Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rachel Ryan

GET UPDATES FROM Rachel Ryan
 

Generation Y-ny Isn't Busy, They're Lazy

Posted: 07/05/2012 7:35 am

So, according to Facebook, everyone and their mother has seen this New York Times editorial, The Busy Trap, by Tim Kreider. Never has an article so polluted my newsfeed, prefaced with user statements like, "So true," "Gotta get here," or a simple thumbs-up 'like'.

Of course everyone is lauding the article as some intellectual, sociological masterpiece of paradigm-shifting proportions. Of course they are. The Busy Trap is a justification for a generational sense of entitlement. A rationale underlying the newfound idea that we, Generation Y, are somehow not only entitled to a fulfilling career at the ripe old age of 22, we are also entitled to plenty of rest and relaxation.

"The goal of the future is full unemployment, so we can play," reiterates Krieder, quoting Arthur C. Clarke, a British author and inventor.

I hate to be the one to break it to you, Gen Y, but no one is -- nor ever has been -- entitled to a playful life of rest and relaxation. That's something you strive for. That's something you earn. Work -- work to survive, no less -- is an eternal human condition.

Work is a constant necessity throughout generations and cultures. Like taxes, few can escape it. The "few" being our dear author, Kreider, who evidently has the means to hop off to the south of France when the going gets tough.

The Busy Trap and its popularity stand as a testament to a generational epidemic: a devastatingly widespread sense of entitlement that is, in part, contributing to those devastating post-grad employment levels.

My generation, Gen Y, has been so inundated with notions of a "fulfilling career" that we have all but discarded reality. See, the thing about work is, it's not always fun and fulfilling. It's work. And, in this economy, you have to work to get a job and keep a job.

Yes, the economy is rough. One of the roughest since the Great Depression. And yes, one in three Americans has a college degree (and 31 per cent of Canadians aged 25 to 44 have a university degree), making your degree markedly less valuable. But, all this talk of "work-life balance" and a "fulfilling career" on failed job interview number 20 isn't doing you any favours.

Not to quote my dad, but, you know what's hard? Getting drafted. That's hard. Thankfully, our society has advanced beyond merciless drafting of citizens, but still, an iota of perspective would be nice. An inbox "full of emails asking [you] to do things" is hardly a hardship. It is an inescapable reality that comes with living and working in the 21st century. With the past century's myriad advancements, from computers to video conferencing, we have moved from the fields and factories to the glass-plated downtown office buildings and laptops. That means a whole new cast of stressors to which we have to accommodate. That's modernization, people.

Until the technological revolution of the modern era, when the sweat poured, the fields were sowed, and the factory doors closed, the workday was over. You simply could not work from home. "Work-life balance" was not a cherished circumstance, but rather, a mere product of the system.

Now, as a third-tier service economy, the workday is never really over.

And therein lies the single prevailing truth of The Busy Trap: our society so values maximum productivity that we nearly prohibit "resolute idleness." And, as much as I would like to operate at maximum efficiency, I'm neither a machine nor a sadist. We are all human. We need some downtime, to which -- I reiterate -- we are to aspire, not de facto expect. But, well-deserved vacations have become no more than "time away from the desk," during which most people are still readily accessible via a handful of social media channels. Of course that breeds anxiety.

According to the National Institute of Mental Health, one in ten Americans suffer from mood disorders, 40 million of whom are plagued with "anxiety."

We worry. We worry that if we put down our phones for an hour, even when on the beach, we will miss a catastrophically, earth-shattering event that just happened not to reach the shores of St. John. We worry that the moment we are utterly inaccessible, a loved one will be hit by a car, or... we'll miss the UPS man.

What to do, what to do? J. Bryan Lowder of Slate suggests that we "need changes in both policy and cultural attitudes in order to make our working lives more humane." But, even if some overarching authority mandated that all offices closed at noon for a Spanish-like siesta, people could and would still work. They could go home and work there. They could keep abreast of the news on their phones. They could, oh, I don't know, read some infuriating article and be compelled to write something on their day off and never really "rest" (which is defined how, exactly?). What conceivable democratic authority has the capacity to institutionalize "relaxation policy?"

