Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Marci Warhaft-Nadler

GET UPDATES FROM Marci Warhaft-Nadler

Schools Need to Lay Off Our Kids' Lunch Bags

Posted: 11/20/2013 12:34 pm

I get it.

Childhood obesity is a growing problem in our society. Some say it's because our kids are playing too many video games, other people blame it on a steady diet of fast food. Whatever the reason, we're constantly being told that our kids are getting fatter and sicker by the minute and that we'd better intervene as quickly as possible. Recently, more and more schools have begun implementing "healthy food programs" in an effort to encourage a healthier lifestyle. Unfortunately, while this may sound good in theory, it can be disastrous when put into action.

The problem is that there just isn't enough research and education being done around these programs before they get into our schools and often times the information our kids are getting is less than accurate and in some cases, even dangerous.

One popular practice has some schools banning "junk food" from lunch bags. This is a policy that I find incredibly difficult to swallow. While I have absolutely no problem with schools refusing to sell foods they feel are unhealthy in their cafeterias or vending machines, I strongly believe that what a parent chooses to pack their own kids for lunch is their own business.

If a child is told that the lunch their parent has provided for them is unacceptable, they will feel confused and humiliated. Children need to trust their parents and parents need to feel confident that the decisions they make for their kids won't be overruled by their school. Lunch bag inspections could also lead to the child hiding the "bad" food and then eating it secretly to avoid being teased or judged. This is not a behaviour we want to encourage.

Another mistake is that by making certain foods "taboo" they will only be making them more enticing for some kids. Telling kids they can't have cookies will only make them want them even more, only now they'll feel guilty for eating them. The last thing we want to do is create negative feelings around food.

We need to be educating our kids about food, not shaming them away from it.

A few years ago, I found myself protesting the "Healthy Eating Plan" that was being implemented at my sons' school. While I appreciated their intentions, it was the execution that I had a problem with. I am very grateful to the teachers who genuinely want to do what's best for their students, which is why I think it's so unfair to them and to our kids when school boards ask them to promote programs that are so flawed.

Just this week, when a mom in Manitoba sent her two kids to school with homemade lunches that included roast beef, potatoes, carrots, oranges and milk, she was shocked to receive a note from the school telling her that their lunches were deemed "unbalanced" and were supplemented with Ritz crackers. The school follows the strict guidelines of what many believe to be a very outdated Canada's Food Guide and felt that the "grains" category had been neglected. To add insult to injury, this mom was fined $10 for her oversight.

It amazes me that chastising this woman for the obviously well balanced meal she chose to pack for her kids didn't seem at all strange to the person writing that note. No offense to Ritz crackers, but what exactly was missing? The sodium? Saturated fat? I'm confused, and if I was this mom, I would be livid.

Another bizarre example of food shaming comes from Richmond, Virginia where a school has decided to eliminate the risk of poor parental lunch choices altogether by making it against school policy to send your kids to school with any kind of lunch at all. Instead, all school lunches will be provided by the school. On what planet, does it seem alright to not allow a parent to have a say in what their child eats during the day? Of course, you can be exempt from this rule, if you provide a note from your doctor with an excuse as to why you want your child to have homemade lunches over the ones in the cafeteria.

I imagine that would read something like this," Please excuse Megan from eating the chicken nuggets, tater tots and other foods from the cafeteria as her mother would prefer she ate...anything else!"

I think these programs are misguided. Instead of worrying about every little thing we're feeding our kids, they should be concerning themselves with the kids who aren't being fed at all. I think schools should provide food for the children who just don't have enough at home because those families could use some support. It should be about looking out for each other and working together as a community to help each other out, not judging each other's parenting choices.

The most confusing part of this story for me, is that while this school doesn't trust their parents enough to pack homemade lunches, they promote the fact that they sell ice cream and nachos during P.E. classes!


There are ways we can teach our kids about nutrition and healthy living without creating weird rules about food, but we have to do the proper research to make sure this is done correctly. I applaud the schools that want to take action, but beg them not to jump into something without looking at it from all angles to make sure that in their effort to encourage healthy kids, they aren't creating confused, embarrassed and eating disordered ones instead.

If our goal is to raise healthy, well-adjusted kids, we have to work together to make that happen. It may take a village to raise a child, but if that village is dysfunctional, what chance does that child have?


