Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Junaid Jahangir

GET UPDATES FROM Junaid Jahangir
 

Queer Muslims Deserve More Than Scriptural Zealotry

Posted: 07/12/2013 5:27 pm

In a recent blog piece, American Islamic scholar Shaykh Hamza Yusuf defended the right to uphold the belief that "homosexuality" constitutes an aberration. He equated queer individuals with ma'buns, a category used in Islamic legal texts to refer to those who are effeminate in speech or desirous of receptive anal intercourse.

Does Shaykh Hamza really want his followers to aspire to teachings that emphasize deviation instead of diversity? By reducing their existence to a sexual act or the manner of speech, does he really wish to dehumanize queer individuals?

In the context of the head cover, he has gone as far as to state that when the law does not serve human beings, they are permitted to abandon it. Likewise, other conservative Muslim leaders usually claim that as a religion of love, mercy and kindness, Islam has given everyone their rights.

In contrast, they have issued opinions on queer Muslims that seem unreasonable and unjust. Of course, the zeal to uphold classical understandings of the scriptural texts at times violates the Islamic spirit of love, mercy and kindness.

Instead of paraphrasing legal texts, will conservative Muslim leaders review how the assumptions of the past jurists influenced their rulings?

Conservative Muslim scholar Shaykh Al Munajjid has clearly defined that in Islamic law, "homosexuality" refers to the act of anal intercourse with males. Indeed, the Islamic tradition is based on rulings on the apparent instead of hidden attributes like sexual orientation.

Harvard based Dr. Khaled El Rouayheb confirms that the past Arab-Islamic world lacked the concept of "homosexuality" as understood today. His seminal work and that of Dr. Scott Kugle clearly indicates that by excluding women and those who do not indulge the act of anal intercourse, the category of ma'bun does not define queer individuals.

When will conservative Muslim leaders recognize that paraphrasing legal texts is not helpful today?

Muslim academic Dr. Kecia Ali has indicated that past exegetes and jurists addressed superfluous desire that could be channeled towards women instead of the exclusive innate orientation towards member of the same sex.

Past exegetes and jurists operated in the context of age and status asymmetrical relationships between unequal partners. The 14th century exegete Ibn Kathir noted that Muslim leaders, jurists and memorizers of the Qur'an were complicit in liwat -- anal intercourse inflicted on males that included youth, slaves, or those classified as ma'buns.

Such same-sex conduct perpetuates through the phenomenon of the Dancing boys of Afghanistan or in the context of gender segregated societies where the active partners, whose wives are pregnant or menstruating, pursue youth or foreign feminized males as surrogates.

However, applying the rulings on liwat to queer Muslims, whose lives are not defined by a specific sexual act in an asymmetrical relationship, would be unreasonable. Likewise, prescribing them to remain permanently celibate merely to uphold classical understandings of the scriptural texts would be unjust.

Dr. Hashim Kamali of the International Institute of Advanced Islamic Sciences in Malaysia has opined that even a clear scriptural text may be given a fresh interpretation in a different context, especially when Islamic rulings contingent on a set of circumstances are deemed unjust in a different context.

He referred to the opinion of the 14th century jurist Ibn Qayyim that unjust rulings should not be part of Islamic law even if they were derived through its application. Likewise, Islamic law scholar Dr. Anver Emon has referred to the opinion of the 14th century jurist Al Tufi that scriptural texts had to be reinterpreted if the rules derived from them did not uphold the good.

Islamic law is not frozen in time. It accounts for social change. Based on the principles of justice and public welfare, past jurists like Al Tufi and the 20th century jurists Muhammad Abduh and Rashid Rida went as far as to advocate deriving Islamic rules even if they were not directly confirmed by scriptural texts.

Conservative Muslim leaders can acknowledge the innate orientation of queer Muslims by referring to the 14th century jurist Al Shatibi who stated that denying innate dispositions may irreparably harm human beings.

They can reference the late Grand Shaykh Tantawi of Al Azhar, who, possibly based on the theological model that the inner soul takes precedence over the outer body, opined that it would be self-deception to outwardly behave in a manner inconsistent with one's inner essence.

By reflecting on the Islamic teaching taklif ma la yutaq -- that Islamic law does not impose unbearable obligations -- they can also reject the harmful prescription of permanent celibacy that deprives human beings from living a worthwhile life based on love, companionship and intimacy.

