Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tanya Enberg

GET UPDATES FROM Tanya Enberg
 

Baby and the Breast

Posted: 05/ 2/2012 10:12 am

A woman's breasts are not sandwiches.

Nor are females cattle, sitting idle waiting for a milking.

Now, if we did share the same mental wiring as the mooing, grass-grazing set, none of us would grapple with the breastfeeding concept or wonder how to transition from seeing breasts as sexualized body parts to providers of milk for newborns. But we're not, and the pressure for new moms to breastfeed is intense.

It's worse than a pushy gym sales guy trying every angle to get you to sign on the dotted line, and perhaps more severe than getting cornered by a Scientologist recruitment member.

It is this incessant force -- which whacks moms-to-be over the head with a good pounding of guilt, shame and eyebrow-raising judgment should they dare wonder whether breastfeeding is right for them -- that turns some gals off.

Now, before going any further, let me say this: I am planning to breastfeed come June when our son is born, as breast milk contains antibodies that help reduce the risk of infections and certain types of diseases.

That said, it feels completely unnatural to me.

Realizing that at this moment in time, questioning breastfeeding is like voluntarily diving into a politically-correct snake pit, I know I am not alone.

A recent book review in the The Globe and Mail confirmed my suspicions that other women are also examining parenthood and the exhaustive realities of breastfeeding, as newborns typically feed every two to three hours.

The book, entitled The Conflict: How Modern Motherhood Undermines the Status of Women, written by Elisabeth Badinter, is getting a ton of ink. It's bound to.

In it, Badinter challenges, among other things, the expectation that maternal instincts automatically demolish all other roles a woman might have played until the onset of parenthood, that with arrival of baby, even the most successful, career-minded women will magically transform into selfless, coo-cooing creatures ready to breastfeed on demand around the clock.

The other day a neighbour and father of a two-month-old told me about the scorn women receive even if they're unable to breastfeed. His wife couldn't due to surgery she'd had, but regardless, she tried, going so far as to hire an at-home lactation consultant and rent a hospital-grade pump.

"Even if you physically can't, you'll be told it's your fault," he warned.

The modern-day message is this: Not breastfeeding equals appallingly bad parenting.

But before it gets lost in the shuffle, allow me to return to the aforementioned breasts as sandwiches analogy, which derives from a rather unpleasant breastfeeding class.

I signed up because a friend asked me to and, at $10 a pop, it seemed a small price to pay to try and warm up to the idea.

It didn't work.

Watching the instructor turn an oversized stuffed breast into a makeshift sandwich, bring it to her mouth and pretend to chomp down to demonstrate how a person would naturally eat it (for the record, don't hold your sandwich vertically, but horizontally) was OK the first time, but three or four sandwich demos later, I'd reached my hoagie limit.

Her goal was to illustrate the proper positioning of a breast to baby's mouth, a message the class certainly got the first time around.

Still, not all was lost.

After a lengthy finger-wagging lecture by the borderline lactation radical, she asked to hear our concerns.
Finally, we speak!

When she reached me, I told the truth: I was desperately struggling with shifting years of programming that's impressed upon me that breasts are sexual, sexy and fun and instead embrace their more pragmatic purposes as lactation devices.

Then, all really was lost.

What followed was a long diatribe about a woman's rights to breastfeed in public.

Ah, yeah, not quite what I was getting at.

I am not rattled by women breastfeeding wherever they find convenient. The obstacle is my own self-image as a sexual being -- a gal who has long enjoyed her body for reasons that have nothing to do with babies.

While I am thrilled to bits to soon meet the person who has been squirming in my belly all these months, that hasn't stopped the wrestling match of questions in my mind.

And, hopefully it never will. After all, we are not cattle.

For now though, I will just keep chugging forward trying to find satisfactory answers. Hopefully they will come before mid-June.

Meantime, I've got to run -- I am pretty sure there's a sandwich in the fridge with my name on it (which I'll be sure to hold correctly when eating).

