Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
J.J. McCullough

GET UPDATES FROM J.J. McCullough
 

According to the Media, Bob's Our Hero

Posted: 06/14/2012 4:48 am

I've always found it quite revealing that Bob Rae rarely ventures out in public without first affixing his tiny Order of Canada medallion to his lapel. You can forgive him for being unduly proud, considering he won it at a time when his professional resume contained little beyond a brief tenure as an NDP backbencher and an equally brief tenure as one of Ontario's least accomplished premiers. In other words, Bob is hardly a stranger to the warm glow of over-praise for under-delivering, which is why yesterday's announcement that he would not be seeking an extension of his term as Liberal boss, and all the fawning retrospectives and editorials that followed, created a spectacle quite consistent with the broader themes of his modest career, feigned pundit shock notwithstanding.

Following Rae's oddly-obscene presser on Wednesday morning, Andrew Coyne prompty tweet-praised him as the "Last friggin' statesman in Canadian politics," while National Post college Jonathan Kay dashed off an article lauding his "principles" and "class." It was all a bit much considering that the ink was barely dry on Coyne's recent eviscerating take-down of Bob's duplicitous leadership doublespeak, to say nothing of the comments page Kay runs, which hasn't exactly been a Rae pep rally lately, to put it mildly.

But if nothing else, the Canadian press is quite good at playing people out, and now that the nicely-dressed ladies have gently ushered Bob to exit stage left, it's that time in our program where the nation's journalists open the envelope of "likely contenders" to replace him.

Since no living human to date has so much as sneezed a passing interest in the Grits' top job, such speculation invariably becomes one of the most flagrant displays of unconscious media bias, as the commentariat breezily pulls names from the narrow Ottawa elite whose presumed right to perpetual power has long ceased to be questioned.

Tasha Kheiriddin expects friendly establishment faces Dominic Leblanc, Marc Garneau and Martha Hall Findlay to "toss their hats in the ring," while in a Wednesday afternoon chat, the Globe and Mail's Jon Ibbitson added David McGuinty, Gerard Kennedy and Jean-Marc Fournier to the mix. No one bothers to point this out, of course, but all six are comfortable denizens of the Toronto-Ottawa-Montreal golden triangle. At least two are from outright dynasties.

This rather shallow survey of federal, ahem, "talent," is usually justified on the presumption that whoever assumes the Liberal crown must posess the eastern political class affectation of being "fluently bilingual," a criterion demanded with such forceful insecurity you'd almost think Canada was in danger of contemplating the alternative. Which would make sense, as the alternative has never been more worthwhile to contemplate.

Despite his exceedingly safe picks in the chatroom, John Ibbitson's first post-Rae editorial spouts the surprisingly unorthodox view that the Liberals' future may not require nearly as much blind fidelity to Quebec as party lore dictates. Far from being a must-have component of any electoral coalition, Ibbitson notes that Quebec is really "an outlier province" that "hasn't voted in substantial numbers for a governing party since 1988." Much better to focus on suburban Ontario instead, he says. Worked for Harper, after all.

So strong is the mythos of the eastern saviour, however, that I've actually been hearing rumours that an amateur Montreal boxer named Justin-somebody might be thinking of entering the race. According to Thomas Walkom at the Toronto Star, it's his contest to lose, in fact.

It all sounds a bit silly, but then again so did the phrase "elder statesman Bob Rae."

 

Follow J.J. McCullough on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JJ_McCullough

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
I've always found it quite revealing that Bob Rae rarely ventures out in public without first affixing his tiny Order of Canada medallion to his lapel. You can forgive him for being unduly proud, co...
I've always found it quite revealing that Bob Rae rarely ventures out in public without first affixing his tiny Order of Canada medallion to his lapel. You can forgive him for being unduly proud, co...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
valar84
09:50 AM on 06/15/2012
This article is so wrong, it looks like the author really has an axe to grind. First, the cheap shots at Bob Rae. The truth is that he took the interim leadership of the party at the worst moment and did well at establishing his presence. The man the author says keeps "under-delivering" was chosen by the MPs themselves (most hostile to his party) as the Parliamentarian of the year.

