Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Nicholas Barber

GET UPDATES FROM Nicholas Barber
 

Want to Quell Student Stress? Don't Take Wente's Advice

Posted: 12/17/2012 12:35 pm

As thousands of university students across the country cram for December exams, a number of articles have appeared detailing efforts to ease finals-related stress. Concerned administrators and campus organizations are offering programs ranging from free yoga classes, to "dog therapy" sessions, all with the goal of ensuring students' mental well-being.

Not everyone is pleased with this trend. Writing in the Globe and Mail on December 6, in a column titled "University's not meant to be easy," Margaret Wente argued that Canadian universities were guilty of "infantilizing," rather than "challenging" students. Monday, December 3 on CBC Radio's The Current, Ken Coates, Canada Research Chair at the University of Saskatchewan and author of the book Campus Confidential, expressed similar sentiments: Universities should function as a "proving ground," he argued, and therefore not be too accommodating.

To be fair, neither Wente nor Coates was speaking about yoga or dog therapy. Rather, both were expressing concerns about more substantive changes, such as those recommended in a recent Queen's University report on student mental health. These include reductions in the amount of required reading and writing at certain times of the semester, greater flexibility on assignment deadlines for students with special needs, and longer exam periods.

In essence, Wente and Coates' argument goes something like this: Universities are admitting more and more students who are unsuited to the rigours of higher education. These institutions have lowered their standards in order to make more money through tuition fees and, at the same time, high schools are "coddling" their students, leaving them "thin-skinned" and unprepared. Instead of reforming these mediocre students' bad habits, universities have made it easier to achieve good grades and, eventually, receive a degree. This, in turn, reduces the economic value of a university education (anyone, it seems, can get a B.A.) and leaves graduates unprepared for the "real world."

Wente and Coates believe that universities should serve the job market. A university degree used to mean something to employers, bemoaned Coates in his Current interview: "It meant you could handle stress; it meant you could cope; it meant you took responsibility for yourself; it meant you managed your classes, managed your workload." Similarly, Wente writes that university should be where you go to "learn to cope with your responsibilities and manage your time."

It is striking that neither Wente nor Coates had anything to say about the content of a university education. The topic of your undergraduate honours thesis, it seems, matters less than whether or not you submitted it on time and formatted the bibliography correctly. Universities are supposed to test students' mettle, to sort the employable wheat from the unproductive chaff.

The problem is that, at least in the case of the social sciences and humanities, universities were never meant to function as a sorting mechanism for the job market. As Mark Kingwell pointed out in a recent Globe and Mail article, "liberal education is about citizenship, not job training or simple personal enrichment." Universities are not supposed to help corporations find productive workers, they are supposed to create an engaged and informed public.

In her article Wente deplores the fact that (according to an unnamed professor friend) university students today are less interested in "challenging or debating" ideas in class than were their predecessors. These students, she posits, simply wish to "collect a credential," rather than engaging in their education in a more meaningful way. This attitude, however, is the logical outcome of precisely the type of higher education that Wente and Coates advocate. A view that sees universities as more valuable for testing instrumental organizational skills than for teaching literature, rhetoric, or philosophy can't help but devalue the process of learning in favour of the simple obtainment of a degree.

I agree with Wente and Cotes on one point: University isn't for everyone. There are plenty of ways to be successful in life without attending university. We would all be better served by eliminating the false and misguided tendency of seeing those who choose not to attend university as "lesser." Indeed, it is this attitude that is responsible for a great deal of students' stress. The possibility of a poor grade seems to imply not only academic, but also personal and societal failure.

Increasing the range of socially acceptable options for graduating high school students does not, however, mean that we should make it harder to attend university, only that we should make it easier and more acceptable to pursue other options.

We shouldn't be bemoaning the fact that more students who are not "academically gifted" in an extremely narrow, extremely traditional sense, are going to university. We shouldn't be trying to root these students out through unnecessarily onerous workloads. The fact that more students are attending university is cause for celebration. We should devote the effort and resources necessary to change university education to better serve all students; to provide them with the facts, theories, and critical thinking skills that will help them better contribute to our democracy.

Attending university shouldn't be more stressful and more demanding. It should be more exciting and engaging.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Find A Fuzzy Friend

    If you don't have an adorable pet of your own, you'll have to call in a favor from a friend on this one. There are few things more calming and purely enjoyable than playing with a puppy or kitty. After 15 minutes of furry fun, you'll be rejuvenated and ready to hit the books again.

  • RUN

    Going for even a 20-minute run (preferably outside -- the cool air will wake you up) releases feel-good endorphins to boost your mood and can help quiet an over-active mind. Try to fit in a quick jog after school and before you start studying so that you can hit the books with a clear mind.

  • Bake A Healthy Breakfast Treat

    Baking, like drawing or playing music, can be a surprisingly soothing activity that helps silence racing thoughts. Try making a healthy, nutrient-packed goodie -- like these protein-packed <a href="http://www.oprah.com/food/Pumpkin-Chia-Seed-Muffins">pumpkin chia-seed muffins</a> -- and you'll have something fast and brain-fueling to throw into your backpack for breakfast in the morning.

  • Talk It Out

    Don't keep your anxiety bottled up inside. Sit down after dinner with Mom or Dad for a cup of tea and a chat. Talk them through your plan for finals week, tell them what's stressing you out and ask for any advice they might have. Often, verbalizing the things that are filling our brains with anxiety robs them of their worry-inducing power.

  • Clean Your Desk

    Sometimes decluttering your space is all you need to declutter your mind. Take an hour or so to totally clear out your desk space (and not just cosmetic cleaning, but really giving it a good scrub), and you'll create a place that allows you to totally focus.

  • Create A Detailed Calendar

    Include not only exam dates and paper deadlines, but anything else in your life (gift shopping, swim practice, yoga class) that you need to make time for. Even the act of writing it down -- and color-coding, if you're so inclined -- will make it all feel more doable.

  • Perform An Act Of Kindness

    Sometimes, doing something nice for another person is the best way to get out of your head and stop obsessing about your own problems. If you have a little free time on a Saturday afternoon, spend an hour volunteering at a homeless shelter. A simple act like reading your little sister a bedtime story or helping your mom unload groceries can have the save effect.

  • Sweat It Out

    Few things are as revitalizing as releasing bodily toxins through a hot yoga class, or if you have access, 30 minutes in a sauna or steam room. Working up a good sweat can make you feel like a new person -- just remember to drink lots of water afterwards to stay hydrated.

  • Take A Social Media Break

    Spending too much time on Facebook, Twitter and Tumblr when exams are looming can only add to your already-mounting stress levels. Turn off your Facebook email notifications so that you're not tempted to log on, and if you're really having trouble, try <a href="https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/leechblock/">LeechBlock</a>, a Firefox add-on that blocks time-wasting sites.

  • Listen To Music

    HuffPost Teen blogger Tara Subramaniam has some helpful <a href="https://twitter.com/Tara_SuperSub/status/273881989818486785">advice</a> for combatting exam-time stress: "listen to A LOT of music." Taking a break to listen to your favorite album or putting on classical music while you study Chemistry can help you majorly chill out.

 

Follow Nicholas Barber on Twitter: www.twitter.com/nccbarber

FOLLOW CANADA LIVING