Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Rachel Décoste

GET UPDATES FROM Rachel Décoste
 

Harper Didn't Deserve His Spot at the Francophone Summit

Posted: 10/15/2012 12:00 am

This week, the World Francophonie Summit was held in Kinshasa, the capital of the Democratic Republic of the Congo. The bi-annual summit provides a forum for States and governments of countries who utilise the French language to engage in matters related to the linguistic ties that bind. Stephen Harper attended the conference despite his dismal record in defending the langue de Molière over his tenure Prime Minister.

In 1969, the Official Languages Act was passed by the Parliament of Canada. The law recognized English and French as official languages of the Canadian federal state. Sadly, PM Harper has demonstrated neither appreciation nor respect for French-speaking Canadians, although we form almost a quarter of the Canadian population.

SLIDESHOW: PHOTOS OF HARPER AT THE SUMMIT

Last month, Minister of Foreign Affairs John Baird and his British counterpart William Hague announced an agreement allowing diplomats of the two countries to merge certain premises of diplomatic missions abroad under the cloak of cost-savings.

"As [British PM David Cameron] said when addressing the Canadian parliament last year: 'We are two nations, but under one Queen and united by one set of values,'" Hague said in a released statement.

The idea of sharing premises and the embassies of the United Kingdom was conveyed without addressing the discomfort that may be felt by francophone taxpayers who may see their right to services in their language of choice extinguished by the flagrant indifference of Conservatives.

One can safely assert that the British do not have the mandate, the obligation nor the willingness to recognize the rights enshrined in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which feted its 30th anniversary under the Harper government's deafening silence.

As government disinterested in minority rights, this was hardly the first slight committed by PM Harper who has appointed two unilingual anglophones to the Supreme Court of Canada from its arrival in office. In 2006, PM Harper's first judicial appointment, Marshall Rothstein solicited much discontent from defenders of language rights. According to a transcript of his 2006 hearing, Judge Rothstein admitted that his lack of French knowledge was a handicap: "I recognize that my not being bilingual [...] will require a greater effort on my part to hear and decide cases argued in French...." The jury is still out on which parties will bare the brunt of his shortcoming: the plaintiffs or the Supreme Court.

PM Harper repeated the offensive gesture a second time in 2011 with the appointment of unilingual judge Michael Moldaver. Harper's choices confirm his disdain for linguistic equality at the Supreme Court.

PM Harper again spit on the policy introduced by former Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau when he appointed another unilingual anglophone -- this time to the position of Auditor General of Canada. In 2011, the appointment of Michael Ferguson is confirmed despite the fact that the applicant did not fulfill all essential job requirements, i.e. the ability to perform in either official language.

In the House of Commons, the scarcity of French spoken in the Conservative ranks speaks for itself. After nearly seven years in power, it laments the number of Conservative MPs who took it upon themselves to learn French, thumbing their collective noses at free language lessons. Their message, however, does not require translation: they don't give a rat's behind about the French language.

The incessant visits of British monarchs have morphed into annual multimillion-dollar expenditures. Not only the Queen but her children and grandchildren are invited to visit their subjects in Canada. The costly royal tours are defrayed in part by French-Canadian taxpayers whose ancestors suffered so greatly under the UK's colonial tyranny.

Allegiance to linguistic duality is constantly under assault in Canada, despite studies which prove it to be a benefit to children's literacy, a suppressant of dementia, and an advancement agent of cognitive kills summarized in recent New York Times article entitled "Why Bilinguals Are Smarter."

Regardless, Stephen Harper managed to capture his coveted majority government without the support of the domestic or foreign francophonies. We can therefore expect continued linguistic cleansing and additional insults to complement the existing injuries from the francophobe Prime Minister of (English) Canada.

