Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
J.J. McCullough

GET UPDATES FROM J.J. McCullough
 

Quebec, You Are Doomed, Dooooomed!!

Posted: 09/03/2012 12:00 am

It's been five gruelling weeks of symptoms and suffering but Canada's lengthy bout of Quebec Election Fever is set to finally break. And not a moment too soon, either -- I'm getting a finger cramp from typing all these accent aigus.

As we may recall, Battle for Quebec '012 began last month amid a flurry of ostentatiously cynical editorials from the brightest bulbs of the Canadian punditocracy, all of whom were eager to spout various exasperated theories about why there were no good choices in this race between three equally hopeless parties led by three equally loser dinguses. Debt! Incompetence! Dubious loyalty to Canada! It matters not who you vote for, puny Quebeckers, either way your province is doomed, dooooomed!

Now that some time has passed, however, and the members of the chattering class have had ample opportunity to move beyond their initial hasty generalizations and rash assumptions and actually analyze, in-depth, the speeches, proposals, and visions of Quebec's wannabe-leaders... they're still convinced everything's terrible.

Premier Charest is still considered a corrupt, directionless, flip-floppin', Anglo-ignorin 'hack  well past his expiry date; Coalition party boss Francois Legault is still deemed too naive, soft-spined, and Pollyannish for prime time, and Parti Quebecois head Pauline Marois is still, well, literal Nazis have been portrayed less Nazi-like.

If only we lived in a world where newspaper editorial boards weren't expected to make tired, ineffective, perfunctory partisan endorsements that serve no purpose other than to further legitimize the appalling buffet of conformist non-choices offered by the empty ritualistic sham we dare to call a democracy! But too bad -- we don't! So let the pain begin!

Ugh, fine, says the Montreal Gazette. If I had to choose, I guess I'd say I kinda like the Coalition party best. I mean, obviously the separatists "have run a despicable campaign" of evil racism "designed to appeal to the most culturally intolerant and xenophobic elements of Quebec society," and obviously ol' man Charest has "notably failed to deliver on promises" of elections past while his government "appears to have irretrievably undermined public trust in its ethics" through its bumbled handling of corruption probes and whatnot. And obviously the Coalition party has a "glaring lack of governmental experience" and "worrisome" policies and -- wait, who are we endorsing again?

A bit more robust in their pro-Coalition sentiment is the National Post (maybe too robust, in fact, since the PQ has now used the nod as one more push-pin in their elaborate Glen Beck-style flow chart linking the just barely right-of-centre party to Stephen Harper). Unlike the jokers running against him, the Posties proclaim, Monsieur Legault "emphasizes nuts-and-bolts policy issues" like fixing health care, curbing the power of unions, and "generally turning Quebec from a have-not province into a have province." Granted, his caucus is also probably full of "unvetted oddballs," but coming from the paper that endorsed the Wildrose Alliance, you can't expect that to be too much of deal-breaker.

The Toronto Star "does not routinely offer advice to voters in other provinces," writes that paper's editorial board before weighing in and making an endorsement anyway (being Torontonians, I imagine it was not a  particularly hard impulse to fight). Among the nation's major papers, they stand alone in throwing their lefty weight solidly behind Premier Charest's Liberals, the only party, they say, with a proven track record of "political stability and prosperity," so long as you define "stability" as  "not actively leading a secessionist movement" and "prosperity" as "maintaining a credit rating at least as good as s0me of the more promising nations of the former Soviet bloc."

'Course, for some papers endorsements are like potato chips or mistresses -- you can't stop at just one! The Globe and Mail, for instance, wants to endorse both the Liberals and the Coalition, or, more specifically a "minority alliance" between the two that " melds experience, daring and willingness to work with the rest of Canada on our shared challenges that lie ahead." Lofty language perhaps, but you have to remember that this is coming from a bunch of guys who live in Ontario, a place which has clearly demonstrated just how inspiring and productive minority governments can be.

Needless to say, no one is endorsing Pauline Marois, what with all her racist racism and Canada-hating and all.

A "truly demagogic politician," scoffs the Post. Under her leadership the separatist movement has "sunk very low" indeed, agrees the Star. A truly awful woman with "irrational, extreme, even perverse views" adds the Globe. Certainly no right-thinking Quebeckers would ever place such a monster in charge of their beautiful province, they all weep.

