More

Supreme Court of Canada

In Canada, Speaking Your Mind is a Crime

Tom Kott | Posted 05.08.2013 | Canada Politics
Tom Kott

The utilitarian belief that individual rights to speak freely are somehow less important than the right of others to not be offended is ludicrous in so many ways. For the top court of the country to support it brings many questions of its legitimacy and effectiveness in protecting the fundamental freedoms that we supposedly enjoy.

Métis Win Historic Dispute

CBC | Posted 05.08.2013 | Canada

Canada's Métis are celebrating a Supreme Court ruling that found the federal government failed to follow through on a promise it made to the Métis p...

Hate Crime Comes of Age in Canada

Wayne K. Spear | Posted 05.04.2013 | Canada Politics
Wayne K. Spear

Numerous examples, as recent and divergent in character as Hutu Power and the suicide of Amanda Todd, establish the causal relationship of hateful expression and material harms. And who can doubt the cranking of the thermostat which would occur if the William Whatcotts had their way? Viewed in this sense, Canadian hate speech laws may best be characterized not only as a striking of balance but as an essentially pre-emptive effort. But the Flanagan case reminds us that even in the absence of a formal criminal charge, an offended majority will impose its justice of the marketplace.

Will Saskatchewan Strike a Balance Between Freedoms and Rights?

Ross Macnab | Posted 05.01.2013 | Canada
Ross Macnab

In 1947, the Saskatchewan Legislature passed The Saskatchewan Bill of Rights Act, and the difficult task of balancing freedoms and rights began. The S...

B.C. Election Gag Law Fix Should Be In Throne Speech

Vincent Gogolek | Posted 04.14.2013 | Canada British Columbia
Vincent Gogolek

The government had a clear opportunity to fix the gag on free political speech built into our province's Election Act last spring, when the act was being amended by the legislature. For reasons unknown, they chose not to.

Drunk Drivers? Put Them Away, But Don't Take Their Truck

Marni Soupcoff | Posted 03.19.2013 | Canada
Marni Soupcoff

It's dangerous to treat drunk drivers too lightly. But it's equally dangerous to entrench a legal precedent that offers an incentive for government prosecution in the form of a valuable prize that the government gets to keep if it wins.

Media Bites: How Niqabs Brought Canadian Media Together

J.J. McCullough | Posted 02.23.2013 | Canada Politics
J.J. McCullough

2012-04-27-mediabitesreal.jpg The Supreme Court of Canada on Thursday ruled that burka-clad women are allowed to keep themselves burka'd whilst testifying at trial. Or something like that. "Sometimes niqab in court will be OK. Sometimes niqab will not be OK," David Frum summarizes.

Top Court Rules On Niqab

CP | The Canadian Press | Posted 02.18.2013 | Canada

OTTAWA - A sharply divided Supreme Court of Canada was not able to definitively rule Thursday whether a woman can wear a religious veil known as a niq...

Public Unions Lose Fight For $28 Billion In Pension Cash

CP | Mike Blanchfield, The Canadian Press | Posted 02.18.2013 | Canada Politics

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada says several major public unions are not entitled to a $28-billion pension surplus that the government hived off ...

A Supreme Decision On End-Of-Life Care

CP | Helen Branswell, The Canadian Press | Posted 02.08.2013 | Canada

Who gets to decide when medical treatments are no longer worth pursuing and should be ended? The doctors? The patients? In the case of those who can't...

Supreme Court Asked To Settle Battle Over Tommy Douglas Dossier

CP | The Canadian Press | Posted 02.08.2013 | Canada Politics

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada is being asked to settle a seven-year battle to lift the shroud of secrecy over a decades-old intelligence dossie...

School District Discriminated Against Dyslexic Boy: SCC

CP | Tamsyn Burgmann, The Canadian Press | Posted 01.09.2013 | Canada British Columbia

VANCOUVER - By the time he finished Grade 3, Jeffrey Moore still didn't know the alphabet and could not read his own birthday cards.His parents sought...