For bottom:

PHOTOS OF HARPER AT THE SUMMIT


Loading Slideshow...
  • Canada Prime Minister Stephen Harper is greeted by Democratic Republic of Congo President Joseph Kabila and his wife Olive as Secretary General of La Francophonie Abdu Diouf looks on at the Francophonie Summit in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo, Saturday,Oct. 13, 2012. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press, Paul Chiasson)

  • Prime Minister Stephen Harper addresse the opening session at the Francophonie Summit in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo, Saturday,Oct. 13, 2012. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press, Paul Chiasson)

  • Canada Prime Minister Stephen Harper delivers a speech at the opening of the French-speaking nations 'Francophonie' summit in Kinshasa on October 13, 2012. AFP PHOTO/ ISSOUF SANOGO

  • Canada Prime Minister Stephen Harper and French President Francois Hollande shake hands prior to a bilateral meeting at the Francophonie Summit in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo, Saturday,Oct. 13, 2012. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press, Paul Chiasson)

  • Canada's Prime Minister Stephen Harper greets students as he visits a vocational school Thursday, Oct. 11, 2012 in Dakar, Senegal. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press, Paul Chiasson)

  • Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper, left, meets with Senegalese President Macky Sall, at the Presidential Palace in Dakar, Senegal, Thursday, Oct. 11, 2012. (AP Photo/Rebecca Blackwell)

  • Canada Prime Minister Stephen Harper is accompanied by the Senegal Health Minister Awa Marie Coll Seck as he heads for his plane Friday, Oct. 12, 2012 in Dakar. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press, Paul Chiasson)

  • Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper, left, and Senegalese President Macky Sall speak during a press conference in Dakar, Senegal, Friday, Oct. 12, 2012. (AP Photo/Rebecca Blackwell)

 

Follow Rachel Décoste on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RachelDecoste

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
This week, the World Francophonie Summit was held in Kinshasa, the capital of the Democratic Republic of the Congo. The bi-annual summit provides a forum for States and governments of countries who ut...
This week, the World Francophonie Summit was held in Kinshasa, the capital of the Democratic Republic of the Congo. The bi-annual summit provides a forum for States and governments of countries who ut...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 45
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:09 AM on 10/18/2012
It's of no surprise to most Canadians that Mr.Harper and his evangelical born again government could care less about what Canada is and what it's traditional values are.It's been Harper's goal to change everything Canadian and to realign us with the British empire,which Mr. Harper thinks is still relevant.Building up our military and changing it's focus from peace keepers to life takers and heart breakers.Cutting services to the poorest Canadians while spending 64 million blowing his own horn and shilling for big oil.Harper is destroying our reputation world wide.He has made us pariahs on the world stage.He talks about restraint while spending more on the military than the governments of the past 60 years.The F35 alone is reason enough to doubt that anyone in Ottawa is really working for all but the wealthiest Canadians.That Harper is slighting the french,as well as the rest of the country is no surprise.He works for corporate Canada and big oil.He is unaware that the rest of us even exist.Until we take to the streets in protest.Then he rolls out his pet police force and arrests without cause or charge.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
reneehoude
02:03 AM on 10/17/2012
Harper is marvellous. His French is excellent compared to other anglo Prime Ministers. We are so sick hearing about French everyday here in Québec, like it is a religion I am a francophone, and I find it over exposed and overwhelming. It is having a perverse effect.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:26 AM on 10/16/2012
missed one ted menzies
After the Conservative victory in the 2006 federal election, he was appointed as parliamentary secretary to Josée Verner, who was serving as the Minister for International Cooperation, Minister responsible for Official Languages, and Minister responsible for La Francophonie.

On February 10, 2006, Menzies received some news coverage when it was revealed that despite being the parliamentary secretary responsible for La Francophonie, he did not speak French. His appointment was criticized by New Democrat Yvon Godin (an Acadian).

In his defence, Menzies replied that "we have two official languages in this country. Not just French. Not just English. We have two official languages." He argued that the best means of representing both languages was with a Francophone minister with an Anglophone parliamentary secretary.[1]
09:40 PM on 10/15/2012
Rachel
Indeed, fascinating how the comments are totally in another universe on the quebec Huff site.

