Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jamil Jivani

GET UPDATES FROM Jamil Jivani
 

Ford and Kenney Stoop to GOP-Style Racial Slurs

Posted: 07/31/2012 9:31 pm

The last two weeks have shown that Canada isn't as different from the United States as it should be.

Last week, Mitt Romney received criticism for his adviser's comments in Britain about President Barack Obama "not fully appreciating" the Anglo-American heritage of the United States. His campaign co-chair also accused President Obama of being un-American for the time he spent in Hawaii and Indonesia. Hawaii is still part of the United States, by the way.

As a Canadian, I often balk at examples of racism and discrimination so explicit in American politics. When I read stories about racism used to attack President Obama, or the often xenophobic debate about immigration in the U.S., I frequently dismiss such moments with a comfortable overconfidence that such a thing is not going to happen in Canada -- the self-professed home of multiculturalism. This time around, in reading about Romney's advisor's comments, I just didn't have the same Holier-Than-Thou Canadian swag.

The idea that an elected official could disrespect immigrant groups or racial minorities so fearlessly in Canada should be unbelievable to someone who calls Toronto home -- a city made up of over 50 per cent immigrants and almost as many racial minorities. In the fallout of Toronto's recent shootings, however, Mayor Rob Ford and Minister Jason Kenney's comments about reviewing "immigration law" (Ford) and "foreign gangsters" (Kenney) are guilty of exactly what members of Romney's team have done -- attempting to turn certain communities into "others" who are somehow less American or Canadian because they are racial minorities who, through their parents or on their own, have roots in other nations. Ford and Kenney, through their rhetoric, effectively labeled Toronto's recent youth offenders, their communities, and the communities associated with them, un-Canadian.

Thankfully, many members of Canadian media have righteously criticized Ford and Kenney. Some of our elected officials have spoken up to distance themselves from these comments, but few, if any, have appropriately highlighted just how offensive and problematic these remarks are.

Unfortunately, our Prime Minister Stephen Harper has failed to responsibly denounce these comments as well.

Still, that such a thing could happen in Canada, and we could have such influential people -- one in charge of Canada's most diverse city and the other in charge of national immigration and citizenship policy -- utter such offensive terms with unsustained outrage and little if any consequences is unacceptable. It is similar to what I have seen in the U.S., where xenophobia and racism have become part of the mainstream political discourse and politicians are too comfortable alienating racial minorities and immigrant groups. We can't forget what has been said and we must remain offended by such remarks.

To send a message to Ford, Kenney, and those who may agree or not disagree enough with these individuals, we must make it clear to our elected officials that we want a Toronto and a Canada where our leaders uncompromisingly promote a vision of our city with the appropriate sensitivities and required moral compass.

And we must also celebrate and remember the diverse history of our country and the various racial, cultural, and linguistic groups that make Canada possible. We must make sure that when people attempt to "otherize" racial minorities and immigrant groups in our country, it's clear how ignorant they are because many of these communities have a storied history in Canada long before Ford, Kenney, or even Romney were born.

Join me in sending this message, in remembering, and in fully restoring my Holier-Than- Thou Canadian swag before the next time Romney and his advisers say something offensive (which could be any minute now).

 
FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 30
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:19 AM on 08/01/2012
Notice Jovani does not get into details about what was actually said, nor provide a link? That's because his allegations that their comments were racist would not pass muster.

This is the worst kind of mud slinging. HP can do better.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hal Wood
11:25 PM on 07/31/2012
Without enough words or ideas to fill a page another self-rightuous has decided to call Canadians racist because we critisize something about immigration.All immigrants are not minorities and most were certainly not minorities in their own country . A lot come to feel safer and no legitimant refugee or immigrant wants the bad elemants from their countries to be part of their new community.You apparently don't believe in borders or laws to justify your attack . Well heres an attack on you , because of your culture you got a job you never would have gotten without it , Racist , yes . Does anyone you know even have a job that contributes to a countries productivety. That is what most newcomers strive for but you are above all that , it was given to you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
djelimon17
what's this thing for?
03:59 PM on 07/31/2012
Divide and rule

If these demagogues keep Canadians at each others throats on ethnic lines then they won't notice that the politicos are screwing them over.

Right out of the republican playbook
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:24 PM on 07/31/2012
Angela Merkel, Nicolas Sarkozy, and David Cameron have all called multiculturalism a failure... Canada might be wise to listen to them.
06:34 PM on 07/31/2012
Well of coarse all of those politically right leaning politicians call multiculturalism a failure, because that is how they gin up support among their political bases in order to win power as well as stay in power. But who can blame any of them with how they all played a role in driving the whole European Union into the ditch they need some way to distract from that.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:48 AM on 08/01/2012
Something tells me they're not all just racists playing the race card.... as you're insinuating.
07:07 PM on 07/31/2012
Or, Canada might be wise to celebrate the remarkable benefits that have accrued to our country as a result of multi-culturalism and simply not play the racist game...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:46 AM on 08/01/2012
Which remarkable benefits are those again?  Diversity doesn't unite us, it divides us.  Take our current political climate as exhibit A.  You should read "Bowling Alone" by Robert Putnam...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:44 AM on 07/31/2012
Thanks for writing this. I'm not sure I can agree, however, when you write, "Thankfully, many members of Canadian media have righteously criticized Ford and Kenney." I'm not sure that "many" actually have. The Toronto Star is insufficient. Ten years ago I suspect that such comments would have produced more of a response from both the media and advocacy groups. Where are the advocacy groups today standing up to such comments? I can't help but feel that racism is somehow becoming more accepted in this country.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:43 AM on 07/31/2012
The fact that Stephan Harper has not denounced these comments comes as no surprise to me or to many, dare I say most, Canadians. Harper is text book when it comes to Conservative ideology. Small, strong government that gets out of the way of corporate interests - period.

Anything that MUST be said outside of pushing economic growth, MIGHT be said.