Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Maude Barlow

GET UPDATES FROM Maude Barlow
 

CETA: A Threat to Local Democracy

Posted: 10/22/11 10:00 AM ET

This week, European Union trade officials are in Canada to meet with their Canadian counterparts on what might be the final round of negotiations on a huge new trade agreement called CETA - the Canada-EU Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement. Because it will affect every Canadian, it is urgent that we get a debate going in this country on this massive new free trade deal.

Unlike some other trade agreements, CETA has had very little media attention or public profile. There are two reasons for this. The first is that the Harper government has kept CETA under wraps and negotiated it in secret. We only know the perimeters of CETA through unofficial reports, the Europeans themselves, who are very open about their demands, and through a now dated leaked draft of the text. The Harper government is ideologically driven by a belief in the privatization, deregulation and strengthened corporate power that attend trade deals like CETA and others it is negotiating, and does not encourage debate on any of them.

The other reason CETA has had little opposition is that many Canadians have an out-dated view of Europe as having higher social, environmental, and worker standards and believe that diversifying our trade away from the U.S. to a more enlightened jurisdiction such as Europe must be a good thing. Indeed, a few years ago, I would have felt the same way.

What Canadians need to know is that Europe is going through a profound transformation. As part of its unification process, it has adopted an agreement on procurement that not only allows the private sector of each country free entry into all other EU countries, but also paves the way for their success by promoting -- often by law -- public-private partnerships to enhance business opportunities for these corporations. As a result, Europe is privatizing its public utilities and services such as transit, water, postal, and hydro at an alarming rate. This is the model of development being negotiated for Canada in CETA. Add to this the "austerity measures" now being imposed on many European countries, which include the wholesale sell-off of assets such as water, and we are talking about a very different Europe where workers are struggling for basic rights and basic social services are being privatized.

CETA poses a grave threat to Canada's social programs and public services because, for the first time, the provinces are at the table negotiating away their own rights and those of their municipalities. CETA allows corporations to bid on all "sub-national procurement," that is, all the ways in which provincial and municipal levels of governments spend our tax revenues. Access to these levels of government contracts was not available in previous trade deals and represents the mother lode for foreign companies, anywhere from $100 billion to $200 billion a year.

European corporations want to sell Canadians the services we now receive publicly, services such as health care, education, water and mail delivery, and CETA will give these private companies the right to bid on government tenders for goods and services including schools, hospitals, airports, public transit, ports, and hydro projects to name just a few. Any rules or practices that favour local economic development, support local food production or promote local or Canadian goods and services will be challenged as unfair barriers to trade. As well, these corporations will have the right to challenge any local laws that promote fair trade or reflect the environmental concerns of the community, such as bottled water bans.

Europe is also in a race with China to nail down access to raw resources such as Canada's fish, potash, natural gas, forests, and minerals and will gain permanent access to these resources through an "investor-state" provision of CETA that will give European corporations the right to sue Canadian governments if they try to interfere with their "right to profit." Under a similar provision in NAFTA, the Harper government shockingly recently paid an American pulp and paper corporation, Abitibi Bowater, $130 million for the timber and water "rights" the company claimed when it picked up and left Newfoundland and the workers high and dry.

The National Farmer's Union is deeply worried that the Harper government will sacrifice supply managed poultry and dairy farming in Canada and give big European agribusiness companies the right to further erode farmer rights to save, exchange and sell seeds from their crops. The move this week to kill the Wheat Board in spite of its very high rating of approval by Western wheat farmers, is a sure sign that the Harper government will sacrifice family farms to get this deal.

Canadians should also know that a clear European demand in CETA is to bring our patent regime for brand name pharmaceuticals into line with their own more business friendly regime. A study done by the Universities of Calgary and Toronto reported that these changes would cost Canadians almost $3 billion more in drug costs a year. Drugs are the fastest-growing component of health care costs in Canada; yet there has been little public debate about this aspect of CETA.

Public awareness of this dangerous trade deal has been growing. Paul Moist, President of the Canadian Union of Public Employees, and I have been on a cross-country tour called Canadian Communities Are Not For Sale and have had a tremendous response. When Canadians find out what is in CETA, they quickly become opposed. Many municipalities have now passed resolutions demanding to know more about the CETA threat to their jurisdictions and, in particular, many are demanding that water services be fully exempt.

