Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Supriya Dwivedi

GET UPDATES FROM Supriya Dwivedi
 

Is International Women's Day an International Joke?

Posted: 03/08/2013 5:16 pm

Today is International Women's Day, and although you might notice the requisite "Let's Empower Women and Girls" op-ed on your social media news feeds, the truth is that this day is more or less a farce. It's a day where society can say they have talked about "women's" issues for a day in order to make themselves feel like they have contributed to the betterment of humanity.

Note the use of quotations. That's because I'm systematically flabbergasted as to how certain facts are perceived to be solely a women's rights issue and not a human rights issue. If any other race, religious organization, or linguistic group were treated in the same manner as women are worldwide the entire planet would be up in arms.

But the fact remains that 48 women are raped every hour in the Congo, global estimates predict that women aged 15-44 are more at risk for rape or domestic violence than from cancer, malaria and car accidents combined, 140 million women and girls have been subject to the barbaric cultural ritual of female genital mutilation, and millions of girls are missing in India due to a societal preference for sons.

There is always the inevitable ensuing commentary from men's rights groups, douchebags and the women who date them, and old white man opinion writers who manage to ask the inane question of why there is no international men's day. (For the record, I suspect these are the very same people who ask why there is no white history month.)

This past year was the year that the President of the United States had to go on television to explain that "Rape is rape," where we all learned what a trans-vaginal ultrasound was, and whereby the Canadian political discourse was hijacked by backbench Conservative MPs in their incessant mission to shove the abortion debate down the public's throat.

Growing up, feminism was never an issue that my mother discussed with me. Its teachings were simply ubiquitous. Whether she was telling me that the archaic notion of women being subservient to men in our South Asian culture was something that I was never expected to adhere to or that I should always speak up if I have an opinion. Feminism's fundamental tenant, gender equality, was omnipresent in my household.

Looking back, I think that is one of the greatest gifts my mother could have imparted unto me. In making the notion of feminism and its values all-pervading I never fell victim into believing any of the negative connotations associated with the dreaded F-word. As an adult, when I tell people I am a feminist I am often met with varying degrees of incredulity and disgust. I suppose this is because the political right did such a good job of vilifying the women's movement that now the mainstream media feels the need to precede the word feminist with militant.

The civil rights movement would have never have happened had Dr. King said, "Well, I sort of have a dream...I think. I guess we should be judged by the content of our character. But maybe it's OK if we all just strive for almost equal. You know, same same but different."

Perhaps it's time we stop allowing for this kind of logical fallacy when it comes to gender parity. Maybe then International Women's Day will be treated with the respect it deserves instead of being the joke that it is. Well, maybe not a joke in the same way that Daniel Tosh tells a good ol' fashioned rape joke. Violent, forced vaginal penetration. Super hilarious, bro.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Child Marriage

    <strong>Of note</strong>: The countries in which underage marriage is common and encouraged include India, Turkey, and Panama, among many others. Marriage under the age of 18 has been correlated with <a href="http://www.pbs.org/now/shows/341/facts.html" target="_hplink">higher rates of dying young, health problems, living in poverty and illiteracy</a>.

  • Female Genital Cutting

    <strong>Of note</strong>: While the majority of countries scarcely engage in this practice, the countries where more than half of the women have their genitals cut include Saudi Arabia, Indonesia and Egypt.

  • Son Preference And Sex Ratios

    <b>Of note</b>: Canada, Colombia and Chile, along with other countries, have notably higher rates of abnormal sex ratios, which has been shown to correlate with <a href="http://www.mendeley.com/research/abnormal-sex-ratios-in-human-populations-causes-and-consequences/" target="_hplink">sex-selective abortions and discrimination in care for girls</a>.

  • Women's Physical Security

    <b>Of note</b>: The countries in which women lack physical security -- which is defined as fewer laws against domestic violence, rape, and marital rape, their enforcement, the taboos or norms about reporting the crimes and existence of 'honour killings' -- include Cambodia, Morocco and Peru, among many others in Africa and the Middle East.

