Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Heather Magee

GET UPDATES FROM Heather Magee
 

Is Lifelong Monogamy Possible?

Posted: 01/04/2013 4:56 pm

2013-01-04-monogamy.jpg(Flickr:hebedesign)

Monogamy is a tricky topic that has continued to pop up in conversation with friends over the years. In my early 20s, it didn't seem feasible. Who wanted to slam the door shut on all sorts of interesting potential partners at such a young age? Weren't we encouraged to date and explore without the pretense of a monogamous relationship? Quite often, as a 20-something, I was encouraged to date around and avoid settling down. Hadn't I all the time in the world to become someone's significant other?

I think back to those wine-induced evenings with my girlfriends trying to piece together the mysteries around our personal lives and solve some of our most pressing issues. Issues like deciding whether or not to be exclusive with someone or determining when it's too early to use the word l-o-v-e. Truly, these were some of the most important conversations I would have in my 20s. Sharing each other's experiences helped shape my own definition of a relationship and what that means to me.

It wasn't so much that I was interested in having multiple partners. I landed in a series of relationships throughout my 20s, albeit not all of them were monogamous or meaningful. Yet as my network of friends and colleagues grew and the conversation around monogamy continued, I eventually met people who participated in open relationships. In some cases it was strictly sexual, where the couple would invite other partners to join them in the bedroom. This seemed to be the most common scenario. With other couples, they would open their relationship right up, both sexually and emotionally.

I have nothing but respect for people who choose to conduct their personal life this way, but it does make me curious. Doesn't anyone get jealous? Is it really healthy to watch your lover carry on with another partner? Are humans truly capable of letting go and making this kind of relationship work?

A friend of mine has been in a committed, open relationship for nearly a decade. He and his partner share a loving bond, but they're both open to the other pursuing sexual relationships outside of their own. I blatantly asked my friend how he could stand it.

Didn't it bother him when his partner would pair up with another man right in front of him? He said that he could either drive himself crazy over it, or he could choose to evolve and be open — both he and his partner — to being with other people in an open, trusted environment. He chose the latter.

In another case, a friend of mine, who married at 23, and her husband decided to switch partners with another married couple. I wouldn't label them as swingers, but rather a couple exploring the boundaries of their marriage and sexual relationship. She doesn't recall feeling jealous or hurt, but in retrospect didn't feel like they had a solid marriage. They divorced a few years later.

Whether you're up for an open relationship or prefer one partner, I don't think we'll ever really know if human beings were built for monogamy or meant to mate for life. Monogamy, to me, is an ongoing conversation you have with yourself and more importantly, with your partner.

Having recently married, I can't tell you if we'll remain monogamous forever. As it stands today, I certainly intend to try. But I think that's a lot of pressure to put on any relationship. Monogamy has to be a lifelong dialogue that takes place as you grow and evolve.

Have you entered into an open relationship? Are you open to trying it out? Or is monogamy the only way you can exist in a relationship? Post a comment, I'd love to hear your thoughts!

Loading Slideshow...

 

Follow Heather Magee on Twitter: www.twitter.com/urbancowgirl

FOLLOW CANADA BRITISH COLUMBIA
(Flickr:hebedesign) Monogamy is a tricky topic that has continued to pop up in conversation with friends over the years. In my early 20s, it didn't seem feasible. Who wanted to slam the door shut on ...
(Flickr:hebedesign) Monogamy is a tricky topic that has continued to pop up in conversation with friends over the years. In my early 20s, it didn't seem feasible. Who wanted to slam the door shut on ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 92
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
jf12
Esta vez saldré como las otras y me escaparé.
12:38 PM on 01/10/2013
Frankly, I experience romantic love as possessive. I think it is diluted if otherwise.
07:04 AM on 01/09/2013
But I think that's a lot of pressure to put on any relationship. Monogamy has to be a lifelong dialogue that takes place as you grow and evolve.
I think if you love somebody you will the the kind of love that will keep you with your partner .Only if it Sex your looking for, than that is not fair to your Partner he would not want a woman who sleeps around ,If in the midst of arguing your spouse will test you and say well its not working out if he means it he will leave So your spouse may even go as far as asking for a divorce if he has not had any experience with women expect that he knows not what too say, it is up too you as the women to either agree or disagree but it boils down to love so only if you are ready to be in a relationship there are ups and downs that is a what you should expect it is a give and take , You must work at your marriage if you want to be happy there are times your Spouse may like tooo do thing you do not like but you do it any way because you love him . then again if every thing is not agreed on then maybe you were not ready to be married in the first place,
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Stacey
Kill guns, not children.
05:58 PM on 01/08/2013
Somewhat amused at all the 'historical basis' for monogamy comments. First, which society? Certainly not many in Africa or the Middle East, or the tropical Pacific. Or Scandinavia. Read a bit of Thomas Hardy, and you'll cross the UK off the list. Continental Europe? Don't make me laugh.