Even long-time supporters of free trade are questioning it. Peter Clark, former government trade negotiator, says that he sees no way that Canada will get a good deal and that Canada "will pay dearly" for CETA. And Michael Hart, Carleton University trade professor, disputes the government claim that CETA will create lots of jobs: "Trade agreements do not create jobs. Never have. Never will, " he says.

CETA negotiations have reached an advanced stage. It is crucial that we demand a national debate and more forthcoming information from the Harper government about just what is on the table. Otherwise, the Conservatives are planning to sign CETA with Europe in the first half of 2012 and then bring it to the House of Commons -- where their majority will allow it passage without Canadian consultation -- and that will be the first time Canadians get to see what our government bargained away. This is not how democracy works.

For more information, please see www.canadians.org/ceta and www.cupe.ca/ceta.

 
This week, European Union trade officials are in Canada to meet with their Canadian counterparts on what might be the final round of negotiations on a huge new trade agreement called CETA - the Canada...
This week, European Union trade officials are in Canada to meet with their Canadian counterparts on what might be the final round of negotiations on a huge new trade agreement called CETA - the Canada...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:51 AM on 11/20/2011
WHERE IS LOUIS RIEL?!
No, seriously. Where is the Canadian National hero that represents the people, communities and cultural heritage of Canada? Why is the Canadian political class so spineless?

Call them out, lay it on the table and lock them out.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Barron
11:05 AM on 10/28/2011
Everyday it is something, who is behind all this privatization? It seems to be sweeping the globe without debate or vote within the public forum.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gravescanada
03:16 PM on 11/01/2011
Silly question. Its corporations that are behind it. They want to get into these untapped markets. Their only way is through Privatization. Just look to the USA and see what its done for them. My wife and I moved to Canada in 2005, our monthly electric bill in the USA Missouri was 350.00 a month. Enough said.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rickthaluddite
What noisy cats are we
11:48 AM on 11/22/2011
Harper painted his picture of the future of Canada in 1997.
http://www.ctv.ca/CTVNews/SpecialEvent7/20051213/elxn_harper_speech_text_051214/
05:25 AM on 10/28/2011
I think we should be able to declare NAFTA and any so called 'free' trade acts that have been enacted since as null and void as they were not in the best interest of Canadians and were actually designed to benefit other countries and big business. Those that have been party to enacting these deals should be tried as traitors to the Canadian people - one of the meanings of being a treasonous is:
'Treason is the violation of allegiance to one's sovereign or state, giving aid to enemies, or levying war against one's state.'
None of those that helped in embroiling us in these 'free' trade acts did so with the allegiance of their own sovereign or state - unless theirs is not Canada. Trade will and has occurred without politicians giving the rest of our country away for free - oh, wait - not for free, they get some cushy jobs once they're done raping the Canadian public.
05:56 AM on 10/28/2011
I'm sorry - I'm just that ticked off about the whole thing - and about what's been happening to Canada. We aren't in any trade act as far as I can tell that actually benefits us, and due to these acts our very rights are being given away.
We don't need these 'free' trade acts with other countries - what happened to someone having a product that not many people have and selling it at a premium? They do that in China with rare earth metals... Stopping these deals would not hurt our trade, but boost the economy, perhaps bring back the manufacturing jobs NAFTA took from us. Canada is not an island but it can be self sufficient, we have been told for too long that we can't do what we used to do for hundreds of years - all the while the countries we enter into deals with still have manufacturing, still have everything they started with, and still to this date have not had to pay any fines for 'trade violations' when Canada has forked out millions. We need to stand up and be the Proud, Strong, and FREE country that we once were, or at least had the illusion of being.
I'm done ranting, I'm sorry. ...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jane48
07:06 PM on 10/27/2011
Bad. Very bad. Learn from our mistakes, Canada. Nothing good can happen from the privatizing of public services. Nothing good. Pay attention. Have you seen what private industry has done to the U.S.? It's horrible here. And, if you don't watch out, it's going to be equally horrible there.