Krieder blames the "present politico-economic system" for the hysteria, but that's just too clichéd for me to stomach. If anyone or anything is to blame, it's modernity. The fact that we're busy is a product of modern advancements, imposing conditions to which we have to adjust. So, given that no one is advocating for a two-decade regression, is relaxation simply a case of human will power? Just put down the phone? Just ignore the 'new email' bing? De-busy? We can't. We won't. The technology is there. In a matter of a decade we have been trained to expect, to need, to crave a constant stream of stimulating data points.

But whining about the barrage of emails and offering an escape to the south of France is hardly a solution. It is utterly laughable and disgustingly entitled.

 

Follow Rachel Ryan on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rachelryan1004

FOLLOW CANADA BUSINESS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 52
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
05:48 PM on 07/08/2012
Hard work is necessary to live. And by live, I don't mean just make money to support ones self or family: I mean people need, very badly, purpose to their every day lives, or they simply cease to strive toward anything. I work in an sector which has a high injury rate, and I see the evidence of this regularly. When my co-workers are off for several weeks or months, often they return heavier than before. The most common pattern of response to suddenly losing one's daily work commitments, whether it's rearing children or working a paid job - in many cases both - is situational depression resulting from literally noy knowing what to do. They confess to over-eating to fill the gap in their lives. I think a generation of people who believe that jobs should be fitted to them and that an early and lucrative retirement should be a given, do so at their personal peril. When I retire, likely at 65 years, I still plan to return to work on a part-time basis. Maybe only a day or two a week, but there will be something. I will have plenty of time to pursue my interests, travel and spend time with friends, but I will to have work to do. There is always honour in even the humblest job, because someone will always need me to get up, pull myself together and give someone else the experience I have. People need to be needed.
03:50 PM on 07/08/2012
I tried to read this but I got sleepy. Can someone give me a quick rundown on what this is about?
01:11 PM on 07/07/2012
Evolution is wonderful thing.
11:25 PM on 07/06/2012
Honestly I think a lot of this BS about what it is we are 'entitled' to is a direct result of the move to non-competitiveness in the school environment and a general shift towards fuzzy-headed I'm ok - you're ok claptrap. An entire generation has been brought up to expect that just showing up is enough; kids are rarely if ever held back in grades and the participation medal that used to be the mark of shame has now replaced the gold medal that actually signalled a reward for being the best at something. Well it looks like that way of thinking is really paying off now doesn't it?
When I was growing up (I just turned 44), my parents constantly drilled it into me that nobody is entitled to anything, that you have to work hard and make sacrifices if you want to achieve anything. Boy did I learn that one in a real world environment. After graduating with an English degree my first job was maintaining urinals and changing light bulbs in a shopping mall. In the 7 years (including the year spent getting a post-grad certificate from college) it took me to get a job remotely fulfilling from either an intellectual or financial standpoint I must have done every crap job in the book including digging ditches. Eventually I got a job as a factory line assembler and worked after hours for free rewriting the training manual to demonstrate that I had a useful skill.
10:35 PM on 07/07/2012
Owriter,

Couldn't agree with you more. However, as a baby-boomer myself, the sin leaves with my generation of drug wasted hippie academia who came up with all those touchy feelly theories that has done so much damage to the Gen Ysers.

Unfortunately they are also put on a pedestal as 'experts' by an unthinking media, politicians and bureaucrats that I am afraid the worst is yet to come.
04:16 PM on 07/06/2012
Albert Einstein once said "Genius is the product of wasted time".
09:24 PM on 07/06/2012
have you never heard the term genius is next to insanity
02:08 PM on 07/06/2012
I have been saying almost the same thing for years. The Y generation has little or no clue about the real world. Once they start looking for work and find out that they are NOT entitled to a job and all the benefits until they earn it. SLOWLY some are waking up.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rolor
'round and 'round we go
11:41 AM on 07/06/2012
Unrealistic expectations about life is what defines youth... but, harshly expressed myopic opinions is what defines ignorance. The problem with modern society is that it has failed to acknowledge the subtle shifting of expectations versus reward over time. What once was considered a fullly compensated work week of 40 hours which was recognized as a sufficient demonstration of commitment to achieve the "rewards" of upward mobility is now considered grounds for dismissal due to a perception that such is an under-effort. What were once mandated breaks included in one's compensation package are now "lunch and learn" opportunities for working. What once was an expectation that if one worked an honest 40-hour work week, they could expect a stable income for life with a chance to enjoy their later years with a comfortable savings to retire on - is now the perpetual fear of a management screw up which will render those additional hundreds - if not thousands of unpaid overtime hours completely meaningless and unappreciated as the pink slip is handed to them with feigned concern that your sacrifice on behalf of their incompetence isn't personal.

