Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Gerald McEachern

GET UPDATES FROM Gerald McEachern
 

Suzuki and Tree-Huggers: Prepare for War

Posted: 04/27/2012 11:05 am

THE GAME is over. It's now all-out war.

This week, David Suzuki and his foundation came under attack by the ironically named Ethical Oil group, a new American anti-environmental video has been making the rounds online, and the $500,000 Koch brothers contribution to Canada's right-wing Fraser Institute made the news.

I don't know which of these I find most disturbing. Or maybe it's the combination of the three that we should find most disturbing. Because what we're seeing is the politicizing and distortion of science. And frankly, we will need a clear scientific perspective if we're to have any hope of keeping our complex human support system going on the planet.

David Suzuki is a scientist. Though he has become a communicator and an activist, nevertheless, it is science that informs him and motivates him. It's more than coincidental that Suzuki and his foundation have come under attack by the oil lobbyists just after the federal government accused the Canadian environmental movement taking money from and being under the influence of "foreign interests."

Back in February, Brian Jean, a Conservative member representing Fort McMurray and the tar sands region of Alberta announced that he planned to table a private member's bill aimed at outlawing foreign donations to Canadian environmentalist groups.

For those who missed it, this is tied to the oil industry's push to get federal approval to build the Northern Gateway pipeline from Alberta to the B.C. coast to export tar sands oil, the Conservative government's support of the industry plan and the inevitable public and environmental push-back against the plan. The Suzuki Foundation was caught in the cross-fire as pro-industry anti-environmentalists began to pressure the organization about its political advocacy activities.

Responding to the pressure, Suzuki resigned from his foundation so he could "speak freely without fear." But, one wonders, or at least I did, why should Suzuki have anything to fear?

The answer came a week later, when EthicalOil.org, with strong ties to their spiritual leader, Ezra Levant, and to the Conservative party, then hired a lawyer and drafted a 44-page letter to have the Suzuki Foundation's charitable status revoked by Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) for allegedly violating the tax laws governing the amount of political advocacy the foundation is allowed to pursue under Canadian tax laws (10 per cent of its total work). Apparently there will be an investigation that should tie up the foundation for months or even years.

Well. That was a rather large cannon ball fired at the foundation's hull; the first man overboard being Suzuki himself.

Ethical Oil, name clearly revealing its true function, was now attacking the ethics of others -- instead of those real but ever-so-irritating environmental issues. Issues such as the actual environmental impact of tar sands oil mining and the potential environmental risks of the proposed pipeline.

Meanwhile, in seeming lockstep with Ethical Oil, the Conservative government has fired up its own war machine on the environmental movement, giving the tax department a windfall of $8 million (this in a time when the CBC budget is being slashed) to enforce the rules on charities and not-for-profits. Yes. There seems to be good reason for Suzuki's choice of the word "fear."

Fear was the weapon of choice once again in a slick but subversive little propaganda video I saw circulating on the net this week. It's called "If I Wanted America to Fail." The video opens with a headshot of a clean-cut young man who delivers a lyrically poetic rant about the evils of environmentalists and their support of "expensive energy" (alternatives such as wind and solar) and their opposition to sources cheap energy (read: fossil fuels), the oil companies and the American way of life. The video is being promoted as "going viral.".

Watching it as a career marketing person, I couldn't help feeling that this was right up there with outright political propaganda complete with misleading information and half-truths, just like most of the commercial advertising we see today.

The difference, of course, between this new "Fail" video and commercial advertising is the fact that the commercial audience knows that the companies are telling one side of the truth to sell products. The propaganda videos, on the other hand, don't have that unspoken preface. The audience is encouraged to view them as "truth." But what gives them away is their emotional appeal rather than the weight of real physical evidence.

What is most maddening is that the new anti-environmentalist approach has become a war on actual fact, a war in which everything is turned away from actual reality toward what the audience interprets is simply a war of conflicting opinion.

