Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
The Purple Fig

GET UPDATES FROM The Purple Fig
 

Mommy Blogging: a Step Back for Feminism?

Posted: 02/15/2013 5:29 pm

I consider myself a feminist. I know it's the 'F' word, but if you actually look at the meaning of feminism I think of many of the people around me as being feminists too. The 'F' doesn't stand for "fanatical" -- although at times I can be accused of being that too -- rather, feminism is simply the belief in equality of rights and opportunities for men and women.

Over the years I have seen women work hard in many different ways to promote positive change in the area of gender inequality helping us move forward towards the goals of feminism. That is, until the setback of the "Mommy Blog."

Some of the biggest hurdles in the strides for equal opportunity include women and their issues being improperly depicted and the lack of self-promotion that affects recognition and access to opportunities. What I've noticed is that when women are not being misrepresented, they are often underselling themselves. The blogosphere is as an amazing tool that is easily accessible to help correct these problems: self-promotion has never been easier.

Mommy blogs that present neurotic, emotionally unstable, kid-crazed mothers, is a misuse of this opportunity. What concerns me the most is that this is a misuse at the hands of women themselves -- we, ourselves, are the ones that are turning this tool into another obstacle to progression.

I am not referring to the blogs written by women who happen to be mothers. Who I am talking about is bloggers that only focus on their roles as mothers and mothers only. You know, the blogs that give you the unsettling impression that the writer arrived in this world the same day their child was born. These women present their lives in a way that suggests that their lives gained meaning at the point of parenthood with nothing before and perhaps, nothing that will come after.

As if all the time spent educating, learning, exploring, understanding and striving to be the women they wanted to be was simply just filler until they became mothers. Many mommy bloggers have well-developed opinions, skills and interests. The same characteristics that made them successful pre-motherhood are probably what have led them to this new endeavor of mommy blogging.

They probably didn't set out to write a blog that depicts them as a crazy mother who is obsessed with canning baby food or the latest gizmo for their child's nursery. Also, they probably don't think that others see them as living in a bubble with no other interests than raising their bubble children. These bloggers likely have the noble intentions to create a forum where women know that they are not alone in their experiences.

The problem is that many of these blogs perpetuate gender stereotypes and generalize female behaviour. Intentionally or unintentionally, many mommy bloggers do one of two things. First, many mommy bloggers may be living very fulfilling and well-rounded lives that you don't get to see through their blogs. However, when all they talk about is such things as making homemade organic-only baby food, they disregard these other aspects of their lives resulting in a partial portrayal of motherhood.

On the flip side, it is true that some mommy bloggers are solely occupied with such tasks as canning baby food yet; their blogs suggest their lives are deeply fulfilling and they wouldn't want to be doing anything else. This type of blog not only perpetuates the false notion that women are only happy to be in the home and would prefer to spend their days fussing over things related to the house; but also, inadvertently isolates other mothers who don't measure up.

Other mothers who read these blogs may feel as though they need to care about the things that mommy bloggers are talking about and if they don't, they are bad mothers. The truth is some women personally have no issue buying a dozen jars of pre-canned baby food but now feel shame about such things.

Ultimately, in either scenario, the main problem is that when the rest of society reads these mommy blogs the life of a woman is simplified. This has the effect of downplaying both the successes and struggles of women. Moreover, it has the effect of narrowing the space that women are striving to open up in order to permit open discussion of their real life experiences -- ironically, directly contradicting the original intention of many mommy bloggers. I cringe at the thought that a man will read these blogs, in turn reinforcing antiquated ideas of women in the home.

I am not saying being a mother or a stay-at-home mom is not meaningful work. I respect the choice to stay home and I understand the many reasons why women opt to do so. I also know that there are a lot of sacrifices and compromises that are made when women decide to stay home.

My issue is simply with how we present the woman who has made that choice. Instead of implying that we need to become obsessive about our childcare duties, it would be inspiring if these women aspired to be domestic trailblazers and reframe the idea of women in the house.

