Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jordan Bateman

GET UPDATES FROM Jordan Bateman
 

Government Ads Use And Abuse Taxpayers' Money

Posted: 11/05/2012 12:45 pm

Once upon a time, a popular opposition firebrand named Christy Clark stood up in the B.C. Legislature to rip the NDP government for spending tax dollars on shameless, self-promoting advertising.

"People don't want the government to spend 700 grand of their money so they can find out how to access services; people want this government to spend their money so that those services are there for them to access. That's what British Columbians want," Clark railed.
"How many firefighters, how many police officers will not be on the street because [the finance minister] is spending ... on her advertising campaign?"

Fast forward 13 years to the Global TV News Hour and there was Clark, now B.C. Liberal premier, last week holding court for 90 seconds of taxpayer-funded ad time to laud her B.C. Jobs Plan -- even promising that four more weekly installments are on the way.

Governments of all stripes and every level love to advertise, spending our tax dollars to remind taxpayers how wonderful they are. This latest provincial ad campaign is expected to cost $15 million -- in a province where residents are groaning under their tax burden and government is trying to balance the budget.

It's not just the provincial government that spends money like this. The federal Conservative government, while running a $26.2 billion deficit this year, has earmarked $64 million for advertising "public service messages" like its Economic Action Plan and the War of 1812 anniversary. Last year, Ottawa spent $83.3 million.

City halls get into the advertising act too by buying up plenty of column inches of ad space in the local newspapers for various municipal initiatives and events, straying far beyond the ads required under provincial law.

All that advertising to promote how great government is, all paid for by taxpayers.

It's been suggested that government should pass a law forbidding advertising except for statutory or emergency purposes. That option sounds good, but the likely result would be governments simply declaring dozens of questionable "emergencies" in order to loosen the purse strings.

Alternatively, we could continue to let governments advertise all they want, but demand they put a disclaimer at the end of every TV commercial and the bottom of every print ad that simply says: "This advertisement was paid for by the taxpayers of British Columbia,"- - or whatever the relevant jurisdiction is.

This simple statement would give any politician pause before approving a big advertising buy. It would make taxpayers consciously connect the cost of government ads to their taxes. The whole tenor of the ad campaign would change, as elected leaders would need a real reason - besides their own re-election - to spend our money.

At the risk of plagiarizing the 1999 Christy Clark: People don't want the government to spend $15 million of their money so they can find out how to access services; people want this government to spend their money so that those services are there for them to access. That's what British Columbians want.

 

Follow Jordan Bateman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jordanbateman

FOLLOW CANADA BRITISH COLUMBIA
Once upon a time, a popular opposition firebrand named Christy Clark stood up in the B.C. Legislature to rip the NDP government for spending tax dollars on shameless, self-promoting advertising. "P...
Once upon a time, a popular opposition firebrand named Christy Clark stood up in the B.C. Legislature to rip the NDP government for spending tax dollars on shameless, self-promoting advertising. "P...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 4
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PMDoyle
02:50 PM on 11/23/2012
Christy Clark and her Blue Liberals are constantly trying to remind us about Glen Clark like we have ever forgot. The problem for her is that the BC Liberals record make Glen Clark's record look good. Plus Adrian Dix is not Glen Clark and the NDP left Gordon Campbell 4 million dollar surplus when they left power. The Liberals need to disband the party and start again. The BC Liberals need to rid themselves of any old Socreds that they are still packing around. Christy Clark needs to go if the Liberals are ever to regain some dignity....
11:05 PM on 11/17/2012
The BC Fiberals are resigned to the fact that they will be badly losing the next election and they are maxing out their credit cards,increasing pension and severance packages and they don't care what BC taxpayers think anymore since they will be able to walk away.. .This is the reason the BC fiberals will not call a election until the last minute .The Fiberals are going to make sure their corporate pals are taking care of before the election.Clearly, Clark's damage control team is working overtime trying to get her off the hook. . How many times can she and her spin doctors say the word "may" without losing all credibility? .Her plan is to bluff her way through every problem with platitudes and the big grin! That's what has worked for her all her life and if the people of B.C. let her get away with it, she'll keep using it. Not to mention a full on criminal for her role in BC Rail.Hope your charged with fraud in the BC rail sale fraud scandal.Former BC Fiberal senior MLA Collin Hansen will probably sing like a canary, as he was going to when criminal fraud charges are laid in the BC rail sale scandal and the hush money paid paid Basi and Virk.The BC Fiberals though six million dollar of taxpayer are money given to lawyers the BC rail sale fraud scandal would go away..
12:25 PM on 11/08/2012
Premier Christy CLark is in serious trouble because she has failed to follow Prime Minister Harpers example by firing her Deputy Minister of Justice.

Harper called it a retirement but it was undoubtedly a termination because the strategy of his Deputy Minister of Justice resulted in the apparent murder of a Federal Court of Appeal judge and an alleged suicide of a department of justice lawyer.

The present Deputy Minister of Justice for BC was a party to that strategy that included, as an implicit term, the murder of the in question.

There are now 12 dead judges linked to the same case and certainly one or more were murdered.

Readers can learn more at http://www.waterwarcrimes.com

Premier Christy Clark would like to hide from this but she cannot and neither can Adrian Dix and they both know it has to do with the issue of water exports from BC an issue that was alive when Dix was assistant to Glen Clark and an issue that continues to play out behind the scenes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
YvonneH
be kind to each other
02:20 AM on 11/08/2012
Here's another politician I can't wait to see get defeated.