It must feel good to be a refugee-hugger. Until a day when your neighbour tells you that your "moral preening," "utopian kumbaya," "politically correct humanism," and your "misguided idealism" endanger our way of life, our women and western Judeo-Christian values. And it is your nice neighbour who says that to you.
The split among Canadians on the question of dangers of the current refugee crisis has been highlighted during Friday's Munk Debate at the Toronto's posh Roy Thomson Hall. After listening to the arguments from two sides, a whopping 45 per cent among the well-attired, well-educated and well-intentioned in audience went home convinced of the perils of holding on to the ideal "give us your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free." They must have forgotten recent darling photos of our Prime Minister putting winter jackets on the shoulders of shell-shocked Syrian children landing at our airports.
On one side of the debate stood ever-undaunted Nigel Farage (leader of the U.K. right-wing party UKIP), flanked by sly and eloquent Mark Steyn (popular writer, commentator). These pragmatists squared off against the idealists -- refreshingly sane unshakable legal juggernaut Louise Arbour (Chief Prosecutor for the International Criminal Tribunals) and poetic historian Simon Schama.
Madame Arbour, quoting Canada's obligations under 1951 Refugee Convention, insisted that Canada needs "to welcome people who like all of us came from somewhere else" and to "provide a generous resettlement program." She added that the panicked voices of the opposition are a replay of the old "ugly response to every new wave of immigrants in history."
The real danger to us, she intoned, lies not with refugees swarming our shores but with violent jihadi groups who "seek to destroy our democracies by letting us slowly self-implode in response to fear."
"A three-year old was raped by a refugee" shouted Mr. Steyn for the pragmatists. Five hundred cases of sexual assault were reported just on one New Year Eve night in Cologne -- "migrant rights now trump women's rights," he said. The chief of police of Vienna advised women that it is no longer safe to go out unaccompanied -- "migrant rights trump the right of free movement." In Sweden the influx of young males has skewed the ratio of boys to girls among the 16-year-olds to 1.23 to 1 -- a number worse than that in China. This immigration wave is different, Mr. Steyn said, many newcomers are not refugees but "economic migrants who want to avail themselves of the comforts of advanced societies."
Shall we do a reality check? I believe that most Canadians do not give a hoot about Canada's "special obligations" under some 1951 convention. Madame Arbour, it will not move anyone to suggest that "we have done only a fraction of what we should do" and that failure to generously welcome refugees is "to look to the past and to stagnate in isolation."
Mr. Farage is absolutely right when he says many Europeans have become "hard-hearted." Advocates of a more generous refugee policy must acknowledge the reality on the ground. Madame Arbour, your aspirations notwithstanding, current political context matters. Right now, 71 per cent of Canadians do not want Canada to accept above the original target of 25,000 Syrians. The warm feeling of moral righteousness is not particularly useful for devising a policy at a time when 60 per cent of Americans agree with Donald Trump's proposal to ban entry of all non-citizen Muslims to the United States. For real. 60 per cent. Do you get a feeling that "we are not in Kansas anymore?"
What are we, bleeding hearts, left to do in this situation? Pivot. Take a dose of reality, a pill of optimistic pragmatism and pivot. Canadian government showed that it knows how to do so. First, it preempted the sexual predator argument and a security concern by excluding Syrian single men from the new asylum admittance rules. Do you think the Refugee Convention allows for that? Do you think Germans could easily get away with the same approach? Also, the government has hinted at moving away from placing "a special priority on Syria." Again, wise move.
Is there a certain ideal that informs our values on immigration?
If Canadians still have questions, let us address them openly and head on. Do Muslim men pose a special danger to women? Years of trauma from violence and war, ever-present stench of death, hate and destitution mixed with adolescent mob mentality -- if unchecked -- will erupt in violence. No surprise. What is key to this issue is a loud and clear confirmation, as Canadian Council of Muslim Women asserts, that the violence against women in Muslim communities in North America is "at a similar rate to women in the general population." There is no Muslim sexual beast roaming the streets out there. Period.
