THE BLOG

On the Mortgage Debate, Mulcair KO'd Flaherty

03/21/2013 12:25 EDT | Updated 10/30/2017 19:46 EDT
AP
Minister of Finance Jim Flaherty holds a news conference at the National Press Theatre in Ottawa, Canada on Thursday, June 21, 2012. Flaherty is tightening mortgage rules to make it harder for people to buy or borrow on their homes. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press,Sean Kilpatrick )

It is important to reiterate that I write my comments on this blog strictly as a private citizen and that my title has been added by the Huffington Post simply as a matter of identifying me.

The federal minister of Finances, Mr. Jim Flaherty, made public comments and exerted pressures for Manulife Bank to withdraw its offer for a five-year-fixed mortgage rate of 2.89 per cent.

NPD leader Thomas Mulcair accused Mr. Flaherty of using his position of power inappropriately.

He's quoted saying: "That's Banana Republic behaviour (...) the minister has no business interfering with the free marketplace. That company is operating completely with full respect of the law, if they see an advantage in attracting clients at this rate, why shouldn't they go out to do that?". He added: "It's none of his business. It's the minister's opinion. It's nuts. We've never seen this before."

Granted, the real estate market is not exactly what you would call a free market devoid of government intervention. The Bank of Canada -- a government creature -- sets the overall interest rate for the economy; CMHC -- another government creature with implicit credit backing from taxpayers -- indirectly subsidizes mortgage loan insurance; the government determines loan lengths and other mortgage rules. But if these government interventions create distortions in the market that the minister doesn't like, such as a real estate bubble and the high level of indebtedness of Canadian households, he should fix them. Not add another layer of government diktat by telling banks how to conduct their business as if he were a Soviet commissar.

I couldn't have said it better myself. Way to go Thomas! A few more positions like this one, and I might actually join your official fan club!

Least Affordable Cities For Housing