Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Melissa Carr

GET UPDATES FROM Melissa Carr
 

B.C. Daycare Costs Are Crippling Families

Posted: 02/14/2013 1:01 pm

Earlier this week I posted on my Facebook page, inquiring if anyone would be willing to speak to the media about what they shell out for daycare each month. The response I got was overwhelming.

From part-time costs at about $600/month to one friend who confided that she spends upwards of $3,000/month on childcare, I was admittedly not shocked. I mean, I know what daycare costs. I have my son in a daycare two days a week, which I consider to be a deal at $38/day.

CTV ran a story about the crippling cost of childcare and highlighted how the Surrey and Burnaby Boards of Trade are pushing for Universal Child Care — much like what happens in Quebec — where daycare would end up costing $10/day. A huge savings to families, but (arguably) a significant burden on taxpayers.

When I posted the video on my Facebook, I received emotional and mixed reactions:

Childcare (for one child) is our second biggest monthly expense. I wonder if the average daily cost ($40) they are referring to is accurate in Surrey and Burnaby? I certainly don't think it is in Vancouver — my daycare, which seems in line with the going rate here, costs close to 50% more than that, based on 4 days a week. I know several people (all women, unfortunately) who have dropped out of the workforce entirely because the financial burden is too high. — Tara R.
This is a ridiculous idea.Why does it always have to be about the people who are not making enough. At what point do we say "sorry, this would be unfair to the taxpayers, you should have thought it through." And before you start complaining, consider yourself in a situation where you are already paying 35% of your paycheck in taxes, and society is still asking for more. — Mizra R.

Back in the fall when a group of influential "online moms" and I met with Premier Christy Clark, childcare costs was a hot topic. Clark's sentiment is that the burden of daycare is a "temporary" one for families. I disagree.

The high cost of childcare for families in B.C. has long-term impacts. Many families cannot afford to purchase a home because of it. Many women (and men) take themselves out of the workforce because of it. Many families go into debt because of it. Many couples decide not to have children (or more than one child) because of it.

Do you feel childcare costs here are ridiculous? What do you think the solution is?

 

Follow Melissa Carr on Twitter: www.twitter.com/meliss604

FOLLOW CANADA BRITISH COLUMBIA
Earlier this week I posted on my Facebook page, inquiring if anyone would be willing to speak to the media about what they shell out for daycare each month. The response I got was overwhelming. Fro...
Earlier this week I posted on my Facebook page, inquiring if anyone would be willing to speak to the media about what they shell out for daycare each month. The response I got was overwhelming. Fro...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:20 PM on 02/15/2013
I pay just under $900/mo for a 3-year old in a City of Vancouver run daycare. There is sufficient staff and healthy meals for lunch and snacks everyday. It is a fair price to pay so that both my wife and I can pursue our careers.

Would I like it to be free, of course, but you can't have everything in life.
04:45 PM on 02/14/2013
Do you have any comparative figures? Wages in Vancouver are significantly higher than they are where I live so I'm not sure if these fees really are as exorbitant as they seem at first glance. Perhaps they are but without really knowing I'm not sure I have a fair opinion. Daycare, if you are going to work outside the home, is a fact of life and needs to be part of your decision making process when deciding to have a family.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
opprobrious
More speech. Less Flagging.
05:36 AM on 02/15/2013
I suppose if you lived in a perfect world you might have a point but, in most people's lives (and the real world), circumstances change. Once they've been brought into the world, children need to be taken care of regardless of circumstance and there are many studies that indicate a strong relationship between investments in early education and positive educational, economic and societal outcomes as those children grow into adulthood. And, by the way, I doubt you should expect that most people are thinking about daycare at the moment of conception..
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Kerry Sauriol
04:21 PM on 02/14/2013
The impact of expensive childcare IS long term and affects more than just 'mom.' I also disagree with the temporary aspect. If I worked my school age kids would need before and after school care which does not run cheap either. So here I am, a SAHM creating her own home-based career around my kids. However. I also have issues with the people wanting a Quebec type model for childcare in BC with the magical idea of us paying $10 a day for this. It is often forgot or not mentioned that the reason Quebec can look so progressive with things like childcare is due to the enormous transfer payments given to Quebec from the Federal gov. I don't have the exact numbers in front of me but I do recall after a big of googling one night that it was almost 3 times as much as we (BC) receive. When I attended a roundtable with some fellow mom bloggers and the Premier, she was very honest about the why's of BC not having it. I agree we need it....but we can't follow the Quebec model unless the Federal Gov was going to be as helpful to us.
11:58 PM on 02/14/2013
you mean unless someone else pays to subsidize your lifestyle.
01:22 PM on 02/18/2013
Transfer payments to Quebec are about 2.5 times those to British Columbia. However, the population of Quebec is about twice that of British Columbia's.

Government subsidized daycare is always a contentious issue, as are paid maternity and paternity leaves, and taxes earmarked for education. Many people consider these to be socialistic programs and are ideologically opposed to them. It doesn't seem to matter that children suffer without them.