I felt like an excited little kid when the theatre lights dimmed and the opening credits rolled for "Act of Valor." The movie stars active duty Navy SEALs and was produced with the cooperation of the U.S. military. Depending on who you ask, it's a recruiting tool, a live action video game, or a multi-million dollar piece of propaganda. It's also a commercial success: The film led the box office on its opening weekend, taking in $24.5 million in U.S. and Canadian theatres. What might surprise you is the reason I eagerly bought my ticket: American patriotism. And by the way, I'm Canadian.
When I think of my country's armed forces, victory at Vimy Ridge and U.N. peacekeeping missions come to mind; more recently I picture the thousands who lined the Highway of Heroes to pay tribute when one of our fallen soldiers came home from Afghanistan. I understood Canada's involvement in that conflict but attended a couple of anti-war rallies after the U.S. invaded Iraq. I would say that along with most of my friends and relatives, I'm a proud Canadian who sits left of centre -- and has for the most part not given the military much thought.
That changed four years ago when I moved to the United States to work in network news. Through my job, I spoke with soldiers, wounded warriors, families whose loved ones were in Iraq and Afghanistan, wives who were now widows, and children who missed their fathers and mothers. I saw soldiers everywhere -- in airports, recruiting stations, and on leave in the city.
Part of that omnipresence is sheer size -- as of December, 2011, there were almost 1.5 million active duty personnel in the U.S. military, with a reserve force that swells the ranks to well above 2.2 million. Compare that to Canada's active duty force -- just over 68,000 in March, 2011 -- and it's easy to see why the military is much more visible south of the border.
But the longer I lived in the States, it was more than just being aware of the military -- my perspective changed. A New York Police officer who had completed one tour of Afghanistan and was preparing for a second told me that after 9/11 he thought it was his duty to enlist -- he felt personally responsible to protect and defend his country.
I know that not everyone joins the military just because of patriotism -- thousands enlist because the military will pay for schooling and others because the recession has made jobs scarce. But as I spoke to more soldiers, there were themes that kept coming up -- duty, responsibility, freedom, country. I don't know if it was a sort of cultural osmosis, but I started to absorb some of that same pride.
Patriotism was a muscle I hadn't really exercised in my home and native land. Canadians are a proud people, but it's a quiet pride (except during the Winter Olympics, then we're fanatics). This new outward, aggressive American emoting was refreshing and satisfying. It made me feel part of something bigger and it pains me to admit it, but I had rarely felt that in the patchwork quilt that is the Canadian national identity.
It also made me realize that the Western world sometimes forgets the role the United States plays as a global police force. I'm not suggesting that every U.S. military action is just -- but I am saying their role as recess monitors on the world stage shouldn't be taken for granted. And I think it's also the reason that Canadians like me don't give much thought to our own military -- we don't have to because we know that our ally the United States is watching the playground for bullies.
And that brings me back to "Act of Valor." The movie left something to be desired in terms of acting and plot, but that wasn't the point. While I was sitting in that theatre, I found myself thinking of the Navy's SEAL Team 6 -- the group of elite soldiers that was virtually unknown until they killed Osama Bin Laden last year and rescued two aid workers in Somalia in January.
And when one of the CIA agents in the film is murdered, I thought of the stars carved into a marble wall at CIA headquarters in Langley, Virginia. Each star represents an agent killed in the line of duty, but because of the covert nature of the job, the stars are anonymous. So too were the SEALs in "Act of Valor" -- their names were concealed to protect them for future missions. Instead, the men asked that the credits include a list of more than 60 SEALs who lost their lives during the last few years. There is nobility and integrity in doing the right thing even when no one is there to see it.
It took living in the United States and being surrounded by American patriotism for me to cultivate my own sense of duty and country. That has in turn made me cognizant of the extraordinary sacrifice both Canadian and American troops make every day so that I can live a free and privileged life. To all of those men and women, thank you.
Ward Carroll: Will SEALs Launch a New Wave of Exploitation Flicks?
