Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Hall

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Hall
 

The Economic Indicators That Need Sober Second Thought

Posted: 11/27/2013 12:23 pm

Leading indicators have gained more prominence in the post-crisis period, if only because the on-again, off-again economy has intensified scrutiny of shifts in momentum. However, the unusual circumstances that gave rise to delayed recovery and the extraordinary stimulative measures taken to rebuff weakness have distorted certain indicators, forcing analysts to pick and choose their favourites. Which ones can we rely on, and are they telling us anything helpful at this point in time?

Composite indicators -- the ones that combine a group of time-tested leading signals -- are still relied on as economic barometers. There's a lot of excitement about their recent direction. Take for example the OECD leading indicator -- it has now risen for 12 consecutive quarters, a rare moment that we have not seen since the gush of stimulus that hit the economy in 2009-10. But is this venerated indicator been tainted by any recent distortions?

Unfortunately, yes. Composite indexes usually include a selected stock market index, a money supply measure and a yield curve calculation (long versus short-term interest rates). Each of these has been influenced significantly by fiscal and monetary policy moves, not only in recent years, but in recent weeks. The mere mention of tapering last May had stock markets retreating and longer-term yields rising -- not to mention altered expectations of growth in monetary aggregates.

If we are going to be months, or more realistically, years in unwinding extraordinary policy measures, which leading indicators can we rely on to point the way for the economy? The housing market is a favourite, and at least in the U.S., it is showing vibrant growth. Although strong pent-up demand is driving the market upward, this reliable indicator may see its own ups and downs, as current activity is occurring in a context of very easy access to financing, which is quickly coming to an end.

Average weekly hours will be an interesting one to watch. Uncertainty has made corporations unusually reticent to hire. When global growth begins to ramp up, we can expect average hours worked to ramp up sharply before companies get the signal that we are in a new hiring cycle. Many economies dealing with ageing populations may see a stronger spike than in past recovery periods.

Sentiment is not normally a go-to harbinger of recovery, but for the moment, this one might be prescient. We have been so gloomy for so long, that it may take recovery in confidence to jolt the world into a sense that things are not so "new-normal-drab" as we have been led to believe.

Business orders for goods and services of all descriptions remain one of the most reliable leading indicators. Thankfully, survey activity has been enhanced over the years to the point that even key emerging markets have solid data to work with. Recent readings also show that orders have been moving upward, convincingly -- that is, the upward movement spans multiple regions of the world and a large variety of industries. Sustained growth going forward will tell the tale for global growth.

This brings me to a lesser-known index. If orders are a strong signal, then freight shipments shouldn't be far behind. After all, inputs have to be shipped before stuff can be made and delivered. Down at the bottom of a pile of other cyclical indicators is the US freight services index, and I'm happy to say that but for a one-off interruption last October, steady growth in this index has now taken it beyond its previous peak level in early 2005. If it's right, it is saying good things about the world's growth engine.

The bottom line? Unprecedented developments in the world economy have had many effects; one of them is a tainting of leading indicators. Thankfully, the untainted ones are projecting solid growth.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Manufacturing: 24,600 fewer jobs (WORST)

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Public administration: 23,600 fewer jobs

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • "Other services": 12,500 fewer jobs

    "Other services" includes laundry, gardening, hairdressing and massage, among other things. Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Utilities: 7,000 more jobs

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Information & cultural industries: 14,600 more jobs

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Finance, insurance and real estate: 47,000 more jobs

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Transportation and warehousing: 52,700 more jobs

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Business/building and other support services: 61,300 more jobs

    Includes janitorial services, waste collection, security services, travel agencies, call centres and tour operators. Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Education: 61,400 more jobs

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Natural resources: 65,100 more jobs

    Includes oil and gas, mining, forestry and fishing. Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Wholesale trade: 71,800 more jobs

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Accommodation and food services: 93,000 more jobs

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Professional, scientific & technical services: 161,700 more jobs

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Construction: 207,800 more jobs

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Health care and social assistance: 248,400 more jobs (BEST)

    Total gains or losses in the number of jobs, July 2009 to Sept. 2013. Source: <a href="http://www.conferenceboard.ca/economics/hot_eco_topics/default/13-11-05/which_industries_are_creating_jobs.aspx">Conference Board of Canada</a>

  • Also on HuffPost:

    HIGHEST PAYING JOBS IN CANADA THAT DON'T NECESSARILY NEED A DEGREE

  • 14: Pilot

    Average salary $44,224.00

  • 13: Farmer

    Average salary: $46,213.00

  • 12: Secretary

    Yes, apparently they still have secretaries. Average salary: $46,369.00

  • 11: Truck Driver

    Average salary: $47,562.00

  • 10: Financial advisor

    Average salary: $52,635.00 *Having some sort of certification in finance or business would likely help in this career, but isn't necessary.

  • 9: Bricklayer

    Average salary: $53,017.00

  • 8: Recruiter

    Average salary: $54,048.00 *Though a degree isn't required, you may be at a disadvantage when searching for work as a recruiter against those with degrees in human resources.

  • 7: Mechanic

    Average salary: $54,279.00

  • 6: Train driver

    Average salary: $56,640.00

  • 5: Human resources manager

    Average salary: $58,033.00 *As with recruiters, you my be at a disadvantage in this field against those with a human resources degree.

  • 4: Electrician

    Average salary: $62,526.00

  • 3: Electrical engineer

    Average salary: $81,349.00 *Adzuna explains: For some electrical engineering jobs, a degree is required, and for others it isn't — there are alternative professional qualifications.

  • 2: Real estate agent

    Average salary: $88,200.00

  • 1: Mining and construction

    Average salary: $93,320.00

  • Also on HuffPost:

    <strong>WHERE ARE THE GRAD JOBS?</strong>

  • Energy / oil and gas - 1,906 jobs

    Number of jobs available at time of Adzuna survey

  • Information technology - 2,559

    Number of jobs available at time of Adzuna survey

  • Consultancy - 3,434

    Number of jobs available at time of Adzuna survey

  • Sales - 3,638

    Number of jobs available at time of Adzuna survey

  • Engineering (best)- 4,968

    Number of jobs available at time of Adzuna survey

  • NEXT:

    BEST-PAYING DEGREE SUBJECTS

  • Mechanical engineering - $68,075

    Source: Adzuna

  • Engineering (overall) - $67,036

    Source: Adzuna

  • Electrical engineering - $67,712

    Source: Adzuna

  • Software engineering - $67,274

    Source: Adzuna

  • Civil engineering (best) - $68,356

    Source: Adzuna

  • NEXT:

    WORST-PAYING GRAD JOBS BY SECTOR

  • PR, advertising and marketing - $42,209

    Source: Adzuna

  • Social work - $42,204

    Source: Adzuna

  • Human resources and recruitment - $42,195

    Source: Adzuna

  • Sales - $41,463

    Source: Adzuna

  • Creative & design (worst) - $36,805

    Source: Adzuna

  • NEXT:

    REGIONAL DISTRIBUTION OF GRADUATE JOBS

  • Manitoba - 28 grads per job

    Average starting salary: $45,650.

  • British Columbia - 20 grads per job

    Average starting salary: $45,450.

 
FOLLOW CANADA BUSINESS