But the laws of physics, unfortunately, can't be suspended to accommodate anyone who chooses to disbelieve the physical laws. Cigarettes do cause cancer. The world is not flat, whatever Thomas Friedman's sense of humour might say. The polar icecaps are melting. And fossil fuel is a non-renewable resource, spin it however we may.

The final news item was the Koch brothers' donations to the Fraser Institute, which pretty much puts the cherry on it in my view. The donations were among the largest handed out by the oil billionaire brothers according to their U.S. records, though the donations were never made public by the Fraser Institute; it took the Vancouver Observer to do that.

For its part the Fraser Institute has been actively involved in influencing and shaping Canadian government policy for decades, while claiming to be "not political and non-partisan." I guess it's one of those suck-and-blow things. What is clear is the Fraser is anti-environmentalist. You can find gems on its website such as: "New video urges Canadians to 'Question the Hype' about global warming," and "Sustainable water exports possible with reformed Canadian water policies," and this classic, "New report details over-looked scientific evidence against simplistic climate alarmism." And it's offering these anti-environmentalist materials to classroom teachers, so your kids can become anti-environmentalists--just as its Koch-funded American counterparts are doing in the U.S.

I don't know about you, but I don't think that the current concern among the vast majority of the world's climate scientists about climate change is "alarmism." I also don't think most Canadians want to start exporting their fresh water to the U.S. or the rest of the world for that matter, unless I've missed some significant new development. And I want my kids to learn how to love the environment, not hate the environmentalists who are trying to protect their future.

But the Fraser Institute, and the people who finance them to influence Canadian policies, certainly do want those things.

So what's really happening? How can the average Canadian separate the real science from the BS? Or the bad opinion from the good?

The simple answer? It's all about motivation. Just ask yourself who stands to gain the most cash and control of our natural resources from any government decision. And there's your answer.

Hint: Somehow I don't think we need to worry about Suzuki selling off our resources to foreigners for a profit -- or for a lifetime seat in the Senate. Do you?

The good news in this declaration of war on the environmental groups is that the wealthy pro-industry forces, through their recent slam-dance tactics, have now openly acknowledged that these "tree-huggers" are highly effective at representing the public's interests. The battles may have escalated but this war is far from over.

 
FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 33
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:09 AM on 05/01/2012
This article made me wonder: Since integrity is doing the right thing when no one is looking, whatever happened to integrity? Why are we not holding individuals who do not act with integrity accountable in a public forum? We are the people, we have the power. We need to always be mindful that we have the right to exercise this power. And in doing so, we show our respect and gratitude for the right to do so.

This is one of the most well written articles I have read in a long time. It very clearly highlights many important issues facing Canadians today. I am grateful for this article. I think everyone in the world should read this.

We must not be afraid to question what we hear as 'fact' or 'truth' and we must always look at the motivations of those who would have us believe one thing or another. If there are vested interests, we must be wary.

We also must not be afraid to stand up and support those we believe in.

"Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter." - Martin Luther King
02:40 AM on 05/10/2012
Really Nice Response, Thank You..a nice reminder
11:29 PM on 04/29/2012
Thank you Gerald. You called it: This IS War. We are entering a new kind of war: Corporations vs the People. This unchecked power is not only in the oil industry, but in the food industry where you see the Monsanto's of the world, joined at the hip to governments to force through their BigAg gmos, pesticides and chemicals onto unsuspecting publics. A trillion dollar industry, with no soul, and will stop at nothing to maintain its power and agendas. Then we have the meat industry and CAFOs; the logging and mining industry raping our forests and all life within them; BigPharma and the health industry; corporate ownership of water rights and land grabbing in both developing and emerging nations. (A fascinating watch: The Truth about Land Grabbing Decisions. Using the #FoodCrisis to disenfranchise small farmers and the trojan horse for gmos and BigAg http://ow.ly/aAh7U ) No wonder the Occupy movements and people are uprising around the world. All the laws, limiting our freedoms (especially on the internet) quietly being passed now under the guise of "security" are, in fact, preparing for this coming revolution. When concerns for our environment and human health are disregarded in pursuit solely for profits the house of cards must fall. Without Nature We Do Not Exist, Period. To the degree nature is sick and out of balance, so are we. Returning to this fundamental understanding will go a long way to bringing people to their senses and, maybe, corporate rehabilitation.
12:15 AM on 05/10/2012
This war has been going on for many centuries. The fact is that things are so bad in this world right now that it has finally become clear what is going on. Also, corporate rehabilitation is completely impossible. The notion of corporation is psychotic to begin with. The only real solution would be to turn corporations into co-operatives, controlled by the people in their communities.
02:35 AM on 05/10/2012
Agree: The horse has been allowed to run wild for too long and it will be all but impossible to put it back into the stable. But who will take such bold action? Our politics are run by the corporations, as are we through consumerism. Voting seems like such a joke unless you know whom is backing whom for what...like being at a horse race :-)) The whole system needs to be re-founded on an agreed upon set of values and principles that lifts all boats, including the environment. But again, by whom?
03:27 PM on 04/29/2012
Gerald your ignorance of the issue is obvious tar sands is not an industry term it is an insulting term used by the tree huggers who would have us all living in caves and huts crapping in the woods the correct term is OilSand or bitumen I would suggest in the future your properly research your subject matter before writing your column
05:50 PM on 04/29/2012
Jody, the tar sands has been the historical name for the Athabasca bitumen deposit. Clearly "tar sands" is not an industry term since it was industry PR types who spun the term into "oil sands" a decade and a half ago. For more on this you might want to do your own research, perhaps starting here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk%3ATar_sands.

Additionally, whether 'potato' or' potahto', this focusing on terminology is only an attempt to dismiss the importance of the events swirling around the industry attempts to silence the environmental movement. Which is the real point.
07:00 PM on 04/29/2012
My research is comprised of a career in the industry no company in our industry wish to silence the environmentalist we would like for them to work within the same rules. all the companies participating within take stewardship of the resource and the land seriously. some of the environmentalist challenging our industry have no clue of what they speak; because Canada is an open country our industry is accessible we are an easy target; encourage these fine folks to travel to areas of the world where there is no environment law wait that would require effort on their part these jet set environmental activist critique our industry while they fly around the world consuming the very fossil fuels they would deny us common folk I laughed out loud when a few months ago the Chiquita came out criticizing our industry while they clear cut massive amounts of rain forest in pursuit of their bottom line remember the term banana republic but all the activist jumped on their band wagon which further shows the lack of knowledge these people have. Mr. Suzuki can voice his ideas and opinions all he wants but when he is being manipulated by foreign interest who only goal is to impact the Canadian economy I support Canadian government in their attempts to level the playing field. If this offends Mr. Suzuki then it is obvious that you only support free speech and the ability to voice opinions when they are in agreement to your own
12:18 AM on 05/10/2012
"...who would have us all living in caves and huts crapping in the wood..."

This is exactly where we are headed towards and exactly where we will end up if we don't transform our economies into renewable economies. I'm, in fact, a technophiliac. I love technology. But if we keep using this obsolete non-renewable supply chain system, we will end up with no technology and a lot of garbage, violence and illnesses to deal with.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GuyCybershy
01:18 PM on 04/29/2012
Canada may not survive Harper's reign. We are being absorbed into the US by stealth.
01:46 PM on 04/29/2012
By stealth and wealth.
10:59 PM on 04/28/2012
Please God help us!

For the love of the earth and all who live here!
10:57 PM on 04/28/2012
Please God help us!

