Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Sandra Charron

GET UPDATES FROM Sandra Charron
 

Being Bullied Makes You Tougher

Posted: 02/03/2013 8:06 am

This week on Facebook I saw a picture of a child with a sign around his neck on which the words, "Shame on me for being a bully" are painted in red. His mother stands beside him, arms crossed, hip jutted out, assuming what one can only describe as an unwavering, disciplining stance. In bold letters, the caption states, "This mom deserves an award."

Really? 'Cause from where I'm standing, seems to me she's giving as good as her kid does.

At the age of 15, I spent six months running scared from a bully. The bully in question would wait for me by the door of my classes, and as I would exit, she would follow closely on my heels; literally on my heels, until the backs of my shoes were frayed and my heels were blistered and bleeding.

I did finally tell my parents who in turn told the school. But 30 years ago, "anti-bullying" campaigns were non-existent, and the mean girl dodged not only consequences from the school, but her parents told my dad that if he was "tougher on me," I'd be able to handle what their kid was dishing out. Somehow I don't think making their daughter stand on the street with a sign around her neck while she posed for a picture would have solved the problem, especially if the household mentality required the individuals involved to be "tougher." Holding a sign would probably conjure the same irritated look as the one on the boy in the Facebook picture, and probably further fuel my bully's hatred of me.

Anti-bullying campaigns have been part of school curricula for at least 10 years, but I question whether the time spent teaching children to "tell a grown up" is even helpful, when in fact, the concerns stem from deeper sources than simply some kid with anger issues. Strength and power are valued in our society. As adults, we constantly strive to be the best we can be; get that promotion over the other guy at work; have a better car than the neighbour next door; buy a bigger house than the one we already can't afford. Survival of the fittest is no longer simply referring to Darwinism, it's a motto that drives our North American culture.

Even reality TV shows are set up to represent a microcosm of society, stacked with strong and weak players; the weaker ones edited to seem stupid, incapable, and useless of furthering themselves in the game. Of course this is purposefully set up in this fashion, but how quickly the roles are assumed in the game, and the bullies are immediately identified by both the viewers and the players, and yet how often are the bullies transformed into charming heroes given the cash in the end. Boston Rob from Survivor? Evil Will from Big Brother? Donald Trump? Mean anything to anybody?

Their superiority is not only flaunted by them, but the producers of their respective shows thrived when these outspoken individuals were in the spotlight referring to the other contestants in derogatory fashion: stupid and weak most often reasons for the demise of their nemesis.

Certainly parents don't encourage their children to dominate over other children in an aggressive manner, but when bullying occurs -- when the parents are contacted by the teacher, principal, basketball coach, boy scout leader and/or the ballet teacher informing them that their kid isn't playing nice -- accepting the truth about our children's behaviour may not only be difficult, but it may be reflective of our own subconscious need to position ourselves above others.

Recently a 13-year-old girl hid crying in a bathroom stall at a pre-teen dance because a group of boys had spent several hours tormenting her with rude and derogatory comments. The tormented girl's parents called the parents of the boys in question, and proceeded to explain what their children had done.

The young girl's mother was told by each of the boys' parents that 1) The boys were only playing, 2) The girl was being overly sensitive, 3) The girl was provoking the boys, and 4) The girl was lying; the scenario had not in fact taken place. Nobody apologized for their children's behaviour, and when the word "bullying" was used, the boys' parents became incensed, wondering out loud, "I don't know where he would get that from?" Yeah, I wonder...

Comedian Chris Rock, who has openly discussed being bullied by other children throughout his childhood, has stated, "I am not pro-bully." That having been said however, he also attributes his success to the fact that being bullied made him stronger.

So is putting a sign around your kid's neck teaching him a lesson or is it teaching him to be better at being tougher? And ultimately, isn't the entire event aimed at making the mom seem like this proactive, marvellous mother, who despite her humiliation tactics, is a hard-ass? And let's face it, North America loves a bully, as long as she/he is wearing a cape.

 

Follow Sandra Charron on Twitter: www.twitter.com/SandraSheWrites

FOLLOW CANADA LIVING
This week on Facebook I saw a picture of a child with a sign around his neck on which the words, "Shame on me for being a bully" are painted in red. His mother stands beside him, arms crossed, hip jut...
This week on Facebook I saw a picture of a child with a sign around his neck on which the words, "Shame on me for being a bully" are painted in red. His mother stands beside him, arms crossed, hip jut...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:44 PM on 02/04/2013
Ex-gay students are frequent targets of bullies, with school officials sometimes joining in verbal attacks. This particular group has little or no recourse because they are politically insignificant. You can't fix hate with more hate.
11:02 AM on 02/04/2013
Bullying can make you stronger.
Or it can make you weaker.
Or it can leave you in therapy for the rest of your life.
Or it can end your life.

Stop excusing it.
10:58 PM on 02/03/2013
Sure, bullying makes you stronger... except when it doesn't. Then it just damages self-esteem and leaves kids living in fear and doubt and self-loathing, potentially long after the bullying has stopped, or leads to the kind of revenge fantasy that seems to underlie some school shootings. Although you deny it in the comments, you do seem to be saying that this is something that kids should work out among themselves, and that ultimately it serves some sort of character building purpose. I completely disagree. The physical violence that some have described in the comments is, quite literally, a criminal offence and should be treated as such. And psychologically speaking, words do quite a lot of damage too.