As such, conservative Muslim leaders like Shaykh Hamza have the choice to continue paraphrasing classical legal texts that define queer Muslims as ma'buns, which caricatures them as effeminates or passive recipients of anal intercourse, or to draw inspiration from the spirit of Islam to replace unjust rules with those that facilitate queer Muslims.

The choice is yet before them.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Rev. Dr. Nancy L. Wilson

    Rev. Dr. Nancy L. Wilson is Moderator of Metropolitan Community Churches

  • Dr. Ibrahim Abdurrahman Farajaje

    Dr. Ibrahim Abdurrahman Farajaje is Provost of Starr King School for the Ministry, Professor of Cultural Studies and Islamic Studies, and Sufi. Taught the first divinity school class in the US on African-American faith communities and HIV prevention.

  • Bishop Gene Robinson

    Bishop of the <a href="http://www.nhepiscopal.org/" target="_hplink">Episcopal Diocese of New Hampshire</a>.

  • Rev. Ouyang Wen Feng

    Reverend Ouyang Wen Feng founded a gay-friendly church outside Kuala Lumpur and is thought to be the country's only openly gay pastor. Although he now lives in the U.S., he frequently returns to Malaysia to call for gay rights, despite the country outlawing homosexuality.

  • Imam Daayiee Abdullah

    Imam Daayiee Abdullah is the imam and religious director of <a href="http://daayieesplaceofinnerpeace.com/MASJID_ANNURAL_ISSLAAH.html" target="_hplink">Masjid An-Nur Al-Isslaah</a>, and the co-director of <a href="http://www.mpvusa.org/" target="_hplink">Muslims for Progressive Values</a>

  • Bishop Mary Douglas Glasspool

    Bishop Mary Douglas Glasspool serves as the Assistant Bishop of <a href="http://www.ladiocese.org/" target="_hplink">The Episcopal Diocese of Los Angeles</a>.

  • Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum

    Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum serves as the spiritual leader of <a href="http://www.cbst.org/" target="_hplink">Congregation Beit Simshat Torah</a>, the largest LGBT synagogue in the world.

  • Rev. Troy Perry

    Rev. Troy Perry founded the LGBT denomination of <a href="http://mccchurch.org/" target="_hplink">Metropolitan Community Churches </a>(MCC) in 1968.

  • Larry Yang

    <a href="http://www.larryyang.org/home.html" target="_hplink">Larry Yang</a> is on the Spirit Rock Teachers' Council and a core teacher at the new East Bay Meditation Center in Oakland, Calif.

  • Pastor Manny Santiago

    Pastor Manny Santiago is the pastor of <a href="http://www.ubcseattle.org/" target="_hplink">University Baptist Church</a> in Seattle, Wa.

  • Rev. Scott Anderson

    Rev. Scott Anderson is the first openly gay PCUSA minister ordained after the church voted to allow individual presbyteries to set their own ordination guidelines around sexual orientation

  • Rev. Pat Bumgardner

    The Rev. Pat Bumgardner is currently the Senior Pastor of <a href="http://mccny.org/wordpress/" target="_hplink">Metropolitan Community Church</a> of New York.

  • Rabbi Steven Greenberg

    Rabbi Steven Greenberg, the first openly gay Orthodox rabbi, is Director of Orthodox Programs for <a href="http://www.nehirim.org/" target="_hplink">Nehirim</a>, the organization for GLBT Jewish culture and spirituality.

  • Bishop Yvette Flunder

    Flunder is founder of the City of Refuge, United Church of Christ, in San Francisco and of The Fellowship, an international group of Christian leaders that she serves as presiding bishop.

  • Irshad Manji

    Irshad Manji is a Muslim and founder and director of the <a href="https://www.irshadmanji.com/Moral-Courage-Project" target="_hplink">Moral Courage Project</a> at New York University's School of Public Service.

  • Archbishop Carl Bean

    Archbishop Carl Bean founded the <a href="http://www.unityfellowshipchurch.org/mainsite/" target="_hplink">Unity Fellowship Church Movement,</a> a primarily African American and LGBT denomination.

  • Rev. Malcolm Boyd

    Rev. Malcolm Boyd is an Episcopalian Priest and author of "<a href="http://www.amazon.com/Are-You-Running-Me-Jesus/dp/1561012750" target="_hplink">Are You Running With Me Jesus?</a>"

  • Justin Lee

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Coloradem"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://i.huffpost.com/profiles/466930-tiny.png?20091015162513" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Coloradem">Coloradem</a>:<br />Justin Lee is the founder and Executive Director of the Gay Christian Network.

