the mother of reinvention. And for that, she's got my respect.


 

Follow Erica Diamond on Twitter: www.twitter.com/WomenOnTheFence

I love Madonna. I have loved Madonna from the moment she burst onto the scene in fishnet stockings, too much hairspray, and a bad die job. If my iPod playlist isn't enough proof, well frankly, I don'...
I love Madonna. I have loved Madonna from the moment she burst onto the scene in fishnet stockings, too much hairspray, and a bad die job. If my iPod playlist isn't enough proof, well frankly, I don'...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
WomenOnTheFence
Founder and Editor-In-Chief of WomenOnTheFence.com
09:42 AM on 02/09/2012
Thank you all for your comments - the good, bad and ugly. :) I appreciate you taking the time to read the article and sharing your views.

Erica Diamond, WomenOnTheFence.com
09:15 PM on 02/07/2012
You just can't defend it, there is nothing lower than lip syncing for money.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kristopher Leang
training to take down the elite
03:17 PM on 02/07/2012
madonnas whole getup seemed trashy, used and boring as usual. way not to push the envelope madonna
02:57 PM on 02/07/2012
People always try to put Madonna in a box. They always project their own notions onto her. Both fans and nonfans place ridiculous limits on her. Neither camp has learned she will never allow herself to be placed in that box.

Madonna is a good singer with a good voice but doesn't have a huge voice. That's OK. She is a gifted songwriter who knows her way around a lyric and melody. Her songs run the gamut from serious to silly. And that's OK. She is a gifted dancer but doesn't always dance like a military drill team. She adds nuance and little touches that get lost in a huge stadium. That's OK.

Madonna is getting older but still looks and acts like she is ageless. It makes some of us uncomfortable but makes others joyous to see a vibrant woman taking on the notions of aging with gusto. That's also OK.

Let Madonna be Madonna and enjoy the ride. The ride is not for everyone and that's, you guessed it, OK!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
11:16 PM on 02/07/2012
'gifted songwriter'?

She's not a musician, she's never really written her own work.

She has stolen almost every 'genre' she every promoted including 'Voguing'.

She is a talented producer of her own Empire (not of music) and a decent entertainers.

That is it.
02:34 PM on 02/07/2012
Great article.

Yes, Madonna still has it. Always has, always will.

I have to laugh at all the lip syncing criticism. Michael Jackson lipped his entire SB performance. Whitney Houston's much heralded Star Spangled Banner rendition was lipped ( she even admitted to it). The NFL likely required the performance to be lipped ( due to technical reasons) but I did hear Like A Prayer was live as demanded by Madonna and Cee-Lo.

Anyone who saw Madonna's last tour knows she can still move as fast and quick as she ever has. She was suffering the lingering effects of a hamstring pull AND those boots were impossible to dance in ( what was she thinking?).

Madonna is an enormous talent- good singer, great songwriter, great performer, great inventor. Her new tour will likely break records again.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
11:18 PM on 02/07/2012
False.

Madonna is not a particularly good singer, moreover, she has a poor voice.

She hasn't ever really written - or even produced - her music.

She hires songwriters, producers, and many other creatives and directs them to copy/steal a style that is in vogue (no pun intended).

She has not 'invented' anything of particular.

But she puts it all together in a way that is her own, and that is respectable.
photo
john frodo
armchair expert
12:16 PM on 02/07/2012
I thought she was horrible, but I always thought that
11:13 AM on 02/07/2012
Congrats on your first Huffington Post appearance! I couldn't agree more with your viewpoint. A friend shared on Facebook that she was less than impressed with Madonna's performance. I thought, are you kidding me? You get up there and try what she's doing and then come back and let me know if you still feel that way. Madonna isn't the 20-something, or 30-something she was before--but she's evolved over time and is still spectacular.

Olisa, National Association of Professional Women (NAPW)
http://www.napw.com
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
11:19 PM on 02/07/2012
To define something as 'impressive' or 'not impressive' on the basis of whether or not 'your friend could do it' isn't exactly the best way to judge high end talent.
09:15 AM on 02/08/2012
Very true, but I didn't exactly list my entire criteria for what I feel is impressive in my 6-sentence comment.

Olisa
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
okgranny
Egalitarian by birth
09:58 PM on 02/06/2012
Madonna is simply wonderful, vibrant and ageless.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
11:19 PM on 02/07/2012
Up close, her age is quite obvious.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tammy Smith
Objectivism is theNew Fascism
09:23 PM on 02/06/2012
I liked Madonna better than Black Eyed Peas last year. They just underwhelmed me. Sure, Madonna is older & probably can't move as well. But I'm not much younger than her & I'm a little slower too. I just find all these jokes about her age to be kind of offensive. And the late Etta James was performing years after people would judge her as "old", but no one told her to stop.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lennbob
09:16 PM on 02/06/2012
I actually felt a little embarrassed for Madonna, reduced to *lip-synching* a 20-year-old song, and trotting out more current artists in a vain attempt to show she's still "relevant".

I don't care so much that Madonna is 53 and still doing dance music. Look at the Pet Shop Boys. But where PSB embrace current trends and fit them to their own style (they do co-produce their own records, after all), Madonna essentially hires the current trendmakers and tries to fit herself to *their* styles.

And that is largely why the last record of hers that I truly enjoyed (though the new song is actually quite catchy, in an "Oh, Mickey, you're so fine, you're so fine you blow my mind, hey, Mickey!" kind of way) was the Ray of Light album. Everything she's done since then shows her being a little *too* eager to re-cast herself in the mold of the pop stars du jour.

Madonna has had enough of an impact on pop music, and an influence on other artists—the Britneys and Christinas among them—that she should have long ago stopped trying to prove her relevance, and instead followed a musical path that was hers and hers alone. Instead, she's trying too hard to be the flavor of the moment, not realizing that nothing tops the original…
07:54 AM on 02/07/2012
Wonderfully said!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kristopher Leang
training to take down the elite
03:19 PM on 02/07/2012
soo truee her diehard fans will justify anything no matter how bad she is.. they are pathetic
09:08 PM on 02/06/2012
Has she still got it, yes she does..She looked great ..Those dancers performing on those bleachers were dangerous with flips all over the place ...I have never seen anyone do that..Her show was not a typical band performance it was a hollywood special. They all did a good job..
08:48 PM on 02/06/2012
...and she hides behind a wall of dancers, lights, props and hoopla.

Let the hate mail begin...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kristopher Leang
training to take down the elite
03:20 PM on 02/07/2012
nay you got a fan! couldnt have said it better