Attacks against Québec are also cheap shots. Québec still has roughly as many people as Alberta and BC together and around the same number of seats. Liberals remember that they used to be elected based on their strength in Ontario and Québec, and Liberals still have the votes of French communities outside Québec because of their support to bilingualism. In fact, more than about Québec itself, the focus on having a leader comfortable in both languages is about maintaining the image of the Liberals as the party of the Canadian tradition to openness to others and respect of minorities.

To turn their back on this heritage would go even further in destroying the Liberal Party.
06:22 AM on 06/15/2012
Thank You.
Very refreshing.

Really,What about Bob?
Canadian politics is so very Milli Vannilli, blame it on the rain.
If you don't like the weather in Canada,wait 15 minutes.
You will never run out of material here.

Bob, well he's the best conservative libel NDPer to ever have written his name in the snow
up in Disneyland North

Please do carry on!
12:32 AM on 06/15/2012
JJ, you play the exact same speculative pundit game you condemn in this article. Rae is old, he is also a statesman? problem?
10:13 PM on 06/14/2012
Bob Rae is my hero. He proved the NDP party is not fit to govern, he decimated the Federal Liberals and then delivered a majority government to Stephen Harper. Long live Bob, my hero.
photo
LilPuppy
Canadian conservative,still left of a democrat
02:51 PM on 06/15/2012
LOL so true
04:16 PM on 06/14/2012
This authors Conservitives slip is showing and he really should just speak for himself. I liked Bob Rae as a good opposition voice in the House and a good Primier of Ontario.
01:18 PM on 06/14/2012
When this author speaks of media bias is he referring to his own or someone else's? His nonchalant cynicism appears rather hollow especially since the sentences that appear before and after and use of the holy words "Harper" or "conservative" are never tainted with the disdain he reserves for...well, everyone else.
01:28 PM on 06/14/2012
This article has literally nothing to do with the Conservative party. Stow your pre-packaged critique, champ.
03:04 PM on 06/14/2012
Of course it has nothing to do with the Conservative party. If it did, the snide, patronizing remarks would disappear and his 'critique' would be filled with glowing praises and "atta boy Steve"'s. Although he speaks of media bias, I have yet to see even faint praise for any non-conservative (unless of course he was quoting a non-conservative who had a favourable comment on a conservative) nor have I seen even a mild rebuke or cynical comment directed at Harper or any member of his government. I have not read every single blog that he wrote. Maybe I missed the day he sang the praises of Jack Layton. But if I have to go back through a month of blogs to find it, then that in itself is evidence of a bias. Mr McCullough demonstrates a conservative bias and exists solely to 'balance' the right's perception that all media is biased against them. Kind of a Fox News Lite with a SK8RBOY haircut.
04:55 PM on 06/14/2012
Of course it had nothing to do with the Conservative party. If it did, the snide condescending tone would disappear and in its place would be glowing praises and "atta boy Steve"'s. His viewpoint is pretty easy to predict. If the subject is a non-conservative, it will be filled with the derisive, barely contained contempt that is his trademark. If the subject revolves around an idea or controversy centered on the Conservative party its all praise or 'nothing to see here folks, keep moving'. As a media 'critic', his existence appears solely to be to provide the needless 'balance' that conservatives perceive to be required in the 'elitist left-wing media'. As such, its pretty easy to predict what slant his comments might take regarding any particular issue or person where a bias is possible. This makes him less of a 'media critic' and more of a 'Conservative mouthpiece'. Champ.
02:04 PM on 06/14/2012
I've found his articles to be well written and great at drawing attention to some of the sheer ridiculousness in Canadian journalism.

And the only mention of Harper is when he sums up another article...