Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
J.J. McCullough

GET UPDATES FROM J.J. McCullough
 

Quebec Protesters Are Putting the Media to Sleep

Posted: 05/31/2012 11:03 am

We're now in what, week 87 of the Quebec student strike? I may be over-estimating slightly, but judging from the latest round of editorials on the matter, it definitely appears that we in the opinion-telling business are starting to run a little low on indignation fuel.

With so much that can be said already having been said during previous fortnights of tuition-fighting turmoil, and lacking any profound changes to the overall shape of the story, or the press' mostly homogeneous opinions on it (to refresh: students -- wrong, Quebec government -- bumbling), I advise skipping straight to the last line of any article on the subject, since that's probably the only place you're going to find fresh insights.

The last line in George Jonas' piece in the National Post, for instance, suggests the PM summon the army to show those students what-for. The rest is just a lot of blah-de-blah about his Hungarian boyhood. Jonas' colleague Matt Gurney uses his last line to predict that the politician known as Jean Charest is almost certainly headed for the ash heap of history, while Robert Asselin at iPolitics thinks Charest's skin could still be saved by an emergency provincial election. I'm having deja vu to week 37!

Even this week's oh-so-scandalous Maclean's cover story (which I'm sure will soon be denounced by legislatures o'er the land, like so much of what that magazine publishes) is a mostly tame regurgitation of the facts as we know them, and only really gets feisty in its parting shots, which describe Charest's authoritarian Bill 78 as "the most draconian public security law in the province's history," and Quebec society as "perhaps irrevocably" transformed. Scary stuff! But then again, "perhaps" is not generally a word one associates with stirring editorials (which is why Emile Zola's original "J'accuse... perhaps!" manifesto never went anywhere).

In this climate of growing monotony, one thing you have to be particularly watchful for is when the columnists start breaking out the ol' "but these tuition protests have really evolved into something bigger" line. This is just journalist code for "I'm tired of trying to understand  the sweet nothings that come out of [student leader] Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois' pie-hole."

Warren Kinsella in the Sun, for instance, devotes most of his "bigger picture" column to mocking various pundits he doesn't care for (who does that?), while on the opposite end of the spectrum, Jerry Agar in the Sun complains about Saul Alinsky and AdBusters, who of course are relevant as ever. Kate Heartfield at the Ottawa Citizen literally just provides a laundry list of issues she's more interested in.

So yes, week 96 has been a big snore, which is why all we owe the National Post's John Moore such an enormous debt of gratitude. Like the proverbial frustrated dad pulling a U-turn in the middle of a congested highway, last Thursday he dramatically swerved our whole boring Quebec conversation into the vastly more exciting ditch of cross-generational conflict.

It's all well and good for you other media guys to "harrumph" endlessly about spoiled students, says Moore, but hey, at least they didn't preside over the creation of a massive welfare state then repeatedly cut their own taxes rather than properly pay for it!

"Today's youth had nothing to do with that profligacy," he notes, "but are being called upon to 'grow up' and shoulder the adult responsibility of paying the debt off." If the old folks really "believe their entitlements were too generous," he adds, "then, perhaps, in the spirit of sharing the burden, they might want to give some of them back."

Well, this sort of generational treason did not go over well with the rest of the geezer set.

I'm giving enough back already, Moore, thank you very much, says Jeffrey Simpson at the Globe and Mail.

Far from being a boomer pleasure cruise, "Quebec has the highest small-business tax rate, the highest sales tax, the second-highest gas tax, the highest payroll tax, and a 3.9 per cent compensation tax on those who work in financial institutions," so there! And not to dust off an old chestnut, he continues, but the province also has the friggin' lowest tuition in North America! (Newspapers should really just pre-stamp their editorial columns with that line).