Fact is, the only thing most people enjoy more than sex with forbidden partners is pointing their fingers at those that get caught.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dkelban
01:44 PM on 01/08/2013
Maybe the author feels monogamy for life is a lot of pressure to put on a relationship, but I certainly don't experience it that way. I see it as not dissimilar to passing the bank: I'd like to have all that money, but I don't rob the bank. Monogamy does take choosing and being the right person, but also acceptance that the best relationship in the world is not going to be perfect and having enough maturity, frustration tolerance, ability to let small disappointments and slights go, not insisting that your mate be exactly like you (is those magazines left on the table really worth fighting over), and most of all having a moral code (which doesn't make excuses for cheating). As one can see, many people marry, but not many have the maturity, kindness, patience, and moral rectitude, to make it work.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Legal Plunder
Nothing forced, nothing forbidden.
10:20 AM on 01/08/2013
"But I think [monogamy is] a lot of pressure to put on any relationship."

I'd argue there's a reason for that. In fact, "many" good reasons. Spend more time "before" marriage to determine if you genuinely love and trust your partner, and vice versa. Get to know the person for who they are and learn about their character; this can be done with no sex involved, mind you. If she/he really is the person for you, and you for them, any ensuing sex shouldn't be an issue.

Also, I'd think less about what you can get out of your partner, and instead focus more on what you can provide for them in a relationship. A good partner will do the same for you.

Bottom line is: you (ideally) have "one" person to give your entire love to. Save it for only that "one," and don't be afraid to take as much time as you need to save it and wait till you find that "one."
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Vicki Larson
Journalist, mom, always questioning
09:03 AM on 01/08/2013
"Monogamy has to be a lifelong dialogue that takes place as you grow and evolve." That is very true, and that is why monogamy is part of "The New I Do: Reshaping Marriage for Cynics, Commitaphobes and Connubial DIYers," the workbook Susan Pease Gadoua and I are writing. Monogamy isn't natural for most species, even humans; it is a man-made construct. Having a discussion — many discussions, actually — about it is essential for anyone considering marriage or a lifelong commitment. Since you are unsure you can remain monogamous, I'm hopeful that's a discussion you and your husband have had. Couples are free to create the marriage they want; one size fits all doesn't work any more.
photo
jf12
Esta vez saldré como las otras y me escaparé.
04:27 PM on 01/08/2013
Constant renegotiation is the opposite of agreement.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Vicki Larson
Journalist, mom, always questioning
07:18 PM on 01/08/2013
A discussion is not a negotiation or a renegotiation. It's a discussion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jock4uni
Fiscally conservative and socially progressive.
08:32 PM on 01/08/2013
Hi, Vicki Larson"

When would your & Susan Pease Gadoua's workbook be published for us to take a look at.

Thanks,
@Jock4uni
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Vicki Larson
Journalist, mom, always questioning
12:42 AM on 01/09/2013
We are shooting for May. Kickstarter coming very soon. We'll keep you posted, and thanks for your interest!
08:56 AM on 01/08/2013
I have no problem with anyone having an open relationship, or just sex buddies, or swinging, or anything that doesnt hurt anyone else. But why would you get married? What is the point of getting married if you see other people? It seems to me that those in an "open" marriage care more about what other people think by appearing to be something they are not.
photo
jf12
Esta vez saldré como las otras y me escaparé.
04:29 PM on 01/08/2013
Yes. They attempt to downgrade those in real marriages.
wsdave
Abusive or Insulting? I won't be responding.
06:35 PM on 01/08/2013
Well, there are the 1,000+ giveaways from the government that married folks get....
wsdave
Abusive or Insulting? I won't be responding.
04:05 AM on 01/08/2013
Involved for 13 years, married for 10, open the whole time. My wife has 2 boyfriends and girlfriend (all of whom I'm friends with), while I have a girlfriend (who my wife is friends with).

Once we got our understanding of the rules worked out, it's been smooth relationship sailing. Niether of us would have it any other way.
jerryvinter
Liberal Libertarian Conservative Independent
09:44 PM on 01/07/2013
Marriage = monogamy. If you can't remain monogamous, get a divorce. If you have to try (I am not talking about occasionally realizing that the person you are married to isn't the best looking man/woman in the planet), get a divorce.

In the long term, you will hurt the person you profess to love and yourself.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nicumber
09:27 PM on 01/07/2013
I have known of, open relationships, between several staff members at a post, college institution, I attended. It was new to me, and I thought very experimental to the persons involved. Not having had the opportunity to follow up on the length of the relationships, I can only give my opinion. Personally, I have doubts that they lasted for any significant time, knowing the people, who knew the participants in the open relationships.

