Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Parmjit Parmar


Gourmet Pumpkin Cheesecake Ice Cream

Posted: 11/10/2013 1:05 am

Eating ice cream brings back a host of fond childhood memories. I particularly remember our neighbourhood ice cream truck. England's legacy of soft-serve ice cream with a flake bar adorning the top trumped. Even today ice cream is one of the most delicious treats to serve your family and guests.

On a recent trip to the Deerhurst Resort in Muskoka, a group of us were treated to a visit to the Belly Ice Cream Company's kitchen. Founded by Shelly Westgarth, a former chef in the resort's kitchens and now purveyor and maker of gourmet ice cream.

Shelly, once head chef of Eclipse restaurant at Deerhurst, started her ice cream venture in 2009. With twin children about to start school, Shelley realized she had to adjust her working hours to accommodate her growing family. As a regular visitor to the Muskoka farmer's markets in summer, she identified an opportunity to make and sell gourmet Ice cream. The rest is history.

Shelly Westgarth

Belly keeps no stock; each order is made fresh for buyers. Ingredients are purchased locally from producers of Honey (Poppa Jim's), Maple, Berries, Stone fruits, Coffee, and even Beer! She makes small batches of hand packed pints with an obsessive attention to detail

Ice Cream Fit for Movie Stars

What's next for this enterprising chef? Ice cream fit for the stars at The Oscars -- a new batch of flavours (raspberry-chocolate truffle and champagne with gold flakes) is in the works for the lucky celebrities attending the awards night in Los Angeles. Stay tuned for more.

Ice Cream Making Lessons
Pumpkin cheesecake with maple swirls and candied pecans

We started our ice cream making adventure by tasting some of her most popular flavours: 16 Vanilla bean Saigon Cinnamon, Wild blueberry cheesecake, Dulce de Leche, Muskoka Maple Mocha, Peppermint patty, Basil gelato, Obscene brownie and Salted caramel.


Shelly had the cheesecake-base ready to go for our lesson (the mixture included: cream cheese, sour cream, lemon zest, sugar, cream, milk, egg yolks, sea salt and vanilla). To this mixture we added the pumpkin mix, which included the pumpkin pie spices and sweetened condensed milk.

The pumpkin cheesecake mixture was then added to the Carpigiani gelato machine. Shelley explained the machine freezes at a very fast rate so that ice crystals are very fine. While freezing it (the machine) churns at a fairly slow pace so that the product is not very aerated. Generally 35 per cent air in comparison to commercial ice cream that can go as high as 120 per cent air.


We added pecans and feulletine (crispy wafer flakes) as well as maple syrup and maple flavouring into a separate bowl.


Once mixed, we gently stirred this into the churned ice cream to create the marble texture.


The finished product was scooped into containers, sealed and placed in the freezer. The next day our precious "cargo" was collected for return trip home.


Here's the recipe to make your own Pumpkin Cheesecake Ice Cream:

1 cup cream cheese
1 cup of 10% cream
1/2 cup sour cream
3/4 cup sugar
1/4 cup maple syrup
¾ cup pumpkin
1/2 cup sweetened condensed milk
1/2 tsp pumpkin pie spice
1 tsp vanilla extract
pinch of salt


Blend together first four ingredients in a blender. In a small saucepan cook remaining ingredients until mixture looses its bright orange colour to resemble pumpkin pie colour.

Allow to cool and then mix into cheesecake base. Gently pour the ice cream mix into a container and chill in the refrigerator or in an ice bath until completely cool. Then place in the freezer overnight. Enjoy!

