Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
GET UPDATES FROM Josh D. Scheinert
 

Tough on Crime? Tough on Non-Criminals

Posted: 02/21/2012 11:01 am

The story is being written and soon reality will settle in. At that point, when the haze of this moment dissipates, and clarity and reason return to our national psyche, we will be faced with a moment of national reckoning for a nation that lost its way.

Too much ink has already been spilled on Stephen Harper's Omnibus Crime Bill, soon to become law. I preface it as Stephen Harper's because we should never forget who steered our criminal justice system, and by proxy, our societies, in this direction.

Let us never forget that as the U.S. Sentencing Commission speaks out against mandatory minimums, as the U.S. State of Texas undoes the disaster it wrought upon itself in the name of mandatory minimums, and here in Canada as the federal prison ombudsman, correctional officers, lawyers, the legal profession, and most recently judges, warn us of the futility, illegality, and cruelty of what we are about to embark upon -- that it was Stephen Harper's stubborn ignorance that led us here.

Perhaps there is a hidden epidemic of crime sweeping this country that has been unreported -- that the statistical fact that crime is at its lowest level since 1973 is incorrect. Such an epidemic might evidence the fact that our current approach to law and order, and dare I say it, rehabilitation, is not having its desired effect.

Let us also suppose for a moment that our social agencies are so flush with cash that we have spent all we can spend on programs proven to reduce recidivism among convicted felons. Let us pretend that Nunavut has at least one addiction treatment centre where in the capital, Iqaluit, 90 per cent of crimes involve some form of substance abuse.

And finally, we can pretend that we have been transported to an earlier era, when justice existed in the gallows. Back then there was no debate about a just society, about fairness. Young or old, all the same. To be strong was to be vindictive.

Stephen Harper and his cronies -- Vic Toews, the Minister of Public Safety, and Rob Nicholson, who my friend Gerald Caplan aptly calls the Injustice Minister, must believe these fallacies. It is the only logical explanation for why they have chosen to embark down the most illogical of roads.

It is easy to prey on people's fears and prejudices. This government has shown that it works. If it is a craft, they have mastered it. The tragic irony is that the boogeyman of this bill -- the first time offender who fell victim to circumstances that those who now condemn him could never begin to navigate, or the youth who at some point will re-enter the societies they have been removed from, will in fact emerge the hardened criminals they are painted as.

Too much evidence (oh, the facts!) tells us that sending non-hardened criminals to prison only gives us more hardened criminals in the long run. We will have created the crime we seek to erase.

Quebec has said it will refuse to pay the bill's cost. It will not embark down a course that will undo all the progress it has made in rehabilitating young offenders so they can rejoin society as citizens, not criminals.

Ontario recently estimated the cost of its share of this disaster at $1 billion. One billion dollars wasted on prisons, on creating criminals, and destroying communities. In an age of austerity, with the future uncertain, instead of spending precious resources where they are needed most -- in our schools, our hospitals, and our industries -- we will waste them on prisons; colossal, mega-prisons.

The strong crushing the weak.

Passing the Omnibus Crime Bill, which the House of Commons has done already and the Senate is poised to do, is only the first chapter in this story. The next chapters will tell of what happens when a smart country does something so utterly stupid. And one can only hope that when confronted with what we know is coming, we will permit ourselves what we are about to deny to too many among us, a second chance.

 
FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
The story is being written and soon reality will settle in. At that point, when the haze of this moment dissipates, and clarity and reason return to our national psyche, we will be faced with a moment...
The story is being written and soon reality will settle in. At that point, when the haze of this moment dissipates, and clarity and reason return to our national psyche, we will be faced with a moment...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
colpy
01:58 AM on 02/22/2012
I absolutely agree that mandatory minimum sentencing is a farce and a travesty of justice.

I agree that the war on soft drugs is idiotic.

But I am still a member of the Conservative party, simply because Mr. Caplan and all the Liberal and NDP opposition do not offer a sane alternative.

Their foreign policy is to alienate and abandon our allies, destroy our military, and pay homage to the clearing house of tyranny and uselessness, the UN

Their domestic policy is to tell me what I can or can not say, push my children into debt paying for ridiculous social programs, and to steal my firearms.