Do we want our children to think that women have only one role and a singular purpose in life? As a mother myself, I hope my daughter will look at me and think I was a good mother. But more than that, I hope she will look at all aspects of my life and think that I was more than just a good mother to her.

Visit The Purple Fig
The Purple Fig on Facebook

Loading Slideshow...
  • We're Better At Recognizing A Pickup Line

    In a 2008 study of heterosexual college students, guys who were shown images of platonic and sexually interested women had a harder time distinguishing between friendly and frisky cues. Men were slightly more likely than women to misidentify the friendly images as sexually interested. While women did mistake about a third of the sexually interested images for folks just being friendly, men did even worse, leading the researchers to deem them as the "perceptually insensitive" sex (feel free to use that line on a clueless date).

  • We're Faster

    Well, at least our circadian rhythms are faster. Researchers at Harvard-affiliated Brigham and Women's Hospital found that the cycle length of the daily biological clock in women was shorter than it was in men (six minutes, on average). This means that many of us tend to wake up earlier -- and this gives us an excuse to go to bed earlier than our partners.

  • We Make More Effective Congresspeople (When We Manage To Get Elected)

    Regardless of party affiliation, congressional women deliver more federal projects to their home districts and sponsor and co-sponsor more legislation than their male colleagues. In a study that was recently published in The American Journal of Political Science, researchers from Stanford University and the University of Chicago attributed women's political success not to some innate political instinct but to the fact that it's really hard for us to get elected (there are currently 360 men and 75 women in the House; 83 men and 17 women in the Senate). They theorize that women feel immense pressure to measure up, so instead of meeting expectations, we surpass them.

  • We're Better Educated

    We've been hearing for decades that women earn more bachelor's degrees than men. But in the 2008-2009 academic year, women earned 60 percent of all master's degrees and finally caught up with men in earning 50.4 percent of doctoral degrees. Congratulations, graduates!

  • We Have Stronger Immune Systems

    A 2009 study by scientists at McGill University indicated that women have a built-in mechanism to protect from infection. Estrogen naturally found in our bodies suppresses an enzyme that interferes with our defense system. These findings may inspire estrogen-based treatments to boost immunity in those (ahem, men) who don't already possess the hormone.

  • We're More Likely To See A Doctor

    Women reported in a national survey in June 2011 that we're three times more likely than men to see a physician on a regular basis.

  • We Mature Into Healthier Eaters

    Studies show that while too many kids are eating junk food (20 to 33 percent eat it three times a week), girls are more likely than guys to lose the taste for it after adolescence. This may explain why you haven't been to a Taco Bell since your senior class trip.

  • We're At Far Lower Risk For Blood Disease

    Hemophilia is a disorder that prevents blood from clotting normally, and can lead to excessive and internal bleeding. It's caused by a gene defect located on the X chromosome. Women will not develop the disease unless both chromosomes are affected -- and that's extremely rare. Because men only have one X chromosome, they are much more susceptible to hemophilia.

  • We Ensure The Continuation Of The Human Race

    At least until that cloning technology gets sorted out.

  • We Have The Power To Reassure

    Participants in a 2010 study who were tapped on the shoulder by a female researcher invested significantly more money in a wager than those patted by a man, leading researchers to theorize that contact with a woman triggered a confidence boost similar to the one they received as children from their mother's touch.

  • After Facial Surgery, We're Camera-Ready Sooner

    Men don't look as good after facial surgeries (like the removal of cancerous basal cells), and it's not just because women are more adept at applying concealer. "The hair follicles in men's faces require more blood vessels," explains Phil Haeck, MD, the president of the American Society of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons, and a surgeon with a private practice in Seattle. "Because men's faces are more vascular, they tend to bruise more."

  • Our Hearts Respond Better To Healthy Choices

    When it comes to heart disease, women can be more strongly impacted than men by risk factors like diabetes and cholesterol levels, according to the American Heart Association. The flip side is that making healthy lifestyle modifications -- getting more exercise and eating right to control blood sugar and cholesterol -- may yield greater benefits to women.