John Geddes at Maclean's agrees, and reminds everyone that the whole point of raising tuition is to bring fiscal "sanity" back to Quebec, and the whole point of fiscal sanity is that it eventually lets us lower taxes while providing more sustainable government services for all. If that's "a cruel intergenerational raw deal," it sure is a funny-looking one, says Geddes. Hell, if anything, boomers are pillars of "strength, patience, adaptiveness, and generosity," adds David Cravit from the National Post. Let's not go nuts, Dave.

As I noted in last week's column about the media's yawn-filled response to a recent visit by our future king, there comes a point in any news cycle -- no matter how theoretically interesting -- where analysts simply run out of intelligent things to say. The fact that the press is now so eagerly groping for some angle -- any angle -- on the Quebec strike that doesn't involve discussing the strike itself should serve as some kinda indication that the Fonzie of English-Canadian interest has clearly jumped the shark of pot-banging rabble-rousing.

For all their intellectual pretenses, in other words, it's fast becoming obvious Quebec's students no longer have much to teach us.

It's time to head back to class.

 

Follow J.J. McCullough on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JJ_McCullough

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
We're now in what, week 87 of the Quebec student strike? I may be over-estimating slightly, but judging from the latest round of editorials on the matter, it definitely appears that we in the opinio...
We're now in what, week 87 of the Quebec student strike? I may be over-estimating slightly, but judging from the latest round of editorials on the matter, it definitely appears that we in the opinio...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:40 PM on 06/03/2012
The media has handled this abominably, rooting for it to fail from the beginning. I actually was very moved to see the support out there during a march, how overwhelmingly positive was the response, and to contrast this with the overwhelming negativism in the media. Mr Nadeau Dubois is practically public enemy number one with a law targeting him very much and to see him so calm in the face of these intimidations is an inspiration.
03:39 PM on 06/01/2012
How can someone be more out of touch than than this? They actually pay you?
02:30 PM on 06/01/2012
You have completely missed the point of these protests. You obviously do not follow our provincial politics enough to understand what is happening. This is about everything being taken away from everyone to profit a few. It's disgusting.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:58 AM on 06/01/2012
I don't understand the premise of this article. Someone help me out. Is the author saying that is the media is 'bored' the story is no longer important or relevant? If so, I completely disagree.
photo
TT Esty1
Failure is a temporary condition.
02:12 AM on 06/01/2012
J.J. McCullough makes it sound like the whole Quebec protest was staged as fodder for the news media. It's like a reality show for the print media. Now, he's ticked because the tension is gone, the arc is missing, the fighting has devolved into negotiation and the reporters and columnists are left without a conflict. Poor scribes.

And who are these people that he names? Should I know them? I hardly know J.J. McCullough.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Burlesque Lea
the dog is the only animal that has seen his god
10:10 PM on 05/31/2012
I do respect everyone's point of view, but i'm stick with the article of Trudo Lemmens "Anglophone Media Using Protest to Attack All Things French-Canadian" which i more realistic and based on real facts.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
08:56 PM on 05/31/2012
You, on the other hand, McCullough, have been boring us for a long time and there's apparently no end in sight to your predictable wet-blanket cynicism. Normally I make a point of not coming to your page so your hit count drops and Worthington finally wisens up and replaces you with someone useful......but this was just too much. The Quebec students have been slandered by the media, you're just "more of the same".......

I know this is a "personal attack" in the commenting guidelines around here, so this probably won't reach publication because you want to keep your kitchen at air-conditioned temperatures....but damn you're pathetic......
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Whistlejackett
Hey stop doing that
08:24 PM on 05/31/2012
It's boring you because there isn't any violence. Just sitting or marching quietly forces you to think, to imagine what life could be like. Protesting within the limits of the law, makes for boring reporting. MSM is boring, the media is afraid to delve into a purpose or meaningful direction. MSM is waiting for the law or the students to break the law. MSM doesn't have the patience or the expertise to report on the why rather than the how. The MSM needs body parts, blood and an Interpol chase to satisfy it's own narcissistic profile.

