Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
GET UPDATES FROM Richard Florida
 

Canada's Greatest Competitive Advantage? Our Creativity

Posted: 07/19/2012 7:11 am

Excerpted with permission from The Rise of the Creative Class Revisited: 10th Anniversary Edition, by Richard Florida. Available from Basic Books, a member of The Perseus Books Group. Copyright (C) 2012.

2012-06-19-TheRiseoftheCreativeClassRevisited1.gif


Four years after the great economic and financial crash of 2008, the U.S. economy continues to sputter and Europe teeters on the brink of economic collapse. Even China appears to be slowing down. Only one advanced nation has been able to rebound to pre-crisis levels of jobs and economic output: Canada.

While policy makers and pundits around the world debate the merits of various short-term fixes -- tax cuts versus stimulus, budget cuts versus monetary easing -- they miss the bigger point, one which I describe in detail in my just-published The Rise of the Creative Class, Revisited. We are living through a massive structural transformation of the economy, similar in scale and scope to the shift from the Agricultural to the Industrial Age. As such, it dwarfs even the Great Depression of the 1930s.

Canada is shifting from the Industrial to the Creative Age, in which creativity, "the ability to create meaningful new forms," as The Random House Webster's Dictionary puts it, has become the decisive source of competitive advantage.

2012-06-21-canasa.jpg


The chart above reveals the depth of this transformation. Based on research by my team at the Martin Prosperity Institute, it tracks Canadian employment from 1900 to 2000. As you can see, the share of Agriculture jobs began to decline precipitously at the beginning of the last century. The past couple of decades have been distinguished by another massive shift: this time from the Industrial to the Creative Age.

Canada entered the Industrial Age in the early part of the 20th century when farming, which once made up more than half of Canada's workforce, began its long decline. The Working Class (35 per cent share of total employment) surpassed Farming (31 per cent) by the 1930s. Farming slipped to just five per cent of employment in 1980 and has fallen even lower today. The Working Class, which accounted for roughly 40 per cent of Canadian employment for most of the 20th century, began to slip in the 1980s and now accounts for about one in four or five of Canadian workers.

The Creative Age is distinguished by the rise of two great social classes. The first is the Creative Class -- workers in science and technology, arts, culture and entertainment, and professional knowledge workers in healthcare, law and management. This epoch-defining class comprised less than five per cent of the workforce at the turn of the 20th century, growing to 31 per cent by mid-century, before surging in the 1980s. Today, five million Canadian workers are members of the Creative Class, roughly thirty per cent of the workforce.

The second, and larger of the two classes, is the Service Class, whose members prepare and serve food, carry out routine clerical and administrative tasks, provide home and personal health assistance, do janitorial work, and the like. Its ranks surged from approximately one quarter of Canada's workforce in 1960 to almost eight million today, roughly half of Canada's workforce.

Service Class workers who work full-time earned just 60 per cent of the average wages paid to the Creative Class -- $46,129 per year compared to $75,199. And, the Service Class is disproportionately concentrated among at risk groups -- recent immigrants, high school drop-outs, aboriginals and single parents -- who earn even less. Single parents take home just three-quarters of the average Service Class wage; recent immigrants just two-thirds.

Though Canada has been astonishingly resilient through the crisis -- it is the only advanced nation where economic output and employment top pre-crisis levels -- the key to sustainable prosperity lies in developing strategies and making investments that can speed the transition to the new Creative Age. That means removing the central props that continue to hold up the old economy -- the incentives and subsidies that keep the badly broken housing-auto-energy economy breathing.

It also means bringing more Canadian workers into the orbit of creativity. The way to do this is to essentially creatify their work. Our MPI research shows that the addition of creative skills to service and manufacturing work boosts wages at an even higher rate than when it's added to Creative Class work.

While we sometimes forget this, the blue-collar jobs that we so pine for today weren't always good family supporting jobs. William Blake aptly dubbed factories "Satanic mills," and for much of the Industrial Age, the work was low-pay, dirty and dangerous -- what Marx said would lead the proletariat to revolt. The post World War II era saw the establishment of a social compact between labour and capital that turned these formerly bad jobs into good ones. Unions helped to forge this and wages rose in tandem with productivity. Much of the blue-collar manufacturing work that remains in Canada is already creative work, tapping workers' intelligence, creativity and skill as a source of continuous productivity improvement.

The last frontier of work-upgrading lies with the Service Class, the largest class in terms of sheer numbers. Upgrading service work is not only good for the workers who do this kind of work, It can provide a much needed boost to the economy as a whole, increasing purchasing power and stimulating demand (as was the case with higher-paying blue-collar jobs in the 1950s and 1960s). Yes, it is true that we will all have to share the cost of higher-paid service work, just as we paid more for cars and manufactured goods after World War II. The burden of long-run prosperity is one we all have to share.

To get there, a new social compact is needed, one that invests in the creativity of every single human being in order to upgrade and generate new higher-paying jobs, address the gross inequities in our economy and society, and lay the institutional foundations for a new era of shared prosperity.

Richard Florida is author of The Rise of the Creative Class Revisited released by Basic Books on June 26th. He is Director of the Martin Prosperity Institute at the University of Toronto's Rotman School of Management.

