Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Joan Sutton

GET UPDATES FROM Joan Sutton
 

After My Husband's Death I Don't Want Closure

Posted: 01/29/2013 12:32 pm

When you reach a certain age, you begin to become familiar with death. Every year brings another round of funerals, so many that life can seem to be a long series of goodbyes. When that becomes too sad, we have to remind ourselves how glad we are that we had the hellos.

With each funeral, we realize two seemingly contradictory things: death is the universal experience yet, every death is unique.

In our minds, we categorize them. If you are a parent, the worst, the very worst, has to be the fear of the death of a child. The pain from that would be unimaginable but, even so, we find ourselves imagining it. And when it happens to the children of friends, we see that the response to death is as unique as the dying. I have seen the death of a child bring a couple together in a way nothing else possibly could; and I have seen the different ways of mourning tear a husband and wife apart and with it, their marriage.

When the daughter of a man I loved died in an automobile accident, all joy died with her. He could not allow himself to find delight in anything. "Every sunset," he said to me, "every piece of music, every good book -- I think, she should be enjoying that, not me." Yet a woman whose teenage son died of leukemia went on to absorb that loss and continue to live an engaged life. When I asked her how she survived, she said, "I am just very grateful for the years he was alive."

Grateful. John Downing, a fellow Toronto journalist, shared with me a quote from Thornton Wilder:

"The highest tribute to the dead is not grief, but gratitude."

I understand that. I am grateful that my husband lived a long and productive life. I am grateful that I met him, that we fell in love, that we married, that we had so many years together. I am grateful that he died before Alzheimer's inflicted even more indignities upon him. I am grateful that he died before I could no longer handle the caregiving, that I have no remorse. And, above all, I am selfishly grateful that he died before he forgot who I am, that he remembered that I loved him, and remembered that he loved me, that those words of love were spoken.

The death that comes to an Alzheimer's patient whose self dies bit by bit long before the body does, is very different from the death that comes suddenly; the death that comes to someone elderly, is different from the death that strikes down a young breadwinner; the death that is the end result of a long fight with pain is very different from the death that steals a last breath while someone is peacefully sleeping; the death that comes from a violent act is like no other. All those left behind will mourn those deaths in different ways.

So, please do not tell me how to grieve. I weep no tears because my husband has died. I do weep tears for the lost years. I weep tears for the young family members deprived by Alzheimer's of the opportunity to truly know him. And, oh yes, I weep tears for myself, for the silence of the house -- how can it be so quiet, when it was never really noisy? I weep for the emptiness of the days that stretch before me without someone to care for, I weep for the uncertain future; I weep for the loosened ties. I am rudderless.

Do not tell me that you feel my pain, because you don't. None of us can feel another's pain. We can try. We can experience empathy. But we cannot truly feel another's pain. The skeins of life and emotions that are part of a person's grief and mourning are unique to that individual.

So, do not assign me a stage, as if the mysteries of the heart can be reduced to some cookie cutter psycho babble. I will experience the coming days, weeks, months, in my own way, and I will work through them -- or I won't -- in my own clumsy fashion. If, after a year, grief is still the dominant characteristic of my life then, you might suggest that I see a grief counsellor. I still might hit you. But I certainly will snap at you if you suggest such a thing now. Who would I be, what kind of woman would I be, if I did not shed tears for someone I loved and lived with happily and joyously for 33 years? Leave me to my tears and to the healing that only tears can bring. Leave me to what is natural for anyone who has loved.

Spare me the euphemisms. My husband did not "pass." He died. I have not "lost" him: I know exactly where his body is, and his spirit is with me.

And. Do. Not. Speak. To. Me. Of. Closure. What a hideous word. Closure. If you have truly loved someone, you do not ever want to close off the memory of that love, the richness of that experience.

Let me be strong enough to absorb this death into my life, let it deepen my understanding of the mystery of life, let it make me wiser.

Bring me acceptance but, never, closure.

