Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
k-os

GET UPDATES FROM k-os
 

Does Pitchfork Have a Race Problem?

Posted: 02/07/2013 11:21 am

Why do they do that?

Why did Pitchfork Media take Chief Keef
a 17-year-old rapper that has had a history of trouble with the law -- and
who was placed on probation after a 2011 incident in which he pointed a gun at police officers
why did that website choose to take this boy to a gun range for a featured interview?
of all the places they could take him
why a gun range?
I'm sure they have interviewed a plethora of bands in their basements and around their musical instruments
or better yet -- in the pixie-like shimmery sunny daylight of a central park
so i shall ask again...
why would they take a troubled black youth to a gun range for a featured interview?
what kind of results were they trying to achieve with these actions?
do you know?
well...
I can tell you what DID happen
after the rapper actually fired a gun at the gun range during the interview
judge Carl Anthony Walker found that Keef exhibited a "willful disregard" of the court
in other words, he violated his probation and as a result was jailed in his hometown of Chicago

So there you have it...
cognitive dissonance to the most disturbing degree
I guess, in one sense, someone at Pictchfork thought the music of Chief Keef was good enough to shine light on
in another sense they couldn't resist the stereotypical "street coolness" of ::::
taking a troubled black youth who had been known for pointing guns at the police to shoot a gun at a gun range
YUP --> GANGSTURR!!

Usually in the state of cognitive dissonance, people may sometimes feel "disequilibrium"
OR -- frustration, dread, guilt, anger embarrassment and anxiety
but I doubt Pitchfork felt any of these emotions
and even if they did...how would we know?
they simply took down the segment from their site

There is an interesting trend happening within our generation
young white 30-somethings feel entitled enough to make an attempt at writing the hip-hop or black culture narrative
they feel like since they grew up with hip-hop, that they "understand it"
and so...I keep asking
why do they do that?
assuming they have right to present "rap" to the world as they see fit

There has never been a better example of the misuse of this assumed power than this Chief Keef incident
strangely enough you hardly find hip-hop or black music websites writing about foxygen or tegan and sara (which maybe they should)

As an artist these bold contradictions in cultural ethos exchange really disturb me
I am tired of watching black culture being fed back to black people and the world without so much as a positive or intellectual spin
by NON-BLACKS
I think the people behind these types of websites act in weak and racist ways
but they hide their racist actions behind humour or tongue in cheek "indie irony"
this type of irony may actually be more disturbing and cowardly than the behaviour of their forefathers
DJANGO UNCHAINED
at least those Colonel Sanders dudes weren't chicken
they just spoke how they really felt through their fear and ignorance
this new yuppie form of fear racism and ignorance tho...is way more subversive and dangerous
simply because the images being presented to the world constantly frame rap and black people in a very violent and specific way
leaving absolutely no room for progressive ideas and positive profiles
despite their obsession with Frank Ocean
George Michael Faith

So I ask you again...
why do they do that?

From what I can assess the underlying motive is fear
fact is -- black music has always changed the pulse and face of pop culture
if you can control the perception of black music at its inception (or indie-ness)
you can control its effects on the whole world
which is A LOT of watch-dog/gatekeeper power for any group of young people to have
this extensive emasculating savage scaffolding continues to be built with the precise skill of white privileged architects
like the tower of Babel
Cody ChestnuTT

Take the one of the headliners of this years Pitchfork Festival for instance -- Mr. R. Kelley
we all know his story
and you can bet that Pitchfork knows it as well
is there any question that playing towards prison convictions is the new new racist subversive fashionista?

Keep spinnin' those prison records on "black" vinyl yawL!
Woop-Woop!
Beep-Beep
I see the message
Saul Williams

And what can be done?
I feel ...
absolutely nothing
however...
what i do hope is that if you read this story and then you go on over to Pitchfork's website
you will realize that the titles
"Frank Ocean and Chris Brown in Fight at L.A. Studio"
OR "Rick Ross Was the Target of Drive-By Shooting"
aren't just headlines
they are deadlines and dread lines...
designed to keep your mind tampered with
like some Holy Books

where the f# *k is Jay- Electronicaaaah
maaaaang!!!!

