Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Mick Côté
 

Is Sex a Job Like Any Other?

Posted: 01/19/12 06:20 PM ET

The ongoing battle with the legality of sex work-related activities is resurfacing in our country's judicial system. Today, workers from the Vancouver area brought their case to the Supreme Court of Canada.

In 2007, the Downtown Eastside Sex Workers United Against Violence Society (SWUAV) introduced the issue to the Supreme Court of British Columbia, claiming that the current laws regarding prostitution are anti-constitutional. The B.C. court agreed with ongoing processes taking place in Ottawa and shut down the case, claiming sex workers did not have the right to argue against the Canadian body of law because the issue may not qualify for court procedures.

According to the court system, lawyers must prove the issues at stake are serious, that the parties involved in launching the case are directly involved, and that the court system is the only remedy to the problem.

Now, SWUAV is pursuing the case in Canada's top court amidst important social and judicial debates about the status of sex work as a job like any others.

While buying and selling sexual services is legal, most activities surrounding prostitution are forbidden. Communicating for the purpose of prostitution, living off the avails of prostitution, and owning or operating a common bawdy house are all listed as criminal activities.

Sex work activists and experts often argue that Canada's laws make it difficult for women to take part in safe practices.

During the inquiry into the Robert Pickton case in B.C., criminologist John Lowman argued that current laws make it easier for women to fall victim to sex predators.

Many Canadian law enforcers make it common practice to put offenders on boundaries, limiting their access to common stroll areas, and subsequently "pushing" sex workers outside their common work zones. Others are typically put on house arrest, fined, or incarcerated.

The issue here is one of security.

While covering the topic of prostitution in Halifax, N.S. I have come across many men and women who were victims of serious physical and sexual assaults.

Rene Ross, executive director at Stepping Stone, a support centre for sex workers in Halifax, argues criminalization has pushed sex workers to the outskirts of the city. Historically, Halifax's main stroll areas were contained within the downtown core.

"Basically criminalization has taken sex work and dispersed it through the city," said Ross. "It forces sex workers to flee from the police, it builds a mistrust between sex workers and law enforcement. Sex workers are also not reporting the crimes against them."

Tracy, who did not wish to share her last name, worked the streets of Halifax and Toronto to afford her addiction to opiates. She recalled an instance where a man drove her to a secluded part of a highway and beat her with his prosthetic leg before leaving her in a ditch and driving off. Tracy never reported the instance in fear of being victimized as a sex worker.

In fact, interviewing sex workers can be a challenge of its own since most active members seek anonymity and secrecy in fear of being recognized by clients or pimps and abused for divulging information about their job.

Not unlike arguments provided by lawyers in the B.C. case, many argue the current laws alienate people who take part in prostitution and make them out to be second-class citizens without rights to security.

Truth is, while it can be argued that some sex workers come from underprivileged backgrounds or take part in the trade for the quick access to money, many set off on the streets out of choice.

Prostitution, as it is, will most likely always create a divide in our society. However, it will be interesting to see the SWUAV's case develop in front of the Supreme Court of Canada and redefine the status of women, men, and transgendered folks who take part our country's sex-trade industry.

 

Follow Mick Côté on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@mickcote

 
 
  • Comments
  • 30
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
01:55 PM on 01/22/2012
The average age for entry into prostitution in Canada is 13-14 years old.
I would invite you to read the facts about prostitution at ..............

www.rapeis.org

Its a real eye opener.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jake Thomas
elastic
04:08 PM on 01/20/2012
Sex Trade workers need and deserve protection under law. It is that simple. The only moral issue that needs to be addressed here is why we treat them like second class citizens. It is when we elevate the status of the most vulnerable members of our communities that we will be a truly just society.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cwebster
predominantly exasperated
12:03 AM on 01/21/2012
Well said.
03:15 PM on 01/20/2012
Women have, since the dawn of time, been able to sell their bodies. Men have, since that same era been able to purchase. Shortly thereafter the profession of "Pimp", Protector, Investor, Manager, Promoter, came into being.

It seems to me that what is really at issue here is the collection and payment of the additional fees of the modern bureaucratic society. Those modern "agents-fees", imposed by Prosecutors, Income-taxers, judicial-Moderators, and Promoters, the state in general, must also be paid to assure that the bureaucratic state survives and thrives.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cwebster
predominantly exasperated
10:40 AM on 01/20/2012
I think it should be legal to operate a co-op type brothel, with requirements for regular medical checkups. It would get sex trade workers off the streets, which are not safe, and hopefully get rid of pimps. I'd like to see laws against pimping made much stricter.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
working onit
Stop Harper
05:40 PM on 01/20/2012
I think the best people to decide how their work environment should be regulated are the sex therapists themselves. (I believe there are benefits to society as a whole with a legal, professional sex industry)

I can see where someone would want to pay a 'manager' or 'administrator' to help them run the business.