  • We Hold The Record For A Heart Reboot

    The longest-surviving open-heart surgery patient in the world is a British woman named Sadie Purdy. She was born with a hole in her heart in 1924, and when she was 17, she suffered complications that required one of the valves in her heart to be tied. Doctors weren't sure whether she'd survive the procedure, which was then still in the experimental stage. Ms. Purdy did, and entered Guinness World Records in 2004. At 86, she's living in a nursing home in England.

  • Luck Is A Lady

    Right, Frank?

  • ... And Death Is A Woman

    In Neil Gaiman's cult-hit comic book series, <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Sandman-Vol-Preludes-Nocturnes/dp/1563890119" target="_hplink"><em>The Sandman</em></a>, Death was a hip young woman who would spend a day every century living and dying as a mortal to understand the value of human life. While there's no proof that women are kinder than men, this version of Death is certainly more empathetic than the scythe-wielding Grim Reaper.

 

Follow The Purple Fig on Twitter: www.twitter.com/thepurplefigmag

FOLLOW CANADA LIVING
I consider myself a feminist. I know it's the 'F' word, but if you actually look at the meaning of feminism I think of many of the people around me as being feminists too. The 'F' doesn't stand for "f...
I consider myself a feminist. I know it's the 'F' word, but if you actually look at the meaning of feminism I think of many of the people around me as being feminists too. The 'F' doesn't stand for "f...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 76
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Leslie Hendry
07:30 PM on 02/23/2013
Where is the whole mommy blogger phenomenon going? Are we getting to share in their lives or are we simply watching another sponsored ad? Will celebrity moms soon usurp these women bloggers? I'm not sure mommy bloggers have anything to do with feminism in the long run, but more of a present day phenomenon. Soon sponsors will simply ditch these moms for the celebrities. We've seen it before.

If anything these women have been entrepreneurs, establishing their own publishing sites, and they've earned income.
05:58 PM on 02/17/2013
I don't want to be "labelled" as anything.......As a citizen of this planet and a mother of two I am frankly too busy trying to lessen my carbon footprint because climate change and the vanishing species are my big concern - being "equal" and "powerful" means absolutely NOTHING to me when there are so many serious issues facing the planet.
01:35 PM on 02/17/2013
if women want to be equal to men, then we have to consider men our equal and therefore the blog should have been called 'stay at home parent blog'. anyways i am sure this blog does not represent the emotional or chaotic state of all mommies, but certainly breaks the isolation that some stay at home parents can feel.
03:04 AM on 02/17/2013
so true. as a new mom, i find it hard to connect to most of the things written in these blogs. this is a new area of competition for people. i find it quite similar to the workplace or school where you have to do things the right way and get the most points.
even people who think they are raising their children "the natural way" have a checklist (cloth diapers, organic food, etc.) adapted from books and other blogs, which i find the most unnatural.
but the worst part of this craze is the way it idolizes and romanticizes motherhood: any negative feeling you may have about becoming a mother is a taboo.
that said, i have my own personal blog that i started recently because writing takes some of that bulky motherhood weight off my shoulders. and i am hopeful about running into people that don't take motherhood this seriosly and make it their only priority.
http://momstates.tumblr.com
12:49 AM on 02/17/2013
I am a woman and still to this day don't know what "empowerment" means. Could someone from the feminist movement enlighten me again? Thank goodness I never bought into this crap. I love staying at home, only working part-time and my children and husband are my top priorities. They always will be. I love being a wife and mother.
11:42 AM on 02/17/2013
Empowerment means not being constrained by societal expectations of what defines a woman. One of the goals of the women's movement was/is to remove the barriers, both overt and subtle that push women to conform to some external ideal. I think that even if we dont agree with or identify with what other women choose, its imporant that all women have a voice.
01:41 PM on 02/17/2013
the word empowerment, means to have power , or control on your life.not all women or men want to lead industries or gov t. i would say you are empowered,you have made a choice and live this to it s fullest.hats off to you.you are leading your life the way you want to! that is feminism and empowerment!
05:54 PM on 02/17/2013
Thanks for your description of "empowerment" - now what is "feminism"?
01:52 PM on 02/16/2013
i find this article offensive and a remnant of second wave feminism; a time when the phrase "the personal is political" was coined.

