Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Samaritanmag.com

GET UPDATES FROM Samaritanmag.com
 

Chatting with 'The Ghosts in our Machine' Director Liz Marshall

Posted: 07/03/2013 5:05 pm

Liz Marshall knows the topic of animal rights is a tough subject. She knows most people would rather look away. That's why she calls them "the ghosts": animals used by humans for food, fur, research, and entertainment. The B.C.-born, Toronto-based filmmaker has just released a new documentary called The Ghosts in Our Machine, which tackles the controversial issue and aims to raise awareness to animal suffering around the world.

Marshall has been committed to making socially conscious film and TV for more than 10 years, from specials about sweatshop labour for music channel MuchMusic to in-the-field work with charity organizations like War Child Canada and the Stephen Lewis Foundation, which supports HIV-AIDS projects in Africa. Her first feature documentary, Water on the Table, was about the protection of freshwater resources. The Ghosts in Our Machine is her first project to focus on animals. It follows award-winning photographer Jo-Anne McArther as she wrangles access into dairy farms and fur factories and other secretive places and tries to put an individual face to the animals held captive there for a book called We Animals. Like Jo-Anne's photos, the film is both difficult to watch and highly captivating. The images speak for themselves -- no preaching required.

The Ghosts in the Machine, which was partially crowdfunded through Indiegogo, premiered at this year's Hot Docs festival in Toronto and is now at Bloor Hot Docs Cinema (Marshall is in attendance for a Q&A on July 3 and 4). It screens at Winnipeg Film Group July 3-7 and 11-12, and Vancouver's VanCity Theatre Aug. 2-3, 16-17. More theatrical screenings are planned throughout the year.

The film's comprehensive website is filled with resources and tips for going "ghost-free," and Marshall, who has been vegan since she started the project three years ago, hopes her efforts will open up discussion about seeing animals in a new way. She spoke to Samaritanmag.com about what she has learned.

How did you become interested in working in social justice issues?

Mostly through my mother, who is a really committed citizen of the world. I grew up in that environment, but my interest became quite clear during my time with War Child Canada. I've always been drawn to people that believe in change and are hopeful and I see myself as part of that movement. So I gradually gravitated towards wanting to make films about goodness in the world.

In the director statement for The Ghosts in Our Machine, you say that this project impacted you more deeply than your past work. How?

What I meant by that, that it tweaked my moral compass differently, is because I had never focused on the animal question in the past. I was focused on human rights and the environment. The Ghosts are the billions of animals that we use within all these industries. My eyes were opened in a different way. I guess I had been wearing blinders and wasn't fully conscious of the impact that we have, as consumers, on all these species or animals that are trapped in the machinery of our modern world.

There are some great scenes in the film at a sanctuary, where we get to see happy animals. Why was it important to you to show not just the dark side?

The place is called Farm Sanctuary, and Jo-Anne's best friend is the director there. It's like a human-animal society, with a sense of equality. The animals are safe; they won't be slaughtered or used for human needs in any way. In the film, we need that reprieve; we need to have those scenes were we can rest and reflect and also have some levity. The greatest challenge in making this film was finding a way to tell the story so people would want to watch. It wasn't made for a niche audience; we're not here to preach to the converted; it's made for a broad demographic. Part of doing that was to create some scenes that have happiness, levity and joy, with a heartwarming quality to them, and other scenes that are challenging and difficult, but important.

You're vegan. Is this film promoting a vegan lifestyle?

It's not a "go vegan" project. We're not advocating for the whole world to go vegan. It's a consciousness-raising project, to open the door, possibly for the first time, to this subject matter. We're not an activist group. We are connected with lots of amazing groups who are doing that work and people can plug into those organizations. People are thanking us. And they say, "Now what do I do?"

What is the "Five-day Ghost Free Journey"?

That's something we initiated as a monthly event on our Facebook page while we were making the movie. It's for people that want to try not eating or wearing animals for five days, and researching the ingredients that are in your house, for animal testing. We've created this blog and we have two coaches. It's supported by Lush Cosmetics, through their Charity Pot grant program. In fact, recently the Lush Vancouver staff, 30 people, took the journey. What people do beyond the five days is up to them. We're not judging people who decide not to be vegan, but the response has been amazing and everyone has told us they've more or less maintained the lifestyle.