Where Mr. Farage is right, I believe, is on the point that we need to feel no shame about changing our minds (our policies, our obligations from 1951) about what we demand of the newcomers to our shores. Reality on the ground forces us to adjust our immigration policies, not -- and this is critical -- our way of life. European bureaucrats, beware. We can stand proudly on what we choose to accept and what we do not. Mayor of Cologne, Henriette Reker, is an idiot for suggesting after the New Year Eve attacks that German women ought to adopt a new "code of conduct." No, no chance. Period.
What is dearly missing in this whole debate is a reassuring voice of wisdom that can help us see if we Canadians got it right in formulating our immigration policies. Is there a certain ideal that informs our values on immigration? Is there an ideal that has withstood test of time and will endure new challenges to it, come what may -- Syrian refugee crisis or another world catastrophe?
Certain pragmatic idealism in our ancestral memory beckons to us at this moment. It is a balanced position epitomized by two minds, who can be credited with planting on this continent centuries ago seeds of good immigration policy. In their words we can see a jubilant embrace for the poor and the huddled, tempered with reasonable caution. Our values have grown out of the ideas articulated by these architects of the American Experiment. Our values have not changed fundamentally, they are strong -- they have weathered the test of time.
If they come of themselves, they are entitled to all the rights of citizenship: but I doubt the expediency of inviting them by extraordinary encouragements.
-- American Founding father, Author of Declaration of Independence, third American president Thomas Jefferson, 1782
Born in other countries, yet believing you could be happy in this, our laws acknowledge, as they should do, your right to join us in society, conforming, as I doubt not you will do, to our established rules.
-- Thomas Jefferson, 1801
The bosom of America is open to receive not only the Opulent and respectable Stranger, but the oppressed and persecuted of all Nations and Religions; whom we shall welcome to a participation of all our rights and privileges, if by decency and propriety of conduct they appear to merit the enjoyment.
-- American Founding father, Commander-in-Chief in the American Revolutionary War, first American president George Washington, Address to the Members of the Volunteer Association of Ireland, 1783
Follow HuffPost Canada Blogs on Facebook
ALSO ON HUFFPOST:
The plight of Syrians besieged in the town of Madaya prompted an international humanitarian response (AP Photo) Hunger, starvation, and extreme malnourishment present existential threats to millions of Syria's most vulnerable people. The young, the elderly, and the infirm are all particularly susceptible to the effects of malnutrition, which can stunt the growth of children, and exacerbate chronic medical conditions. Unicef deputy director Lily Caprani told HuffPost UK about the effects long-term malnourishment are having as the Syrian conflict enters its fifth year. She said: "There’s hunger in the short term, and then malnutrition over the longer term severely and in some cases irreversibly damages children’s development, so a child who at the age of two or three is undernourished can physical stop growing. “Unfortunately there are some cases where that cannot be undone. We’re trying to stop getting it to that stage." Unicef continues to work in Syria, and it estimates it has helped the majority of those who need help in accessible areas. That still leaves as many as two million out of reach of aid, however. Towns which are besieged by fighting are particularly difficult to access. In one example, the situation in the Syrian town of Madaya, north west of Damascus, had become so dire that the UN estimated 400 residents needed to be immediately evacuated to receive life-saving treatment. Their conditions related to extreme malnourishment and starvation, as well as medical conditions.
Syrian boys play with snow following a storm in the northern Syrian city of Aleppo on January 5 Exposure to the elements is become a concern for aid agencies operating in and around Syria. Harsh winters bring snow, ice, and chilling winds - making for harrowing conditions in houses lacking electricity and the refugee camps bordering on vast, desolate landscapes. "One of the key things we worry about every year in that on top of everything else, we now have extreme cold," Lily Caprani of Unicef UK says, "Although we're doing everything we can to them, they're living in tents, in containers." The organisation is leading a campaign to keep children warm this winter with hats, gloves and scalfs. "Many of the refugees in... countries such as Jordan and Lebanon live in terrible conditions and are struggling to find warmth as temperatures fall," Robert Mardini, director for the Near and Middle East with the International Committee of the Red Cross, told Al Jazeera. "They live with the uncertainty of not knowing what tomorrow will bring, or even if they will ever make it back home one day."