 

Follow Tanya Enberg on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ChicTravels

FOLLOW PARENTS
A woman's breasts are not sandwiches. Nor are females cattle, sitting idle waiting for a milking. Now, if we did share the same mental wiring as the mooing, grass-grazing set, none of us would...
A woman's breasts are not sandwiches. Nor are females cattle, sitting idle waiting for a milking. Now, if we did share the same mental wiring as the mooing, grass-grazing set, none of us would...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Tanya Enberg
09:36 AM on 05/04/2012
Thank-you everyone for your comments. They are thought-provoking .. and it's great to hear so many different views on this subject!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:56 AM on 05/04/2012
When my best friend had her first last year we spent a lot of time with the baby out in public. She chose to pump almost from the start for a whole lot of reasons. You will not believe how many people, mostly women, would walk right up to her and give her advise or outright tell her off for choosing not to breast feed what at first was a newborn. The last time I was there and it happened baby was 7months or so. Before you stick your oar in remember that what is in the bottle may very be at least part breast milk and just because you feel comfortable with your boob out in public(as is totally fine!!) that may not be true for someone else. As a very overweight woman with massive boobies my friend felt extra conspicuous trying to breast feed in semi-public. It wasn't the only reason she pumped, but was part of it. Also some women need meds that making breast feeding inadvisable at all, and you have no right to comment on or be told of someone's medical status. Breast may be best, but modern formula has been revolutionary and even reduced infant mortality and is a good runner up.
11:24 PM on 05/03/2012
Tanya, if you think this way, you most likely will not succeed at breastfeeding. Why not keep an open mind before making any decisions. Perhaps you should visit a site like Kelly Mom and get yourself informed ahead of time. Remember, breastfeeding is a relationship between you and your child. It isn't just a one way street.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christopher Koulouris
06:16 PM on 05/03/2012
Nevermind, my grand idea should I ever become a daddy, is to casually ruffle my child’s hair, smile kindly at them before quietly tip toeing past the child’s mother to the garden with my preferred bottle of red wine of choice and wonder out aloud how good daddy’s actually have it….

http://scallywagandvagabond.com/2012/05/elisabeth-badinter-wants-to-teach-you-girls-what-parenting-is-really-all-about/
05:32 PM on 05/03/2012
Ah! For me it was a simple choice of doing whatever is necessary to give my daughter the best. Also, anecdotal evidence can be twisted to support anything. I know of a woman who was forced to feed her baby formula since her milk hadn't come in. The hospital wasn't ready to discharge the baby since they feared the baby would be starved. She was given a ton of baby formula from various companies at this time (pushy don't you think?). See what I did? Turned the article the other way around..
The truth is that in the modern world you can do no right. Whether you breastfeed or formula-feed.
09:32 AM on 05/03/2012
I always struggled with the whole 'it's natural' concept as well, and then I figured out that although it's something that our body may 'naturally' enable us to do, there certainly is nothing natural about figuring out how to get your baby to latch on properly, how to get the 'fatty milk' to them, and how to not cringe when they first latch on and you're so sore you could bawl! That being said, I breastfed each of my children and each one longer than the previous (finally got it right with my third and after 11 months switched her from the boob to a cup - no bottles to wash!).
At our hospital we have a very well known 'breastfeeding nazi' and everyone who knows about her avoids her like the plague. Breastfeeding is a choice, and our children will survive and thrive whether we do or we don't....and I'm pretty sure that whole ear infection thing is a myth, my youngest is the only one of my children's who has had one, and I breastfed her the longest.
.....and breastfeeding doesn't stop your breasts from being sexual,sexy and fun - that's all in your head :)
08:55 AM on 05/03/2012
Healthcare providers and community educators should not judge or belittle their patients/clients. Other moms shouldn't judge either. We all have our battles and most people don't know what our battles are. However, having both breast and bottle fed my kids- I'd say that preparing a bottle is much more time consuming than giving baby a boob to suck on. There's also the option of pumping and giving baby breastmilk in a bottle.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hharrison22
12:19 AM on 05/03/2012
Am I the only one who thinks that Badinter’s age might make her a bit out of touch with this generation of parents? No one seems to be mentioning this fact or the fact that she has a huge stake in formula given her millionaire status with Nestle. I answer the question, “Who is Elisabeth Badinter” here:
http://www.themommypsychologist.com/2012/04/27/who-is-elisabeth-badinter/
10:33 PM on 05/02/2012
Not going to bash anyone at all. I am pro-breastfeeding, but I am also pro-supporting moms of all types. My only comment is that I was surprised that so many women find breastfeeding to be unnatural. It is the most natural way for humans to feed their babies. It was how babies were fed prior to formula being created. Just surprised, so please don't be angered by my post. Every mom is entitled to choose how to feed their baby...so long as they love and care for their baby and feed them well, I refrain from judging. I just continue to feel a little shocked by people thinking that breastfeeding is unnatural.
02:52 PM on 05/02/2012
What an overall sad article.
I feel sorry for the author: For instance, where did you get the idea that woman are cattle, by providing natural baby nutrition as opposed to -- the vastly inferior -- artificial baby food (a.k.a. "formula")?

