Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Worthington

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Worthington
 

How to Avoid G20 Violence Again? Let the Police do Their Jobs

Posted: 05/22/2012 1:00 pm

Even those who are sick of the subject have difficulty escaping the regurgitations of the 2010 G20 demonstrations that went horribly wrong.

The findings of the Independent Police Review director, Gerry McNeilly, seem reasonable and sensible. Still, they are doing some more second guessing -- as are all of the punditry and political and media comments that have been flowing ever since the vandalism of that G20 Saturday, followed on Sunday by police arresting the greatest number of people that had ever been taken into custody at one time.

Mistakes were made, force was over-used and misdirected, blah, blah, blah.

Get over it.

Everyone in authority has acknowledged error, and (one hopes) lessons have been learned; the same mistakes will not be repeated next time. And undoubtedly, there will be a next time.

That's a hazard of living in a largely peaceful and orderly democracy -- authorities are not used to coping with mobs and demonstrations that go bad. Any totalitarian regime would have handled the G20 protests, call them what you will, with ease, efficiency and brutality.

After all, the G20 was not in Greece, Syria, Libya, Egypt, Yemen or Somalia.

And although McNeilly's 300-page report of the G20 covers a lot of bases, the whole mess can be pinpointed to a couple of realities -- the guts of the whole affair.

The police are being faulted for their "take back the streets" attitude when, in fact, the streets were never taken away. A (relative) handful of Black Bloc hooded criminals indulged in hooliganism, intimidation, criminality, violence and provocative acts on that Saturday, which offended and surprised many of the demonstrators on the streets.

These hooligans, we've been told, came mostly from Quebec for fun and games. They were the fuse that led to the police plow-up the next day.

But where were the cops on that Saturday? Why were they so reluctant to do their job of apprehending criminals that so many witnessed and photographed breaking the law?

For some reason, the police stepped down -- were under orders not to provoke anything, to do nothing to stop the vandals. Whether ordered to or not, that's what they did.

Even the burning of a police car was tolerated, a video of which was aired around the world, giving people the impression that Toronto was in flames.

One can't help but feel that it wasn't cops on the beat who were at fault, but their superiors who ordered them to show restraint, to tolerate more than they should have.

It was a bit of the Caledonian attitude that infected our top police command. At the Caledonia impasse, the OPP were told to lay off the Indians who were threatening, invading homes, blocking roads, demanding identification of residents, intimidating locals while the cops watched and did nothing.

One guy protesting the lack of police response to native provocation was arrested for raising a Canadain flag, for God's sake.

At the time, OPP Commissioner Julian Faninto (now an MP and Associate Defence Minister!) gave orders that there would be no police confrontation of Indians. It is a theme that has limited police response ever since Dudley George was killed while protesting at Ipperwash, nearly a decade ago.

Anyway, that seems to be the flavour of G20 Saturday. Overnight, the police policy changed, and a storm trooper mentality prevailed -- not against criminal elements, but against peaceful protesters, demonstrators and spectators.

So what's the message? Well, police should be police and stop criminals -- and at demonstrations, be suspicious of people who wear masks. If they had done their duty on Saturday, there would have been no Sunday shame of arresting the wrong people.

But move on. Quit reliving what can't be changed, and ensure it won't happen again.

 
FOLLOW CANADA
Even those who are sick of the subject have difficulty escaping the regurgitations of the 2010 G20 demonstrations that went horribly wrong. The findings of the Independent Police Review d...
Even those who are sick of the subject have difficulty escaping the regurgitations of the 2010 G20 demonstrations that went horribly wrong. The findings of the Independent Police Review d...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LauraNo
03:05 PM on 05/23/2012
I was unaware of the fact that somebody is not letting the police do their jobs.
02:11 PM on 05/23/2012
Well this was vomit-inducing, thanks HuffPo.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
14Kestrel
12:56 PM on 05/23/2012
"get over it ...blah,blah blah" This is what the co-founder of a national newspaper thinks about the suspension of civil rights. The right wing in Canada has truly lost it's collective mind. When did I go to bed and wake up in North Korea. What's next Pete? Re-education camps when I don't cheer or cry at the correct moment.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SayBlade
This micro bio intentionally left blank.
10:12 AM on 05/23/2012
I watched video footage of protesters steering looters away from broken store windows and in some cases tackling the looters and forcing them to put back items they had stolen. The whole thing stunk of anti-Toronto vitriol from our Prime Minister. If the G20 were located further enough north and east, it would have been in Harper's old neighbourhood of Leaside.