Kinds of illustrate how so doomed this country is as a joint entity. There is so much hatred on the English site, it's phenomenal!
09:16 PM on 10/15/2012
Discussions like this are great to illustrate why this country needs to disband and pronto too!
05:49 PM on 10/15/2012
Don't get why there has always been an aversion by certain people in Canada against bilingualism. It's not like people have to be bilingual - they just have to let French-speakers have their language - at the very least. In India there are many official languages. In Europe people speak multiple languages, proudly. In the NWT there are 11 official languages and society functions without disaster. In fact, before colonization, most Aboriginal people were multilingual because of trade. And I've met some of those old-timers, most who are gone now, but they spoke English, their traditional language, different dialects of their language and then 2 or 3 other languages of other Nations in the area. There was a time when human beings aspired to know one another, understand other languages and be able to communicate to many. Harper and his ilk have decided that their idea of anglo-supremacy has to be reasserted in the world. They are just plain and simple, afraid of knowledge.
04:02 PM on 10/15/2012
What a wonderful article I mean i have read articles before that were good but this article is just wonderful in the world of information and prose this stands alone as a wonderful use of grammar to bad it wasn't Bilingual so that everyone could truley enjoy this did i say this before wonderful work.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Rachel Decoste
Motivational speaker + | Conférencière ++
09:20 PM on 10/15/2012
Gyice50, Thank you. The article is available in French (http://quebec.huffingtonpost.ca/rachel-decoste/francophonie-federal_b_1913225.html). What is fascinating is the comments on the French version -- completely different viewpoints from the English.
02:40 PM on 10/15/2012
What is Harper supposed to be defending the French language (or the langue de Moliere, so much more pretentious) from anyways? English? Chinese street signs in Vancouver? Cantonese instructions on the ATM?

Expecting the Premiere of Quebec to defend the language is one thing, expecting the Prime Minister of a Bilingual country to "defend" one official language from the other is nonsense.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Rachel Decoste
Motivational speaker + | Conférencière ++
09:21 PM on 10/15/2012
Then why did he attend the World Francophonie Summit?
10:21 AM on 10/16/2012
Four missions of the Francophonie:

Promoting French language and cultural and linguistic diversity.
Promoting peace, democracy and human rights.
Supporting education, training, higher education and scientific research.
Expand cooperation for sustainable development

Nothing there about "defending" the French language.
12:20 PM on 10/15/2012
The article basically comes down to the entitlements if your biligual you should be given any job or position regardless of Merit. Who in this country speaks for the Majority we seem to always be bending over to ensure accomodation for everyone but English Speaking Canadians and I for one believe that all position should be awarded on Merit first and Politics at least a very distant second. Let's face it in 5 years you will be able to pick up a Universal translator and your local Best Buy, but it won't be quite as easy to aquire a high quality Doctor, Judge, Lawyer or tradesman who feel they have to leave the province just because they aren't one whom French is their first language.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Rachel Decoste
Motivational speaker + | Conférencière ++
09:23 PM on 10/15/2012
Ever used a computerized translator? I feel good translates to "je sens bon".Nuf said.
10:22 AM on 10/15/2012
This is just the same old entitlement argument it has nothing to do with Bilingualism and if it did wouldn't it in todays world, the argument really be about getting your kids trained in Mandarin? Saying that Stephen placed someone in the Supreme court based on Merit and not being able to speak French first is that really the argument she wants to go with. Should she really be so concerned about entitlements maybe she should present her arguments to the Northern First Nations who's land you stole then flooded for your Hydro generating stations. I also heard now, there is probably no basis for this, but promoting based on French first and skills a distant second may lead to corruption any of that going around in Le Bell Province?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kenneth T Tellis
10:09 AM on 10/15/2012
Rachel Dacoste!