i am a stay-at-home-mom and i also consider myself a feminist. my son is my priority. i don't blog about it, but if i had a blog it would be about him. i stay at home for financial reasons and personal reasons. i don't think i am less of a feminist.
01:45 PM on 02/17/2013
i own my house, am self employed and don t consider myself a feminist.i believe in gender or human equality, to me that means having the best person to do the job, male or female.you probably are not less of a feminist.
09:23 PM on 02/18/2013
well, in my opinion, believing in gender and human equality makes you a feminist! i mean that in the best way possible.
01:40 PM on 02/16/2013
I don't think the author is saying to silence any mommy bloggers. Isn't she just saying that there are so many sides to a woman/mother and when SOME bloggers only portray one tiny little side, that possibly that doesn't do justice to portraying the enormity of being a mother?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:08 PM on 02/16/2013
Freedom is about choice, you work diligently accompanied by your down the nose view of women who have made a choice to be mothers, to remove that choice. All you do is replace the old tyranny with a new tyranny. My mother taught me how to communicate, maintain eye contact, honesty, true honesty without the aid of an all seeing guilt instilling God. How to sew, knit, cook, and clean. How to care for my children. My mother taught me how to forgive and be forgiven, what is inside of me has value and beauty, acceptance of who I am. Above all she taught me how to love and be loved, despite my floors. These gifts, by the age of five. If generation “X” is lost maybe it’s because no one was there to show them the way. In a thousand years from now, when historians ask what went wrong the answer will be; the only lasting legacy of the feminist agenda was the right for women to give up their babies.
12:21 PM on 02/16/2013
Here's an opinion from the "y" chromosome.
That was the funniest article I've read for some time.
When my wife and I started our family, my wife who originally did not want children, decided the best thing for our kids, was to follow a long and proud tradition of being a Mom. This difficult choice has come with hardship on both of us, but that is what being a parent is about. one of her greatest compliments comes from teachers who comment on how rounded and secure my two children are knowing that Mom is home when needed and dedicates herself as her full time job to ensuring when all is said and done, we have raised two wonderful human beings to send out into the world.
The only time she ever feels anger with what she has choosen as her present "career" path is when the "feminist" moms who, bring the lids to day care, go to work, the salon, drinks with the girls etc. ask her what she does with all her free time.
There seems to be an unspoken competition that everything outside of the hardest job you'll ever have is more important and to belittle what generations of women have naturally done. I think in two very large ways (my son and daughter) my wife is changing the world for the good.
let's get behind moms, instead of degrading the most important job the world has
02:18 PM on 02/16/2013
haaa ohh stevee...
11:00 AM on 02/17/2013
Hey kiddo
I appreciate you reading the story. maybe when you grow up and meet an intelligent well rounded women (such as my wife or many who responded to the story) you'll have a little more depth and life experience. Keep on trying and you'll get there.
By the way, next time you respond to a comment or story, have your Mom check the spelling and ensure you put capital on the right letters.
Cheers
11:45 AM on 02/16/2013
One of the goals of the women's movement was to fight the silencing of women who didnt fit the society's norm of how women *ought* to look, think and behave. By suggesting the "mommy bloggers" should censor themselves in order to support some other idealization of womanhood runs counter to that goal.
02:25 PM on 02/16/2013
i thin her pint was more along the lines they should not present themselves as a 2 dimensional soley parenting oriented, newest baby and toddler gizmo buying unstable individuals.

THis slowly reverts back to painting the sexist and anti-feminist stereotyping that women are child rearing emotional beings while whose minds must leap from unstable and crazy mothering shenanigan to the next.

I do agree though it is kind of far fetched. kind of like criticizing construction blog writing men for reinforcing male chauvinism, at the same time different. i do think her arguments are valid given the history of feminine portrayal and i am a 23 year old male!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DebbyM
11:04 PM on 02/17/2013
So instead of these women being free to do and talk about the things and lifestyle that are the most important to them, the author would rather see them conform to her idea of what a feminist is.