We Hope Our Day in Court Will Help Eliminate Election Fraud

Stephen Thiele | Posted 12.27.2012 | Canada Politics
Stephen Thiele

As the lawyers who represented Borys Wrzesnewskyj in his contested election application, the four to three Supreme Court of Canada decision to uphold the election result in Etobicoke Centre was, of course, disappointing. Hopefully the decision of the Supreme Court will lead to real and meaningful electoral reform which will reduce or eliminate the issues that led to this application. While the majority decision acknowledges that "imperfection" and "uncertainty" are a part of the electoral process, Elections Canada should always strive to eliminate them.

Pro-Choice or Pro-Life, Canada Needs a Clear Ruling on Abortion

Brent Rathgeber | Posted 11.26.2012 | Canada Politics
Brent Rathgeber

One of the most contentious issues facing the 41st Parliament is Motion 312. My feelings on the abortion issue are complex and have evolved over time. I have come to the conclusion after years of deliberation and inner debate that I am both Pro-Choice and Pro-Life.

Who Will Choose Next Supreme Court Justice?

CP | The Canadian Press | Posted 10.08.2012 | Canada Politics

OTTAWA - Three Conservative MPs, a New Democrat and a Liberal will help select the Supreme Court of Canada's next judge.The federal government says Co...

Court Ruling Clarifies Organized Crime Definition

CP | The Canadian Press | Posted 09.05.2012 | Canada

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada on Friday used a Montreal drug case to give lower courts some guidance on what constitutes a criminal organizatio...

Omar Khadr Has the Right to Return to a Canadian Prison

Sukanya Pillay | Posted 09.05.2012 | Canada Politics
Sukanya Pillay

The U.S. has now agreed to transfer Omar Khadr to a Canadian prison to serve the remainder of his sentence. By law, the Canadian government should not obstruct his transfer to a Canadian prison. Here is why we believe it is time to repatriate Omar Khadr ASAP.

Can Battered Women Hire A Hitman?

CP | Mike Blanchfield, The Canadian Press | Posted 08.12.2012 | Canada

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada will hear arguments this week on whether the battered woman's defence can be widened to include the hiring of a h...

Parents, Christian Groups Upset By Religion Class Ruling

CBC | Posted 04.19.2012 | Canada

A coalition of Christian groups is disappointed by a Supreme Court of Canada ruling that will prevent their children from opting out of a...

Supreme Court Makes It Easier For Mentally Disabled To Testify

CP | Steve Rennie, The Canadian Press | Posted 04.11.2012 | Canada Politics

OTTAWA - The Supreme Court of Canada has set aside the acquittal of a man charged with sexually assaulting a developmentally challenged woman, and ord...

ISPs Not Broadcasters, Don't Need To Follow CanCon Rules: Supreme Court

CBC | Posted 04.10.2012 | Canada Business

Retail internet service providers, such as Rogers and Bell, that provide end‑users with access to broadcasting over the internet are no...

HIV Disclosure Going To Top Court

CBC | Posted 04.08.2012 | Canada Politics

Canada's top court is hearing the case of two HIV-positive Canadians who did not disclose their medical condition to their sexual partner...

Crystal-Ball Gazing: The Year Ahead in Tech Law and Policy

Michael Geist | Posted 02.21.2012 | Canada Business
Michael Geist

Technology law and policy is notoriously unpredictable but 2012 promises to be a busy year. My weekly technology law column offers some guesses for the coming months. January: The Supreme Court of Canada holds a hearing on whether Internet service providers can be treated as broadcasters under the Broadcasting Act.

Supreme Court Shoots Down Proposed Federal Securities Regulator

CP | Julian Beltrame, The Canadian Press | Posted 02.20.2012 | Canada Business

OTTAWA - Canada's top court has dealt what is likely a fatal blow to the federal government's attempt to create a national stock market regulator, rul...

Veiled Threat: Niqab in the Courtroom

J.S. Vijaya | Posted 02.20.2012 | Canada
J.S. Vijaya

I have conducted hundreds of trials. I can tell you that during trial many things go on simultaneously in the courtroom. The cross-examiner listens and watches very carefully to every inflection, every movement, every subtle change of mood, and facial tics that the witness conveys while testifying.