You are no acountant. The figures of the last census rated the pseudo French-SPEAKING population at 20% in Canada. So don't blow up the figures to get an advantage.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Rachel Decoste
Motivational speaker + | Conférencière ++
11:13 AM on 10/15/2012
What blown up figures? There are Seven million French-speaking Canadians. The accounting comes from Stats Can. http://www41.statcan.gc.ca/2008/50000/ceb50000_000-eng.htm
02:16 PM on 10/15/2012
22% and declining according to that link.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kenneth T Tellis
05:52 PM on 10/30/2012
There are people in Canada who are not French at all, but Joual-speaking (French patois) who are really METIS. And if you are going to call anyone who speaks a few words in a French patois language, then you will also have to count anyone who speaks a few words of English as English-speaking. But Kebec refuses that argument, and agrees with the theory that it only applies to pseydo Francophones.
photo
Liz Wilson 2
“a small group can change the world
09:51 AM on 10/15/2012
Harper is the king of smoke and mirrors.
georgee2
My Canada Includes Everyone
08:51 AM on 10/15/2012
I agree completely with this piece. But Harper also has little or no respect for English citizens either.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mike vdB
Get involved, always question, don't just exist.
08:18 AM on 10/15/2012
I will never fully understand this argument. I grew up in BC where there are many cultures and languages. Many cultures have proven that they don't need government intervention to use their language. They bind together as a group and create what they need. If there is a service or a need, someone finds a way to fill it. There are many examples of this throughout the lower mainland in businesses and private institutions. Yes, one could argue it is easier in larger urban centres to gain access to services. But with all the technology, services and information are only a click away.
10:23 AM on 10/15/2012
Mike exactly
No need for any English services in Montreal, a few clicks away from Terabytes of stuffs from the US
Would greatly help to reduce the tax bill in Qc
Thanks
11:03 AM on 10/15/2012
Actually it would reduce the tax bill for the ROC more than for Quebec. Also, I am sure that the English population in Montreal is at the very least equal to the very small French speaking requirement in the ROC that makes communities pay for services in both official languages.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mike vdB
Get involved, always question, don't just exist.
12:25 PM on 10/15/2012
Yes, it does go both ways.  No province is obligated to offer services in both official languages but BC does make an effort to send some communications in many of the major languages or offer translation services.  They did this because there was a demand.  Alberta, for instance, does not.  But one thing you will notice is that BC only mandates children are sent to schools with approved curriculums and does not use a complex formula to see if one ethnic group can send their children to the school of their choice.  They also do not have language police going around and dictating what language has to be put on business signs.  You also seem to forget that there are quite a few francophone communities outside of Quebec that do quite fine in protecting their language without govt language laws.
This comment has been removed.
04:21 AM on 10/15/2012
This is the kind of tribal whining whining that gives the Rest of Canada heartburn.
First Decoste complains that we should not save money by sharing some foreign offices, then she turns into a fiscal hawk, saying that the Queen is an un-necessary expense, that's a mid-stream conversion if there ever was one.
Then she goes on about the unfairness of not restricting the Supreme Court to Francophones only, ...."unfairness"....I don't think the proponents of Franco-Only Supreme Court fathom the irony of their position.
And then she says"We can therefore expect continued linguistic cleansing" and expects us to keep a straight face. Ms.Decoste, read the Montreal papers, the only "linguistic cleansing" going on is being instigated by Pauline Marois, who promises to further punish any English person left in Quebec.
And no mention of the 7 Billion a year Quebec receives from ROC....no of course not.
Ms.Decoste, this is a fundamentally dishonest article.
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JPLeger
07:23 AM on 10/15/2012
And you accuse Ms Decoste to be dishonest. First explain me what you are talking about when you say Pauline Marois is doing a linguistic cleansing? Why do you even mention perequetion, what does it have to do with the debate? I suggest you to read any other newspapper than Montreal Gazette, try a francophone one for instance.
08:05 AM on 10/15/2012
The English newspapers reflect my perspective, because their writers have all lived with anti-English racism rampant in Quebec. This is how we feel. Why don't you try reading an English paper, and understand us for a change.
So far in Canada, all accommodation has been a one way street.
Here is an exerpt from the Montreal newspaper The Suburban:

"Pragmatically, it showed that anything, linguistic cleansing included, is possible in a free and democratic society — as long as you do it etape par etape, and marshal enough militant clout on the national stage to press your agenda into law.

Further, from defaced English signs and anonymous threats to vandalized offices and broken store windows — Bill 101 showed that, in Canada, political and social aggression works."

http://www.vigile.net/A-nationalism-that-cannot-be
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Douglas Sinclair
sufferin' succotash!
11:56 AM on 10/15/2012
"... French-Canadian taxpayers whose ancestors suffered so greatly under the UK's colonial tyranny."
Help us out here JP. What does she mean here? Does she mean that Britain's colonialism in general was tyrannical (which it certainly was by today's standards as was the colonialism of every European state) or that colonialism in Quebec was uniquely harsh.

The reason I ask is I'm wondering what history books she's been reading. At the time of the fall of Quebec, Catholics didn't have full legal rights in Britain and speaking in non-English (Gaelic) was illegal in Scotland and Ireland (Britain's original colony) .

Those ancestors she refers to enjoyed both privileges, which was unique for the time.

On the other hand, maybe she's referring to Lord Durham's Report 60 years later that recommended assimilation?