Yields Approximately 750 ml.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Olive Oil Saffron Ice Cream with Burnt Orange Caramel Swirl

    <em><strong><a href="http://food52.com/recipes/18846-olive-oil-saffron-ice-cream-with-burnt-orange-caramel-swirl" target="_hplink">Get the recipe on Food52</a></strong>.</em><br><br> Orange, olive oil, and saffron may bring to mind a paella more than dessert, but they pack quite a punch together in this ice cream. The olive oil ice cream base is from "Jeni's Splendid Ice Cream at Home." -Amanda and Merrill <br><em>Photo by James Ransom</em>

  • Fresh Ricotta Ice Cream

    <em><strong><a href="http://food52.com/recipes/18735-fresh-ricotta-ice-cream" target="_hplink">Get the recipe on Food52</a></strong>.</em><br><br> The ricotta taste really came through, while the addition of the heavy cream made it smooth and rich. -baker23 <br><em>Photo by James Ransom</em>

  • Mango Ice Cream with Chili Sea Salt

    <em><strong><a href="http://food52.com/recipes/17494-52-scoops-mango-ice-cream-with-chili-sea-salt" class="">Save and print this recipe on Food52</a></strong><br><br> The addition of just a little bit of the chili salt adds just the right amount of spice and salt to the sweet and tart mango for a fun and different treat. - biffbourgeois <br><em>Photo by James Ransom</em>

  • Strawberry Fennel Ice Cream

    <em><strong><a href="http://food52.com/recipes/4860-strawberry-fennel-ice-cream" target="_hplink">Get the recipe on Food52</a></strong>.</em><br><br> You would think that the key ingredient in this ice cream would be the fragrant fennel pollen, but it's actually the agave nectar. - Amanda and Merrill <br><em>Photo by Sarah Shatz</em>

  • Maple Ice Cream with Tipsy Raisins and Maple Candied Cashews

    <em><strong><a href="http://food52.com/recipes/16735-maple-ice-cream-with-tipsy-raisins-and-maple-candied-cashews" target="_hplink">Get the recipe on Food52</a></strong>.</em><br><br> The caramelized nuts and boozy raisins are the perfect complement with the strong maple ice cream. -biffbourgeois <br><em>Photo by James Ransom</em>

  • Arnold Palmer Ice Cream

    <em><strong><a href="http://food52.com/recipes/18807-arnold-palmer-ice-cream" target="_hplink">Get the recipe on Food52</a></strong>.</em><br><br> You may be tempted, as we initially were, to forego the "tea crunchies" and lemon zest topping and just spoon it up straight from the ice cream maker, but the combo adds a definite "wow," much like when Arnie ripped a 3-wood to within 18 feet of the 13th hole in the 1958 Masters. -wssmom <br><em>Photo by James Ransom</em>

  • Ginger Ice Cream with Honey Sesame Brittle

    <em><strong><a href="http://food52.com/recipes/18839-ginger-ice-cream-with-honey-sesame-brittle" target="_hplink">Get the recipe on Food52</a></strong>.</em><br><br> This is a delightful ice cream that packs a wollop of flavor.The toasty sesame brittle is excellent with the ice cream. - biffbourgeois <br><em>Photo by James Ransom</em>

  • Kabocha Vanilla Chai Ice Cream

    <em><strong><a href="http://food52.com/recipes/18782-kabocha-vanilla-chai-ice-cream" target="_hplink">Get the recipe on Food52</a></strong>.</em><br><br> The milk is infused with chai flavors to add extra oomph to Jeni's classic base, and roasted, pureed kabocha squash adds body. - Amanda and Merrill <br><em>Photo by James Ransom</em>

  • Maple-Sage Ice Cream with Maple-Sage Sugared Walnuts

    <em><strong><a href="http://food52.com/recipes/15540-maple-sage-ice-cream-with-maple-sage-sugared-walnuts" target="_hplink">Get the recipe on Food52</a></strong>.</em><br><br> The sage is no shrinking violet in this silky ice cream that contrasts beautifully with the crunchy, caramelized walnuts. - Amanda and Merrill <br><em>Photo by James Ransom</em>

  • Oatmeal Ice Cream with Toasted Walnuts

    <em><strong><a href="http://food52.com/recipes/21570-oatmeal-ice-cream-with-toasted-walnuts" target="_hplink">Get the recipe on Food52</a></strong>.</em><br><br> This ice cream is pleasantly milky, reminiscent of the best porridge you've ever had, sweetened up in just the right ways. - Amanda and Merrill <br><em>Photo by James Ransom</em>


Follow Parmjit Parmar on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ParmieP