  • Trafficking Of Females

    <b>Of note</b>: The countries in which trafficking is not illegal and commonly practiced include Myanmar, Venezuela and North Korea. Studies have found that <a href="http://www.popcenter.org/problems/trafficked_women/" target="_hplink">70 per cent of trafficked women end up in the sex trade</a>.

  • Maternal Mortality

    <b>Of note</b>: Maternal mortality rate is linked with the general health of a society, as <a href="http://consultation.dfid.gov.uk/maternalhealth2010/why-is-maternal-and-reproductive-health-important/" target="_hplink">a lower rate positively affects families and economy</a>. The countries that have more than 300 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births include almost all of central Africa, Pakistan and Bolivia.

  • Discrepancy In Education

    <b>Of note</b>: The countries in which there is a greater than 20 per cent difference between male and female education, as well 'significant' legal and cultural restrictions to it, include Afghanistan, Somalia and Haiti.<br> <a href="http://www.right-to-education.org/node/187" target="_hplink">Educating women has been shown to help improve health, poverty and create equality</a> between men and women.

  • Government Participation

    <b>Of note</b>: The countries in which 0 to 10 per cent of parliament is composed of women include China, Japan and Brazil (despite their female president). A 2010 study by Deloitte emphasized<a href="http://www.deloitte.com/pathstopower" target="_hplink"> the importance of women in government in order to foster equality</a>. They found that a critical mass of one-third of women in government can help societies move beyond 'gender-centric issues.'

  • Discrepant Government Behaviour

    <b>Of note</b>: The countries in which there is virtually no enforcement of laws concerning the <a href="http://www.un.org/womenwatch/daw/cedaw/cedaw.htm" target="_hplink">Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women</a> include Iran, Papua New Guinea, and Eritrea, despite the <a href="http://treaties.un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?src=TREATY&mtdsg_no=IV-8&chapter=4&lang=en" target="_hplink">latter two countries' accession to the convention in 1995</a>.

 

Follow Supriya Dwivedi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/supriyadwivedi

FOLLOW CANADA
Today is International Women's Day, and although you might notice the requisite "Let's Empower Women and Girls" op-ed on your social media news feeds, the truth is that this day is more or less a farc...
Today is International Women's Day, and although you might notice the requisite "Let's Empower Women and Girls" op-ed on your social media news feeds, the truth is that this day is more or less a farc...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 13
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:37 AM on 03/24/2013
And the veiled misogyny and the not so veiled apologists for men's movements in the below comments are but a few examples of why IWD is not a joke. Likewise, I do understand that feminism is about - among other things - women choosing how they want to live - and what kind of activities they want to do. It's not about one set of women telling other women that how they chose to honour something is - a joke. While I absolutely agree that women's rights are human rights, the truth is that for this to be total a sum value, there will need first to be total equality. Still women are targeted for death simply because they are women - in the Americas, this is called femicide. In some of the countries most violent to women in the Americas there was the heart beat of events for IWD (Honduras, Guatemala, for example). For these women, participating in IWD related activities is anything but a joke. It puts them on the front lines of being targeted for death - all because they are women. I guess the biggest question to the article is WHO is treating it as it joke? The author? Men? Vanguard feminists? Is it because of privileged those who Joke do so?
10:16 AM on 03/10/2013
I'm writing this from Kigali, Rwanda, where we just had the IWD celebrations and had a public holiday to recognize it. Here, it was no joke, it was an element of pride for everyone (women and men, boys and girls). Perhaps the thing that was most poignant about it was when the more senior women leaders called for recognition of shortcomings of delivering services to men and boys, in terms of HIV and healthcare, treatment and retention. These are issues that don't tend to come out in the western media.
There are very few men's advocacy groups in the developing world and it seems clear that their strongest advocates are the local women, not men or women in the west. So, on this IWD, I ask our sisters to be proud and strong, and help men to learn from their successes.
10:26 PM on 03/09/2013
I strongly agree with this that World is failing on improving the condition of women in society and on securing for them a position of dignity and fair and equitable treatment. But where is the fault? Are the law makers are responsible or its man`s own instinct? Ofcourse its man own instinct.Today Nations are competing for civilization and for this they follow those laws which are dictated by materialistic urges.Every indiviual is free to grow in his own way and to interpret life without refrence to any large and basic principles.They are subordinate of civilization.so they are using women too as their subordinate to flourish their civilization only.The lives of every indiviual should be defined by certain limits to stop this ill treatment.
08:18 PM on 03/09/2013
Why be a feminist? I understand that the idea is to promote equal rights for women but wouldn't it be easier to do so if one used a more inclusive term? Why not be an egalitarian, promoting equal rights for everyone?