And what's worse, is that each subsequent generation just meekly accepts the gradual deterioration of their quality of life while having to suffer vilification by the brownshirted task-masters pretending to speak for their peers.
10:42 PM on 07/07/2012
Rolor,

Your Avatar tells what is blinding you. The drive in the 60s - 80s less work more play is what brought us the the ruins of today's employment vacuum. I think, you are the one that did not detect the shift.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rolor
'round and 'round we go
11:52 PM on 07/07/2012
Your response betrays your biases and your predilection for inventing simplistic fantasies for ameliorating the frustrations you experience from living in a world which overwhelms you with its complexities. ;-)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pax333
10:44 AM on 07/08/2012
rolor, as a boomer myself, I agree with you. Whinging about "the youth today" is almost as old as time itself and those who suggest every young person is the same as portrayed in media is simply ridiculous.

It's interesting that when I read these article or listen to people going on about "what's the matter with kids today" very few look at how different the working world is for each ensuing generation. As you rightly point out people did have expectations of their 40 hour work week and knew that as a rule loyalty to their company or boss usually translated into returned loyalty in most jobs which is very lacking in many employers today. A large number of boomers also found themselves unemployed and their pensions gone because they'd not adjusted their thinking to the new way of doing things.

I also think that Generation Y was sold a bill of goods about a degree paving the way for them. Not only is that not the case but many schools ignored 'the trades' completely making for far fewer skilled people so those skills become more of an expensive premium all the time. Certainly the trades work hard physically but, as an example, I know a plumber who makes twice what his sister does as a physician and he has far more R & R than she could hope for.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rolor
'round and 'round we go
12:40 PM on 07/08/2012
I agree. It amazes me how those who mock the younger generations are only echoing the same sort of mocking the elders of today experienced in their youth. I find myself extremely embarrassed by people who blindly vilify youth as being lazy while mocking their (what was not that long ago viewed as an advanced degree - even though by today's standards, a Bachelor's degree is considered a minimum requisite for achieving some form of longe term career stability) post-secondary education as only being good for getting a job flipping burgers.

What's even more egregious to me is how completely blind some people are to an incredibly obvious difference between today's working environment -  which requires, at minimum, two full-time employed parents to be able to afford raising a family on what is often an almost impossible budget which requires one or both to moonlight for more money -  and only a few short decades ago when all that was required to be able to afford raising a family, a mortgage, and a car payment was one person working a single steady job they could feel reasonable comfort within the belief that it would sustain them for decades.

Kids today have every reason and every right to protest the lies that have been sold to the vanishing middle class for the last 30 years because the consequence of this progressive betrayal of what was once sincerely held up as a dream we all could share is a future of despair
09:47 AM on 07/06/2012
My issue has always been this: (As a Gen X-er, and now even moreso the Y's), we are required to have University degrees and years of experience to replace our parents in jobs that they got out of High School. I ask people my parent's age what kind of education they had, and usually it was very little. People today grow up using computers and understanding technology, so that can't be used as a reason for extra education needed.

My mother worked in a doctor's office without any college/university. My dad worked for an Aerospace company purchasing engine parts before he went to night school to get a better job. My aunt started out as a clerk in the government and moved up to director of a department with a Bachelor of Arts. Her husband is a machinist - only training he had was in the army.

Me? I've got 6 years of post-secondary education behind me to be qualified to buy and keep track of books and magazines at my library as well as do research for patrons. Most of my job is sending out emails, letters and phone calls requesting items, keeping a spreadsheet updated with what to buy/what's been bought and making sure things arrive on time. 6 years of University and College education to even qualify for this job.