For those people who won't be adopting vegan or even vegetarian diet on a regular basis, what are the ways that they can help?

It begins with examining our behavior. If in the summer we usually take our kids to the zoo, maybe we can think about other ways to teach our kids about animals in the wild. Maybe start considering what life is like for the animals, not just for us. A sanctuary is designed with the animal in mind. A zoo is designed with a human consumer in mind. If we can understand that, that's one way that we can make a difference for the animals.

What is your ultimate goal for this project?

We want it to do well, to get this issue on the radar. We want people to care. I know it's a challenging issue. I know it's hard to watch, the reality that humans put these animals in. Ultimately, I think just like Jo-Anne says at the end of the movie, that she truly believes that we are all compassionate and that if we are given the opportunity to care, we will. I believe that too.

By Liisa Ladouceur | www.samaritanmag.com

* Samaritanmag.com is an online magazine covering the good deeds of individuals, charities and businesses.

Loading Slideshow...
  • The Good: Charges Against Maple Lodge Farms

    <a href="http://www.thestar.com/news/article/1112005--maple-lodge-farms-hit-with-60-criminal-charges">The Canadian Food Inspection Agency laid 60 criminal charges</a> against food company Maple Lodge Farms, according to <em>The Toronto Star</em>. The company was charged for routinely allowing thousands of chickens to die during transportation from farms to slaughterhouses.

  • The Good: Elephants Moved From Toronto Zoo

    Toronto city council <a href="http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/story/2012/11/27/toronto-zoo-elephants.html">recognized the needs of three elephants</a> at the Toronto Zoo and voted to move them to a sanctuary in California.

  • The Good: Quebec Promotes Better Animal Care

    The province of Quebec created a provincial animal welfare body to help promote better care for animals in the province.

  • The Good: Cities Ban The Sale Of Cats And Dogs

    In 2012, <a href="http://www.citynews.ca/2011/09/21/toronto-bans-the-sale-of-cats-and-dogs-in-pet-stores/">Toronto followed Richmond, B.C. and became the second Canadian city to restrict the sale of cats and dogs in pet shops</a> environmentalists deemed unhealthy. The city of <a href="http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/mississauga/article/1218232--mississauga-bans-t-store-sales-of-privately-bred-cats-and-dogs">Mississauga has also banned the sale of all privately bred cats and dogs</a> (where the animals are often bred in deplorable conditions) in pet stores.

  • The Good: Critical Habitat For Orca Whales Protected

    In 2012, <a href="http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/court-ruling-compels-ottawa-to-protect-killer-whale-habitat/article4107454/">the Federal Court of Appeals ruled the Minister of Fisheries must protect critical habitats for orca whales</a> as outlined in the Species at Risk Act.

  • The Good: Tim Hortons Took A Stand

    Last year, <a href="http://www.thestar.com/business/article/1173020--tim-hortons-puts-more-eggs-in-animal-welfare-basket?bn=1">Tim Hortons gave its pork suppliers until the end of 2012 to have "clear plans" in place to phase out the use of gestation stalls</a>.

  • The Good: Ban On Cropping Dogs' Ears For Aesthetic Purposes

    <a href="http://news.nationalpost.com/2012/02/10/dog-ear-cropping-banned-in-manitoba-as-inhumane-we-need-to-change-breed-standards-vet-says/">Manitoba became the second province after Newfoundland to ban the practice of cropping dogs' ears</a>, a procedure that can lead to infection and illness.

  • The Good: UBC Forced To Release Details

    <a href="http://www.globaltvbc.com/ubc+ordered+to+release+more+information+on+animal+research+facility/6442571140/story.html">The Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner ordered the University of British Columbia to release all details of their animal research program.</a> This is a good first step in creating more transparency in how taxpayers’ money is used in public research facilities, according to Global News.