Loading Slideshow...
  • Fruits And Vegetables

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 2-3 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 4

  • Fruits And Vegetables

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 4-8 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 5

  • Fruits And Vegetables

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 9-13 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 6

  • Grain Products

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 2-3 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 3

  • Grain Products

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 4-8 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 4

  • Grain Products

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 9-13 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 6

  • Milk And Alternatives

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 2-3 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 2

  • Milk And Alternatives

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 4-8 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 2

  • Milk And Alternatives

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 9-13 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 3-4

  • Meat And Alternatives

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 2-3 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 1

  • Meat And Alternatives

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 4-8 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 1

  • Meat And Alternatives

    <strong>AGE:</strong> 9-13 <strong>SERVING:</strong> 1-2

  • NEXT: 14 Yummy Lunch Box Ideas Your Kids Will Love

  • Ants on a Log

    <strong>Ants on a log:</strong> This one might make you feel nostalgic as you make it. Turns out this classic kindergarten snack isn't just fun, it's also healthy: celery is a source of potassium, peanut butter has protein, and raisins have fibre.

  • Carrot Sticks and Hummus

    <strong>Carrot sticks and hummus:</strong> Make this crunchy snack — a great way to get some protein and vitamin A into their bellie — easy to transport and eat by putting the hummus at the bottom of a small jar and placing the carrot sticks in so they stand up. A great idea for a workday snack for you, too!

  • Smoothies

    These are the perfect way to sneak in healthy ingredients like yogurt, greens, or chia seeds — <a href="http://www.marthastewart.com/search/apachesolr_search/smoothies" target="_hplink">Martha Stewart's site has some great recipes</a>, but doing an online search for your favourite ingredient plus "smoothie" is sure to bring up tons of suggestion. Companies like <a href="http://thesilico.com/proddetail.php?prod=silisqueeze" target="_hplink">Sili Squeeze</a> and <a href="http://www.yummipouch.com/" target="_hplink">Yummi Pouch</a> sell portable smoothie containers that are great for all ages, from toddlers and up. Just squeeze and enjoy!

  • Fruit

    It's hard to beat simple, whole fruit as a snack — it's healthy, it's easy to transport, it requires zero prep, and it's inexpensive.

  • Bento Box

    Okay, maybe your creations won't be quite as stunning as <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/01/back-to-school-bento-box-lunches_n_1730487.html" target="_hplink">these Japanese ones</a>, but a bento box is still a great snack idea. You can make ingredients like rice balls en masse and use them throughout the week, and layer in other options like chopped meat (a way to repurpose leftovers!) and raw veggies.

  • Pita Wheels

    There are a million things you can do with this basic recipe: get a healthy pita (look for whole grains and fibre), spread it with your ingredients of choice (goat cheese and jelly, almond butter and chard, hummus and thinly sliced meat, anything you can come up with — just make sure you have a sticky layer), roll it up, and then chop it into fun wheels.

  • Roasted Chickpeas

    Here's a great option if your kids love chips — you can incorporate their favourite flavours, like salt and vinegar or chili, with a healthy ingredient like chickpeas, a source of fibre and protein. <a href="http://www.howsweeteats.com/2012/10/exactly-how-i-roast-my-chickpeas/" target="_hplink">This basic recipe</a> can be adjusted with your favourite herbs and spices.

  • Greek Yogurt

    Greek yogurt is all over the grocery aisles now, and it's a good thing — it's full of healthy bacteria that keep your gut humming along, and it's a great source of calcium. To avoid excess added sugars, look for plain yogurt, and add in your own mixers like berries or chopped pineapple.

  • Homemade Trail Mix

    Trail mix can be a great snack, but packed mixes are often full of fat and added salt and sugar. Easy solution: make your own! Just pick the ingredients you'd like to have, mix through, and package into smaller containers to make it easy to grab and go.

  • Babybel

    These cheese discs are easy to transport, fun to unwrap, and a great hit of calcium, filling fat and protein. They come in several different flavors so you can give your kids their favorite cheese.

  • Mini Pizzas

    Kids love pizza, but it can be greasy and covered in unhealthy toppings. An easy solution is to make your own — you can go lighter on the cheese, and heavier on the healthy stuff like greens and lean meats. Mini pitas or slider buns are a great way to make these mini, which also makes them more fun.

  • Baked Pitas and Dip

    You can give the kids something crunchy without putting chips in the lunch bag. Crisp up some pitas in the oven—brush them with a bit of olive oil, maybe sprinkle with a bit of cumin for a kick. And pair it with a healthy dip or salsa — even homemade!

  • Parmesan Popcorn

    Popcorn is actually a whole grain, and it's a good way to get some fibre in your kids' bellies. And if you air pop it, it's low in calories, which means you can beef it up with some fresh parmesan and your kids' favourite herbs or spices.

  • Edamame

    In Japan, edamame is a bar food — sprinkle with salt, pop them open, and enjoy. Much healthier than pretzels! They can be a fun snack for your kids too, one that provides them with some protein to help them get through the afternoon.


Follow Marci Warhaft-Nadler on Twitter: www.twitter.com/fit_vs_fiction