  • William R. Johnson

    William R. Johnson - First Openly Gay person ordained in a mainline denomination (United Church of Christ) and founder of the UCC Coalition for LGBT Concerns and Maranatha: Riversiders for LGBT Concerns at the Riverside Church, NYC.

  • Rev. Robin Reiter

    Rev. Robin Reiter is the Founder and director of Sacred Abundance Ministries

  • Rev. August Gold

    Founder of the Spiritual Center - NYC, Author, speaker, life coach.

  • Jimmy Creech

    Jimmy Creech was defrocked by the United Methodist Church and lost his ordination for performing same-sex commitment ceremonies. He is the author of Adam's Gift: A Memoir of a Pastor's Calling to Defy The Church's Persecution of Lesbians and Gays.

  • Minister Mychaeltodd

    Executive Director of Fig Leaf

  • Rev. Dr. Jo Hudson

    Rev. Dr. Jo Hudson is Senior Pastor at Cathedral of Hope in Dallas, TX

  • Bayard Rustin

    Bayard Rsutin was the Quaker activist who not only mentored Dr. King in the principles of non-violent, non cooperation, but also helped found the Southern Church Leadership Conference. Rustin was the chief organizer of the '63 March on Washington, as well as of the first Freedom Rides in 1947. Because Rustin was openly gay, he had to remain behind the scenes in the Civil Rights movement, as his sexuality was the target of attacks by anti Civil Rights antagonists.

  • Candace Chellew-Hodge

    Candace Chellew-Hodge is the founder of Whosoever: An Online Magazine for GLBT Christians that was founded in 1996. The magazine was the first of its kind on the internet has continued to be a resource for the LGBT community since then at whosoever.org. She is also the author of Bulletproof Faith: A Spiritual Survival Guide for Gay and Lesbian Christians published in 2008.

  • Rabbi Denise Eger

    Rabbi Denise Eger serves at Congregation Kol Ami and long time LGBT activist

  • Rev. Peter J. Gomes

    Rev. Peter J. Gomes (who passed away earlier this year) was longtime pastor of The Memorial Church at Harvard. He came out in 1991, saying "I am a Christian who happens as well to be gay. Those realities, which are irreconcilable to some, are reconciled in me by a loving God."

  • Pastor Dennis A. Meredith

    Pastor Dennis A. Meredith is the Pastor of Tabernacle Baptist Church, Atlanta, GA

  • Pastor Darlene C. A. Franklin

    Pastor Franklin is the Pastor of Agape Spirit Life Ministries in Detroit. She is a leader in social justice and a pioneer in spiritual equality for the LGBT Community.

  • Rev. Roger E. Hayes

    Rev. Hayes is the Senior Pastor of Church Of The Holy Spirit Fellowship located in Winston Salem, Nc

  • The Rev. Elder Jim Mitulski

    Rev. Jim Mitulski, pastor of MCC New York City, came to MCC San Francisco. Under Jim's leadership for 15 years, the church entered a period of sustained growth during the devastating years of the AIDS epidemic and shifted from being a place to meet on Sundays into an integrated part of the San Francisco queer community.

  • Dr. Herukhuti

    Dr. Herukhuti, Founder of Black Funk: The Center for Culture, Sexuality, and Spirituality; author of Conjuring Black Funk: Notes on Culture, Sexuality, and Spirituality; and practitioner of traditional African and African Diasporic spirituality.

  • Archbishop Michael Seneco

    Archbishop Michael Seneco, the presiding bishop of the North American Old Catholic Church- a progressive Catholic denomination with ministries in 23 states.

  • The Rev. Dr. Katrina D. Foster

    Rev. Dr. Katrina D. Foster is an Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) pastor. In 2007 she came out of the floor of her denomination's national assembly, after which the bishops put forth a resolution allowing them to abstain from discipling lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender pastors with families and not face disciplinary action themselves for not bringing charges against these pastors.

  • Rabbi Andrea Myers

    Rabbi Andrea Myers is the author of the book, "The Choosing-A Rabbi's Journey from Silent Nights to High Holy Days", an activist and mother.

  • Author Jay Michaelson

    Jay Michaelson is a writer, scholar, and actvist whose work focuses on the intersections of religion, spirituality, sexuality, and law. His newest book, "God vs. Gay? The Religious Case for Equality" shows that the Bible supports equal rights.

  • The Rev. Dr. Neil Thomas

    The Rev. Dr. Neil Thomas is currently the Senior Pastor of Metropolitan Community Church of Los Angeles.