That is my issue with today's generation - we're over-educated and we do feel entitled to more than our parents, because we earned it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aesops
Appearances often are deceiving
01:06 AM on 07/08/2012
You are on to something there. We are an over-educated/under-experienced group. Education spends a lot of time with big picture ideas and understanding, but does not prepare one for the routine and often dull realities of day to day work in the modern economy. Disillusionment is baked in to the process.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
06:07 AM on 07/06/2012
What a person needs to do is figure out what they need to be content.
Not happy.
Just 'content'.
"Content" is pretty good, spread out over a lifetime.
Happiness or the realization of such is almost like a drug rush.
You're always expecting it to be better than it is, but once you had a taste.... you want more.
So I'm content to be content.
There's a lot less stress striving to be content than striving for happiness.
Even though the work-load is about the same.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aesops
Appearances often are deceiving
01:36 AM on 07/08/2012
Interesting point - I have found the same. My generation has been sold a bill of goods with respect to happiness and work. Looking back I realized that in the early years we are all particulary searching for something to connect with. Something to give us meaning. And before we even had time to think, a marketing man told us that it lies in our job, in competition, winning and constant stimulation. We didn't realize that this was in his interest, not ours. Now we search for meaning in all the wrong places.

Our group has a grandiose understanding of what fulfillment means. It cannot be a humble or quiet thing for us, it must be loud and it must be public. Because there is nothing greater than Us. We are our own Gods now, and that is very frightening place to be - a fraud. So we look for something external for validation. Something else must give us this fulfillment (often our jobs, public adulation) and we are looking around, waiting nervously for it to "arrive" along with all the other frauds.

This generation will become disillusioned with the external, of shallow connectedness, and one day will withdraw, stop grasping and start understanding that a peaceful mind and letting go is not death.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
07:04 AM on 07/08/2012
Nicely said.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
HagueAbductions
Card carrying member of The Patriarchy
04:46 AM on 07/06/2012
You took the words right out of my mouth. With all the build-up around the "Busy Trap" I was totally underwhelmed upon reading it. Certainly there were some valid observations made but the analysis and contextualization of them left much to be desired. As human society progresses it is natural that expectations will rise. There are significant, and growing, numbers making vocal arguments that things like access to the internet, college education, immigration and contraception are "human rights." Perhaps I am behind the times in a sense, but I find that such ideas reflect an enormous sense of entitlement. I'm not against the idea of a society that can afford to offer such privileges to its people but it's gotten to the point where such a society is expected as part of some fundamental social contract. For many it would seem there is such a thing as a free lunch..and a free breakfast and dinner! Not only do they exist, but they are, increasingly, considered to be inalienable rights.
11:00 PM on 07/07/2012
As politicians trying to buy votes by offering more and more freebies, it is only natural to feel entitled.

Which was precisely what felt the communist system. When people discover their reward is the same regardless of their effort, less and less are willing to work for a day's fair work (forget about 80% of what those management 'experts' teaches). As such, the countries economy collapses.

The good thing is: greed is a human equalizer. Those who took jobs away from us are breeding their own Gen Ys. May be, just may be someday everyone will wait for their brother to feed him that humanity will exist no more. Those days may not be so far off, just look at Greece. The country is bringing in foreign workers because unemployed youth are not willing to take the low income jobs that others will travel far to get.
10:36 PM on 07/05/2012
Gen Y is screwed. The ones who pay a little attention to reality, know it. The majority who have been indoctrinated into dreamland by those who profit from mindless sheep will be happy as long as they are told they are happy, sold happiness, drugged into happiness, or believe it when they are told happiness is just around the corner if they only buy now and pay forever later. If I were gen Y and know what I know, I would likely not give a F. I would know I was sold out before I was even born. Gen greedhead is currently living this entitlement lifestyle that our youth are supposedly feeling entitled to. I think we are turning out generations of hopeless continually degrading lives. They should rightfully hate us for what we let happen in our consuming lazy ignorance. Working hard at a job is not all there is to being a decent hard working human being. We quit working for our society, for our future as a society. We worked to buy things. we forgot about working to keep and grow ideas and ideals.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Maria Korovessis Sewell
To decimate is to reduce by one tenth.
04:00 PM on 07/05/2012
I think a lot of readers who are older and have more experiences to look back upon, sympathize with younger people who believe in balancing work and life.
11:10 PM on 07/07/2012
Maria,

I believe everyone agrees that there is a balance. The problem is - what is balance? and whose definition should be used?