For the love of this earth.
09:46 PM on 04/28/2012
Wow.. within 20 seconds, the "If I wanted America to fail" video supports war in order to obtain oil. Nice free market.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kori77
09:32 PM on 04/28/2012
This video is BS. Do these knuckle heads realize the free market in fact did fail. Watch the new PBS series on Wall Street. Over $16 trillion dollars has been printed to prop up this system and "cheap energy" is no longer going to be cheap. Either we pay for it at the pump or through our taxes, that have to fund cleanup efforts like the Gulf oil spill. We must stop externalization of costs. These free market libertarian types are such hypocrites, if don't want to rely on the government, why are you attached to so many government IV poles? You drive on roads that were no doubt laid my government funded tax dollars, send your kinds to government funded schools, etc.
12:27 AM on 05/10/2012
Not hypocrities, just not fully informed. They can't see the big picture. I understand their point of view, because I see the govenrment corruption everywhere and I believe we would be far better off with smaller government, but we would also need to completely erradicate the disease called "corporations" from this Earth too, otherwise we would be doomed!
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
03:07 PM on 04/28/2012
David Suzuki is a modern day Canadian hero, in my opinion. His legacy as a man who cares for the future of both his country and the entire world will put Harper's legacy to shame.

The CONs act as though they are waging war against the Canadians of both present and future....Harper must go.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:22 AM on 04/28/2012
"What is clear is the Fraser [Institute] is anti-environmentalist."

and

"And it's offering these anti-environmentalist materials to classroom teachers, so your kids can become anti-environmentalists..."

and

"For its part the Fraser Institute has been actively involved in influencing and shaping Canadian government policy for decades, while claiming to be "not political and non-partisan.""

Yet the Fraser Institute continues to have charitable status in Canada while The David Suzuki Foundation is under attack by "EthicalOil" to have it's charitable status revoked based on David Suzuki's political remarks.

With the Harper government trying to reduce environmental assessment procedures to fast track the Northern Gate pipeline, their is an obvious conflict of interest when corporate money from the Koch brothers is being laundered though a Canadian Conservative think tank, the Fraser Institute, with registered charitable status, to influence our government that is supposed to act on behave of Canadians. And as we know, a government the majority of Canadian voters did not want.
10:17 AM on 04/28/2012
Sorry buddy....but it's time the environmentalist movement came under some of the same scrutiny that they are handing out to everyone else.
georgee2
My Canada Includes Everyone
12:51 PM on 04/28/2012
Your joking of course?
01:35 PM on 04/30/2012
Environmental groups have nothing to hide -- but the oil companies sure do!
07:04 PM on 04/30/2012
That's BS and you know it. Just Google Tides Canada/USA. Just watch Ezra Levant on Sun TV. Like everything else...environmentalism is being corrupted by money. It turns out these eco alarmists have to scare the hell out of everyone more and more to keep their donations up.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
westcoastkid
07:51 AM on 04/28/2012
Great article, but what can we do?

In response to the recent witch-hunt against Dr Suzuki, I was compelled to make a donation to the Suzuki Foundation, with the special note that it was directly because of the ridiculous persecution they are facing. Similarly, the Dogwood initiative is an ACTUAL grassroots organization, unlike "Ethical Oil" which is, as we all now, is nothing more than a greenwash funded by Enbridge.

Sigh.... With the majority government, there is literally nothing stopping Harper from declaring David Suzuki an enemy of the state and our toothless opposition will be helpless to do anything. Canadian's deserve this train-wreck of a government, unfortunately. Unless people get out and vote, the grannies and grampies who have voted CPC since the 40's will continue to dictate our federal government. Oblivious to the subversive and unethical behaviour of those who they elect because they cannot/do not use the internet or any other alternative media.

What can we do?

https://secure.e2rm.com/registrant/donate.aspx?EventID=57832&LangPref=en-CA&Referrer=http%3a%2f%2fwww.davidsuzuki.org%2fwhat-you-can-do%2f

http://dogwoodinitiative.org/no-tankers/petition