Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rachel Ryan

GET UPDATES FROM Rachel Ryan
 

First They Came for the Soda, Then for the Foie Gras

Posted: 06/13/2012 12:27 pm

The American media and general public were recently sent into a tizzy over Mayor Michael Bloomberg's announcement that a 16-ounce limit would be on New York City's sugary drinks. While some, like Michelle Obama, lauded efforts to curtail America's rapidly expanding waistline, others expressed outrage at an apparent offense against our individual liberties and "right to choose."

Kristen Davis at The Libertarian Republican accused Bloomberg of being the "proponent of the Nanny State," lamenting the ban's imposition of restrictions on individual dietary choices. Kristen's sentiment was echoed by the media and general public reacting to a very abrupt, radical attempt to limit individual consumption to healthier portion sizes.

A full-page ad in the New York Times ran depicting Bloomberg as a Nanny and asking, "What's next? Limits on the width of a pizza slice, size of a hamburger or amount of cream cheese on your bagel?"

I'll tell you what's next: foie gras.

In a matter of weeks, on July 1, Californians will no longer be able to enjoy foie gras, or "fat liver."

Unlike New York City's soda ban, the impetus behind the foie gras ban extends beyond rising obesity rates, into the realm of animal rights. The "Delicacy of Despair," as so named by People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), is made from an especially fat duck or goose. The birds are force fed with a small plastic tube, or "gavage," that is placed down the throat several times a day for three weeks, causing the birds' livers to bloat up to ten times their normal size.

Like Bloomberg's ban, the foie gras ban has garnered substantial criticism. Californians from San Francisco down to San Diego are lining up at local restaurants to order their last taste of the fatty liver before rolling into July. In the face of animal rights protesters, several Wine Country chefs hosted Farewell to Foie Gras dinners throughout the spring. A handful of California chefs have even formed a coalition in opposition, calling for an alternative to the ban that supports ethical treatment of animals while also allowing for consumption of the delicacy.

The Coalition for Humane and Ethical Farming Standards (CHEFS) have warned that "the total ban on foie gras... goes too far," proposing instead regulations requiring adherence to a more humane treatment of ducks and geese. CHEFS insists that "if we ban foie gras, animals will be the victims of a newly-created black market," underscoring issues surrounding legislative oversight and reinforcement.

As Trevor Butterworth points out in Slate, enforcement of Bloomberg's soda ban will also be cumbersome, asking, "You're going to police this how? Shut down restaurants that don't comply?"

However, despite the onslaught of criticism and obvious complications, legislators on both coasts are moving each of the respective bans forward, riling bellies from the Red Wood Forest to the Hudson River.

 

Follow Rachel Ryan on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rachelryan1004

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
The American media and general public were recently sent into a tizzy over Mayor Michael Bloomberg's announcement that a 16-ounce limit would be on New York City's sugary drinks. While some, like ...
The American media and general public were recently sent into a tizzy over Mayor Michael Bloomberg's announcement that a 16-ounce limit would be on New York City's sugary drinks. While some, like ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AuntiFascist
Democracy is dead in Canada
07:59 AM on 06/14/2012
Veal, foie gras, shark fin and many others need to disappear from the human diet. Cruelty to animals for tasty and expensive plate of food is just plain wrong. Can a balanced human being think of the suffering of the animal while eating the product of that suffering and still enjoy it?

Ban it!!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AdamWeissman
07:17 PM on 06/13/2012
My great-grandmother died in a Nazi concentration camp. Somehow I fail to see the comparison between the Holocaust and banning super-sized sodas and an expensive delicacy made by torturing animals.

But hey, I guess it's not shocking that someone who makes light of the Holocaust would be unmoved by animal suffering.

Out of curiosity, Rachel, when you see photos like this:

http://popartmachine.com/artwork/LOC+1159988/0/These-inmates-of-the-Amphing-%5Bi.e.,-Ampfing%5D-concentration-camp-in...-painting-artwork-print.jpg

is your reaction "Let them eat foie gras and drink Big Gulps?" That'll fatten 'em up, right?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
see-ellen2001
07:14 PM on 06/13/2012
(disclosure time: i am an ovo-lacto vegetarian) I am not sure how they decide one form of 'food production and harvesting' is wrong, yet not another. If foie gras, what about veal, battery hens for eggs, and pig breeding? Is it bcs foie gras is not a 'staple' of US dinner plates yet eggs, veal and pork are? They don't want to ruffle the feathers of those big industries (pun intended)?
05:11 PM on 06/13/2012
How can anyone think thier taste bud is more special or important then the life and well being of a living, breathing animal. not to mention it's bad for you.
photo
Opus Fideo
Atheist. Social Democrat. Canadian.
03:35 PM on 06/13/2012
Bans foie gras...

...but cigarettes still legal...

*facepalm*
01:07 PM on 06/14/2012
Idiots who smoke make that decision for themselves and suffer the consequences.

Geese have no choice over being tortured to please the palate of greedy people who don't give a damn about any living thing other than themself.
jojolapopola
i like cheese and chicken and shrimp and beer and
01:57 PM on 06/13/2012
doesn't california have better things to worry about? like closing a bunch of their jails so they can balance their backwards budget?

in fact, wouldn't it be better to make healthy food more accessible than banning huge sodas? that would do more to fix the obesity problem

all this is the political equivalent of running a screen play