 

Follow k-os on Twitter: www.twitter.com/kosinception

FOLLOW CANADA MUSIC
 
 
  • Comments
  • 36
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
03:26 PM on 03/04/2013
This article will only appeal to the very demographic it criticizes. I grew up with hip-hop music but turned my back when I realized what an emotionally and intellectually stunted culture it is - thanks to those that bought it and to those that sold it out. To me, it should have remained a tree falling in the woods.
10:59 PM on 02/09/2013
Everyone who talked negative about this article, is not from the GHETTO wont ever understand. Thats fine cant expect someone to understand something they know nothing about. People who bash Chief have to understand that no one wants to be born into poverty and violence, when Chief got more money he left. Think ppl. Pitchfork and Fader are both racist, they need do present hiphop in a presentable way, so I do like that, but they will post lil b before J Electronica... crazy
10:59 PM on 02/08/2013
The issue k-Os seems to be speaking about isn't just about equal employment opportunities for Black journalists (bcuz hiring Black journalists doesn't mean they have to write about Black-culture-related topics) - and nothing to do with whether White writers have a valid opinion on Black culture. It IS about WHO, in an area of journalism with extremely LIMITED spaces, is allowed/chosen/privileged to write specifically about Black culture, and WHO (by default of these institutional limitations) isn't. This favoring of White/Non-Black writers over Black writers - (for whatever explicit/implicit, aloof, good/bad-intentioned reasons) - in a subject-area of journalism, so obviously rooted in, consequential to, and dependent upon, the experiences of Blacks - is racism. So again, it's not that White journalists don't have the right to write about Black culture; or don't have extremely valid or important opinions on Black culture (even when those opinions are flawed/problematic). It's that when these positions for writing on Black culture are LIMITED and within a powerful/influential institution capitalizing off Black culture - it is as much their journalistic/socio-corporate responsibility to ensure their writers have the most critical understanding of Black culture, as it would be if the topic-matter was about Syria, Afghanistan, or any subject where the stakes, with respect to pop culture's HEALTHY understanding of the people/groups represented/affected by these narratives, are HIGH. And those high stakes DEMAND (within these limited and profit-making systems) responsible anti-racist journalism practices.
01:54 PM on 02/08/2013
Not holding an artist at a minimum, partly accountable to the perception they are broadcasting especially in such an overt instance is short sighted.
As far as I can tell Pitchfork has reviewed every genre of music I can think of. If they didn't review rap it would be consipcuous in it's absence.
The worst part is that you may have actually have a relevant point or two and it is clear you feel strongly about it but your one-sidedness and the examples you extrapolate are such a stretch that it negatively impacts your credibility. It's like you wrote this to purposefully upset people.
09:20 AM on 02/08/2013
This is the strangest poem I've ever read.
09:13 AM on 02/08/2013
why would they not have the right to present rap to the world however they see fit?
why does Mr. os use the term "troubled black youth" instead of youth with a prior gun conviction?
why point out that he's black?
The fact that K-os believes black people are superior to any other race when it comes to "writing the hip-hop narrative" makes him the text book definition of a racist. And it's possible to have a "race problem" without being a racist.
09:13 AM on 02/08/2013
Maybe because he shoots guns and is a gangbanger, so it makes sense to take him to a shooting range. Obviously he was not forced to go there.
You don't see them taking Earl Sweatshirt to the shooting range, but he gets plenty of space on Pitchfork, so quit your bullshit.
Websites can post whatever they want and write about whatever they want, who are you to sensor this and say they must write about more black artists when a huge majority of their audience are white kids who like indie rock?
07:10 AM on 02/08/2013
Can anyone name a single Asian musical artist other than PSY? Anyone of Indian heritage other than Dr Gupta? You'd think there were only two races in America.
Calling someone a "troubled Youth" after he aimed a gun at police is racist in itself. He should be called a Hoodlum.
06:47 AM on 02/08/2013
Pitchfork's race problem is that they so blatantly have a quota for black artists to fill, and it's always diverted to the space they reserve for mainstream hip hop to 'ironically' praise as 'genius' in that indie hipster way that they have.
01:46 AM on 02/08/2013
The evidence for Pitchfork's "Race Problem" is hilariously thin