As far as I am concerned, that's what the real issue is, natural vs. artificial baby nutrition, and the latter coming with huge health risks that are, indeed, comparable to smoking.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MarcEdward
likes all cats more than most people
09:12 AM on 05/03/2012
I think the author must be a new parent. Those of us who have been around the block a few times get that it's not a big deal to put your own needs behind the needs of a newborn, helpless baby.
05:17 PM on 05/03/2012
Well said!
12:53 AM on 05/04/2012
I agree. Breastfeeding is incredibly natural and very important. It's not only antibodies you are transferring, but also beneficial bacteria which will colonize your baby's gut and allow it to develop a healthy digestive system. Not to mention the traces of arsenic and DDT found in formula. I think to choose formula over breastfeeding simply because you don't feel like it is terribly irresponsible.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:11 PM on 05/02/2012
I concur wholeheartedly. I think the true message of Badinter's book is lost on the majority of people that comment on these articles. She's not advocating one method of parenting over another, but instead bringing to focus that expecting ALL mothers to adhere to a very rigid set of matronly expectations is ridiculous. I made the mistake of mentioning in the hospital that I wasn't completely comfortable breastfeeding (and even more uncomfortable with everyone manhandling the goods...usually I require dinner first before getting to that step) and I never heard the end of it from the nurses. God forbid a woman struggle with the role of motherhood and all the crazy expectations while simultaneously trying to hold onto a shred of her self throughout the whole process.
11:26 AM on 05/02/2012
For the first 2 and a half, maybe 3 seconds, after your child is latched on for the first time, you might feel a bit strange, mixing the old "messages" with the new situation, and then, my experience was that an entirely new and incredibly old, as in ancient, almost "mammallian" feeling will take the place of the strangeness and if you are like me, the realization of This Is How It Is Supposed To Be will take over. And, there won't be a problem understanding that a baby's cry will cause your milk to let down, as will an orgasm. Your body naturally, and appropriately, responds to both. The problem isn't your body, only those who think that it is either one or the other.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:41 AM on 05/03/2012
Sigh. If only it were that easy. My child's cries made me want to run screaming from my house.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MarcEdward
likes all cats more than most people
09:13 AM on 05/03/2012
New babies tend to sound like siamese cats
09:40 AM on 05/03/2012
Postpartum depression. Been there with my wife after two of our three kids. Sometimes specific supplements can help reduce the anxiety. Talk to a Naturopath for more info. If you don't like that sort of approach, talk to your doctor. There are numerous anxiety meds that have acceptable risk levels for breastfeeding Moms/babies. Check the lists at KellyMom if you are concerned.

Most important for anyone experiencing issues like what you describe is GET HELP! You are not weak or anything like that. Postpartum depression is real and can have deadly side effects.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:36 AM on 05/02/2012
#firstworldproblems
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:01 PM on 05/02/2012
exactly what I was thinking... seriously, if you don't want to breastfeed then don't? then own it instead of feeling guilty about it and making it seem like everyone is against you