I probably got off pretty lightly- I was only verbally bullied for about two years in middle school, grades seven and eight, by a couple of boys in my class who were verbally abusive to many people. I went to a different high school than them and managed much better. I'm now 35, and I can still cringe remembering some of the things that they said and how nasty/dirty/worthless it made me feel. I still remember both of their names, long after I've forgotten the names of many of the other kids in that class. I can't say it made me stronger, but it definitely left an impression I would rather not have.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DebbyM
09:45 PM on 02/03/2013
The philosophy expressed by this mother is awful and I'd like her to go and run this by the parents of a child who has killed themselves as a result of being bullied.
04:42 PM on 02/03/2013
I fail to see the logic in this writer's thinking. She goes on at length about parents who are in willful denial about their kids' bullying of others, but she criticizes the mother who very rightly outs her son as a bully by making him wear a sign declaring it. Of course that kid is mad at being outed, but it may well make him think twice about bullying again if he knows his parent will dole out some real justice to him for doing it. In later years he'll thank his mom for her ethics and zero-tolerance for bullying from her own kid.
02:36 PM on 02/03/2013
I was given advice 40 years ago to stand up to the bully. I did that and got a worse beating. When we were hauled into the Principal's office I got as much punishment as the bully did. There was no recognition of what the bully had done or was doing in the playground every day. The only solution was to band together with some of the other children that were being bullied by this guy and avoid him as much as possible. The teachers were no help at all. When they were on playground duty they should have been issued a white cane!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
10:51 PM on 02/03/2013
then there's bullying by teachers......
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lkvk101
A fools' paradise is a wise mans hell.
02:08 PM on 02/03/2013
As I read this article, my brain was going in several different directions.

Talking to a grownup.....what choices do they have? Suffer it out? NO.

There is a pecking order on the playground for sure, always has been, but bullying is unacceptable. Children are loving kind creatures when they are innocent but it doesn't take long to find out that the nasty things in life will rear its ugly head sooner or later. It is up to ALL adults to teach children respect and love. I believe most bullying comes from the home.

It is hard enough when one is an adult and runs into a bully in the workplace, never mind a child trying to handle it.
Makes one stronger.?....not always. Makes one sad, feeling of worthlessness and depressed.....more likely.
01:28 PM on 02/03/2013
I don't understand what your point of view is on all this. I agree that society encourages bullying in adults and that seeing a mom effectively bully their child to show that bullying isn't acceptable makes no sense but are you suggesting that bullying should be accepted in schools because it will make some kids tougher? That is just complete madness, especially when you look at stuff like suicide rates.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
01:03 PM on 02/03/2013
I have to agree for the most part, with the author. I won't claim to have all the answers but I grew up a being bullied. I was smaller than the other boys but managed to be a happy kid therefore I was able to make more friends than enemies. I remember at the age of 10 there were 2 older boys that bullied me, as well as the other smaller kids, and it was tough... I learned to be sneaky about leaving school, different times or back doors, but occationally they would catch me and beat me up and I would run home crying. My mother was a wonderful woman and had a way with words... she said this: "you will live your whole life surrounded by bullies, strength might help you to fight but learning how to deal with it early will help you survive." She was not cold about it.... what was she gunna do... walk me too and from school? The bullies parents were drunks, should she have talked to them? No. Every situation is different and must be approched that way. I think what I am getting at is that I think it is more important to teach kids early on that there ARE bullies in this world, and they WILL be bullied, and that life WILL go on, and that when they get older they WILL be stronger for it.
05:10 AM on 02/03/2013
Telling kids to talk to a grownup isn't helpful? Mixed messages in this article.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jeremy Bursac
You're not the bossa nova me.
02:42 AM on 02/03/2013
The best outcome here would be to test this thesis on the children (or young relatives) of the author. And not just bullying by peers, but defamation and disfranchisement from clergy, politicians, teachers and other family members. Because that's what we're talking about regarding glbt students in many regions, particularly the bible areas of the US.

Then we'd see whether the author would stick with this right wing talking point or not.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DebbyM
09:48 PM on 02/03/2013
Exactly. What kind of a post will she write when her kid is the one being abused to the point of living in fear and then kills him or herself? Or maybe her kid is one of the bullies and she's trying to find some way to justify not dealing with his rotten behaviour. I can't imagine any one suggesting that we don't need to be proactive in the case of bullying.
12:42 AM on 02/03/2013
My oldest child was a bully-magnet. He is small and quiet and introverted and fabulously intelligent and bookish. And very easy to get a reaction. Two kids in particular would needle and prod and goad until he would explode. No one ever saw this chain of events, they just saw the explosion. My son (the smallest and physically weakest in the class) was labeled the bully and put on disciplinary "watch." Finally, because he was now being "watched," the actions of the others were seen. And finally their behavior was called into question and their parents were dragged into the mix. All of this left my son pigeonholed as "explosive" and as insignificant in any way other than "better stay away from him." He luckily has two friends who were also picked on through elementary school, and he looks very much forward to going to high school next year because he will be going to a very accepting and KIND place (yes, they do exist!) that places less value on the perceived strong and powerful. Great piece.