 

Follow Richard Florida on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Richard_Florida

FOLLOW CANADA
Excerpted with permission from The Rise of the Creative Class Revisited: 10th Anniversary Edition, by Richard Florida. Available from Basic Books, a member of The Perseus Books Group. Copyright (C) 2...
Excerpted with permission from The Rise of the Creative Class Revisited: 10th Anniversary Edition, by Richard Florida. Available from Basic Books, a member of The Perseus Books Group. Copyright (C) 2...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skbull44
Check out Olduvai the novel
08:33 AM on 07/22/2012
Florida's thesis, in fact his entire philosophy, rest of some grandiose assumptions, not least of which is that past trends indicate future ones. This is nonsense, as shown by Nasim Taleb in The Black Swan. A Black Swan event can reverse trends at any time. As Taleb so eloquently demonstrates, making predictions, especially about complex systems where humans are involved, is a game for fools. Meteorologists, at least, give probabilities for their predictions and recognise that the further out in time from the prediction (e.g. 12+ hours), the more likelihood of the prediction being incorrect.
Given the fragility of the global economic and political systems we have in place, I would argue (as an educator) that the better path would be one of educating our citizens in the 'arts' of self-reliance and self-sufficiency on a local scale. Pushing the lever in the direction Florida suggests would only hasten society's collapse since the 'creative' class is further removed from the base of all existence: food production!
09:21 AM on 07/21/2012
This guy gives both balderdash and gobbledygook bad names!
03:37 PM on 07/20/2012
I hope you're right. It would be nice to see an economy based on creativity.
09:02 AM on 07/20/2012
sooo why is canada unloading its scientists, has no meaningful competition in production and cant even come close in electronics. Canada is still a colonie most engineering jobs in canada are extraction (either of Oil, Aluminum, Uranium, Nickel, Gold and so on) the reason canada is slowing down now and will continue to slow down after other countries are coming back is because A they cant buy our materials. well guess what that means canadians are going to have o shell out more to buy goods because we make next to nothing here. people always talk about the doctors leaving because of money, most of my friends including myself left because there weren't enough jobs for engineers who didn't wanna work on the oil fields, or in a mine shaft.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sgillhoolley
Occupy the discussion.
03:04 PM on 07/20/2012
It's a shame none of you started your own business.
03:05 PM on 07/21/2012
It's unfortunate that the society that educated you will have to miss the benefit of your labors.
07:31 AM on 07/20/2012
While we are perpetually being told that Canada's banking sector was the crowning jewel in the global banking system over the past five years, in fact, this article shows that without a massive bailout, Canada's banks would have been in the same sad shape as many banks around the world:

http://viableopposition.blogspot.ca/2012/06/canadas-healthy-banking-system-fact-or.html

What is most concerning about this bailout is that, at its peak, the size of the bailout exceeded the market capitalization of some of the banks by a
03:33 PM on 07/20/2012
For all their faults (and they have MANY faults), Canadian banks did not require a bailout. If I sell you my car to make my mortgage payment, did you bail me out? In the US, banks were given money to make their payments, and they kept their car. That's a bailout.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:22 AM on 07/22/2012
The US Federal Reserve forwarded $ to Canadian Banks.
12:00 AM on 07/20/2012
I have been telling people for a long time that a "platoon' approach to survival in any jungle is the only way. The jungle in this case being the global economy. Canada's population is small enough that it can maneuver more quickly and each province/municipality is beginning to retract from the central control of national government and international economic policy (read American policy). Canada does have the advantage of the natural resources now but as peak oil passes the smaller communities that believe in "Community" still have people with a multitude of skills which can be shared. These are the people that we will have to count on in the future. We cannot count on the global economy to save us because as anyone can see it is floundering because the approach of
global control over resources and technology patents is weakening. Resources are dwindling. New economies are competitive in new technology. The change coming will be exponential not just because of climate change but because survival will dictate how people adjust.

I have read Richard Florida and he has recognized the innovate lose of corporations in their attempt to control.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sgillhoolley
Occupy the discussion.
03:06 PM on 07/20/2012
I find your idea of the platoon interesting. Can you speak to that further please?
06:34 PM on 07/19/2012
I believe you had a premise, the rise of the creative class, and have selected certain data to support your hypothesis while ignoring other relevant data.

I believe we have weathered the financial storm for other reasons than the creative class.

Canada has been able to exploit certain natural resources(petroleum, potash ect) over the last few years that are in demand by developed countries.

Canada's banking system was stronger(though there are some reports the Harper Govt supported the banks to a greater extent behind the scenes) than other developed nations. CMHC did not have sub prime mortgages therefore protecting the housing sector to some extent. Also, in the 90's the chartered banks wanted more flexibility in their investments and wanted less regulation but were denied this by the Chretian government.

Canada has had a higher immigration rate than any other developed nation and new immigrants have been exploited by the rest of Canada.

While Canadians complain about Health Care, Canada spends less on Health Care as % of GDP than the USA, however, most of the important medical discoveries are in the USA.

The American system is corrupted by their legal system. The American legal system has given all american corporations a disadvantage due to the amount they pay in liability insurance.

I could go on but am limited in the space available. I retired as a CFO for a company with international operations and I would say Americans are the most creative.
09:59 PM on 07/19/2012
boo.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sgillhoolley
Occupy the discussion.
03:08 PM on 07/20/2012
The US is losing its' lead in terms of patents, in all areas. Most discoveries are coming from Asia these days, and soon China will dominate patents as well.