I thought feminism was all about women being (equally) allowed to chose their own path instead of having some male dominated society tell them what is acceptable. Now interestingly, we have a woman telling other women how to behave acceptably. Very interesting.
08:41 AM on 02/16/2013
FINALLY!! Someone willing to come out and ask for the end of the mommy blog. I don't understand these women. It is exactly as if they aren't really women, they have become something else- mommies. Many of them even self identify as only a mommy, they use it as their usernames throughout the internet "shanesmum1203" or "proud2bellasmom". These blogs have created a new source of inter-woman shaming and guilt trips with their 'mommy wars'. Do you cloth diaper? Did you breastfeed until little Mason was 5?" Did you get him into Princeton nursery school" "Oh you don't feed organic?". Suddenly these once smart, educated women have given themselves up to the cult of mommy, never to return.

If the mommy blogs would provide some more perspective, it would probably help a lot of women.
07:38 PM on 02/16/2013
As a woman who is getting a PhD at an Ivy league university and a mommy, I can see your point but also where these blog mommies are coming from. I think that if society was more accepting and inclusive of mothers, and saw it as a serious role, a lot of women would feel such a need to publicize (and a blog is a public persona, of course) their extreme mommy-hood. I, like many working moms, work in a world where babies just don't have a place. Consequently, when I do meet up with other moms I sometimes find myself going into extreme mommy la-la land and just letting myself go wild on topics like feeding, crazy sleep schedules, diapering etc. I can only imagine what it would be like if I was a full time mom, and a "smart, educated" one, in a world that didn't take me seriously. I might rebel, and that might take the form of (legitimate, because as any parent knows, parenting is a crazy crazy world) defining myself exclusively as a mommy.
08:38 AM on 02/16/2013
What the author perceives as women completely losing their identity when they become mothers, should be seen from an entirely different perspective. Growing up in this culture, I believed from a very early age that I could be as educated and as successful as I wanted to be. My focus was always on higher education and advancing my career. Once I did become a mother, it hit me like a ton of bricks that none of my education prepared me for the most difficult challenge of my life. I was clueless about the most basic aspects of caring for a newborn. Every step of the way I had to educate myself. Reading the "mommy" blogs is both comforting and informative for me. There are many times that I wish I had been raised in a culture that valued women's roles as mothers as equally as those roles requiring higher education and/or climbing the corporate ladder. With all of my years of education and experience in the workforce, nothing has been as important to me as the time and energy I have put into raising my children. I thank those women who take the time to blog and share their experiences, because it takes a village to raise a child.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
canobserv
07:49 AM on 02/16/2013
doesn't feminism mean that women are allowed to CHOOSE what they wish to do with thier lives......if they CHOOSE to devote their lives to their children and families who are you to tell them they aren't advancing the "feminist cause".....whatever that is...frankly you come across as no differant than the right wing men who think all women should stay home....two sides same coin
07:36 AM on 02/16/2013
I must say that I agree.I believe that after reading a few of those blogs - some mothers,mothers-to-be,or fathers can feel pressure to be a "a perfect parent",and what's worst put pressure on their kids to be the "perfect children".I would recommend for anyone not to to take to hearth every advice found on those Blogs - not everything may work the same for the parents or the kids as every situation (family situation,kids) is different.Some things do work, but some will leave parents feeling like a failure.No such thing as a perfect parent or a perfect child...As for women wanting to stay at home and raise their kids instead of chasing after career - choices should be understood by others.Women fought for their rights and choices - any choice is good as long as it is made by them,and not pressures coming from either side....As long as your kids and you are happy - that is all that matters...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
King Stevie Harper
05:17 AM on 02/16/2013
Its not about equality, it is in the Muslim world for sure, but in North America its narcissim, attention-seeking, whining and control issues. North American women are spoiled brats, unless you are poor, native, muslim or black you are more than equal. Get over yourself spoiled white girls. There it is. Deal with it. Narcissima was the pride of Pamona!