Canada's Natural Resources Minister Joe Oliver is holding out hope after the European Commission ruled this month that it would officially discriminate against oil from Canada's oil sands, labeling it as too high in carbon emissions to be imported by EU countries. Oliver thinks there's still a chance that the Europeans could come to their senses.
"We definitely don't think we've lost," Oliver told Reuters on Tuesday. "This is far from over." There's a "good chance" that Europe could reverse course, he said, "because we believe science is on our side." The European Union still has to pass the Commission's directive.
Oliver's right of course: The science doesn't back up this puzzling decision. The Europeans are happy to unfairly smear oil sands oil as environmentally problematic, and yet they'll give their blessing to the oil from elsewhere, even if its carbon profile is similar.
And that's just the environmental question. All that OPEC oil Europe seems prepared to commit itself to, instead of Canadian oil, also comes with a massive conflict footprint. Recently we've watched in the news as Venezuela's been condemned for trampling basic civil rights, like freedom of the press and democratic elections; we see sectarian violence erupting in Nigeria; and, of course, the Iranians--who also sell loads of oil to Europe--are carrying out secret executions, brutally persecuting gays and lesbians as well as religious minorities, and imprisoning journalists. There's also the little matter of the terrorist bombing the Iranian regime had reportedly been planning inside the United States (until American intelligence disrupted it in time).
If there's any oil that Europeans should be worried about, it's all the bloody conflict oil entering its borders and that it will continue to depend on as long as they insist on closing their doors to ethical, Canadian oil. Let's hope our natural resources minister is right and that there's still reason to believe that Europe could yet do the right thing and recognize that Canada's oil sands oil isn't only environmentally competitive with many other sources, but it's also one source of oil that doesn't fund repression, war, persecution, and terror. Canada doesn't just have science "on our side" as Oliver points out. We have peace, security and human rights on our side, too.
Follow Kathryn Marshall on Twitter: www.twitter.com/KVMarshall
Ben Amunwa: Canada's Dirty and Dangerous Oil Sands
Ethical oil is not about trade
Ethical oil argument is ludicrous
How much is the processing of this slop going to cost? Do you really think they are buying your ethical argument?
Unless you think sticking a pipe in the ground and watching the pure oil shoot in the air is somehow more expensive than endless processing of tar.
By the time this gooey muck is processed, how much will it cost? How much of the environment will be ruined?
Ethical is probably the only label you can give it because it stinks in every other department. Oh and is case you havent noticed the way despots keep falling in the middle east they will soon be calling their oil "democracy oil"
At present, the oilsands are the very least of their enormous problems. !!
I guess the oil companies preferred corrupt and disgusting regimes.
Why do you support torture?
I guess the first 50 years they were just confused.
Ethical as opposed to what? More Big Oil spin tactics and lies.
The oil sands alsoi produce about as much CO2 "well to wheels" as Venezuelan, Nigerian, and Californian oil.
Which points to a common theme about this debate. Those protesting the oil sands often are grossly misinformed, even to the point of not being able to cite a single accurate statistic on it.
You understand you are talking about Nigerian oil?
They spill more oil every year than BP.
Their oil releases more C02 than our oil.
BTW, do you know of any countries that are 600sq km in area?
What is the name of that country?
http://viableopposition.blogspot.com/2010/09/athabasca-river-how-many-politicians_07.html
The halo of contamination around the mine site is at least 50 kilometres in diameter and is impacting Aboriginal settlements downstream from the operations.