Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Marcia Sirota

GET UPDATES FROM Marcia Sirota

Face the Truth About Your Bad Relationship

Posted: 09/02/11 03:01 PM ET

Are you one of those people who finds it really hard to see the bad in others? Do you need to believe that everyone in your life is a good person and can't imagine that someone you love or respect could be capable of cruelty, manipulation or thoughtlessness? Do you always give the other person the benefit of the doubt?

If this is you, you're setting yourself up to be hurt. People who refuse to accept that others are capable of bad behaviour are extreme idealists. They're overly attached to values like honesty, integrity and decency. They think that if they're not capable of behaving badly, others couldn't possibly be, either.

I've lost track of the number of times a patient has begun telling me a story of how their spouse, friend or boss had been hurtful to them, and then finished by saying, "I can't believe they treated me this way. I don't understand it!" Like the above-mentioned idealists, these patients had too-high expectations of the people in their lives and were constantly encountering disappointment.

I've noticed that when someone has trouble facing the truth about hurtful people, it's not just because they have an overly-optimistic view of human nature. They're sensitive souls who find it too painful to believe that others can behave badly, so they'd rather not know.

This type of denial has its roots in early-life hurts or losses. In fact, those who're afraid to see others as capable of bad behaviour often have a history of painful experiences in their own childhood.

Children can't accept that their parents or guardians could be cruel or neglectful. It's too overwhelming to recognize that the people who're supposed to love them, care for them and protect them actually might be letting them down.

As adults, they maintain their denial. Their childhood experiences of loss or disappointment left them feeling especially vulnerable. Any disappointment in the present day is unbearable, so they resist seeing the truth about the people in their adult lives.

The reality, however, is that people are indeed, capable of bad behavior. Some of these hurtful individuals are angry because of their own childhood trauma and they take out their pain and frustration on others.

Some people have no conscience, no sense of responsibility, empathy or remorse. These individuals are deliberately cruel. Then there are the well-meaning people who are inadvertently hurtful, and those who don't care enough to do the right thing.

Whatever the cause, hurtful people engage in all sorts of bad behavior, ranging from minor insensitivity to outright sadism. Denying this truth about human nature will lead to many difficulties.

For example, there's the mother who refuses to believe that her husband is capable of molesting his daughter and therefore turns a blind eye, essentially perpetuating the abuse.

There's the employee who insists that his boss is fair-minded and that all his hard work, loyalty and self-sacrifice will be rewarded, when in fact he's being exploited.

There's the husband who risks his marriage when he repeatedly fails to protect his wife from his mother's constant criticisms, telling her instead, "Oh, that's just the way Mom is."

There's the woman who refuses to believe that her husband is capable of two-timing her, and the man who's constantly lending money to his freeloading buddy because he needs to see him as a "good guy."

There's the girl who agrees to have unprotected sex with her brand-new boyfriend because she wants to think she can trust him, and the man who hands over his entire life savings to a financial adviser, convinced that this person will invest his money wisely.

If you deny the possibility that someone could be hurtful, you put yourself and your loved ones at great risk. Facing this truth, on the other hand, is empowering and will enable you to make the kinds of choices which will give you a better life.

When people are inadvertently hurtful, calling them on their behavior affords them the opportunity to make amends and change their ways. When people are deliberately hurtful or just don't care, confronting them will bring out defensiveness or hostility and reveal their true nature.

Denying other people's capacity for cruelty or thoughtlessness ultimately serves to perpetuate it. Acknowledging that hurtful people do exist will empower those who've been hurt to take much better care of themselves and their loved ones in the future.

Facing the truth will allow those on the receiving end of bad behaviour to do what they couldn't as children: assert themselves, defend themselves or walk away from relationships which are neglectful or abusive.

It may be disappointing and disillusioning to face the truth about someone's hurtful actions, but it will prevent a lot of unhappiness, now and in the days to come.

 
 
 

Follow Marcia Sirota on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@rcinstitute

 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:22 PM on 09/13/2011
This outstanding, and came to me at a time when I can really understand it, and employ the concept in my life...a time of thinking and planning. Thank you. A thousand thank yous for putting this up on HP.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
peachfuzz
my favorite color is pinko
12:11 PM on 09/11/2011
Great article. I've had people tell me that they can't live if they entertain the thought that people are not going to act in everyone's best interest. The same people who can't get over being hurt ... the same people who keep making the same mistakes. When your parents hurt you, it damages you and robs you of your life until you learn to see things clearer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Helen In Canada
12:45 PM on 09/07/2011
Very nicely stated! Thank you.
10:33 AM on 09/06/2011
I am in the midst of a divorce and relocating to another state next month. My husband is/was (divorce not final yet) a psychiatrist. I am now 54, but when I was 26-29, he was "my" psychiatrist. Bells should have sounded. They did not. I thought he walked on water. After I married him, at age 41, after us finding one another again, I was so surprised to see this "other" side of him. This mentally and physically abusive side of him. I kept denying it was there. Your words ring so true for me. Because, as you said, in denying it, you ultimately perpetuate it. Thank you for such an insightful article. He is not allowed to ever contact me again. I am beginning to heal.
Brenda
12:11 PM on 09/04/2011
Ms. Sirota, this is a helpful post. Thank you. Perhaps this is a response to your previous post about women’s intuition?

Perhaps one way of thinking and talking about it is not as either good or bad. Instead, how about clearly identifying cruel behavior as cruel? One can only hope you are working on that point with Ellie now. Otherwise she’ll be burned twice: once from her lying husband and once from you whose assumptions were not made clear to her earlier. And I know, this challenges the psychotherapeutic conceit that you might get entangled or it wouldn’t allow her to make decisions for herself. Of course that is a larger issue, but sorry, it’s poppycock. If a woman walked out into traffic and didn’t see a car coming and you did, would you tell them to get out of harms way? Likewise, if someone comes to you for help and it is obviously conveyed or subtly implicit that it will be given to them and yet, at least for them, it is denied, how would they react? As has been mentioned by many more than me, they’d need therapy to get over their therapy. I suspect she is merely living from a point of trust that is no longer valid. That’s not delusional, it’s reasonable and human. No one needs a double dose of betrayal. As is obvious I speak from experience.

But please don’t get me wrong. Your post is a very positive step in the right direction.
photo
abhorson
in favor of legalized bar fighting
09:05 AM on 09/04/2011
"There's the woman who refuses to believe that her husband is capable of two-timing her.."

Funny, ALL the wives (girlfriends) I know (mine/friends') or I've had ... all thought the opposite .. that their boyfriend / husband must be doing something if he's not home on time, or on a business trip, or has a young, cute secretary ...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
teacherfor25
I say it like I see it.
01:27 AM on 09/04/2011
I know there is bad in people. I would never deny that. I just am tired of being emotional crushed by those people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Veronica
08:59 PM on 09/03/2011
There's a really great book called "In Sheep's Clothing" by Dr. George Simon, who has a far different take on treating personality disorders from the average clinical psychologist. That is, he's more interested in helping the victims of narcissists, manipulators and the like recognize bad behavior and take back some control in the relationship than trying to change said narcissists and manipulators themselves, which he views as a usually pointless endeavor. They end up trying to manipulate the therapist or view therapy sessions as an outlet for their self-absorption. I grew up the child of a narcissist who chose as my stepfather another arch narcissist and this book helped me immensely! What you said about the denial that comes from childhood mistreatment also hit close to home.
09:15 AM on 09/07/2011
Wow! I thought trying to take back control was the ONLY way to deal with these types of people. I would never waste my time trying to change someone else, that's a fool's errand with a poor ROI.