Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Worthington

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Worthington
 

Iran Doesn't Want Our Diplomacy Anyway

Posted: 09/13/2012 7:50 am

The only puzzling thing about Canada cutting diplomatic relations with Iran is why now?

Can it be that Canada (i.e. the Harper government) thinks patience is running out for that bellicose regime, and that Israel is close to taking it upon itself to attack Iran's nuclear facilities?

Canada pulling its 10 diplomatic staff from its embassy in Tehran is cautionary. Countries rarely do that unless they think something drastic may be about to happen.

Certainly Israel will not remain indefinitely passive while its Western allies dither and urge restraint. The U.S. is unlikely to do anything with its election is in full swing, but there's no guarantee Israel won't act -- if it feels its survival necessitates direct action.

Foreign Minister John Baird accurately calls Iran "the most significant threat to global peace and security," but that assessment was as accurate a decade ago as it is now.

Iran and North Korea are the world's two leading rogue regimes. But Iran is more dangerous.

North Korea has an impressive record of playing the U.S. like a fiddle -- making nuclear threats, testing missiles that could reach the west coast, goading South Korea into nervous agitation, all of which tend to persuade the U.S. to provide food aid, which is diverted to the military.

Still, there's something almost comical about North Korea's xenophobic posturing. It has little in the way of manufacturing resources, cannot feed itself, is so mindlessly adoring of itself that it's like a comic book.

The only war its huge army has fought since 1953 is against its own people, rooting out those who fail to genuflect sufficiently before the statue of Kim Il-sung.

Kim's grandson (Kim Jong-un) is now in charge, and is showing signs of sanity and normality that make optimists wonder if he's trying to re-join the modern world.

So forget North Korea as a realistic threat, and focus on Iran -- which Prime Minister Harper seems to be doing. The more the world aligns against the mad mullahs of Iran, the greater the chances that changes may come within that country, as they have throughout the Middle East in the past couple of years.

Of course, Iranian diplomats and spokesmen rant at Canada. If evidence is needed that we are doing the right thing, the reaction of Iranians in charge tends to verify it.

If further evidence is need, look no further than the NDP's Paul Dewar whom the Toronto Star quotes as calling Canada's act irresponsible and bizarre.

The Star itself, editorially, thinks we erred by not keeping a diplomatic channel open with Tehran. Why, one wonders? When has Iran ever responded sensibly to a Canadian gesture? Three Canadians are on death row in Iran, and Canada's efforts on their behalf have been fruitless.

Iran brutally murdered Iranian born Canadian photographer Zahra Kazemi in 2003, and scoffed at Canada's protests at the time. What good has diplomacy achieved?

Canada could have suspended relations then, but it was a Liberal government in charge that evidently wanted to "keep diplomatic channels open," thereby pleasing the folk who write (and read?) Star editorials, but achieving zilch.

Anyway, Canada has made its choice. We stand against what Iran is doing -- not because we are Israel's ally, but because Iran is a rogue regime that must be opposed for the sake of world security and decency -- without the necessity of another war.

 
FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
albertarick
These are questions for wise men with skinny arms
11:15 PM on 09/13/2012
I don't want your commentary either Mr. Worthington, but day after day, there it is.
Thelonius
Lived in Middle East for
12:02 PM on 09/13/2012
This move by Harper and Baird is pure pandering and kowtowing to Israel and its Canadian lobby. It is also hypocritical. The government's silence on Israel's documented belligerent/illegal/brutal occupation of Palestinian and other Arab lands and its ongoing/accelerating dispossession of the native inhabitants, theft of their water resources, destruction of their homes and construction of illegal Jewish settlement/colonies is deafening.

According to Janes and other sources, Israel possesses over 200 nuclear warheads and missiles capable of delivering them throughout the region and far beyond. (There is no credible evidence that Iran is developing nuclear weapons). Israel also refuses to sign the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and will not permit international inspections of its nuclear facilities. Contrary to pro-Israel spin, Iran has never threatened to launch a war against Israel. Israel, however, has repeatedly threatened to attack Iran.

Israel has also rebuffed repeated calls by Iran and the Arab League to make the entire region nuclear weapons free. Why? Because Israel wants to remain the region’s only nuclear armed state so it can continue to occupy, oppress and dispossess the native inhabitants.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:45 AM on 09/13/2012
Author spends a great deal of time explaining why North Korea is less of a threat than it is often made out to be. Spends zero time explaining why Iran should be considered a threat at all. Yes, the regime there is brutal and is guilty of innumerable human rights abuses. So are lots of other regimes, including many nations that we consider allies or trading partners. I see no reason to believe that Iran is any threat to Canada or its allies, though perhaps that could change if we continue to provoke them with our drums of war.
photo
Turdinthepunchbowl
I float like a butterfly but stink like the GOP
10:58 AM on 09/13/2012
Hey Worthington. You might want to read the book by Stephen Kinzer, "All the Shah's Men." It reveals that Iran did have a democratically elected leader in 1953 (which many right wingers know yet refuse to acknowledge for it challenges their non-evidenced based ideology), but he was overthrown in a coup supported mainly by the British and the Americans because he dared to place the rights and needs of the Iranian people ahead of the British and American oil interests. The Shah (a terrorist to his own people) was installed and the Savak secret police over the decades slaughtered tens of thousands of innocent Iranians while the "West," bestowed great honour on this "Western" imposed butcher. This led directly to the Iranian Revolution and our current geopolitical mess. I know you're a thrifty fellow, so you can read it for free as a PDF file.

http://m.friendfeed-media.com/dd49e5cf015b24b21b3a5ef9a9977b7e684af106
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Glass Cannon
Let every eye negotiate for itself.
09:56 AM on 09/13/2012
Someone, somewhere, is getting ready to take action against Iran in a big way, and Canada wants to be well clear diplomatically, or capable of minimizing damages, while participating.

My prediction.