Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Shayna Zamkanei
 

What Next for Israel's Orthodox Women -- the Burka?

Posted: 01/26/2012 3:18 pm

In recent months, a new form of war is being waged in Israel.

On Wednesday, three out of the four male suspects who attacked Natali Mashiah for dressing "immodestly"--vandalizing her car and pouring bleach on her--were released due to "weak" evidence.

A country that has elected a female head of state, conscripted women in the military, and produced both a Nobel Prize winner and Sports Illustrated swimsuit model sounds remarkably Scandinavian. Yet within Israel, women within select religious communities are being attacked for being women at the wrong place and time.

Years ago, when I sat at the front of the infamous Egged 2 bus that snakes its way through some of Jerusalem's conservative Orthodox areas, a few men tried to bully my friend and I into sitting at the back the bus. "Sorry, apartheid is over," we told them. Since that incident, I've noticed dozens of similar stories popping up in the news: women being sexually harassed, spat on, punched in the face, blacked out in advertisements, and segregated at state-sponsored secular events.

What is particularly peculiar about these events is the relative "newness" of excluding women from the public domain. If men have traditionally learned in religious seminaries or yeshivas, who, then, was earning the living? Who went to the marketplace to make purchases and sell goods? Who took care of businesses during office hours? Women. And if women were actively seen outside of the home back then, why are they being discouraged from occupying these same roles now?

The aggressors argue that women's dress today is immodest and that modesty must be preserved in the public arena. Naked arms prompt thoughts of naked limbs; naked limbs, naked sex. And men who think about sex with strangers are men who cannot possibly focus on learning the laws of a good, moral life.

One caveat: None of these attacks involved uber-scantily clad women (not that there's anything wrong with that). In fact, the woman who was punched in the face on the Egged bus was herself religious. She was traveling on a segregated bus partitioned down the middle, when a man insisted that she go to the back of the bus (are we tired of this theme yet?) where he wouldn't be able to see her. Real scholars of Jewish law know, however, that it is incumbent upon men to divert their eyes from attractive women who are not their wives. No lustful gazes permitted or even peekaboos.

Clearly, this form of misogyny is a problem that extends beyond manners of dress. In response to increasing permissive sexual attitudes and behaviour in "secular" society, certain members of the religious community have decided to blame women for the lasciviousness that has permeated the borders of their already insular communities. To recall: Kosher cellphones didn't become fashionable because women were calling 1-900 numbers and downloading naughty bits onto their cell phones.

Beyond the clothing, however, I suggest that the growing intolerance for women's presence is yet another symptom of the Occupation. Learning to hate the forcibly marginalized isn't a process that ends with a particular group. Having sought out others, the hate turns within to feed.

But lest you think that blaming the Occupation is hopelessly unoriginal, I suggest that men within these communities lack a certain function. They hope that by beating up women, their lives achieve purpose. Because these men are able to study religious texts all day, supported by the state and their institutions in a way that is unprecedented, they feel obligated to do so.