Women face horrible oppression in many countries, and I am thoroughly appalled by such treatment, but such oppression isn't seen in western society. The feminist movement in the west gained equality, a successful progression from previous male movements to gain universal male suffrage/equality. In western countries what one has now is modern, radical feminists, not pressing for equality any more, but for special treatment/benefits over and above men, and this ostracizes western men who would otherwise be more inclined to fight for gender equality in developing nations.

I'm a 21 year old male growing up in Canada. I'm seeing a minister for women's issues, but none for men's issues, an international women's day, but no international men's day, the public education system catering to female learning styles, leaving men behind, and a higher percentage of women in my university than men. Is it any wonder that on international women's day I would find myself feeling defensive, instead of motivated to support women's issues in developing countries?

Feminism has lost its original meaning, while it used to be about gender equality it is now frequently seen as exclusive and discriminatory toward men. I recommend future efforts towards achieving equality be taken under the banner of egalitarianism, not feminism.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NadineL
unseatHarper
05:50 PM on 03/09/2013
WOWOWOOW you just said everything I had been feeling... TANKS MAN, SKIRT OFF TO YA
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lkvk101
A fools' paradise is a wise mans hell.
05:05 PM on 03/09/2013
Do you actually think International Womens Day is going to amount to a hill of beans? While reading this article, I had the feeling the writer really has an axe to grind and when she did mention feminist and a few other phrases, I immediately labeled her as a zealot. Being a female myself, I feel that everyone deserves to be treated equally but will that ever happen?? Too many humans have a mean streak and abuse of power can be held by a male or female whether it be in a household or not or even in this country or not.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:08 PM on 03/09/2013
Citizens only vote every four years or so. Does that make voting a joke? Only an ideological purist with a fantasy agenda for a new form of social organization would say so. Most people are not preoccupied with "issues" of this or that, but gain from being reminded a) that they exist, and b) that the dignity of an official "day" confers more than usual importance on the issue. If the moral question is "are you sufficiently engaged or preoccupied" to satisfy a true enthusiast for the cause, of course not. If the question is "does IWD spark some social reflection and update interested citizens on the state of affairs", it serves a good purpose.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dennis Schmunk
09:23 AM on 03/09/2013
Having a 'day' diminshes the message into something trite and typically UN. It's another day like Mothers Day without the boost to the sales of mundane greeting cards.

Of course it could be international walk for women day or bike for your gender day. Then people could marvel at the idea of putting one foot in front of the other and accomplish even more than a UN declaration. Namely doing something anything even if it doesn't move the yardsticks.

Other than that having the UN declare a day is like having the UN declare peace in Syria.
09:13 PM on 03/08/2013
I am a woman and mother of two sons and I want to know why there is no International Mens' Day as well.? I also have HUGE respect for every type of animals so I think there should also be an International Animals' Day.
12:44 AM on 03/09/2013
international men's day is everyday. but officially its in november
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:24 AM on 03/09/2013
Why does the US not have White History Month? Because technically every day is white history month.
In a world where women are considered lesser every day, an International Women's Day is necessary. While here in the West women are generally equal (not always), in the majority of the world they are not hence the International label.
But yes, you can make a very good case for International Animals' Day.
By the way, I am a man.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:06 PM on 03/08/2013
it was good up to the feminist part
06:27 PM on 03/08/2013
1) I think we should go back and look at the origins of the day (E Europe, Russia) and what it really historically means, out of the equality of the Socialist movement, rather than how we interpret it now in a 21st century lens, and 2) take a look at the list of 25 countries that actually have IWD as a national holiday and check out their record on women's rights. Not great. Quite telling.

(fyi to the DBs you mention: some countries do have a "men's day". Russia celebrated it last month, and it evolved from the "Defender of the Fatherland" day. It's not a holiday like WD, which is a very important observance there).