The evidence for k-os's grammar, punctuation, and basic formatting problem is quite conclusive however
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shahanshah
Liberalism is destroying western civilization
11:22 PM on 02/07/2013
....Are you kidding me?

So this guy, a Black Disciples member who pointed a loaded gun at a cop is the victim of some sort of internet racism because they took a trap rapper to a gun range?

You are the epitome of what is wrong with society.
09:55 PM on 02/07/2013
First, let me say, thrilled to see k-os on HuffPost. Second, I think this encapsulates perfectly the interesting underlying sociological trends with black culture mixing in the indie-hipster scene (which is predominantly white, let's face it). Very impressed with the points brought up concerning the inequalities here. I'm glad this conversation has been started.
05:56 PM on 02/07/2013
I totally agree... but this isn't the beginning of the media feeding on a certain "blackness"... this is just a tragic example... another example, not so tragic but another child birthed out of this incestuousness relationship, "Douglas, you not black... you don't act black or sound black, you just dark skinned" (in my mind, i think, geez, im dark skinned and you have an identity problem).

I see that you, almost randomly, placed a few interesting artist in the article, and i feel that for quite some time, media dictates who just don't fit in the media's stereotype... so they aren't "good enough" to make it in "mainstream hiphop"... Cody Chesnutt, Saul Williams, Jill Scott, Esperanza Spaulding, Ramona Robbins, TV on the Radio, Corrine Bailey Rae, and the Noisettes and many many other "black people' that should be dictating what "black music" sounds like... instead of what the subpar bull you will hear when you turn your radio on... when was the last time you learned as you listened about anything new.. you heard and rhyme and had to break out a book to figure out what in the world is going on??? Don't understand the point i am trying to make?? Play Mos Def's Black on Both Sides and gain understanding...

Closing, you know where i saw your first video K-os? on BET''s 106 and Park... think on that...
05:22 PM on 02/07/2013
Thanks, K-Os, for pointing this out. That was a pretty crappy think Pitchfork did.

Bit of friendly advice from a fan? Get an editor next time. I'm available.
09:44 PM on 02/07/2013
"Pretty crappy thin(g) Pitchfork did."

Don't quit your day-job just yet...
10:19 PM on 02/07/2013
(um...from one English major to another, reread your second sentence.)
06:48 AM on 02/08/2013
Take a look at your own.
01:39 PM on 03/03/2013
Ha, you're right. That was a pretty funny error.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SadieMae23
05:13 PM on 02/07/2013
Pitchfork has a race problem. Obviously - but at least they have writers who can string together coherent sentences, which is more than you can say for some rappers turned journalists...
08:22 PM on 02/07/2013
If you have seen his blogs posts you'll understand that this is his style. Rapper turned journalist? By whose reckoning. Come off it, man.
10:05 PM on 02/07/2013
A lack of punctuation altogether, is not style... it's a clever way of hiding his grammatic ignorance. Like, "I can't use it wrong, if I don't use it at all!"

If he doesn't understand something, he should've done what any journalist that takes their writing seriously, does - investigate it.

The issue the article goes into, is a very significant subject, in and outside of the music industry. It deserves to be taken more seriously than his "style" is capable of.

Readers need to respect their authors. I assume you can see how that's an issue, here...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ProgressiveCDN
A Progressive Moderate
11:13 PM on 02/07/2013
no kidding. F & F