Syrians searching for survivors in the rubble of destroyed buildings following the barrel bomb-attacks of Syrian air forces on February 2, 2014, in Aleppo, Syria. Barrel bombs continue to plague Syrian cities. The improvised devices are thrown from transport helicopters, without the ability to hit specific targets. According to the Syrian Network for Human Rights, the number of civilains killed by Syrian regime barrel bombs outnumbers those slain by the so-called Islamic State and al-Qaeda. Jeremy Binnie, Middle East editor for IHS Jane's Defence Weekly, told HuffPost UK that the bombs were developed due to either a lack of weaponry or aircraft around a year or so into the current conflict. He said: “While early ones appeared to be similar in size to oil barrels, the ones that have been seen generally have a smaller diameter. “They were first seen in the summer of 2012. “They are a way of turning the Syrian air force’s Mi-8/17 helicopters into attack aircraft as the improvised bombs can be rolled out the rear cargo doors.” “The bombs are capable of destroying buildings and killing people, but almost certainly have less explosive power than mass-produced aircraft bombs of similar size."
A Russian bomber drops bombs on a target. Russia has unleashed another barrage of airstrikes against targets in Syria Airstrikes from foreign forces continue to pose a threat to civilian life - however unintended this may be. In December, at least 26 people were believed to have been killed following US-led airstrikes attacking suspected Isis positions. The Guardian reported Rami Abdel Rahman of the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights as saying Isis is in control of Al-Khan but is only on its outskirts, “which is why all of the deaths were civilians”. The US military command said it was investigating the claims. Britain's Royal Air Force, which received Parliamentary authority to commence airstrikes last year, says it is able to say no civilians have died as a result of its recent airstrikes in Syria which are planned meticulously to prevent collateral damage.
A health worker marks the thumb of a Syrian child after giving him polio vaccine (File Photo) Dirty water and the resulting disease pose a continued threat to Syrians living in increasingly unsanitary conditions. Unicef is one of a number of aid agencies working to mitigate the risks, but even it admits that millions of Syrian children and adults who continue to be at risk in areas that cannot be easily reached. While the threat continues to be high - disease is one of the areas of success for agencies trying hard to prevent a public health disaster dovetailing with the fierce conflict. Lily Caprani of Unicef told HuffPost UK: "We’re making sure children and the vulnerable are immunized against waterborne disease, because we know they are going to be exposed to disease so we make sure they’re going to be protected. “This can help prevent a public health disaster. One of the very few pieces of good news is that you would expect the resurgence of disease and infections we would normally not see. “But because we’ve managed to immunize we’ve prevented this. There have been no new cases of polio since January 2014 and that’s short of a miracle. "It’s relatively cheap to do - it doesn’t cost a lot of money and it prevents the snowball effect of a public health emergency." Nonetheless, the shocking state of health uncovered at the besieged town of Madaya in January points towards localised medical emergencies being commonplace in some areas in the country.
A visitor looks at photographs in the 'Caesar's Photos: Inside Syria's Secret Prisons', a collection of photographs smuggled out of Syria last year Torture and execution remain a threat to civilian life throughout Syria, with hundreds allegedly killed at the hands of President Assad's regime alone. Syria has systematically tortured and executed 11,000 of its citizens in the three-year war, according to a report by former war crimes prosecutors, who compared the bodies they saw to images of Nazi death camp victims. Meanwhile the so-called Islamic State has been adept at publicising its regime's torture and execution, even publishing reports in its own magazine, with countless Syrians and scores of foreigners killed in the now signature orange jumpsuits. In January, the Syrian Observatory of Human Rights reported that an Islamic State militant executed his own mother, after she encouraged him to leave the terror group.
Violence and exploitation resulting from the break down of Syrian society present a real threat to the lives of adults and children alike, whilst kidnapping remains a tactic of fear used by militants. There are countless examples of violence between warring factions spilling over into civilian communities, wounding and killing innocent people. Unicef's experience of conflict emergencies across the world has led it to the conclusion that education can protect children from violence and exploitation. Lily Caprani, UK deputy director, told HuffPost UK: "If children are in education, they’re in a safe space. If children are in a safe environment with safe people, the risks of violence and exploitation are lower. "This protects children from adults who might not have their best interests at heart." Kidnapping by Islamic State militants continues to present a real threat to civilian life. Last year, hundreds of innocent people were taken by the group amid mounting international calls for the release of those abducted.
Follow Nicholas Nazar on Twitter: www.twitter.com/NicholasNazar