Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Kolby Solinsky

GET UPDATES FROM Kolby Solinsky
 

Is Hockey a Racist Sport?

Posted: 02/15/2013 8:42 am

--------------------------------------------------

Finally.

Finally somebody said it. Finally somebody defended the innocent actions of Evander Kane, and finally somebody said those words we all knew we'd finally hear a hockey player say, one day. It's just too bad it had to be Kane, himself, who said them.

"I think a good portion of (the criticism of me) is because I'm black and I'm not afraid to say that," the left winger told The Hockey News. (*The story is set to come out on March 4, said The Sporting News.)

He then clarified his statements with a solid one-line just after.

"I don't feel like a victim and I don't want to be perceived as one."

Now, the defenders of the realm will be quick to throw up their arms and roll back their eyes. Oh, please, they'll say. Not everything is a racial issue. Just because he's black doesn't mean that's why he's been criticized.

They'll be quick to point out that he's been flagged for a number of off-ice indiscretions and misconducts. They'll tell you he's overreacting. They'll say it's another case of a young player with a big mouth. After all, it's easier to say that than it is to admit the truth, and the truth is not something normally uncovered by sports journalists.

It's odd, though, that people now seem to be more afraid of being politically correct than they are of being racist.

The fact is, hockey is and has always been a whites-only sport. Okay, maybe not whites-only. More, like 95-per cent-white-and-the-rest-just-whatever. Hockey is inherently a white sport, and a white Canadian one, at that. Hockey Night in Canada and its post-20-minute patriotic terrier praise good ol' Canadian boys and the way they play the sport we love.

But, take a minute and think about what the words good ol' Canadian boy mean. What's the image that comes to your mind? Who do you see, and what does he look like?

Sure, it doesn't have the word "white" in it, but neither does the word "Jesus", and I think it's fair to say he's always been depicted as rather pale for someone supposedly born in the Middle East.

Think of the things Kane has been criticized for.

It was rumoured he skipped out of a restaurant bill or two. Okay. So, that's not great and it's nothing to admire, but it's hardly a case for Scotland Yard. Patrick Kane physically assaulted a cab driver in 2008, and I don't remember Chicago ever wondering whether he was a problem for their organization.

And, besides, the Kane/Dine-n-Dash thing was a rumour.

Someone held up a sign suggesting it in another team's rink. That was literally the whole story. Kane laughed about it, and so did the Jets.

Then, Kane was caught in the offseason posting an image of him in Las Vegas flashing two stacks of dollar bills. The photo was taken during the NHL lockout and while many normal people who aren't paid into the millions per year are still struggling to find employment in the wake of the 2008 global economic recession.

Okay, it was a meathead moment. It was a little silly, and it made him look a little immature (which is fair, since Kane is 21 freakin' years old).

But, it wasn't a crime. It was nothing of note. It wasn't a DUI or an assault. It was a personal moment of indulgence and it shouldn't have been aired on social media. Boo hoo.

The fact is, hockey has never had to confront its race issues because, well, it hasn't always had them. Sure, some of us know that Willie O'Ree was the first black player in the NHL, but he's hardly a celebrity in the realm of Jackie Robinson (who broke his barrier 11 years before O'Ree) or even Roberto Clemente.

In fact, O'Ree is barely known.

And, yes, there are only a handful of black players in the league at any given moment -- Joel Ward, Jarome Iginla, P.K. Subban, Wayne Simmonds, and Devante Smith-Pelley, just to name a few -- but that doesn't mean we're not racist. It just means we're not inclusive.

Canadians have always lived with the false notion that they are morally superior when it comes to race issues than our neighbours to the south. Amistad, a hundred years (and more) of slavery, the Ku Klux Clan, Jim Crow, and the Civil Rights Movement? Those are all American things, but it doesn't mean we get to wash our hands clean and call ourselves pure from the womb out.

Our treatment of our aboriginal people (historically and still today) is deplorable. We have a history with the Clan, and we casually try to distance ourselves from phrases like "Komagata Maru" and "Japanese Internment".

And, let's not forget hockey.

In the last year and a half, Wayne Simmonds (a black player for the Philadelphia Flyers) has had a banana thrown at him, and Joel Ward (Washington) and Malcolm Subban (the OHL's Belleville Bulls) have been called the n-word by hateful waves of people on Twitter.

Does this sound like an enlightened country, or like the chorus of "Strange Fruit"?

In the video above, CBC anchor Diana Swain calls the Joel Ward affair a "low for the sport," but is it? It seems like it's status quo.

"I'm not surprised," said Ward's mother, Celia, at the time. "He grew up with it."

As a hockey nation, we also tend to completely dismiss the character and toughness of European players and, specifically, Russian players. (And, yes, French-Canadian players, too.) We call this analysis, but that's not really true. Russian players are treated from their draft day like they have to prove something over and above their Canadian counterparts, or like they have to atone for previous players from Moscow and the surrounding area who were viewed as soft or fragile or Prima Donnas, despite any evidence to the contrary.

Is there really much difference between Henrik Sedin and Ryan Nugent-Hopkins? What about Sergei Fedorov and Steve Yzerman? Or, Teemu Selanne and Ryan Getzlaf? Gretzky and Kurri?

Let's face it: hockey is an extension of us, and we all still have a lot of work to do.

*This was originally posted on White Cover Magazine.

Loading Slideshow...