Obligation doesn't beget success, however. Not everybody can be the brilliant yeshiva student who marries the most beautiful woman, and those who can't are most certainly aware of it. Some eventually leave the yeshiva environment and enter the workforce, helping to support their large families. Some of those who cannot succeed but choose not to leave, however, resemble high school drop outs. They loiter outside smoking, waiting to prey on their next victim to reaffirm their place as outliers in a system not meant for them. The response? Get a job.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
markhahn
rational progressive
12:45 AM on 01/30/2012
what we really need to be talking about here is pluralism: how modern society is most fundamentally based on a rule-of-law-based respect for diversity.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cdncommentator
11:21 PM on 01/29/2012
Bravo!! And kol ha'kavod!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
toofarleft4thisworld
The Right Is So Wrong
04:04 PM on 01/29/2012
no need to worry, America will make sure Israel can continue on it's merry way unabated by any moral judgement from the outside world. we need Israeli's to fix Israel.
10:11 PM on 01/28/2012
Without religion this BS wouldn't be going on.
12:14 AM on 01/28/2012
Unstated is the Jewish belief that everyone who isn't Jewish is inferior. i.e. some seven billion "goy" must accept the fact that fifteen million Jews are inherently smarter, and Jews have rights which others don't. The Haredi and ultra orthodox continue to thrive and will expand in numbers until Israel either forces them to go to schools like other Israeli schools and work like otherr Israelis work or Israel will go under thanks to the tax costs of allowing them to sit at home and figure out how to impose their beliefs on those who disagree with them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Karmazenuk
Author, Freelance Journalist, Curmudgeon
11:02 AM on 01/27/2012
An Abrahamic religious system that's misogynistic, repressive and hateful towards others? What are the odds? Jews, Christians, Muslims...all act alike: utter bereft of the love of God they proclaim.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:53 AM on 01/27/2012
The ultras ARE minorities, in fact they are more so than women considering that there are more women in Israel than Ultras. It has nothing to do with the "Occupation", it has to do with their crazy religiosity and minority point of view. They aren't happy being allowed to practice their own religion, they feel like they have to force it on everyone who is around them too.
03:52 AM on 01/27/2012
" I suggest that the growing intolerance for women's presence is yet another symptom of the Occupation. Learning to hate the forcibly marginalized isn't a process that ends with a particular group. Having sought out others, the hate turns within to feed."
This comment alone displays great ignorance of what is going on in Israel and its religious communities. Blaming the 'occupation' is probably the laziest intellectual tack someone can try.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Maria Korovessis Sewell
To decimate is to reduce by one tenth.
01:01 PM on 01/27/2012
Itzchak, I'm curious as to how someone who understands what is going on in Israel and its religious communities would explain the increase in intolerance?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Juanne Michaud
Proud Canadian, loony lefty
11:40 PM on 01/26/2012
When it happens to women, it's "cultural" or "religious". When it happens to men, it's "human rights violation".

Let's call it for what it is, shall we?

I realize Israel is a Jewish state, but isn't it about time that some of its citizens were dragged kicking and screaming into the 18th century? The laws they study so assiduously were written -- when? Some 5,000 years ago? Does this make sense in today's world?

These attacks on women have nothing to do with morality or spirituality; they are a pathetic attempt by sad little men to wield power over somebody, anybody. The fact that the Israeli government and the so-called justice system looks the other way because they do not wish to offend the religious element is sad. When religion is offensive, then it should be pursued and punished.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:57 AM on 01/27/2012
It is a matter of family and history. After the Holocaust, some groups turned to secularism and others retreated further into their religion. Many of the Ultra communities lived segregated in Europe in their own towns, and continued this when they moved to Israel. Because they work hard to disconnect themselves from mainstream society, their children do not adapt to Israel, and they get left farther and farther behind. Now, to attack them brings back memories of the Holocaust considering that Israel was made so all Jews can practice their faith without restrictions.

Also, ALL Jews believe in the Law, just interpretations and "weight" defer based on denominations, unless you are a secular or cultural or Reconstructionist Jew.
03:50 AM on 01/29/2012
"Also, ALL Jews believe in the Law, just interpreta­tions and "weight" defer based on denominati­ons, unless you are a secular or cultural or Reconstruc­tionist Jew."
That's the problem with all religions. They start by promoting "Love thy neighbour" and they end up pushing "Hate thy neighbour". Unfortunately, too often, religion becomes the refuge of "nutcases".
06:55 PM on 01/26/2012
It puts me in mind of a woman columnist doing a tour in Afghanistan. She was visiting a market place to dig up some colour for her columns. She had an interpreter with her. She was wearing a head scarf, because of dirt and heat presumably and was told by a merchant to put on a burka. When she asked the interpreter what was said, he told her the merchant was insisting she should be wearing the face covering. Her comment to the interpreter was to tell the merchant " tell him to kiss my ass".
Nuff said. Israeli women should tell those fundamentalist idiots the same thing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
see-ellen2001
05:25 PM on 01/26/2012
Very well said. Tell them this...if YOU are so bothered by the sight of a woman then lock YOUrself inside or tape YOUr eyes shut. It is not about woMEn, it is about YOU.
08:17 PM on 01/26/2012
I read the best solution here on HP. Let those men who can't be bothered controlling their thoughts wear a paper bag over their heads. Problem solved.
02:36 PM on 01/28/2012
My sentiments exactly.