 
FOLLOW FIFTY
When you reach a certain age, you begin to become familiar with death. Every year brings another round of funerals, so many that life can seem to be a long series of goodbyes. When that becomes too sa...
When you reach a certain age, you begin to become familiar with death. Every year brings another round of funerals, so many that life can seem to be a long series of goodbyes. When that becomes too sa...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 26
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
great, green, globs of greasy grimey GOPerspeak.
11:09 AM on 02/04/2013
Is it a wonder that people are uncomfortable around those who have had a loved one die. They are afraid that they will not say the "correct" thing. There has been a series of articles on HP during the last year of what not to say. Most people are just trying to comfort someone who is experiencing a pain that cannot be made better. Yes, they are often clumsy in their speech. Please pass out a list of rules to those around you so that they don't say the wrong thing while trying to be a friend in your time of mourning. I have always thought that communication is a two way street. Both partners to a conversation are speaking from their own experiences and feelings. Those around you who are trying to comfort you are, most likely, mourning, too. Their grief and relationship with your husband was certainly not as profound but their loss is just as real. You can choose to interpret the condolences are poorly worded or you can choose to see them as sincere expressions of caring. I'll choose the latter. Professionals(therapists, doctors) should be held to a higher standing in their communication but these articles are just going to make the average person more reluctant to seek out the bereaved not less reluctant. Anger is a part of grief but directing it at others is not helpful to them or to you.
07:37 PM on 02/04/2013
I welcome my friends who comfort me and my words were not directed at individuals who express sympathy, however they do it.My anger -- if that is what it is -- is directed at a society that thinks that tears and sadness are abnormal and cause for a pill or a visit to a therapist, and at a society that refuses to admit that death is a part of the cycle of life. I will try to address this misunderstanding in my next blog. Thank you for writing.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:48 PM on 02/02/2013
Exactly. Our society has found so many ways to sugarcoat death. To each his own way to grieve the death of a loved one who died.
10:00 AM on 02/04/2013
Thank you. jss
09:26 AM on 02/02/2013
I wish I could just hit "like" on this article. It is so cogent and well written; I managed my father's affairs until he died of Parkinson and I totally agree with what you wrote.
09:22 AM on 02/02/2013
Is there a way to "like" an article? Cause I like this one. "Closure" is such a blah term/concept. Thank you.
05:18 PM on 02/01/2013
My husband's body died last Summer. He passed, I say. Passed. I was raised South Louisiana, where death, dying and the dead are celebrated. White-washed tombs are included in Estates. Children picnic with their families in our cemeteries. Death is as natural as life. A going on; a passing over. I have lost a child, my father, my mother, and now my only sister is being treated for incurable cancer but nothing, absolutely nothing compares to Jim - to living day after day, moment after moment apart from his hands and his body. Nothing. I miss my husband's body. His body died but my husband was not his body. The body he was in, gave out. My husband did not die. I won't agree to it. I don't want closure. Neither do I want acceptance. I will never agree. My wonderful, beautiful husband passed away from here and that means I can pass away too and be with him. Jim's body died but he's somewhere, and I will be somewhere with him when my body dies. It's just a body. Jim did not die.
10:38 PM on 02/01/2013
Each of us who has lost someone must find our own way to live with that loss. I respect your way,and hope it brings you peace.
photo
TapestryMood
Don't "trickle down" on my parade.
11:52 PM on 01/31/2013
Ahhh, Joan...thank you.
As the wife of a man with early onset Alzheimers, I appreciate your column more than I can say.
We knew at 50 that he was showing the same signs as his father, and also the grandfather of his mom's side...Now in our 60's, we deal every day with more and more signals that changes are happening more rapidly. Although basically strong and healthy myself, like you, the worries about care when he is bedridden is always on my mind....so, have been doing daily some really good exercises for strength, back and arms, weight maintenance...and just for the joy of exercising.

We accept, we move forward, we have good/awful days/weeks, we are far more fortunate than many who have faced this inexorable disease. When the time comes....he wants no service...I will go to my beloved Washington State ocean shore for peace....will do some scattering of ashes... some will always be in my golf bag as he requested;-)