 

Follow Kolby Solinsky on Twitter: www.twitter.com/WhiteCoverMag

FOLLOW CANADA
-------------------------------------------------- Finally. Finally somebody said it. Finally somebody defended the innocent actions of Evander Kane, and finally somebody said those words we all k...
-------------------------------------------------- Finally. Finally somebody said it. Finally somebody defended the innocent actions of Evander Kane, and finally somebody said those words we all k...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:59 AM on 02/17/2013
Of course it's racist and bigoted! Always been.
Think Richard riot, think why Toronto has more Hall of famers then Mtl despite not even winning half as many cups! .then there's a proud traditions of racists:Campbells, Bettman, Don Cherry, etc.. It is an accurate depiction of Canada!

But it is probably a bit better these days, than back when a few " old boys" controlled it all... But Bettman is well known for his views!!
01:09 PM on 02/15/2013
Sorry, but this article is a stretch to say the least. Sure, it's undeniable that hockey is predominantly played by Caucasians, but in no way does that make the sport inherently racist. If you're good enough to play in the league, you get picked up by a team. Simple as that.
Are the NBA and NFL also racist because their players are mainly African American?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:25 AM on 02/15/2013
strange reading a Canadian saying the American terms 'black' and 'white'...quite bizarre :3
10:07 AM on 02/15/2013
Hockey is comprised of a Majority of White Kids because it's the sport their Dads grew up playing. Also because it's a sport that's ridiculously expensive to play, the socio-economic background is Upper-Middle class or better. You just don't see visible minorities of that financial capacity choosing to put their kids into hockey.

I've played hockey my entire life, still do. Sure I've played with every visible minority I can think of, but about 80% of all my teammates have been other "White Guys". Polish, Ukrainian, Croatian, Russian, Hungarian I guess don't count.

Evander Kane is a juvenile more occupied by dreams of hanging out with YMCMB than becoming a better player. A proud working class city like Winnipeg expects players to conduct themselves with class and follow the ubiquitous 'Code'. But the vitriol he faces via twitter can't be excused. There's always a small but vocal percentage of Racists around. But Hockey in and of itself is NOT a racist sport. I don't know that such a thing is possible.
09:56 AM on 02/15/2013
I think white people will need to find a new planet to live on. It doesn't seem like we can do anything right according to some people. I guess unless we are willing to be a silent majority that freely gives up its rights to do anything lest it offend someone, or keep bringing in immigrants from any country but a white country, we will need to find a new planet. It seems the voices for multiculturalism are always from a group that wants a one religion/culture nation yet wants to say how other nations should live. We have become so PC that it will kill us off as a race. This will one day be understood as the biggest expression of racism by the one last dying white man.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Kolby Solinsky
10:35 AM on 02/15/2013
You sure live up to your last name, Bill Banter.
09:49 AM on 02/15/2013
Hockey has a class problem. Class has a race problem. Iginla's parents are a lawyer and a teacher. The Subbans' parents are a school principal and a banker. Furthermore, I looked up Karl Subban and he wanted to play hockey as a kid but his parents were too poor to support it. The number one reason there are no more black kids in the NHL is that there are not more black kids in the middle class. That has absolutely nothing to do with hockey, though it does have to do with Canada.
10:52 AM on 02/15/2013
it truly is an elitist sport, i would be in the same boat as the senior Subban. every year i asked, every year i got the same answer, we cant afford it.
09:16 AM on 02/15/2013
Hockey is not a racist or sexist sport. There have been black players in the NHL for decades and if they're good enough they make the headlines then we hear about them. Grant Fuhr and Jerome Iginla immediately come to mind. How about PK Subban, or his younger brother, Malcolm, who was praised plenty for his netminding in this years World Juniors? I guess that's not controversial enough for you eh?
The problem is that it's become fashionable to criticize hockey because that's the society we live in now. Everyone thinks they have a right to change anything that remotely offends them, so they go out looking for a pot to stir. Don't like hockey? There's no shortage of people willing to listen and become outraged on your behalf.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Kolby Solinsky
10:14 AM on 02/15/2013
Yeah, I'm not sure you read what I wrote...
11:02 AM on 02/15/2013
Yes, I have. You make the assertion numerous times that the sport is inherently racist. You also indicate that it's a problem in Canada and then try to use our Government's abhorent treatment of aboriginals to support your claims.
Regarding Wayne Simmonds and the thrown banana, he also said this--

"That's a first for me. I guess it's something I obviously have to deal with — being a black player playing in a predominantly white sport. I've grown a lot playing in this league and throughout my whole life. I'm not going to dwell on that. It's over with now."

Maybe you should get over it, too.
And using twitter to support your claim? Seriously? I'm not even going to bother with that one.

I think you need to seriously consider the possibility that you're trying too hard to chase down the 'let's blame hockey' bandwagon. If your predominant readership were middle-aged, minivan driving soccer moms then yes, you would find the support you're seeking, but you won't find it from those of us who are constantly being talked down to by people who know little to nothing of the sport's history and likely never will.
It's our national sport, along with Lacrosse, and while it may not be perfect, it's far from racist. Maybe try being proud of what we have instead of looking for an edge to pry up.

0.02
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
robertmiller252
08:24 AM on 02/15/2013
Ever thought that there are just not enough good minority hockey players?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Kolby Solinsky
10:14 AM on 02/15/2013
Thanks for your comment, Robert.

I don't disagree with you. I was just saying something which I think is rather obvious, which is that hockey is not a very multi-ethnic sport and, because of that, it hasn't historically had to confront the same issues that baseball and basketball have.