  • The Good: More Severe Fines For Animal Abuse

    <a href="http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/story/2012/05/03/nl-animal-act-503.html">Newfoundland and Labrador passed a new Animal Health and Protection Act which includes increased penalties for animal abuse.</a> Anyone convicted of animal cruelty or neglect can now face fines of up to $50,000 or six months jail time.

  • The Good: Harp Seal Pups Released Back To The Wild

    <a href="http://www.digitaljournal.com/article/333139">After an international outcry, the Aquarium des Iles in Quebec, released 6-month old pups Zak and Mika back into the wild</a>. Both harp seals were scheduled for euthanasia.

  • The Good: Air Canada Will No Longer Transport Primates

    The Canadian Transport Authority will now allow Air Canada to discontinue the transportation of primates for medical research.

  • The Good: Darwin Sent To Sanctuary

    Darwin, <a href="http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/story/2012/12/10/toronto-ikea-monkey.html">the five-month-old "Ikea monkey" is now in the care of Story Book Farms Primate Sanctuary</a> in southern Ontario.

  • The Bad: Marineland Animals Are Still Suffering

    <a href="http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/article/1241961--marineland-animals-suffering-former-staffers-say">Seals, sea lions, walruses and dolphins at Marineland are suffering fur loss, skin damage and even blindness</a> because of recurring water problems at the Niagara Falls, Ont. theme park.

  • The Bad: Ripley's Aquarium Stocked With Wild Sharks

    <a href="http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/article/1240875">In 2012, it was announced Toronto's newest aquarium</a> will house sand tiger sharks taken from the wild.

  • The Bad: The Senate Approved A Cull For 70,000 Grey Seals

    Last year, <a href="http://thechronicleherald.ca/canada/153016-senate-committee-recommends-cull-of-grey-seals">it was reported Ottawa should approve a cull of 70,000 seals off Canada's East Coast.</a> The decision was made as part of a controversial four-year experiment aimed at helping the recovery of cod stocks.

  • The Bad: Canada Allows Dog And Cat Fur

    China is the world’s largest exporter of fur garments, mostly made from mink, fox and raccoon dog. Even though <a href="http://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/1218580--how-canada-gets-dog-and-cat-fur-from-china">most Western countries prohibit imports of cat and dog fur, Canada does not</a>.

  • The Ugly: Man Kills 56 Sled Dogs

    <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/11/22/whistler-sled-dogs-killer-robert-fawcett-sentence_n_2174775.html">Robert Fawcett, the man who pleaded guilty to killing at least 56 sled dogs in Whistler B.C.,</a> was given a small fine and no jail time. The B.C. court system missed an opportunity to set new standards for preventing animal cruelty in the province.

  • The Ugly: 3 Horses Died At The Calgary Stampede

    <a href="http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/story/2012/07/13/calgary-chuck-wagon-horse-death-folo.html">Three horses died as a result of chuckwagon races during last summer's Calgary Stampede.</a> Many activist groups have called for a suspension of these types of races.

  • The Ugly: The Inhumane Treatment Of Factory Farm Animals

    Last year, W5 exposed a Winnipeg farm for performing inhumane practices like <a href="http://www.ctvnews.ca/w5/undercover-investigation-reveals-disturbing-and-inhumane-treatment-of-factory-farm-animals-1.1070919">castration without pain medication, confinement housing and “thumping” of piglets</a>. However, researchers concluded the farm was within accepted industry standards and, likely, did not break any laws.

  • The Ugly: "DIY" Pet Surgeries

    In 2012, it was noted do-it-yourself pet surgeries were on the rise. One report found that <a href="http://www.castanet.net/news/Canada/82605/Do-it-yourself-pet-surgery">dog owners used elastrator bands to neuter their dogs</a>.

  • The Ugly: Groups Deemed Extremist

    <a href="http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/security-services-deem-environmental-animal-rights-groups-extremist-threats/article2340162/">Federal security services identified Greenpeace and People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals as extremist groups</a> that were capable of carrying out attacks against Canadian infrastructures.

 

Follow Samaritanmag.com on Twitter: www.twitter.com/samaritanmag

FOLLOW CANADA IMPACT