All of this might be good to keep in mind if you're the gambling type.

After all, to paraphrase H.L Mencken, no one ever lost money betting against optimistic fantasies of the the Canadian press.

 

Follow J.J. McCullough on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JJ_McCullough

FOLLOW CANADA
It's been five gruelling weeks of symptoms and suffering but Canada's lengthy bout of Quebec Election Fever is set to finally break. And not a moment too soon, either -- I'm getting a finger cramp f...
It's been five gruelling weeks of symptoms and suffering but Canada's lengthy bout of Quebec Election Fever is set to finally break. And not a moment too soon, either -- I'm getting a finger cramp f...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
Brady Postma
Know-it-all.
02:42 PM on 09/04/2012
I kinda want Pauline Marois to win (and then rule with brilliant reasonableness) just to prove the press as wrong as possible.
08:08 AM on 09/04/2012
I left Quebec 40 years ago. They seem to be in the same place. We just returned from a holiday in the mountains north of Montreal. All the French people we spoke with (in French) were frustrated that their choices were so poor. None want to separate. I didn't know that Pauline Marois (Separatiste) is financially very secure with pensions from previous roles and married to a multi-millionaire husband. Considering her very radical stance, she personally does not have her financial security at stake if the province separated.
photo
TonyOnly
Truth matters.
06:40 AM on 09/04/2012
Sometimes prosperity can be something as simple as a lower unemployment rate than seen in decades, at a time when most are stagnant or increasing.

Sometimes stability can be a sense of job security where there never was one.

Doomed? Hmmm. I think les Québecois are smarter than many people give them credit for. I think aligning themselves with protesting students who expect to be spoon fed, is not how many Québecois see themselves.

I'm going to go waaayy, waaayy out on a limb and predict Marois will not win this election. The percentage of PQ support has not moved this entire campaign. I predict the significant percentage of undecided will be mostly split between the PLQ and the CAQ. And that will decide this election in favour of one those two parties.
03:34 PM on 09/04/2012
Hoping against hope, you may very well be right...
Hafingnetonne
A few words
11:36 PM on 09/03/2012
Realism will prevail. Every time we had a PQ government it is panic at the harem! (Panique au harem) Charest was the Berlusconi of Quebec- a lazy man pretending to work- only at election time he showed he had fire in his belly. We would have wished him to tackle better the corruption in construction sector and Revenu Quebec! Legault is a goofy dumball, Pluto would be brilliant in his stead! And his French is odious he mixes easily feminine and masculine nouns giving them the wrong genre! Oh lala! ! Ms Marois like Jean Cjhrétien has done all ministries and let them with sulphurous paths still felt by the nurses of Quebec. I dread the incoming confrontation with the Red Square tribe! I found the PC and PM Harper most respectful of democracy letting that bridge come to us and panicless facing a Hurricane that may vanish as fast as it came. Que sera sera! Realism will prevail.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Burlesque Lea
the dog is the only animal that has seen his god
06:47 PM on 09/03/2012
I love this guy OMG! This is one of the few cases where the dichotomy is well employed.
This comment has been removed.
06:14 PM on 09/03/2012
May Pauline Marois become Prime Minister very soon of Quebec.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Burlesque Lea
the dog is the only animal that has seen his god
06:50 PM on 09/03/2012
Well, a head of a government is just the image of its people. Keep dreaming.
02:20 AM on 09/04/2012
The polls suggest that it shall become reality. I hope they are right.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ansdlmol
06:58 PM on 09/03/2012
Only if you want to commit financial suicide.
02:18 AM on 09/04/2012
We have had PQ governments for 18 years and our finances are not dead.
06:10 PM on 09/03/2012
Well, now, have I been banned or something. Last comment vanished into thin air.

All I remarked on is that the pundits are jinxing us and assuring Pauline's win, in a sarcastic manner.
05:57 PM on 09/03/2012
Well, I guess that settles it. If every single pundit says noone could possibly vote for her, Pauline it is.

I so very much hope this turns out to be sarcastic and not prophetic.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Maria Korovessis Sewell
To decimate is to reduce by one tenth.
01:53 PM on 09/05/2012
Ooops! I hate it when that happens...
05:46 PM on 09/03/2012
Best article yet about the election!