One is forced to continue their support for a government of the right simply because the alternative is so atrocious.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
valar84
09:00 AM on 02/22/2012
The left-wing foreign policy had made Canada into a respected and beloved country on the world stage. Canada has never had, and will never have, a military big enough to impose its will and presence in world affairs, nor should it ever. Canada's power was soft power, and it worked better than America's demonstrations of its hard power. Tell me, what successes did bypassing the UN give the Bush Administration? Am I supposed to believe the Iraq fiasco is a great success?

To be a friend is to tell them when they are wrong and try to convince them to change their ways. Never to criticize is to be a follower or a pet, not an ally.

The left-wing cares more about freedom of speech than the Conservatives do. The NDP is the party with the best track record on balanced budgets, the Liberals had huge surpluses in the 90s and early 2000s, surpluses that Harper and his ilk squandered away in GST and business tax cuts. Even now, Harper is cutting taxes for big businesses, funding them by increasing the deficit. "Steal your firearms"? Why, just because they asked you to register them, like you do your car? Are they planning to steal your car too?

You believe in myths, time to wake up.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
okgranny
Egalitarian by birth
12:59 PM on 02/22/2012
Thank you Valar for your articulate viewpoint. I am reminded again of why I fanned you. Faved!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
okgranny
Egalitarian by birth
05:18 PM on 02/22/2012
In a free and just society, security never trumps freedom. Fear is not our friend.
Your are condoning human tragedy to nurse your own paranoid delusions about the world. Give your inflated ego a rest and maybe go look at this world which frightens you so much. You might be surprised.
No one is perfect but much of conservative policy is harmful if not down right wicked..
01:29 AM on 02/22/2012
If you ask Corrections Canada, they will tell you that our prisons are dire need of infrastructure upgrades. Overcrowding prisons in not in the best interest of the prisoners. More importantly, when you overcrowd a decaying facility, it makes the job of a Correctional Officer less safe. We need a balanced approach. Simply stating that the Conservatives are just hell-bent on building prisons and locking people up is not at all accurate. Seems like all the critics of the new Bill simply gloss over the fact that it addresses the concerns of victims of crime. You know, the people nobody seems to want to talk about in this debate – particularly the “Hug a Thug” crowd. Should we invest more money into crime prevention and rehabilitation? Absolutely without question. That said, reduced sentences ought to be tied to successful completion of life-skills and drug /alcohol addiction programs. Letting somebody out on the street just to free up a bed-space is not the answer. Finally, let’s not forget there is also a place for justice. Criminal actions must have clear consequences. Personally, I’d like to see prisoners doing hard labour from dusk ‘til dawn - with breaks only to sleep, eat and counselling programs to help them stay clean. No TV. No internet. No smoking. No mini-put golf. When prisoners have loads of free time on their hands, they often use it to plot schemes, get high, run their drug businesses and brutalize each other.
04:56 PM on 02/23/2012
Personally, I’d like to see prisoners doing hard labour from dusk ‘til dawn"

-----------------------------------

Especially all those evil marijuana users, eh Steve? Is that you Harpo?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Lives
The Venus Project ... look it up
05:29 PM on 02/21/2012
I think it is because of their religious beliefs, combined with bad science, that leads Harper and company to push this policy against all scientific knowledge to the contrary. I would love to know the underlying reason these men push this policy. Because I doubt its the same reasons they espouse publicly.
01:35 PM on 02/21/2012
Stephen Harper, John Baird, Rob Nicholson and Vic Toews should be tarred and feathered, then banished from Canada!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
colpy
01:52 AM on 02/22/2012
So....is this the Left's idea of democracy? Punish the elected when they do what they promised?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
working onit
Stop Harper
01:21 PM on 02/21/2012
A previous poster commented on a private prison company, GEO I believe, lobbying the federal government. It is big business in the US. Since logic and science do not support these changes, but in fact refutes them, greed is the only explanation.

Canadians need to wake up & occupy our government before its too late. I fear when the online spying bill becomes law those of us who oppose Harper's plans risk being unwilling guests of these private prisons. Few of us will risk even anonymous postings like this forum.