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_6GWWZHCiF84/TB_NuS0kPaI/AAAAAAAAABw/tHj7rQaGLXI/s1600/G8-G20-Huntsville-Toronto2010.jpg
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stanschurman
09:49 AM on 05/23/2012
So, if our Peter was to be beaten to the ground, cuffed and thrown in a cage for 24+ hours for just walking by a demonstration, he'd be good with that. Is that what we are to infer by his missive? Because, if that happened to him it would simply be because mistakes were made and it's all part of the learning curve. Is that correct Peter?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LauraNo
01:08 PM on 05/23/2012
No. He and his are only good with the 'others' being treated like that.
08:50 AM on 05/23/2012
If you want to avoid these kinds of protests perhaps these "brilliant" politicians should hold their meetings in the middle of nowhere rather than downtown in a large urban city. These meetings produce no results except to provide boondogles and photo ops for these so called leaders. The people end up paying for these folks and their big groups of hangers on and then paying again for all the inquests afterwards. Isn't the definition of insane doing the same thing over and over expecting a different result? Seems to me the same thing happens at these big meetings but they continue to hold them in large cities. Maybe they are insane?
This comment has been removed.
05:27 AM on 05/23/2012
Sounds a little naive to think it won't happen again. Just to say it won't again is like assuming governments are right as long as they say we are sorry. Why did police take off identifications use force like they did in the first place. There was no need for it when peaceful demonstrations are a right.

All this was is over reaction with an autocratic form of government. Lets not accept this and maybe start taking our rights back like the are doing iin Montreal. Great to see a younger generation to take back their rights from an oppressive government here in Canada.
Seamus OMalley
My micro-bio is no longer empty.
08:26 AM on 05/23/2012
" There was no need for it when peaceful demonstrations are a right."

===

Emphasis on PEACEFUL.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LauraNo
01:11 PM on 05/23/2012
Don't conservatives claim to understand human behavior? Of course he understands it will happen again, but lying about it might get a pass from scrutiny, thereby ensuring it will happen again. He is a conservative which usually means he is an authoritarian, a aristocrat, and a plutocrat all rolled into one.
10:46 PM on 05/22/2012
So.....

Let me just make sure I've got this right...

A large group of people were seized at random for doing nothing illegal, (sometimes spelled "K I D N A P P I N G" ) and held in conditions that are only marginally acceptable for farm animals; a "Free Speech Zone" (I remember when the Free Speech Zone was called the Dominion of Canada, remember those days, Pete?) is sacked by an armed mob; a completely compliant citizen gets his face kicked in in front of 16 police officers, who when questioned didn't see nuthin', didn't do nuthin', don't know nuthin' and is then slandered by the Chief of Police; both the Premier and the Police lie repeatedly and emphatically about what the law allows them to do, and two years later they're investigated by their buddies, but we should just move on and trust our ruling class to get it right next time?

Are we taking citizenship lessons from Turkmenistan, now?
09:19 PM on 05/22/2012
Police Chiefs and police forces are like the Generals and the armed forces. Neither can be left alone to protect the public interests.
08:39 PM on 05/22/2012
We'll get over it once the officers are charged and punished. That's fairly simple to understand, isn't it? Admitting wrong isn't the same as paying the price for wrong behaviour.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:13 PM on 05/22/2012
Correct me if I'm wrong are you advocating state sponsored violence against lawful protests?
06:56 PM on 05/22/2012
"Mistakes were made, force was over-used and misdirected, blah, blah, blah."

Pete would have us believe the free world would be well served if only we could only go back to depending upon his ilk and "accurate reporting, prophetorial opinion and consensus we can all live by".
You had your chance and blew it ;the free world rejected you with the internet, Pete.

Get over it.
10:48 PM on 05/22/2012
I think Pete spent so much time getting thrown in jail in third world dictatorships when he worked for the Telegraph, that he's forgotten that it's supposed to be different here.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
okgranny
Egalitarian by birth
06:50 PM on 05/22/2012
You are so unbelievably irrelevant.
06:18 PM on 05/22/2012
"Everyone in authority has acknowledged error, and (one hopes) lessons have been learned; the same mistakes will not be repeated next time."

Just googled "police brutality"... got over 23 million hits... Helluva lot of lessons must have been learned... We're bound to be safe next time around :)
01:55 PM on 05/23/2012
Apparently Chief Blair has admitted to no personal responsibility. The buck stops somewhere else down below I guess.