The MSM has not evolved it has merely stayed involved until the bell rings in the boxing arena, and everyone has had their fill of excitement. Your post is insulting to the finer aspects of the human race. Bored people are boring.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:03 AM on 06/01/2012
I think you are absolutely correct. The media can't stand a story that isn't sensationalized with violence for them to exploit. I live in Montreal. The pots and pans movement is still picking up steam. It's peaceful, it has people motivated and energized, it is definitely not boring.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Francmon
Homo homini lupus
07:51 PM on 05/31/2012
Hey J.J. you should read Trudo Lemmens' blog on HP, published today. By thinking beyond anti-student, anti-youth and anti-Quebec rethorics, that man has managed to find interesting ideas about this crisis. And he managed, unlike you, to stay on the civilized side of the debate, by refraining on the use of condescending and demeaning tired old lines.
07:47 PM on 05/31/2012
Meh, all the pundits and opinions cited in this article just remind me that the corporate media is a vacuum in which baseless prejudices and shallow critiques just reflect themselves endlessly. There is really nothing of substance here.

If there is anything worth saying (not that this mediocre hack would ever cough up anything of the sort) it's that these sort of protests have a choice of either spreading or fading away. If this becomes something broader which spreads to English Canada and non-students it could well eventually gain the momentum to confront the direction this country is going it. If not it will fizzle out.

Don't let the much needed energy of this moment become nothing more than a bargaining chip for student unions, get out there and make it something genuinely threatening to the 'business as usual' crowd. The actions against 'Plan Nord' and it's potential environmental devastation of northern Quebec give an example of how this can happen. By the end of the next couple weeks we will know if this has come about or if we have to start to gain the momentum again from square one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
03:59 PM on 05/31/2012
Give us what we want or we'll smash stuff.
We can't afford to give any more.
Smash!
It sounds better when you say it in french.lol
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FearlessFreep
A radical leftist with a JS Woodsworth avatar.
01:24 PM on 05/31/2012
Funny how the media never seem to get bored by Kim Kardashian.
photo
Brady Postma
Know-it-all.
03:00 PM on 05/31/2012
Clearly, Quebec protesters need a reality show and sexier clothes.
01:12 PM on 05/31/2012
That's because the media is blacking out all the real issues, as always.

At least RT covers different view points, quite sad really that we get more views from Russian news then Canadian news. Why don't you write a story on that?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQwUc79VGmM
photo
The Canadian
Stop Harper
01:06 PM on 05/31/2012
Another in the long list of useless columns from this pundit.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
J.J. McCullough
02:11 PM on 05/31/2012
And yet, here you are.
photo
The Canadian
Stop Harper
04:07 AM on 06/01/2012
I read everything, Mr. McCullough, not just things that confirm my existing opinions. Not one side has the monopoly on good sense.

Curious why I think this column was useless? It's nicely summed up in your concluding paragraphs:

"For all their intellectual pretenses, in other words, it's fast becoming obvious Quebec's students no longer have much to teach us.

It's time to head back to class."

Really? So there's nothing significant going on in Quebec any more? Just because the media has a short attention span for this protest movement, but endless fascination with pop culture icons like Justin Bieber, doesn't mean that the story has ended.

A protest movement that lasts almost 100+ days is unprecedented in Canada, especially now that they face increasingly draconian responses. Tuition raises may have been the spark, but this type of sustained, revolutionary-type anger is frightening to the authorities,

The blind spot of analysts in Canada is that they think there's nothing in this country that could spur anything remotely revolutionary in nature. But for people on the wrong side of the growing income gap, political corruption, and rightwing ideologically motivated austerity policies, the logical response is to get as angry as hell and fight back.

So Mr. McCullough, the media may be bored with the Quebec protests, but the protesters won't be for a long time yet. And if these protests go national, as they are starting to do, will you still be so jaded over the story then?
photo
Brady Postma
Know-it-all.
03:06 PM on 05/31/2012
Isn't it convenient to have the Canadian media's reactions summarized in a few paragraphs?