50-50? 60-40? What is 60 and what is 40? Unfortunately for many, life is earned. It does not matter what period of humanity you are from - no work no eat. The male who stays at the cave waiting for someone else's stew won't be there for long.
02:14 PM on 07/05/2012
"The Busy Trap and its popularity stands as a testament to a generational epidemic: a devastatingly widespread sense of entitlement that is, in part, contributing to those devastating post-grad employment levels."

Actually I think The Busy Trap is a "mission statement" if you will, of the gradual awakening of the modern worker. I'm a Gen Xer who put in my time and worked my way up in the same company for the last 15 years. I was the "busy" person. 50-60 hrs a week while getting paid for 40. Mortgage, car payments, credit card bill etc etc.
Now I look back and wonder what was the point? Work yourself to the bone until you retire and hope your health is good enough to enjoy everything you wish you had done when you were younger?

The author of the Busy Trap is spot on in many ways, especially in today's economic conditions. Why work that hard for a pittance of the companies profits? Real wages for the middle class stagnate while corporate profits and executive compensation sky rocket.

" Advertising has us chasing cars and clothes, working jobs we hate so we can buy sh** we don't need"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AlexEm El
Not Unlike a Socialist
01:01 PM on 07/05/2012
Again throwing around the word "entitlement". I'm sorry, but it seems to me that we produce more than people ever consume, we work to make things that are no longer necessary, the job market is dying because we don't have money to spend. I don't think that generation Y is entitled at all, I think they're simply disillusioned with the economic system we face, less likely to pursue the suburban home/minivan/2 kids and a wife combo than our predecessors. Work will not set you free, material possessions won't set you free, only your personal goals and achievements will. People from generation Y prefer being poor and fulfilled than rich and unhappy, and that means putting their effort into what they need.

On top of that, need I remind you that companies are profiting more than ever from workers. Look at the CEO paychecks that have risen by 300% since the 1970s? If they were to return their profits to their employees, no one would have to work 40 hours a week! Don't tell us we're entitled, we just know we could have it so much better.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Doctor Nick
Hi, everybody!
12:37 PM on 07/05/2012
" But, even if some overarching authority mandated that all offices closed at noon for a Spanish-like siesta, people could and would still work. They could go home and work there. They could keep abreast of the news on their phones. They could, oh, I don't know, read some infuriating article and be compelled to write something on their day off and never really "rest" (which is defined how, exactly?). What conceivable democratic authority has the capacity to institutionalize "relaxation policy?"

Actually it seems to work pretty well in Continental Europe. The legislation they have there about vacation days, etc. seems to actually work, based on all of the studies about how much people work. [http://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=ANHRS]

Germans - who are no slouches (so let's not make sneering comments at Spanish siestas) - work 80% of the hours per year that Americans do. Obviously you would need to change the culture AND the laws to get America to look more like Germany, but changing the laws is the first step.
11:23 PM on 07/07/2012
Doc,

Yours is a shallow comparison. Don't think Germany is any better than the US. The German economy is a time bomb like the housing crisis in the US. They have been profiting from the PIGS, who really didn't have the economy to support their spending of the last 15 years. The Germans have been keeping their economy high by exporting to those countries in trouble today by giving them credits. When those economies collapse, it will bring Germany to its knees.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Doctor Nick
Hi, everybody!
10:28 PM on 07/08/2012
Um, my point is just that they (and many other Europeans) work less. I thought this article was about "work" and people feeling "busy" rather than about the German trade surplus within the EU and I was addressing the ability of governments to influence this.  I think I agree with your point as I understand it but it is irrelevant to the topic of hand (and if it isn't, you need to explain your point better and relate it to the topic of this article).