  • Rev. Canon Susan Russell

    Rev. Canon Susan Russell is the Associate Pastor at All Saints Pasadena, CA, past president of Integrity, HRC Religion and Faith Council.

  • Pastor Bradley Schmeling

    Rev. Bradley Schmeling is Pastor of Gloria Die Lutheran Church in St. Paul Led the way for full inclusion of LGBT clergy in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA).

  • Rev. Michael S. Piazza

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/mjk_h4pj"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://s.huffpost.com/images/profile/user_placeholder.gif" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/mjk_h4pj">mjk h4pj</a>:<br />Senior Pastor of Virginia-Highland Church in Atlanta, President of Hope for Peace & Justice, Co-Executive Director, Center for Progressive Renewal

  • Rev. Michael Hydes

    Rev. Michael Hydes is the Pastor of New Light Metropolitan Community Church in Hagerstown, MD

  • The Rev. Jeff R. Johnson

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/vagtsama"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://graph.facebook.com/602710258/picture?type=square" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/vagtsama">vagtsama</a>:<br />The Rev. Jeff R. Johnson was one of the first openly gay seminarians in the Lutheran church (ELCA) and a founder of a Lutheran movement to extraordinarily ordain publicly identified LGBT people. Ordained in 1990, Pastor Johnson currently serves University Lutheran Chapel of Berkeley, CA.

  • Bishop George R. Lucey, FCM

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/wjfreeman"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://s.huffpost.com/images/profile/user_placeholder.gif" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/wjfreeman">wjfreeman</a>:<br />The Most Reverend George R. Lucey, FCM, Presiding Bishop of the American National Catholic Church. The denomination has parishes and ministries across the U.S.

  • Rabbi Tracee Rosen

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/lilalexei"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://s.huffpost.com/images/profile/user_placeholder.gif" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/lilalexei">lilalexei</a>:<br />Rabbi Tracee Rosen joined Temple Gan Elohim in September 2010. Before coming to Phoenix, she was the senior rabbi of Congregation Kol Ami, a Reform and Conservative congregation in Utah, from 2003-2010. Prior to that, she served as one of the rabbis at Valley Beth Shalom in Encino, California with Rabbis Harold Schulweis and Ed Feinstein. She was ordained in the second graduating class of the Ziegler School of Rabbinic Studies at the American Jewish University in Los Angeles, CA, where she received numerous awards for academic excellence. She also holds a bachelor’s degree in Jewish Studies and an MBA from Washington University in St. Louis, Missouri. Prior to rabbinical school, she was a banker, working for one of the top banking corporations in the country. Rabbi Tracee, her life partner, and their daughter, recently relocated from Salt Lake City to be closer to family.

  • The Rev. Jeff R. Johnson

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/vagtsama"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://graph.facebook.com/602710258/picture?type=square" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/vagtsama">vagtsama</a>:<br />The Rev. Jeff R. Johnson was one of the first openly gay seminarians in the Lutheran church (ELCA) and a founder of a Lutheran movement to extraordinarily ordain publicly identified LGBT people. Ordained in 1990, Pastor Johnson currently serves University Lutheran Chapel of Berkeley, CA

  • Bishop Christopher Senjonyo

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/frank_mcmullan"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://s.huffpost.com/images/profile/user_placeholder.gif" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/frank_mcmullan">frank mcmullan</a>:<br />Bishop Christopher Senjonyo, Uganda

  • Rev Mervyn Kingston

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/frank_mcmullan"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://s.huffpost.com/images/profile/user_placeholder.gif" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/frank_mcmullan">frank mcmullan</a>:<br />Rev Mervyn Kingston, Ireland

  • John McNeill, SJ

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/frank_mcmullan"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://s.huffpost.com/images/profile/user_placeholder.gif" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/frank_mcmullan">frank mcmullan</a>:<br />Fr John McNeill

  • Sr Jeannine Gramick

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/frank_mcmullan"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://s.huffpost.com/images/profile/user_placeholder.gif" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/frank_mcmullan">frank mcmullan</a>:<br />Sr Jeannine Gramick

  • Archbishop Desmond Tutu

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/frank_mcmullan"><img style="float:left;padding-right:6px !important;" src="http://s.huffpost.com/images/profile/user_placeholder.gif" /></a><a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/frank_mcmullan">frank mcmullan</a>:<br />Archbishop Desmond Tutu, South Africa

 
FOLLOW CANADA LIVING