Act of Valor - Rotten Tomatoes
Act Of Valor (2012) Official Trailer - HD Movie - Navy SEALS ...
I truly hope you take the time to read some of these well thought out responses with an open mind.
The US spends almost half of what the rest of the world spends on the military. It's obscene in a post cold war era, especially when they don't even have a public health insurance system and are starving their public education and infrastructure to pay for it. And next in line is their Social Security program.
They also are the world's biggest exporter of weapons and not just to nice democracies either. The CIA then foments war, arms both sides, and the military industrial complex makes $. And the offshoot is that after selling off last years stock to these clients, they go to Washington for more $ for newer shinier human killing machines to replace the supply they sold. And on and on. That is the reality of "policing" the world. It's big business for them and also for media networks like you work for, as everyone is glued to the screen and its garishly loud graphics.
I love action films, I really wanted to see this movie. But there's a fundamental line that's being crossed here, about charging people $10 + some income tax to feel good about something the government is doing, that has nothing to do with patriotism and soldiers. In fact, I guess, SEEING this film seemed to me unpatriotic. Its not what America is about, to spend tax money on propaganda.
Good grief. Then most US interventions are just? She sounds like a Harper operative. Seems you really have bought in to the "U.S. as a global force for good" line. And how do you think Iraqi or Afghan civilians might feel about that sentiment? U.S. and Cdn troops might be doing some important work but it is pure folly to believe they are hard at work protecting our "freedom and privileges". By whom exactly is our freedom imminently threatened? Oh yes, "terrorists" of course.
It's a slippery slope you walk when you reject facts and reason in favour of emotion-driven, nationalism. "We're number 1! U-S-A! U-S-A!" Remember what Samuel Johnson wisely said: "patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bUsePoATbrU
http://www.warisaracket.org/
Not that it's a terrible movie: it's an hour and a half of military porn, showing off cool hardware and excessively elaborate set-pieces that strain belief (according to this movie, the only way SEALs arrive anywhere is by high-altitude parachute).
If you actually pay attention to this movie though, it shows why the US is bankrupt and losing conflicts around the world.
First, just try and estimate how much money these seals spent from beginning to end... a few million worth of helicopters here, a few million in boats there, etc, etc... all to fight about fifty bucks worth of explosives from getting sneaked into the country. The goal of the terrorists in the movie was to cripple the US economy: guess what? They won. Second, the entire plot is dependant on the waste and idiocy of the 'war on drugs" making sure that the Bad Guys (tm) have huge piles of money, ready access to desperate people, smuggling channels and a whole black market to deal in.
Soldiers don't really care about geopolitics or wider policy issues. That's not their job. But it's sad seeing highly trained people being tasked with doing something completely pointless.
Canada is a nation of true warriors. The Americans could not invade despite superior numbers and equipment, the Germans feared Canadians, the "army of Stormtroopers and the Taliban military leader called "all the ally troops cowards, except the Canadians" who were true soldiers.
In the WW wars, Canadian troops were the shock troops and those who could be counted on to hold while others ran.
Canada invented; medics, the platoon system and with the Americans "special forces" (there is a 50's movie abouyt this called the "Devil Brigade.") We also perfected for the first time the rolling barrage at Vimy.
The protection and sailing of supply ships in WW2 was simply heroic, those enlisting as sailors knowing they would be lucky to survive.
The accomplishments are not just on the battlefield but also in invention. The Avro Arrow was decades ahead with the government being tricked by the Americans to abandon it and then luring Canadian scientists to be key to the start of the space program and the a decade later a fighter that could match the Arrow.
While the Americans are good soldiers Canada is second to none. As Tom Brocoff (sp) said in his fiinal newscast to Americans. "Canadians are a peace loving, polite people but in a fight there is no one else you would want on your side."
Patriotism is an emotion. Nationalism is a policy.
Patriotism requires a love of country, of kin, of community.
Nationalism requires a military to enforce "our" national will on other nations or to keep "them" from doing the same to us.