Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jordan Bateman

GET UPDATES FROM Jordan Bateman
 

The Dirty Secret About MP Pensions

Posted: 04/30/2012 12:12 am

If you could put a loonie into a machine and get $23.30 out every time, would you ever stop?
Probably not. That human nature may explain why Members of Parliament have been moving so slowly to reform their platinum-plated pension plan. Unfortunately for taxpayers, we are that cash machine.

Earlier this year, the Canadian Taxpayers Federation (CTF) released a report showing that taxpayers put in $23.30 for every one dollar parliamentarians contribute to their pension plans. Some MPs snarled back at the CTF, claiming the numbers were wrong (they aren't). Others made it clear they were entitled to their entitlements. A few shared the public's concern that the payouts were too far out of line with what regular Canadians were experiencing.

Still nothing has changed. The governing Conservatives have promised action, but the federal budget came and went with no specifics on MP pension reform. So the taxpayer keeps on paying.

The dirty little secret about MP pensions is that they aren't invested in the market like other pension funds. They simply set an arbitrary rate of interest and taxpayers kick in whatever amount is necessary to make it grow by that much. Naturally, MPs settled on a return of 10.4 per cent per year -- making it the best-performing pension in Canada.

When the recession hit in 2008, the MP pension fund still grew by its legally mandated 10.4 per cent, while the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) lost 18.6 per cent, the B.C. Public Service Pension Plan lost 14.2 per cent, the B.C. Teachers Pension Plan lost 13 per cent and the WorkSafe B.C. Pension Plan lost 11.2 per cent.

Add to that an incredibly low eligibility threshold for MPs to collect -- age 55, six years of service, fully indexed at age 60 and tied to CPI increases annually -- and taxpayers are on the hook for millions and millions of dollars for a pension they could only dream of receiving themselves. It would take a normal Canadian nearly 30 years to save the nest egg necessary to produce the pension payout a backbench MP receives after six years of service -- making the same monthly contribution.

If he retired from politics in 2015, a second-term, opposition MP like Don Davies (Vancouver Kingsway, NDP) would start with an annual pension of $33,148. If he collected until age 80, Davies would take home $1.07 million in total pension payouts. That's basically the bare minimum for serving as an MP, after annually contributing $10,900 of his own money while in office.

On the opposite end of the spectrum is Hedy Fry (Vancouver Centre, Liberal), who would start with an annual pension of $134,211. John Duncan (Vancouver Island North, Conservative) would collect $126,829. Dick Harris (Cariboo-Prince George, Conservative) would start with $118,236. And Libby Davies (Vancouver East, NDP) would have to make due with $94,818. These amounts are all indexed to inflation and increase every year -- thanks to Canadian taxpayers.

This has to change. The Conservative government has promised details of a new MP pension plan this fall, but taxpayers have been waiting years already -- politicians continue to be reluctant to step away from the machine multiplying their money.

It's up to taxpayers to unplug the machine by putting pressure on their local member to support MP pension reform.

 

Follow Jordan Bateman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jordanbateman

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dale Chan
Hope is both panacea and poison.
03:07 PM on 05/01/2012
Those at the top of the social pyramid have a vested interest in the status quo. Even while others suffer they prosper, they have no incentive to change.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Capital Ottawa
02:34 PM on 04/30/2012
Obscene! Most people have to work 30+ years before they get their pension, and most plans have individuals contributing 50% towards retirement. Average annual pensions for Public service employees is currently $33,519... after 30 - 35 years of service. MP's pensions should be brought in line with the rest of the Public Service.
10:59 AM on 04/30/2012
Public officials' pensions should only be paid out for as many years as the official served - no more and no less. Bilking the taxpayer 'til death us do part' is totally ridiculous...not to mention expensive.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:51 AM on 04/30/2012
You must be crazy if you think this government or any government in Canada will make changes to there Pension for LIfe . This has been going on for a long time and every year they the MP's get alittle increase on the pension payour. The job of being elected into the Canadian government as an MP is a job much though after by many a Businessman and people who have a political connection to the government. This job if elected is the gravey train of life in Canada . You will never be of the middle class and you will never be a poor person. Because as you said the tax payers will always have to pay into your Pension plan. as a MP . The first thing the government does is collect Taxes on everyhting . The GST and all thoses other wonderful taxes ; that keeps this government or any government alive is the TAX payers on the street. Mean while if you are a MP you get a gas allowanced and many other ways to right off your TAXes as an MP . How much they pay into there own Pension is very small to what an normal tax payer pays intaxes. You see it is an eliete job if you can get into government .
georgee2
My Canada Includes Everyone
10:33 AM on 04/30/2012
My guess is that the government will make changes so the taxpayer puts in $22.00 for each $1.00 they contribute. Not the current $23.00. Than they will tote this as a major change and hardship for their MP's. Nothing will change.
10:14 AM on 04/30/2012
and I still dont have a Doctor.. my husbands Doctor just notified the town he is leaving next month why are they allowed to move to Canada and only do 4 years in a remote location them move??
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sgillhoolley
Occupy the discussion.
09:19 AM on 04/30/2012
As long as we Canadians do nothing more than complain, the government will continue to take more and more for itself. They are supposed to be our servants, not our masters, but Canadians are wimps who are willing to take anything. How sad.
06:05 AM on 04/30/2012
AFP, Apr. 17, 2012
"Wall Street titan Goldman Sachs on Tuesday booked a $2.1 billion profit for the first quarter, more than doubling the amount made at the same time last year and smashing market expectations.
Lower revenues in the company's all important investment banking unit -- as well as fixed income, commodities, currency and underwriting -- were offset by higher revenues from financial advisory and stock investments."

Well, now you know where your pension money has gone and I do mean gone. And now, you know where some of your tax money is going. Public pension plans in the states got whacked last year, and just to make it fair let us see what happens to the Canadian public pension plans in the coming four years. Get ready for the "too generous pension cut backs," this will probably put the public pensions on par with the busted and underfunded private sector pension plans. Fair social value for the 99% indeed. Not so for the MP pension plan.
The one percent are doing well.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:52 AM on 04/30/2012
What is a Libetarian extremeits doing on a supposedly "left wing", blog like this? Never mind pensions, how come you guys don't support fair taxation. You know, like killing the captial gains exemption, and making the wealthy pay their share? You are simply a front group for the wealthy and Bay Street. Stop pretending you have the public's interest at heart. That isn't what you are about, even if you are managing to fool a lot of people.

Want to prove me wrong, release your donors list and let us have a look.