Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Hon. Carolyn Bennett

Hon. Carolyn Bennett

GET UPDATES FROM Hon. Carolyn Bennett

Surely Not in Canada Too?

Posted: 05/26/11 08:00 AM ET

On the morning of election day 2006, my team arrived at the campaign office to find that the lock to the front door had been glued shut. When the property manager -- a recent immigrant to Canada from Afghanistan -- let us in through the back door, he said, "Oh dear, I didn't know this kind of thing happened in Canada too." His comments at the time have stayed with us forever.

Elections are supposed to be passionate, but vandalism of campaign signs has become an expensive and unfortunately predictable aspect of Canadian political campaigns. Signs are smashed and cut in half. Signs are stolen. Signs are also placed on the property of those who haven't requested them. Often moustaches are drawn onto candidates' photos, and more hateful messages like swastikas or 'homo' are written on the signs of gay candidates. All of this is often attributed to 'kids' and literally written off as the signs are replaced and the extra expense incurred.

In the 2008 election, the campaign in my riding of St. Paul's experienced more than just vandalism, as citizens displaying Liberal signs were targeted and victimized -- brake lines were cut and 'L's keyed in the enamel of their cars, and anti-liberal graffiti was spray-painted on the walls of their homes.

The Toronto Police Service conducted an intensive investigation, but no charges were ever laid and no one was ever caught. Targeting of Liberal supporters also occurred the next night in Parkdale-High Park and there had been a few similar incidents in the Willowdale and Guelph 2008 byelections.

Fast forward to April 23 in the 2011 election. At 9:50 a.m. we got the first report of tires being slashed on cars in the driveway of homes with a Bennett sign on their lawn. The calls kept coming all day. Sometimes all eight tires were slashed if there were two cars in the driveway. One home didn't have a sign this year because they had been targeted in 2008. Nonetheless the perpetrator hit them again. Another family was attacked three nights in a row. Again, this was not just a local issue, as similar attacks on our democracy took place in other ridings.

As the calls came in, we again notified all homeowners displaying Bennett signs to alert them. Many felt they needed to take their sign down. Others chose to replace their small sign with a large sign. All expressed their upset that they had been targeted because they were actively participating in our democratic process, and that their hard-fought-for freedom of political expression was under attack. Yet again, citizens were being intimidated, and some had had their lives placed at risk. Again the words of the Afghan-Canadian reverberated... surely not here in Canada.

We do not believe that any of the other campaigns were responsible for these criminal acts. However, all Canadians must speak out against those people whose rhetoric and actions can incite the kind of hatred that can motivate this kind of behaviour. Surely we must all do more to protect and promote freedom of expression and respect for the democratic process.

Intimidation of voters has no place in our democracy. Not now, not ever.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:29 AM on 05/28/2011
Dr. Bennet, you've done nothing in all the years as the St. Paul's MP but meaningless op-ed pieces like this. The sad truth is a monkey could run as the Liberal candidate in this riding and win. I would show more interest in you if you actually took a stand on public issues that matter, instead of bawling about damaged lawn signs !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FearlessFreep
A radical leftist with a JS Woodsworth avatar.
01:41 AM on 05/27/2011
I heard you speaking at the Fair Vote rally!
04:57 PM on 05/26/2011
It's too bad that Maureen Harquail, the conservative candidate for St. Paul's riding in Toronto, did not speak out in any meaningful way about this vandalism. And @stint on Twitter...who's video Maureen Harquail uploaded to her campaign website ... openly suggested that the Liberals were responsible for the slashing of tires and sign vandalism.

These acts -- targetting Liberal MP's Hoskins, Rae and Bennett -- scared me. Of course I voted but I decided to have my name removed from Canada's electoral list. Why? We see physical vandalism now, however I predict that electoral lists -- falling into the hands of irresponsible people and third parties -- are ripe to be used for a different sort of vandalism. Social media has it's downside and I think everyone should support the continuation of the Paper Vote!
12:37 AM on 05/27/2011
You can take some comfort if Ford can abuse the election process because the voters list in the last municipal election were at least 10-15 years out of date.

I live in Bob Rae's riding and on the morning of the election, everyone in my building was left with a card from the NDP telling us to vote NDP. I called Elections Canada to complain but there were many people whose first language is not English and some thought they HAD to vote that way.

I agree with Dr. Bennett, we have to protect the integrity of our electoral process. We have a Prime Minister that has no regard for the democratic principles of our country but his propaganda machine is one well oiled factory that managed to trivialize the seriousness of his lack of ethics.
03:50 PM on 05/30/2011
It's probably a little late now to respond to this, but it is very discouraging to see kkrisfalusi (aka @ipoliticseh) continue these unfounded attacks against me. Sure, I'm suspicious and I stated such in my tweets in late April. Yet, many of Carolyn Bennett's supporters did implicitly and directly point the finger at her adversary's campaign.

Significantly, no perpetrator has been caught to date. And the only real beneficiary of these attacks was Carolyn Bennett, with the sympathy generated helping her to hold her seat despite the Conservative wave.

Were the victims of these crimes merely cannon fodder in a larger battle? Who knows? Although I would not rule it out, it would be foolish to make the accusation that she did it to herself without evidence. I will, however, leave you with this shot (http://bit.ly/hAuPFe) of so-called graffitti painted on one of her supporter's house. IMHO, it simply does not look like the work of some furtive vandal.