I think what you may mean is penalties for sex slavery should be stricter. I completely agree.

A legalized, regulated adult sex industry frees law enforcement to focus on and pursue crimes like child prostitution and sex slavery.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cwebster
predominantly exasperated
12:04 AM on 01/21/2012
Sorry...the reason I mentioned the co-op is that some sex trade workers in Vancouver were trying to get approval to do exactly that.
12:54 AM on 01/20/2012
The survival sex trade is much different than boutique prostitution.

Survival sex trade workers are there typically because of addictions, mental health (can't hold a 'proper' job), violence and victimization (by pimps, gangs). Many are underage. I personally believe that laws actually help these women get out of bad situations, and get them the help and social services that they need. Don't paint all the laws with the brush of self-righteousness. If you ever worked in front line social services (I have), you know there is no black and white...just infinite shades of grey.
photo
Blodo
Time to build a better world
11:11 PM on 01/19/2012
If a society really wants to decrease prostitution, they should copy the example of Sweden. They have essentially legalized the selling of sex services but established severe penalties on the buying of those services, pimping and procurement. The buying of sex, in Sweden is seen to have at its root, male violence against women and children.

The success of this model can be seen in comparative figures of those reported engaged in prostitution. In Sweden, with a population of 9.5 million had in 2008 about 300 women engaged in street prostitution and 50 men, and another 300 in internet sex.

By comparison, Denmark, with a population of only 5.5 million, and which has far more tolerant laws in regard to the buying of those services, had 5567 persons visibly engaged in prostitution, of whom 1415 were on the street.
08:04 AM on 01/20/2012
That's ridiculous. Women and men have the right to sell their body if they want to, and so do clients have the right to buy them.
photo
Blodo
Time to build a better world
11:58 AM on 01/20/2012
"Rights" do not exist in a vacuum. Rights are established by people and codified in laws. Change the laws and you change the "rights".

Further...there is nothing ridiculous about reducing either violence against women, exploitation of children or human trafficking. All these goals are commendable from the perspective of any civilized society. Whatever works to achieve those goals should be seriously considered.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Glass Cannon
Let every eye negotiate for itself.
01:17 PM on 01/20/2012
Sure, but to buy another person to use in such a way is harmful. Unless you also ensure that every single person you are buying also has good medical care, protection from violence, and good social services to bolster mental and physical health, including enough food. Although once you ensure those things you may find no one wants to sell themselves for sex anymore. Because it's so often a desperate act, an act for basic survival only. It is not a statement of human rights, or even for pleasure.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dbrett480
09:08 PM on 01/19/2012
A society that considers itself progressive and supportive of women's rights cannot also support the selling of women's bodies.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Denis OBrien
10:26 AM on 01/20/2012
But...if a society is progressive and supportive of women's rights....then that society should also support the right of the woman to her own body...whether that be (unpopular to some) medical procedures or the rental of her person.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dbrett480
07:46 PM on 01/20/2012
How can someone consider themselves a progressive or a feminist and support the idea of a woman's body as a commodity to be bought and sold?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SayBlade
This micro bio intentionally left blank.
10:48 AM on 01/20/2012
Except when that society allows them to decide to do it themselves without fear of arrest from the authorities and in a safe place where their johns won't attack, rob or inflict disease upon them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
fumes
Midnight Toker
07:40 PM on 01/19/2012
sex has been around..

longer than QhanehBos!

time to LEGALIZE BOTH..

"Then the Lord said to Moses, "Take the following fine spices: 500 shekels of liquid myrrh, half as much of fragrant cinnamon, 250 shekels of qhaneh-bosm, 500 shekels of cassia--all according to the sanctuary shekel--and a hind of olive oil. Make these into a sacred anointing oil, a fragrant blend, the work of a perfumer. It will be the sacred anointing oil." Exodus 30:23

It is this term "qhaneh bosm”, or fragrant cane, that is the most remarkable of mistranslations found within the Bible. When it was rendered into Greek it became "calamus", a common marsh plant that had no place in the sacred anointing oil of Yahweh. But so it has come down to us. In fact the Hebrew term is qhaneh bosm, or kaneh bosm. And according to Rabbi Herschels??? Hebrew-English dictionary, such eminent scholars as Sula Benet, Weston LaBarre and the British journal New Scientist, what this term refers to is none other than cannabis. Indeed the "m" which ends the word is the Hebrew plural, so in the singular it reads as 'kaneh bos" which doesn't take a leap of faith to be understood for what it is.
http://www.forbiddenfruitpublishing.com/sexdrugs/kanehbosm.html