What people say or don't say...I/we have experienced in other family deaths....and, I will accept all with love and understanding...people do not mean to cause more pain...but, you and I are total agreement on the "terms" for death, our own identification of grief and moving on...at our own pace and way.. The very best to you and yours...Tapestry
07:52 AM on 02/01/2013
Dear Alzheimer's wife, my heart is with you. I can't tell you that the future will be easy. But clearly, it is filled with love. As to what people say, my comments were not meant at the individuals who reach out to comfort us, however clumsily....but to a society that tries to eliminate sadness, and will not confront the reality of death. jss
photo
TapestryMood
Don't "trickle down" on my parade.
10:52 AM on 02/01/2013
Thank you for the response...yes, I did know what you meant.....and just added my 2 cents;-)
Tapestry
09:54 PM on 01/31/2013
Very well written., I am the ED of a Funeral Directors Associatio, and I would like to reprint this in an upcoming newsletter. Is that possible?
09:02 AM on 02/01/2013
I will check with Huffington Post about this and get back to you. js
12:46 PM on 02/01/2013
I am told this is fine....be my guest, just make sure that I am credited as the author, and that it is labelled as published in The Huffington Post. Thanks for your interest. j
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ladyvee1969
"Ghetto Surburbanite"
06:19 PM on 01/31/2013
Why are people so mad. People offering condolences were never given books to show them how it's done. We are just trying to find the words to show you we care and we're sorry. Due to the fact people don't often have to deal with death alot, things sometimes come out wrong. I have commited this fas pas against people and they have committed it against me. But I didn't mind. I know most of their intentions were good. No wonder why people ignore the grieving you are damned if you do and damned if you don't.
10:56 PM on 01/31/2013
Sorry if I sounded mad......My comments and those of readers were not aimed so much at individuals who do their best to comfort, but to the self-help world out there who want to make mourning go away as quickly as possible , and to a culture that can't confront that death is a part of the cycle of life. Every word from a friend is a comfort to me, no matter how it is phrased. Perhaps an essay like mine will help those who don't know what to say, learn how to say it. BUt, however you say it, you are not damned!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ladyvee1969
"Ghetto Surburbanite"
09:17 AM on 02/01/2013
Thank you Miss Straus, my son and wife lost their baby, my grandmother, and my stepfathers' mom and dad died last year and I kept feeling so guilty wanting to make them feel better but in reality knowing that nothing I could say would help.  The best thing I told my son was to  not to fight the feeling of sadness, embrace it and cry your heart out, cry until you can't cry anymore. And pray alot. I think crying and prayer are the most soothing, stress relievers in the world.  And I agree with you, in the U.S. we want to hide death, hurry it up and get it over, put them in the ground, we're done. This does not really give us time to grieve properly and when it happens too us we don't know how to deal with ourselves let alone others.  Thanks again for responding.
04:31 PM on 01/30/2013
Thank you for eloquently stating what many of us feel but are unable to express. Well done.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:25 AM on 01/30/2013
Beautifully written piece, you have imparted with gentle and lyrical force what most people feel in these situations, but are unable to express. Thank you Joan.
08:28 AM on 01/30/2013
thank you. jss
10:07 PM on 01/29/2013
This is one of the best pieces on grief I've read. My husband of 35 years died suddenly of a brain aneurism Nov 28, 2011. I did not "lose" him nor did he "pass" away - he died period. There will never be closure. I cringe when people say how lucky I was to have such a special relationship all those years from friends/colleagues who never had a life partner. All I can feel is the absence of his presence and love for the next 25-30 years (with luck) of my life and what will never be. I cry most days and welcome the tears because they remind me of the love. I don't care if it makes others ill at ease or worried that they upset me. Thank you for writing this - it touched me.
02:27 PM on 01/29/2013
Perfect post! I couldn't agree more on all counts. What is this "closure" that people talk about, and why do I need it? Guess what? I don't! And I don't need to learn how to grieve. People have been doing it just fine on their own for 1000s of years, so who are you to dare to think you can teach it to me? (usually by someone who's never experienced a death). Then there's those that will offer you medication to deal with your depression after the death of a loved one... HELLO? You're supposed to be depressed! Depression is the emotion we keep in the bottom of our emotion drawer. We use it as needed and eventually, if we're lucky, we get to put it away again. Take your antidepressant and shove it! Let people discover their normal emotional states, and revel in being a human!
03:06 PM on 01/29/2013
Brava! and lets not forget the ones who think you should get over it, after all, it's been TWO WEEKS! jss
02:20 PM on 01/29/2013
Joan, as usual, brilliantly written. I, too, abhor 'pass' for died and lost - my loved ones are not 'lost' to me, I know exactly where they are.
03:07 PM on 01/29/2013
love ti when readers agree with me....let's hope there will be enough of us willing to face the reality of the cycles of life.
01:29 PM on 01/29/2013
Thank you to Joan Sutton for championing 2 of my pet peeves. i.e. 1) people do not "pass away" - as Joan said: they die. 2) people who die are not "lost".- as Joan said: she knows exactly where they are! We need to become more careful about the language we use because language sets the tone and social concepts.... Roberta Beek, Prescott Ontario