Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Worthington

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Worthington
 

Bob Rae's the Only Good (and Experienced) Apple In the Bunch

Posted: 06/19/2012 11:27 am

Bob Rae's only problem -- no, that's not right his "biggest" problem -- is that if he were Liberal leader and not just an interim leader, it's unlikely he and his party would be elected to run the country.

Rae's got too much baggage, especially when he led the Ontario NDP and was premier. Everything disintegrated around him, immunizing the province against electing another "socialist" government. Instead, the province got Dalton McGuinty.

Bob Rae has recently come out and stated firmly and unapologetically that he will not run for the permanent leadership of the Liberals. Anyone following Canadian federal politics is aware that the most effective leader in the Liberal Party is Bob Rae. Like him or not, he knows politics and handles any issue with grace and is never an embarrassment to himself, his party or his country.

When he took the interim job he pledged that he wouldn't run. So who's likely to be chosen liberal leader? It's a sorry field when Justin Trudeau seems the choice of many -- a callow fellow who many claim has charisma -- as if that's a substitute for wisdom and judgment.

Astronaut Marc Garneau may also be a leadership contender. While he has little in the way of damaging baggage, he also has little in the way of obvious substance to be PM. In fact, looking over the field of Liberal hopefuls, the only one with apparent substance of leadership is... Bob Rae.

But he's isolated himself -- declared he won't renege on his original word! Okay, so what if he were "drafted," begged by the party to be their leader? Well, then things would change. How could he refuse? He's already acknowledge that he'd like to be PM and that he thinks he could do the job, but that he's not moping or shedding tears. He's prepared to soldier on as an ordinary MP.

It's kind of noble -- but it may also be a ploy.

Liberals are unlikely to unanimously agree to draft Rae as leader rather than go through a leadership convention. A tough choice for the party. One gathers Trudeau would be a shoo-in if he chose to run -- which he's said is not something he's contemplating at this moment. The more he resists, the more tempting it is to pressure him. A reluctant bridegroom, so to speak.

Curiously, just as Bob Rae has baggage that would probably get the Liberals defeated in an election, Justin Trudeau might have even greater trouble. His father, when he made his bid for leadership, had more Liberals against him than for him until the final ballot. His first election was a decent majority (after nearly a decade of minority governments) and his second election was a two-seat minority government. Lucky for him it was nice Bob Stanfield as his Tory opposition.

Trudeau may be the Liberal flavour of the week, but as a political operator he's not in the same class as Bob Rae. And that reality must burn Rae's britches. Neither one is likely to lead the Liberal party to victory. So get used to Stephen Harper, whose Conservative government has made Canada the envy of the world in these times of crumbling economies and European unrest.

 
FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
Bob Rae's only problem -- no, that's not right his "biggest" problem -- is that if he were Liberal leader and not just an interim leader, it's unlikely he and his party would be elected to run the cou...
Bob Rae's only problem -- no, that's not right his "biggest" problem -- is that if he were Liberal leader and not just an interim leader, it's unlikely he and his party would be elected to run the cou...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
lilkitten22
Be the change that you wish to see in the world
11:23 PM on 06/20/2012
I'm sure there are others that can be elected to the head of the party, I don't see Bob Rae as being the only one.
georgee2
My Canada Includes Everyone
12:09 PM on 06/20/2012
You may be right Peter, but there is still one problem with Mr. Rae. Canadians will not elect him Prime Minister.
photo
Gnomish
ego doctus ignarus
08:14 PM on 06/19/2012
Old world, old ideas, old, grievances, old news.

This is a not so brave New World! We need need blood and new ideas on cooperation.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:51 PM on 06/19/2012
A scientist and former astronaut doesn't have "the right stuff"?

Lawyers who have real experience in disaster creation are much more suitable for the position of PM. At least he knows what it's like being a failed leader. 2nd time is a charm!
05:43 PM on 06/19/2012
The Liberal party is both old and ossified. It will take a complete revamp of policy to make it relevant to the people of Canada. Bob Rae cannot make the changes to Liberal policy because he does not believe they are necessary, Trudeau could, but he does not have the gravitas to move the mass of the party. It will take another election cycle, perhaps two, to traumatize the Liberals into changing. The pain of electoral loss is what forced the Reform party to move closer to the centre and eventual merger with the PC party (and the lack of threat to allow it to move back to the right).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tnanimation
05:02 PM on 06/19/2012
Here comes the Reform Party spin on the upcoming Liberal leadership decision with Peter (Little Bothersome Man) Worthington as the tip of the spear. He and Ezra Levant will be an intersting puppet show to watch as this story develops.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jason Hartwick
neither conservative nor liberal be, instead think
04:22 PM on 06/19/2012
Only one problem with Bob Rae? Experienced he may be, but is there any evidence he learned anything from the FIASCO of a government he ran (into the ground) in Ontario? The Conservatives were blasted because of "what Mike Harris did" to Ontario, but he only had to take those drastic (and admittedly cruel at times) measures because of the absolute lack of fiscal responsibility shown by Rae's government. 10 extra school days to save money. Right. Until they realized the teachers were being paid salary. Then they decided to train them on these days, costing us MORE money. His plan to make Ontario known for "innovation". Which actually sounds GREAT, until you realize that any crackpot with a half-formed scheme that could create a "report" about the wonders of their "innovation" that was enough pages that nobody wanted to read it was handed twice as much money as they actually asked for. People were quitting their jobs to live on welfare because they made more money that way. Rae goes far beyond "socialism" into the realm of stupidity.
wetcoastm
Free Speech As Dictated By Our Sponsors
04:08 PM on 06/19/2012
It is funny that extremist conservatives are devoting so much time on the leadership of a party they have labeled as dead. Why is that? Three years is a long time, plenty of time for the public to really see the impact of the foolish policies of the Conservative Party and for a new party leader to get ready to defeat Harper.
01:20 PM on 06/19/2012
Mr. Worthington, how can anyone assess the field of Liberal hopefuls so confidently at this point? Perhaps you could share with us the list of individuals included in this field and what special power you have to identify them.

As for the last point, I suggest Canada is the envy of the world in spite of the current prime minister, not because of him. You also appear to be under the impression Canadians will have only Liberals and Conservatives to choose from in the next election. I suspect the party that constitutes Her Majesty’s Loyal Opposition, i.e. the party that most all-knowing pundits like yourself are so quick to dismiss, will be running candidates as well. I have no idea how they will do next time around, but then neither does anyone else, even the pundits.