I thot Canada was above this stuff. Huh! I guess not. Don't be gullible. Don't listen to the propaganda, cuz that's exactly what it is. My grandparents emigrated to Boston from NFL, and for the past 10 years, I've been wishing I was in Canada. I've been thinking ...gotta send my college educated daughter to Canada--it will be better there. But, now that I read about CETA, I can guarantee you that it will get bad, very bad, real soon. Don't do it, Canada. You were a beautiful and people loving country. Stop it now. Do everything you can.

Did you see our Iraqi veteran (who survived two tours in Iraq) who was seriously injured in Oakland, CA? Police are out of control in this country, and the reason is because the corporations now have their allegiance.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Lives
The Venus Project ... look it up
05:37 PM on 10/26/2011
Still think Harper is all about democracy?
12:21 PM on 10/26/2011
Worth reading for those Canadians who think #ows is more of an American problem. #cdnpoli
10:33 AM on 10/25/2011
How can this be stopped, really, what can be done? I've signed online petitions . . . any other suggestions please! This is far too important to let slip through our fingers.
photo
BCSLAVE
Got a key?
03:26 PM on 10/23/2011
So much for the "status quo" and moderation that the Harper Reform Party ran election on. Now we are to learn we will be owned by foreigners because of a MASSIVE NEW SECRET DEAL???

Where is the transparency? Where is the mandate? Where is the truth? What a bunch of crooks!
10:50 AM on 10/23/2011
*The Harper government is ideologically driven by a belief in the privatization, deregulation and strengthened corporate power.* Yes, now, all you *occupiers*, where you during the last three elections -- municipal, federal and provincial -- held during the past 12 months? You see, THIS is how it works in a democracy. Voting really does matter.
11:48 AM on 10/23/2011
Too true! I did vote, but to no avail.

Unfortunately, the only issue pushed in the last election campaign was leadership. It was as if any actual issues or local candidates simply didn't matter. Combined with the Conservatives' mud slinging attack adds it is hard to fault people for not being engaged. Maybe that was the plan.
photo
BCSLAVE
Got a key?
03:27 PM on 10/23/2011
It was the plan - to hold an election on no issues other than faux status quo.
11:12 PM on 10/22/2011
With each administration, we have seen more power accruing to the PM's office until with Harper, who pretty much muzzles his MPs, we have what almost amounts to a dictatorship. The question is how do we stop the Harper administration from selling us out on this and other globalization fronts?
09:40 PM on 10/22/2011
As always, the Cons strive to sell out Canadian''s interests in favour of their corporate buddies. They did it under Mulroney with the FTA, and now they're doing it again, but even more blatantly.
They have no conscience, or shame.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DidiM
Human 'being'
04:19 PM on 10/22/2011
The Constitutional Statutes of Law Making Regulations state: That If a Law is going to be introduced, enacted or amended that will 'diminish the lives of the public or segment of the population, in any way', that Law Is A Public Law - and must have the "Full Prior knowledge and Full (Significant) Majority Consent Of the People Of Canada"!
The Statutes DO NOT SAY - That our Federal (or Provincial) Legislators may vote or speak on behalf of the people they prefess to represent - as they are doing now and have been doing for too many years! What they are in fact doing is ILLEGAL & Deemed Null & Void & Ineffective and a GROSS VIOLATION AND ABUSE OF THEIR POWERS! THIS Illegal Behavior by our MP's, MNA's & MLA's must be made public and MUST CEASE - right now!! Whenever such a law is enacted our MP's have been suggesting the people have agreed that they - and/or our Majority Government Reps - are free do change any laws and/or sell our property - whenever and however they like and that is not only a LIE - it is a CRIME that allows our Legislators to behave like Dictators - ALSO ILLEGAL and deemed a criminal act. We had better let ALL Our MP's & Elected Officials know - they will be held fully accountable for any & all skewing, introducing & amending "Public Laws" we have NOT VOTED ON!
06:05 PM on 10/22/2011
DidiM the Harper government is secretive. It is doing what it wants and does not feel any of Canadian values are to be protecte. Hopefully they will be the first to receive a mandatory sentence and enter one of the new jails we don't need and can't afford. I have never known any political person to be so in the pocket of antiquated but costly thinking. I am reminded of Germany in the thirties. the difference is Germany was struggling with war reparations and Canada was was warm and comfortably prosperous with thoughts of sharing and not tearing up.