Monogamy is tougher in today's world, but it is worth working for, as I have looked back at the time in college, and at the couples, who have remained in a monogamous relationship in a traditional marriage. Possibly we do not have enough information and experience about productive communication prior to marriage, and during marriage to know how to stay in a monogamous relationship. I believe that monogamy is attainable and worth it, but it is not for everyone, given the lack of our own perception often, and lack of knowledge of the person(s), we marry.

Laurel
RealistBC
Micro-bios must pass muster.
09:05 PM on 01/07/2013
Yes, it's possible. There are several people who comment here to clearly have had such success. But for the majority, I have to say no.
04:49 PM on 01/08/2013
Of course it's possible.  My parents celebrated 62 years of marriage with zero infidelity.  I've never cheated nor have any of my brothers and sisters... the average length of marriage being over 25 years.
RealistBC
Micro-bios must pass muster.
10:06 PM on 01/08/2013
I'll order enough Gold Stars to go around.
12:20 PM on 01/09/2013
I'm always curious when I see posts like this. How could you possibly know whether or not any of these people in your family cheated? Do you think that every one of them would tell you if they did?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:44 PM on 01/07/2013
I'd really like a more comprehensive picture of the types of people who are in long term committed but open relationships. What are they like at work, what are their social and economic classes, what have their prior relationships like, etc? I feel like this is such an obvious destructive and selfish practice there is probably a lot I am not understanding about these couples. Then again, we come out of a particular context. We all have know gay, straight and bi are orientations we have no control over, is swinging an orientation too?
09:43 AM on 01/10/2013
Looking at the clubs I go to, they are more relaxed about getting rid of the shackles of yesteryear, and tend to be better educated (I don't know why, perhaps that gives you the self-esteem to confront the radical monogamists and other Taliban).
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:40 PM on 01/10/2013
So if you're not swinging your part of the Taliban?
photo
urbancowgirl2010
Lifestyle & Entertainment Blogger
05:24 PM on 01/16/2013
I don't think 'swinging' has anything to do with sexual orientation, but more about a personal preference to explore multiple partners at once.
07:47 PM on 01/07/2013
Monogamy is possible, just not probable.
06:25 PM on 01/07/2013
I'm not a fan of marriage this being said I do believe in monogamous or at least committed relationships be it hetro LGBT or even mixed groups of whatever sex a person chooses. I think that When you make a commitment be it group or whatever you are more interested in seeing your partner/s succeed and be happy because their welfare and happiness increases your own. Otherwise perhaps the thing you should look to is friends with benefits.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:05 PM on 01/07/2013
The problem you & others today are having is not with the concept of "monogamy". It's the fact you allow others to shape & define what a relationship is for you.

Why is divorce the majority end result today, because that's what our society is instilling in everyone. Just as having multiple relationships is being instilled in you through your conversations with your girl friends.

Look at our past & you will see the answer clear as day. Up until the last 50 years humans for the most part mated for life. Infidelity has always existed yet was always rather limited to a small subset of the population.

Today however, if your partner snores to loud it's an excuse for divorce. Based on your blog your marriage won't last, you have already instilled that belief in yourself (that pressure).

Also, sex is not a defining factor in a long term relationship, Love is. Sex can compliment Love but not the other way around.
photo
urbancowgirl2010
Lifestyle & Entertainment Blogger
05:18 PM on 01/16/2013
I'm not so sure I agree with you declaring my marriage a failure already, however I do agree that people are too quick to throw in the towel these days. That said, could it be that the definition of marriage in the traditional sense is changing?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:54 PM on 01/17/2013
You are the one expressing issues with remaining monogamous forever (that pressure), not me.

I honestly felt sorry for your friend who has chosen to remain in a relationship, despite the pain the partner is causing that person by sleeping around. It's sad when someone loves another & that love is not reciprocal, those are the relationships people shouldn't remain in.

Sex is not a relationship, sex is an act for which we receive pleasure & give pleasure. When you intentionally give pleasure, rather than take, that is Love.

Traditional marriages? Marriage to me is a mutual commitment based on Love. Love is not an emotion, it's real & it's instantaneous. Love never dies or fades away, it's with us forever. We simply learn to hide it away behind walls inside ourselves, to protect us from pain & harm.

That Love is always there, I know this because the Love I felt for my first wife is still there inside me. As strong today as it was 28 years ago when we first met. We divorced 21 years ago. I lost that love or so I had thought until about 5 years ago, no not back together. Love doesn't mean you will remain together forever, it's just the only glue that can make it happen.

Marriage has not changed, our beliefs have!